Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that I'm better than a computer and a team of mechanics!

53 replies

MargoLivebetter · 07/08/2026 11:52

This is potentially a dull tale for those not mechanically minded - but I can't work out whether I feel pissed off and / or vindicated or both.

When I took my car in for its service and MOT, I said to them, I think one of the cylinders is mis-firing slightly. I said that if felt like the car is "pinking" or "knocking" and when idling the revs are too low. The mechanic chuckled and said "oh, we haven't used the term 'pinking' for years now, but yes, well take a look". He wasn't at all rude, but equally I couldn't help wondering that if a man had handed in his car reporting those issues, if the mechanic would have chuckled and been quite so dismissive.

Pick up the car after its service and asked about the mis-firing. Chap smiled and said "oh, yes you were asking about "pinking" weren't you" again in a slightly dismissive 'silly little woman' way. Well, he said you'll be glad to hear that the computer didn't show any faults in the engine. I queried it and said but at idling speed the revs seem too low, as well as the sensation of mis-firing. He replied saying that the car passed its service and MOT with flying colours, so all was well. As in - shut up & go away now!

Roll on two months and the car sounded considerably worse, so I took it back. Well, wouldn't you know one of the cylinder coils is mis-firing and needs to be replaced!!!! I did remind them that I had reported the mis-fire two months ago and was told once again that the computer hadn't reported any faults.

I'm not a car enthusiast but my long dead father was and I paid attention and picked up lots of useful information. Over the years I've fixed various things and diagnosed various issues myself and yet I can guarantee that when I go into a garage and try to discuss my car in a more technical way other than "its making a funny noise" it is like I'm speaking a foreign language. Grrrrr, we need more female mechanics and maybe some thinking outside of the computer diagnostics!

OP posts:
HobgoblinNorFoulFiend · 07/08/2026 16:40

My late husband could strip an engine and diagnose/fix most things (diesel engine). Garage mechanics were just as dismissive of him as you. He’d order parts and fix things himself and tell them he’d done so when he had to get it MOTd and they were astonished, but still only react to what the EMS said. So no, it’s a sign of the times really more than misogyny.

Walkden · 07/08/2026 16:16

How likely were you to agree to change the coils when you first raised the issue? Sounds like the fault was intermittent and without a code to diagnose which cylinder was at fault there could have been some labour charges to identify which one was at fault / check spark plugs and cylinders condition etc.

Most customers probably would not agree to this until a code comes up on the ems, regardless of sex.

Pistachiocake · 07/08/2026 16:05

TBF I've known men be dismissed in exactly the same way. So yes it could have been sexism, but not necessarily (and the managers at both our local garages are women).
But there seems to be a computer says yes/no attitude to everything these days. Obviously you were right in this case!

Swipe left for the next trending thread