Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect my sister to help cover Mum's care?

266 replies

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 16:42

So my mum is 84, she has multiple health issues including arthritis, epilepsy and she has issues with her memory at times (we’ve been to the memory clinic and there was no diagnosis).
My daughter is her carer, alongside raising her own children. She makes sure my mum takes all her medication, cleans her home, prepares all her meals, takes her to all appointments, collects her prescription etc.
I currently work 30 hours a week, on the two week days I don’t work, I help out by doing the afternoon visit, this lets my daughter take her children to toddler groups etc.
I also co-ordinate some of my annual leave to cover when my daughter goes on holiday and my son helps out too.
I haven’t been on holiday in 3 years now, I desperately want to go away in the easter school holidays with my children and their children. However my mum is extremely resistant to external carers.
I have asked my sister who lives 20 minutes away, no longer works, has a car etc. If she would be willing to help cover for a week in April, my daughter has asked her cousin too.
Cousin has said she can do the Monday to Friday leg, if we can make sure there are no appointments scheduled, food is stocked etc. She has asked if we can provide a travel cot as she will be brining her own children and just staying overnight for 4 nights, absolutely fine we can do this, we have even offered to make sure there is food stocked for her and the children too (well my daughter has).
However we still need the Friday to Monday covered, I’ve asked my sister and she has outright said no chance. She said she is too busy. I told her she doesn’t have to stay overnight, and a neighbour has offered to check in and make sure the night time tablets have been taken (my mum hates taking them so asking her on the phone isn’t enough you have to go over and stand with her while she takes them or she throws them in the bin!), so it would just be morning and afternoon.

AIBU to think this is ridiculous? It’s months in advance and she hasn’t said anything about a holiday or wedding so I have no idea how she already knows she’s too busy that weekend? Obviously we can just go away for 5 days instead of 7, but I was looking at the Canary Islands and that flight with 5 children doesn’t seem worth it for just 5 days.

OP posts:
rookiemere · 16/08/2026 17:23

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 17:09

We don’t want this to happen, she is perfectly okay on her own overnight and for most of the day, the visits are short and we are happy to provide these until it is truly no longer possible to do it at home, not some arbitrary 4 visits rules.
We would rather skip holidays than have to put mum in a home. I will be retiring in a few years and can take on some of the burden to ease up my daughters time and let her get back to work, but for now it works well as she is home with her children anyway.

Well then that’s your choice, but it’s not necessarily your sisters. If your DD is formally claiming carers allowance then I think there’s a possibility of paid for respite care.

JustAnotherWhinger · 16/08/2026 17:22

Wouldn’t your mother at least allow outside carers for a short period to allow you the break?

That seems a more sensible option than everyone trying to juggle everything round.

NoCommentingFromNowOn · 16/08/2026 17:20

You all have options to do it differently but none of you want to explore those options. That’s fine, but there’s no point moaning about it.

Lockupyourbiscuits · 16/08/2026 17:20

It’s not your sister being difficult here

Viviennemary · 16/08/2026 17:20

I thjnk it is unreasonable to expect this level of care from a family member. You have revolved your lives round this but in all honesty you cannot expect others to be prepared to do the same even if it is only for a week.

Rockfrock · 16/08/2026 17:20

Yes, you are being very unreasonable.
You cannot force your DSis to do this.
Has anyone got POA for your DM?
Has Attendance Allowance been applied for?
You will need these going forward.

Pinkbananaa · 16/08/2026 17:19

If it wasnt a problem you wouldnt have posted. Your dsis doesnt want to go doen the rabbit hole of providing care. I dont blame her. Your DM doesnt get to dictate.

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 17:17

Credittocress · 16/08/2026 17:16

No it doesn’t. You haven’t been on holiday for three years despite wanting to and you resent your sister. It isn’t working perfectly well.

I could have gone on holiday. The only reason I haven’t is I’ve had no one to go with. It’s just now I want to go with both my children. If I really wanted to I could go with my children separately.

OP posts:
Pinkbananaa · 16/08/2026 17:17

So get carers in. Even if they come in once or twice it takes the pressure off

Cookiesunderthesofa · 16/08/2026 17:16

Toddlers are resistant to putting their coats on and going in car seats - but you have to insist for their wellbeing.

it’s the same principle here - you need to TELL not ask her that you are going away on this date. Cousin is covering first 5 days and the remainder needs to be covered by carers.

does she wish to phone the agency to organise or would she like you to do so? Would she like to be involved in choosing the agency or would she like you to arrange it all?

no matter how ‘resistant’ she is to the idea of carers it has to happen unless she can come up with a plausible safe alternative option.

you have to put your foot down about this as you need a break.

Credittocress · 16/08/2026 17:16

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 17:13

It works perfectly well 51 weeks of the year?

Only on this occasion where I want to go on holiday with both my children at once is it an issue. We can just do centre parcs Monday to Friday if my sister really doesn’t want to help.

No it doesn’t. You haven’t been on holiday for three years despite wanting to and you resent your sister. It isn’t working perfectly well.

NervousSheepy · 16/08/2026 17:16

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 17:13

It works perfectly well 51 weeks of the year?

