Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I cooking shit or being stingy??

491 replies

Hydranga · 06/08/2026 13:44

Currently on holiday with my sister, her husband, their 8 year old DS Amanda 14 year old daughter

i had originally booked it for just me, DH and Ds (8) but I invited them last minute at no cost to them as sister was stressed about money and not being able to take the kids out.

They have complained non stop about the food. First evening we got a takeaway but first morning they asked what was for breakfast so I said I had porridge or Greek yogurt and fruit and nuts. BIL burst out laughing saying “so it’s either prison food or bird food?”. Sister said “don’t you have anything in for the kids?” So I said I’d got the porridge for the kids and I have honey, jam or Nutella to stir into it. Teen rolled her eyes and sister said “I’ll go to shop later and get something in”. Was it really so bad???

that evening I made spaghetti bolognese. 75g dry pasta each and a 600g pack of mince shared between us all with mushrooms, bacon and various veggies. When I served it BIL pulled a face and said where’s the rest of it? They all started laughing - teen dramatically pulled a bit up from her plate and let it fall back down slowly whilst pulling a face. Sister said “what’s up with you?” And teen said “it tastes funny”. They all laughed.

I was getting pissed off at this point and told them they’re welcome to buy and cook their own food if they’d prefer. BIL said “oh here we go, here’s the catch” so I said no I’m more than happy to carry on buying and cooking but not to be insulted and laughed at. DH then decided to tell everyone I’m always on weird diets which isn’t true, I have ibs so I do try and restrict certain things but he made it out to be about weight loss which it isn’t. DS said he likes the food and DN said “yeah but you’re used to eating crap”

So yesterday I refused to cook. They’d bought their own cereals but when it came to evening meal I told them I was cooking a curry for us 3 so they might want to pop to shop and get something in which they did and came back with dohnuts and loads of sweet food. Fair enough.

tonight sister had told me she can’t afford to go back to shop as they hadn’t budgeted for repeated shopping trips. I’ve told her I’m cooking paella and they’re welcome to join us without insults. She said she’d talk to them.

as of 10 minutes ago teen was still asking what was for dinner so she clearly daren’t tell her.

Am I really cooking shit or being stingy?? I’m starting to wonder if it’s me

OP posts:
PickyTits · 06/08/2026 17:59

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:09

Who said its nasty to offer the food choices the op has?

What insecurities, who said I am insecure?!

Youre making stuff up really. And, I answered the op's question. The thread hasnt been derailed at all, i am responding to those who feel the op is not being unreasonable, where as I think she is being unreasonable.

Sounds like youre projecting because of your reference to your sil's body type.

Bit rich of you (unlike your fatty bolognese) to accuse others of making stuff up when you have repeatedly derailed the entire thread by fabricating some imaginary watery bolognese. If you don't know how to correctly cook a bolognese without making watery when including vegetables then just say that, no need to accuse others of substandard cooking just because yours isn't up to scratch.

Zoopet · 06/08/2026 17:58

Pardon the pun but this thread has turned into a bun fight!
I'm Team OP!

hoarahloux · 06/08/2026 17:54

Your food sounds great, 75g of pasta in a meat and vegetable sauce is a completely normal portion with garlic bread. I wouldn't be making them anything else. And if they want a bit of Victoria sponge they can go and buy their own from Tesco 😊

and since people keep feeling the need to let everyone know they're Normal and Not Fat and eat Much More Pasta, I'm a big fatty and 75g per person is what I weigh out every time.

ShakaWhenTheWallsFell · 06/08/2026 17:54

First off, they're obviously rude and ungrateful. But, I really don't understand how this has blown up on holiday.

They’re your family, haven't they been round to yours to eat before? How do they not know the sorts of meals you typically cook and have a vague idea of the portion size you dish up?
When you invited them, how was their no discussion about foid/cooking. It's fine that they don't like the same food as you, it's fine for them to have different preferences and eat larger portions. But I'm assuming they wouldn't have been in the dark on this. How did they not express that and suggest that the two families would keep cooking separate to cater to your different rates? Or they'd bring the snacks and extra sides to contribute?

Your food choices sound fine, but wouldn't all be to my preference in a holiday situation, and your portions would be on the low side for my family (we're healthy weights before you ask) But I think one adult could talk to another about this without hurting anyone's feelings. Families all have a different idea of what is normal. The way they've handled it is just rude. Maybe you've handled it poorly too. Do you think what you do in your family is "correct"? Are they responding to your implicit judgement of their food choices? Do you think you're better than them? Do they think you think that, even if it's not true ? They probably have a chip on their shoulder anyway since there's a wealth disparity. Not saying that's right, but it's a human thing to feel jealous. And maybe they're pushing back with rudeness at their perceived version of you lording it over them with your charitable holiday offer and "good" food choices

Merryoldgoat · 06/08/2026 17:52

600g of mince for 7 people is not enough in my opinion but there are separate issues here:

  1. On a holiday like this where food is cooked and shared it’s usual to discuss expectations and what people like - if I invited people on holiday with me and was covering the costs I would ask what they like for breakfast and other foods in general.
  2. Regardless of how they feel about the food their rudeness is inexcusable.
  3. If money is so tight that your sister can’t go to the shop you shouldn’t have invited her if you aren’t covering all the costs. Adding monetary stress to a supposed holiday just puts everyone on edge.

