Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I cooking shit or being stingy??

467 replies

Hydranga · 06/08/2026 13:44

Currently on holiday with my sister, her husband, their 8 year old DS Amanda 14 year old daughter

i had originally booked it for just me, DH and Ds (8) but I invited them last minute at no cost to them as sister was stressed about money and not being able to take the kids out.

They have complained non stop about the food. First evening we got a takeaway but first morning they asked what was for breakfast so I said I had porridge or Greek yogurt and fruit and nuts. BIL burst out laughing saying “so it’s either prison food or bird food?”. Sister said “don’t you have anything in for the kids?” So I said I’d got the porridge for the kids and I have honey, jam or Nutella to stir into it. Teen rolled her eyes and sister said “I’ll go to shop later and get something in”. Was it really so bad???

that evening I made spaghetti bolognese. 75g dry pasta each and a 600g pack of mince shared between us all with mushrooms, bacon and various veggies. When I served it BIL pulled a face and said where’s the rest of it? They all started laughing - teen dramatically pulled a bit up from her plate and let it fall back down slowly whilst pulling a face. Sister said “what’s up with you?” And teen said “it tastes funny”. They all laughed.

I was getting pissed off at this point and told them they’re welcome to buy and cook their own food if they’d prefer. BIL said “oh here we go, here’s the catch” so I said no I’m more than happy to carry on buying and cooking but not to be insulted and laughed at. DH then decided to tell everyone I’m always on weird diets which isn’t true, I have ibs so I do try and restrict certain things but he made it out to be about weight loss which it isn’t. DS said he likes the food and DN said “yeah but you’re used to eating crap”

So yesterday I refused to cook. They’d bought their own cereals but when it came to evening meal I told them I was cooking a curry for us 3 so they might want to pop to shop and get something in which they did and came back with dohnuts and loads of sweet food. Fair enough.

tonight sister had told me she can’t afford to go back to shop as they hadn’t budgeted for repeated shopping trips. I’ve told her I’m cooking paella and they’re welcome to join us without insults. She said she’d talk to them.

as of 10 minutes ago teen was still asking what was for dinner so she clearly daren’t tell her.

Am I really cooking shit or being stingy?? I’m starting to wonder if it’s me

OP posts:
theneighboureatmysalad · Yesterday 15:02

member08713 · Yesterday 14:54

Portion sizes and obesity were exactly my thoughts but you’ve been brave enough to say it @Howyoudoings

if you give the same portion size to every person, that might be the problem

member08713 · Yesterday 14:54

Portion sizes and obesity were exactly my thoughts but you’ve been brave enough to say it @Howyoudoings

Howyoudoings · Yesterday 14:40

LejlaKapovic · Yesterday 12:51

No, we just don't eat child portions either.

who said anything about child portions ? These a reason there is an obesity issue in the uk .

Didimum · Yesterday 14:19

I think they are being incredibly rude, without a doubt, and they should graciously keep their mouths shut.

However, yes the food is a bit stingy – we use 400g mince for a spag Bol, and that for two 7yr olds and me who eats very small meat portions – even then it's only just enough. Teens and men are, on average, going to have bigger appetites. And while porridge and yoghurt is ideal for me, I would have extend the breakfast offerings to cereals, toast and eggs.

Again, they are 100% in the wrong, but I can see how a bunch of rude people would complain about the above. You've done a really nice thing for them and I would never complain and I would give my kids a sharp talking to if they did too!

Moreholidaysthanjudithchalmers · Yesterday 13:46

LejlaKapovic · Yesterday 12:51

No, we just don't eat child portions either.

75g dry pasta is the recommended healthy adult portion size (see bupa link I posted easier)
Lots of people add veg or pulses to bulk out red meat for health or cost reasons.
It might not be what they’d have a home eg their bolognese might be a big pack of fatty mince and a jar of smartprice sauce. Op prefers less meat and lots of veg. She’s cooking.
Two garlic bread for 7 people is at least 1/4 garlic bread a person too in addition to pasta so not lacking carbs.
If you are still hungry have a snack.

justasking111 · Yesterday 13:33

ACH. They can go to the supermarket buy their own food and stuff their faces. For goodness sake they must eat at home.

DancingNotDrowning · Yesterday 13:23

It’s all a bit weird.

your sister is rude and ungrateful and you are being odd about the food.

if I invited my DS on holiday as a treat because I knew she was struggling financially I’d want to make sure she had a good time. If that involved getting a loaf of bread and some cocoa pops in for my DNs I absolutely would.

You must surely have eaten with your sister and family before? In which case you must know there’s a lack of alignment around food preferences?

a bit of discussion and give and take over cooking might have worked better for you both. Serving food you must know her fam wouldn’t be keen on and saying it’s that or nothing feels a bit lady bountiful

LejlaKapovic · Yesterday 12:51

Howyoudoings · 06/08/2026 14:21

You seem to eat very similar to me I think a lot of people are use to eating large portions. Sound like your sister has a bad diet. . She also sounds rude and I wouldn’t be cooking for them .

