Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is no good death?

80 replies

SurvivorInstinctIsJustInconvenient · 11/08/2026 17:32

It's either preceded by a long and drawn out period of pain, suffering and loss of dignity or it's quick and painful. Well, I guess in both cases it's painful. It's always painful, isn't it? And shit. No matter how good your life has been the end is always crap. Not that all levels of suffering are the same but I'm just saying that there always is suffering. A lot of suffering. (And even if you satisfy the criteria for euthanasia you are already suffering immensely.) Maybe if you are religious there is some comfort you can take from your faith or maybe it makes it less terrible. I don't know. It's not something I have.

I'm just terrified for my parents. My dad is 90, has a neuro degenerative disorder and dementia. Lost most of his vision and hearing. Can't walk or do anything independently anymore. He is in constant pain. Has paranoid delusions. And he is aware enough to know how much he has lost and that there is little left for him. But he could go on for years like this. And he's always had quite strong faith but the dementia has taken that away as well. I think. And my mum is healthy but equally beholden to his dementia and 24h unreasonable demands. It's a shit life for her as well. I don't even know why I'm posting. Especially not in AIbu. I think it would be nice to hear stories of good deaths. If they exist.

OP posts:
Papyrophile · 11/08/2026 17:39

My beloved DM had a sudden turn in the garden killing ants' nests one sunny Saturday, sat down awkwardly and needed help getting up. She had a comfortable early night, and we talked on Sunday morning when she complained about having a bruised bum. Another quiet day and another early night: she went to bed with a dram, took out her hearing aids and went quietly to sleep and beyond. She was 89 and had been well all her life; had not been to the doctor except for vaccinations (Covid and flu) in nine months. It was very gentle and peaceful, and she lived independently, with some help doing the shopping, to the end.

TheGirlWhoLived · 11/08/2026 17:39

YABU, my nan went a lovely way, very short illness in hospital and then passed with family around her. She would not have been a fan of dementia or being in a nursing home or losing her faculties so I think there are better deaths than others

Lifesyoungdream · 11/08/2026 17:38

People go sleep and just don’t wake up. I would think that was a peaceful way to go.

SpottyPyjama · 11/08/2026 17:37

YABU. My Nan had a lovely death as they go. Out shopping having a lovely afternoon and then by the next day was surrounded by all her family as she painlessly drifted off.

Some people die in their sleep.

Some people have no warning at all and just drop dead out of nowhere.

Obviously not everyone is lucky enough to have a good death, but they do exist and are not uncommon.

Dmsandfloatydress · 11/08/2026 17:36

I dont know, lots of my relatives have had a pretty short end, heartattack and over or dying in their sleep. Im sure it hurts but so does being born, for both the mother and the child. I think this western notion that life shouldnt contain any suffering is childlike and unrealistic. I can imagine the situation with your father is extremely distressing and im very sorry , but i dont think most endings are like this.