Your sister and her family sound like they have a different lifestyle to you and if that’s the case, a holiday like this where you are sharing all meals would always be fraught.

TheChosenTwo · 06/08/2026 17:49

The spag Bol serving size is much smaller than we would prepare and eat at home, also when hosting and especially when on holiday we tend to offer more (although in my mind spag Bol is not holiday food and I don’t know why 😂).
Food/meals etc should really have been discussed beforehand, I wouldn’t want someone deciding on meals for me on holiday - they would have had to have fed themselves at home so they should be spending the money now on nice food they want to eat, contributing to the holiday in some way.
Was it said to them before you left that you would be cooking and/or all meals? With further information so they could decide whether they would join in or make something separately? The whole set up is quite confusing!

Anyway, you’ve done a nice thing but they should really have declined your invite if they don’t have any spare cash at all.
if perhaps they were planning on spending the next week running down their freezer and eating a random assortment from their cupboards until payday or whatever then maybe they just really don’t have any extra money. But then it would take more than a free holiday for me to go somewhere totally empty handed, if I knew I could contribute absolutely nothing then I’d have thanked you and stayed at home.

FishersGate · 06/08/2026 17:41

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:35

When did I say I eat junk? I eat well cooked meals and provide the same for my guests

I am not looking down on anyone but stating my opinion to the aibu

What are your well cooked meals?

What is not well cooked about a spaghetti bol on holiday.

OP nothing wrong with your meals. We holiday abroad every year to a family home and out breakfasts consists of muesli fruit greek yoghurt. Occasionally crossiants for the beach. There is leeway rest of the day day for ice creams, fizzy drinks, meal out. I cook a spaghetti bol once a week there too. Even at our all inclusive in May this year our breakfasts were the same.

Just got rude ungrateful family i am afraid

Babyboomtastic · 06/08/2026 17:40

pinkspeakers · 06/08/2026 17:34

100g for mince absolutely is enough for a meal! I've been browsing recipes online and it seems to be a completely standard portion size. I don't think Jamie Oliver is known for skimpy portions and he uses 500g mince for six people Best spaghetti Bolognese recipe | Easy guide BBC recipe the same The best spaghetti bolognese recipe (with video) | Good Food. And my sisters absolutely love my homemade granola with yoghurt and berries and would be very disappointed if it wasn't served when we holiday together!

But the main points are that people going on holiday together should always discuss and plan food together in advance, even if only to agree that they will cater separately. And the OP's relatives are very very rude!

I agree about the size tbh.
I've got a 750g pack of mince for lasagne tomorrow which will be for 4 adults and 2 kids. There will be leftovers. For the 4 of us (2 adults, 2 kids), I'd use a 500g pack (plus bacon) and there is usually leftovers.

I did pasta yesterday, which was 480g for the 4 of us, and there was enough leftover food lunch for 2 adults today and some snacking in between. One of my children does eat like a sparrow though.

I don't understand why they op wouldn't discuss meal planning in advance though. Not everyone eats seafood so paella is quite a brave dish to cook without discussing it.

DandelionClockSeeds · 06/08/2026 17:39

Id have struggled with breakfast - as im a fussy bugger who won't eat yoghurt or porridge. Id have eaten some fruit and bought bread for the other mornings.

Your evening meals sound great.

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:35

ThisOneLife · 06/08/2026 17:32

You’re the one “looking down” on people. You admit you eat junk but can’t conceive that good cooked well that has veg in it, is not watery. Get some lessons!

When did I say I eat junk? I eat well cooked meals and provide the same for my guests

I am not looking down on anyone but stating my opinion to the aibu

pinkspeakers · 06/08/2026 17:34

100g for mince absolutely is enough for a meal! I've been browsing recipes online and it seems to be a completely standard portion size. I don't think Jamie Oliver is known for skimpy portions and he uses 500g mince for six people Best spaghetti Bolognese recipe | Easy guide BBC recipe the same The best spaghetti bolognese recipe (with video) | Good Food. And my sisters absolutely love my homemade granola with yoghurt and berries and would be very disappointed if it wasn't served when we holiday together!

But the main points are that people going on holiday together should always discuss and plan food together in advance, even if only to agree that they will cater separately. And the OP's relatives are very very rude!

Two bowls of spaghetti topped with bolognese sauce and a pan of extra sauce on the side.

The best spaghetti bolognese recipe

Our best ever spaghetti bolognese is super easy and a true Italian classic with a meaty, chilli sauce. This pasta bolognese recipe is sure to become a family favourite.

https://www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/best-spaghetti-bolognese-recipe

IronEverything · 06/08/2026 17:33

ThisOneLife · 06/08/2026 17:28

I learned from an Italian chef how to make proper ragu (bolognaise). For depth of flavour it has mushrooms, celery, carrots, herbs and pancetta as well as meat tomatoes and onions. That’s the correct way to make it. What’s often offered up in the UK bears NO resemblance.