No, we just don't eat child portions either.

LejlaKapovic · Yesterday 12:44

Hydranga · 06/08/2026 13:44

Currently on holiday with my sister, her husband, their 8 year old DS Amanda 14 year old daughter

i had originally booked it for just me, DH and Ds (8) but I invited them last minute at no cost to them as sister was stressed about money and not being able to take the kids out.

They have complained non stop about the food. First evening we got a takeaway but first morning they asked what was for breakfast so I said I had porridge or Greek yogurt and fruit and nuts. BIL burst out laughing saying “so it’s either prison food or bird food?”. Sister said “don’t you have anything in for the kids?” So I said I’d got the porridge for the kids and I have honey, jam or Nutella to stir into it. Teen rolled her eyes and sister said “I’ll go to shop later and get something in”. Was it really so bad???

that evening I made spaghetti bolognese. 75g dry pasta each and a 600g pack of mince shared between us all with mushrooms, bacon and various veggies. When I served it BIL pulled a face and said where’s the rest of it? They all started laughing - teen dramatically pulled a bit up from her plate and let it fall back down slowly whilst pulling a face. Sister said “what’s up with you?” And teen said “it tastes funny”. They all laughed.

I was getting pissed off at this point and told them they’re welcome to buy and cook their own food if they’d prefer. BIL said “oh here we go, here’s the catch” so I said no I’m more than happy to carry on buying and cooking but not to be insulted and laughed at. DH then decided to tell everyone I’m always on weird diets which isn’t true, I have ibs so I do try and restrict certain things but he made it out to be about weight loss which it isn’t. DS said he likes the food and DN said “yeah but you’re used to eating crap”

So yesterday I refused to cook. They’d bought their own cereals but when it came to evening meal I told them I was cooking a curry for us 3 so they might want to pop to shop and get something in which they did and came back with dohnuts and loads of sweet food. Fair enough.

tonight sister had told me she can’t afford to go back to shop as they hadn’t budgeted for repeated shopping trips. I’ve told her I’m cooking paella and they’re welcome to join us without insults. She said she’d talk to them.

as of 10 minutes ago teen was still asking what was for dinner so she clearly daren’t tell her.

Am I really cooking shit or being stingy?? I’m starting to wonder if it’s me

Your portions do sound stingy, to be honest. 75 grams of pasta per person? 600 grams of meat between 7 people? That's quite measly.

Your choice of breakfast also isn't to my taste at all as it's way too carby and sweet, and I'd be hungry again within an hour - but, it's the food your family eats, and the food was bought and prepared for them mainly. Your sister and her husband seem to think they're in a resort, and that you're their personal chef. Why are they asking you "what's there to eat?" when they are adults and capable of planning their own meals? Why is it your responsibility to feed them?

I would tell them you won't be responsible for their meals, it's your vacation, and you don't want to spend it in the kitchen. They are welcome to eat what you prepare anyway, but you won't be taking meal requests from anybody.

TreeDudette · Yesterday 12:36

I wouldn't cook for anyone who was rude about my food. I am old and grumpy and no longer put up with CFers.

theneighboureatmysalad · Yesterday 12:12

Sharptonguedwoman · Yesterday 10:08

As a guest, pasta is fine. What on earth were you envisaging?

there was irony in my post... in reply to previous posts I can't be bothered to quote

theallypallywasp · Yesterday 11:32

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 14:53

I dont really know what to say, i am genuine 😕

Ive seen watery bolognese- which is what you get when you pad it out with mushrooms and veg

For your guests, who you know like a bit of food!

I am a shite cook and I confirm that there is such a thing as watery bolognese when padded out with veg 😄. It is very disappointing but is provided by me a few times a year!
The best bolognese is Delia but it is a right faff on and I'd be fucked if I would do it for anyone in OP's situation. They would be getting Dolmio!

Moreholidaysthanjudithchalmers · Yesterday 11:10

Just because Op is making some meals in the holiday home it doesn’t mean they aren’t having any special holiday treats. The Nutella might have been an extra for her ds not a daily staple.
When I was small my mum would cook on holiday but we’d have those mini cereal boxes as a treat and ice cream out etc.
I’d class things like ice cream, a cornish pasty, fish and chips as holiday treats but not want to eat fatty or sweet stuff for all meals. It’s nice after a busy day to have something like bolognese and garlic bread, maybe play some board games. Op is baking so homemade cake is available.
It sounds like Op and sister have very different lifestyles.

