Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I get that a&e is busy, but was not expecting to be spoken to so rudely

833 replies

mitsicar · 05/08/2026 23:21

Went to a&e tonight. I have a foreign object stuck in my ear. I did not know it was in there until someone looked last night before I left my house and said i should get it looked at. Wasn't able to go to a&e today as my son had his own medical appointment in another city that I have waited months for and we were in a hotel for last night. There was no way I was cancelling it for my own ailment.

The pain has got significantly worse. Have shooting pains into my jaw and cheek bone and my ear is making clicking noises. This is since about lunch time today. Went to a&e this evening and the triage nurse asked me how long it had been in my ear. I said I suspect a few weeks, but I thought I just had an earache and it went away after a while so thought it was gone. Got some new foam ear plugs last week (which obviously pushed the foreign body in further!) and am now suffering for it. I hadn't finished when she cut me off and said 'well I don't really understand why you have picked this evening to come to a&e' and told me I would be better off going to my GP. I am in some pain but ended up leaving because she just made me feel like I had done an awful thing by heading straight after my son's appointment. I spoke to 111 earlier in the day and they told me to go to a&e asap because I could risk my hearing and that whilst it isn't life threatening, it is both an accident and an emergency. I asked if I could wait until morning and they said no. This was the 111 dr not the triage staff. I have no idea if this is the correct advice.

AIBU to think I didn't do anything wrong? I told her a medical professional has looked at it (a friend of mine who is a dr of 30 years) and said it needs ent because of how far in it is and she actually rolled her eyes at me and said I should see an actual GP (I suspect by that she meant my own GP?) and that a&e were sending everyone to minor injuries and that cases like mine are the reason she now has a 6 hour waiting list.

Is this normal for a&e now? Is it so awful working there that being rude has just become the norm or do most people have a better bedside manner? I haven't been to a&e since I was a child and was really shocked by the way I was spoken to, after being advised to go there by 111 and a trusted friend who is a medical doctor (GP).

To add, she didn't look in my ear.

Would you have done anything different? Am I missing something?

OP posts:
amijustnaive · 06/08/2026 07:02

W333ds · 06/08/2026 06:57

It’s hugely difficult to get a GP appointment for many. Surgeries switch off online booking early in the day for many and there is more often than not a 2 week wait if you do get to fill out a form. No GP is going to fiddle around with the inner ear. I guess the op is supposed to wait until the object has got infected and she’s rolling round in agony.

No, but the fact she could wait for a date and time that was convenient to her suggests that it’s not quite a&e material. Go to MIU.

Totalmayhem · 06/08/2026 07:01

TheGoldenOwl · 06/08/2026 06:56

Play on their hierarchy.

"She was sent here by her doctor. You think a doctor is wrong? That is concerning. Can you put this in writing so that I can take it back to the surgery. You're sure the doctor is wrong? If that is the case I will make a complaint to the GP surgery saying the nurse said the doctor there was wrong."

Then watch then go "uuhhh no errr no no of course not uhhhh"

Edited

I like that tactic! Will use it at some point no doubt. My dd has 4(!) friends who have been sent to our local hospital with suspected appendicitis in recent years and then had them burst because they leave them hanging around for days….

W333ds · 06/08/2026 06:57

It’s hugely difficult to get a GP appointment for many. Surgeries switch off online booking early in the day for many and there is more often than not a 2 week wait if you do get to fill out a form. No GP is going to fiddle around with the inner ear. I guess the op is supposed to wait until the object has got infected and she’s rolling round in agony.

TheGoldenOwl · 06/08/2026 06:56

Rainallnight · 06/08/2026 06:49

My DD was sent to paeds A&E by the GP last week with suspected appendicitis. The triage nurses were very dismissive and told me ‘she looked fine’.

Sbe had surgery to remove her appendix the next day.

Play on their hierarchy.

"She was sent here by her doctor. You think a doctor is wrong? That is concerning. Can you put this in writing so that I can take it back to the surgery. You're sure the doctor is wrong? If that is the case I will make a complaint to the GP surgery saying the nurse said the doctor there was wrong."