Only on this occasion where I want to go on holiday with both my children at once is it an issue. We can just do centre parcs Monday to Friday if my sister really doesn’t want to help.

Well then just arrange outside care as a one off for a few days, I'm sure your mum will understand and not want you guys to miss out when you do so much for her.

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 17:15

Pinkbananaa · 16/08/2026 17:14

Has your dm got alot of money of a big house? You are unreasonable to put on your sister and your nieces.

No she lives in a council bungalow and doesn’t have any savings. She’s on state pension and disability payments.

OP posts:
timtamsarebetterthanpenguins · 16/08/2026 17:15

If your sister doesn't want to help, you can't make her.

This is why carers exist. You need to employ someone if you can't cope.

Pinkbananaa · 16/08/2026 17:14

Has your dm got alot of money of a big house? You are unreasonable to put on your sister and your nieces.

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 17:14

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 16/08/2026 17:12

This, is your dd really happy to have to do so much care? Is it more about saving money and not paying for care?

My daughter volunteered, it works well for her, she gets more time with her children than she would if she had been back at work already, is always able to do school drop off and pick up, nativity plays etc. The children brighten up my mums day.

OP posts:
Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 17:13

NervousSheepy · 16/08/2026 17:11

It doesn't sound as though it is working all that well though. I'm afraid that you and her all seem resistant to some of the options that could help make your lives easier, which is your choice, but is not the same choice your sister wishes to make.

It works perfectly well 51 weeks of the year?

Only on this occasion where I want to go on holiday with both my children at once is it an issue. We can just do centre parcs Monday to Friday if my sister really doesn’t want to help.

OP posts:
Pinkbananaa · 16/08/2026 17:12

Your poor dd is carring the main load she should be enjoying her young children and going back to work. Why is your dm her responsibility. Shes not going to get time back with her young kids. I speak as someone whos dad had carers in. It was never expected of me to met his care needs.

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 16/08/2026 17:12

Pinkbananaa · 16/08/2026 17:09

Its your dd and your choice to care for your dm. I think its crazy your poor dd is burdened with caring for your mother whilst you work. She should be enjoying her life with her young family 3 times a day is crazy. Your sister and her child have put boundaries in place that they dont want to provide care. Personally i dont blame them its abit ask. Your dm needs carers in or a care home or the very least respite

This, is your dd really happy to have to do so much care? Is it more about saving money and not paying for care?

NervousSheepy · 16/08/2026 17:11

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 17:09

We don’t want this to happen, she is perfectly okay on her own overnight and for most of the day, the visits are short and we are happy to provide these until it is truly no longer possible to do it at home, not some arbitrary 4 visits rules.
We would rather skip holidays than have to put mum in a home. I will be retiring in a few years and can take on some of the burden to ease up my daughters time and let her get back to work, but for now it works well as she is home with her children anyway.

It doesn't sound as though it is working all that well though. I'm afraid that you and her all seem resistant to some of the options that could help make your lives easier, which is your choice, but is not the same choice your sister wishes to make.

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 17:11

HeddaGarbled · 16/08/2026 17:07

Are there any men in the family who could take a turn?

No, I only have a sister, I’m not married, my sister is, my sister has 2 daughters, I have a daughter and son. My son covers when his sister is on holiday where he can.

OP posts:
Credittocress · 16/08/2026 17:10

If you choose to take care of your mum that’s on you. No one is obliged to take care of a parent and you certainly can’t just sign up a sibling based on what you think is reasonable.

You need to do what you are happy with, if you aren’t happy with what you are doing then cut back

TriciaMcMillan · 16/08/2026 17:10

I agree with previous posters that you need to start considering other options. How long has your daughter played such a significant role in her grandmother's care? It's sounds like she's doing a tremendous amount, alongside caring for young children. That's unlikely to be sustainable. Does she (and do you) have support through your local carers centre? Carer burnout and consequent breakdown is common and increasingly likely here.

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 17:09

Potooooooooes · 16/08/2026 17:06

Ok.
In my area once you get to needing 4 visits or more per 24 hours, that moves the care needs into the 24 hour care bracket and thus a move to a formal setting is recommended if 24 hour live-in carers is not affordable by the person.

Your Mum is brushing close to this red line, so preparing herself, and the family, to make plans for a move is sensible. We all understand that people would, in an ideal world, remain at home, but circumstances and changes in needs might mean a move to stay safe is best.

I am sending best wishes, a difficult stage is coming.

We don’t want this to happen, she is perfectly okay on her own overnight and for most of the day, the visits are short and we are happy to provide these until it is truly no longer possible to do it at home, not some arbitrary 4 visits rules.
We would rather skip holidays than have to put mum in a home. I will be retiring in a few years and can take on some of the burden to ease up my daughters time and let her get back to work, but for now it works well as she is home with her children anyway.

OP posts:
Pinkbananaa · 16/08/2026 17:09

Its your dd and your choice to care for your dm. I think its crazy your poor dd is burdened with caring for your mother whilst you work. She should be enjoying her life with her young family 3 times a day is crazy. Your sister and her child have put boundaries in place that they dont want to provide care. Personally i dont blame them its abit ask. Your dm needs carers in or a care home or the very least respite

Swipe left for the next trending thread