Lookingdownthebarrell · Yesterday 11:06

You know they’re being ungrateful and exceptionally rude. How many days gone and how many more to go? In your situation I would ask them to pack up and go back home to their home and frozen food as it sounds they’d be happier back home.

Moreholidaysthanjudithchalmers · Yesterday 11:00

Who decides what is a ‘proper range’ of breakfast food? Op is self catering on holiday not a 5 star hotel buffet. There was porridge, yoghurt, fruit, nuts, honey, nutella. If you want toast pop to shop for bread or if your teen is fussy and only eats coco pops or brioche bring some.
I suspect whatever Op had bought would have been rudely sneered at. Eg if she had served seeded toast they wouldn’t have wanted white toastie loaf. Sausages from farm shop too herby etc.

ElectoralControversy · Yesterday 10:41

I do a shared holiday with family every year; we take it in turn to cook (and pay for) dinner and we do anything thats simple and multiplies up well - I actually did bolognaise on my night this year and had no complaints and many coming up for seconds.

The secret is to cook down the vegetables first so they're not watery, for those recoiling in horror ...and of course you add bacon, most italian recipes call for pancetta in with the soffrito

Highly unreasonable to suggest op is 'hosting' and should be providing dinner party level food, its her holiday too!

Yetone · Yesterday 10:09

TheOctopus · Yesterday 09:51

I agree with this. I wouldn't eat more in quantity on holiday but what I do want is nice, special food that is a little different from the daily menu at home.

But you can’t expect your sister to provide this for you. Op said she was sharing with her sister not hosting.

Sharptonguedwoman · Yesterday 10:08

theneighboureatmysalad · 06/08/2026 20:14

I would be surprised if I was served a lazy dish like pasta when someone is "hosting". That's kids food and family food on busy work days.

Bit odd to serve pasta when you host guests? I'd make more of an effort but each to their own.

As a guest, pasta is fine. What on earth were you envisaging?

Wadsworthy · Yesterday 10:06

TheOctopus · Yesterday 09:51

I agree with this. I wouldn't eat more in quantity on holiday but what I do want is nice, special food that is a little different from the daily menu at home.

But you would expect to pay for it, or cook it yourself, on a family holiday, I assume?

Or are you the OP's brother-in-law?

Tamtim · Yesterday 10:02

The three of them are arseholes. Never invite them away again. Imagine being treated to a free holiday including all meals cooked for you and behaving that way. I could never. Your son sounds lovely. Well done you for raising a sweet, gracious human.

I would raise the behaviour with your sister upon return.

Sharptonguedwoman · Yesterday 10:01

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 15:48

No sorry, only offering granola to your guests on their holidays isnt appropriate.

You offer a proper range of food

That said, as ive said - you wouldnt be rude to the host.

The 'guests' can go and get bread for toast or bacon or whatever, surely.

Teacaketravesty · Yesterday 09:59

TheRealMagic · 06/08/2026 20:25

To be fair I suspect the BIL is really embarrassed that they've basically had to accept charity from his SIL to be able to give their kids a holiday at all. While it's not an ok reaction to be so incredibly rude in the face of that charity, I think that's probably why he's trying to throw his weight around and assert himself. He sounds like the kind of 'bloke' who probably feels quite emasculated by the whole thing.

Yeah, and maybe OP’s sister’s feeling insecure about it too, esp if there’s history of OP ‘doing better’ than her. If this is the case, let it slide off you, @Hydranga. If it weren’t the food it’d be some other constructed moan to devalue your gift so they don’t have the discomfort of feeling grateful.

TheOctopus · Yesterday 09:51

Yetone · 06/08/2026 21:50

But anyone who regularly ate the right amount of food would probably not want extra on holiday.

I agree with this. I wouldn't eat more in quantity on holiday but what I do want is nice, special food that is a little different from the daily menu at home.

SaySomethingMan · Yesterday 08:37

Wow how are they so entitled and rude, especially as it seems they can’t afford to feed themselves.

They probably should return home. They’re ruining your holiday. Did you know they’re like this?

I don’t see anything wrong with what you have offered and honestly don’t understand how they were planning on you feeding them for the whole holiday, not planning to cook meals for you all, etc.

Maybe they’re behaving badly out of embarrassment.

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · Yesterday 08:19

Delatron · Yesterday 08:07

For all those moaning about granola, fruit, yoghurt and porridge - or saying the teen may not eat those. It would have been really easy for the sister to throw a bag of supermarket croissants/ a box of cereal/ loaf of bread/jam - in the car with them no? Especially if you know you have a fussy eater.

They are having a free holiday. They are being unspeakably rude.

Exactly. I have a teenager who wouldn't eat fruit yoghurt granola or porridge at breakfast time. If we were invited on a free holiday at short notice I would grab a shopping bag and take our cereal and nutella and other regular supplies from the larder

Swipe left for the next trending thread