Did your "proper Italian chef" (who obviously doesn't make a traditional Bolognese) forget to tell you that people can cook and eat whatever they want?

A chicken tikka masala isn't proper Indian food. Doesn't mean it isn't delicious.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/08/2026 17:33

I think the Italian chef conversations are a bit of a derail!

OP only needs to establish it was a decent meal (which it was imo) not that it was a “proper” Italian bolognese or ragu.

Babyboomtastic · 06/08/2026 17:32

Apparently the authentic recipe for Bolognese registered with the Italian Academy of Cooking only uses beef, pancetta, onions, carrots, celery, tomato paste, white or red wine, broth, and a little milk.

ThisOneLife · 06/08/2026 17:32

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:19

Porridge and mushrooms make you 'above' someone?!

No need to look down your nose at people

Edited

You’re the one “looking down” on people. You admit you eat junk but can’t conceive that good cooked well that has veg in it, is not watery. Get some lessons!

Babyboomtastic · 06/08/2026 17:31

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:29

The proper italian chef i knew would be disgusted, and states that only a soffrito is the veg needed.

Absolutely. No mushrooms!!!

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:29

ThisOneLife · 06/08/2026 17:28

I learned from an Italian chef how to make proper ragu (bolognaise). For depth of flavour it has mushrooms, celery, carrots, herbs and pancetta as well as meat tomatoes and onions. That’s the correct way to make it. What’s often offered up in the UK bears NO resemblance.

The proper italian chef i knew would be disgusted, and states that only a soffrito is the veg needed.

ThisOneLife · 06/08/2026 17:28

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 14:28

How?!

Mushroom and veggies in a bolognese for guests!

I understand if its a quick weeknight dinner for the kids

Whats yours then?

I learned from an Italian chef how to make proper ragu (bolognaise). For depth of flavour it has mushrooms, celery, carrots, herbs and pancetta as well as meat tomatoes and onions. That’s the correct way to make it. What’s often offered up in the UK bears NO resemblance.

Babyboomtastic · 06/08/2026 17:27

Greenandyellowday · 06/08/2026 17:16

But quick (or fake) Bolognese is supposed to be made with vegetables. You start off by making a sofrito of sautéed onion, celery and carrot.

Absolutely. But not mushrooms and 'various veggies'. Mushrooms in Bolognese are more contentious than pineapple on pizza, and the sort of ingredient that many people (especially kids) went like. Bolognese shouldn't just be used as coffee for beefy pasta sauce with random other ingredients thrown in.

Personally, I think mushrooms in Bolognese are an abomination! And not even having a loaf of bread for toast at breakfast is IMO odd.

If I was catering for another family as well as my own, I'd discuss the meal plan and dietary stuff in advance personally.

This doesn't excuse the rudeness of the SIL and family though.

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:26

theneighboureatmysalad · 06/08/2026 17:23

we get it, YOU are the sister.

It's more than acceptable to look down at people as rude as sister and her family are.

I am not 🤣

I have hosted people and so offer advice on that basis

And it really isnt okay to imply that someone isnt as good as you because they want feeding on their holidays

Dragonflyspeeding · 06/08/2026 17:26

They are being rude BUT the spag Bol portions seem very small tbh.

I don’t understand why they can’t shop and cook alternative evenings. It really isn’t fair for one person to do it every day.

Badgerstmary · 06/08/2026 17:24

Op your food sounds delicious & just the sort of food we cook. It was incredibly rude of them to complain about what you are paying for & cooking for them.
You say they had already bought their weeks shopping & it was mostly frozen. What do they normally eat in a typical day? Was there no meat, fish, fruit, veg, carbs they could have brought with them? If this is the case then your delicious , healthy food must have been a shock for them.
En joy your paella.

theneighboureatmysalad · 06/08/2026 17:23

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:19

Porridge and mushrooms make you 'above' someone?!

No need to look down your nose at people

Edited

we get it, YOU are the sister.

It's more than acceptable to look down at people as rude as sister and her family are.

BobbysDazzler · 06/08/2026 17:19

I think its the family who are the problem and are being ungrateful and rude. If they don't like it then buy and cook their own, you have given them a free holiday, you can't be expected to supply everything else as well surely?!

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:19

Bollihobs · 06/08/2026 17:16

It was 600g plus mushrooms, bacon and vegetables with garlic bread as a side. Hardly stingy. Standard guide on dried pasta for an adult would be 75g per serving. And no point making enough for "seconds" if they were being rude about the "firsts".

OP your food sounds amazing, tasty and more than enough - dare I say it's a bit "above them"? Are they more takeaways, ready meals and trays of doughnuts types? Sod them, you do you and let them see to themselves food wise. And as for how they are speaking to you, I cut that off too - be nice or go home.

Edited

Porridge and mushrooms make you 'above' someone?!

No need to look down your nose at people