Then watch then go "uuhhh no errr no no of course not uhhhh"

Totalmayhem · 06/08/2026 06:54

Miu is exactly where you should be - your gp can do nothing to sort this. Go back, it’s where you were told to go by 111. Incidentally I also had an unpleasant experience with our local MIU this week - at ours you have to make an appointment - I rang them to say I had a dc with an injury (open & bleeding) and they just flatly & rudely said ‘no space today’, I asked where else they’d recommend I try instead and she said ‘no idea, how would I know?’. I ended up driving to another miu an hour away who sorted the injury really efficiently and quickly. I get they are under pressure but being rude is just so unnecessary- especially in your case where you’ve gone home with an issue that really needs sorting! Get yourself back there and put on a thicker skin. Hope they sort you asap.

amijustnaive · 06/08/2026 06:53

OneAmberFinch · 06/08/2026 06:52

Agree, I don't really see the purpose of a service which just says "go to A&E, we can't risk telling you anything different". Also have had several pointless visits until I wised up!

Yep. It told me to go to a&e for eczema once. I just wanted help with getting a GP appointment.

I’ve found it’s much more useful to phone, but every single encounter is recorded on your record. I find that annoying.

TheGoldenOwl · 06/08/2026 06:52

There are signs everywhere about "zero tolerance for rude behaviour to medical staff"

...pity we patients can't have the same!

Iocanepowder · 06/08/2026 06:52

amijustnaive · 06/08/2026 06:47

The nurse is right. It clearly wasn’t an emergency. You should’ve gone to your local urgent treatment centre. What a waste of time, leaving!

All very well saying that but not all places have those separately to the actual hospital. Where I live doesn’t.

OneAmberFinch · 06/08/2026 06:52

Shatenoeuf · 05/08/2026 23:31

This.
A&E is for when people need immediate medical treatment in life threatening situations.

111 really is ridiculous. They send everyone to A&E. I've stopped using it after 3 embarrassing visits to A&E.

Call your gp.

Agree, I don't really see the purpose of a service which just says "go to A&E, we can't risk telling you anything different". Also have had several pointless visits until I wised up!

TheGoldenOwl · 06/08/2026 06:51

roshi42 · 06/08/2026 05:18

I’ve been to the GP maybe 5 times over the past few years and have been sent to A&E every time. I don’t know what the GP actually does anymore tbh. Everything just gets sent straight to A&E and you wait for 4 hours feeling guilty for being there

"I dont know what the GP does anymore"

They are glorified pharmacists.

Rainallnight · 06/08/2026 06:49

My DD was sent to paeds A&E by the GP last week with suspected appendicitis. The triage nurses were very dismissive and told me ‘she looked fine’.

Sbe had surgery to remove her appendix the next day.

justaquickquestionifyouplease · 06/08/2026 06:48

UniquePinkSwan · 06/08/2026 06:47

IME nurses are usually like this. I used to work in a call centre and would get a lot of nurses. They were the most entitled, abusive people who phoned. I now don’t have a lot of time for them.

That’s really stereotypical and rude.

justaquickquestionifyouplease · 06/08/2026 06:48

I repeat, the GP won’t touch this, it’s an urgent treatment centre job.

amijustnaive · 06/08/2026 06:47

The nurse is right. It clearly wasn’t an emergency. You should’ve gone to your local urgent treatment centre. What a waste of time, leaving!

UniquePinkSwan · 06/08/2026 06:47

IME nurses are usually like this. I used to work in a call centre and would get a lot of nurses. They were the most entitled, abusive people who phoned. I now don’t have a lot of time for them.

Iocanepowder · 06/08/2026 06:45

Gettingbysomehow · 05/08/2026 23:37

I also went into a&e last week OP with red flag symptoms. Bear in mind Ive been a medical professional for 46 years so I only go if its absolutely essential.
I was given an extremely cursory examination and told this is a&e why are you here and dismissed.
I cant go into too much detail as its subject to a complaint.
I was not happy with this and went to the next hospital 30 miles away where I was rushed in for emergency surgery and told if Id gone home I would have died.
A quick look on AI would have given ghe a& e staff all the info they needed to treat me.
Instead they chose to insult me and send me home.
The hospital who did my op told me to put a formal comaint in.
Im not going to that a&e ever again!
Have you called 111 OP they give really good advice in situations like this and Id Dvise you to call them before going into a&e next time.

That’s awful! Good on you for making the trip to the other hospital as I doubt most other people would have done that. Hope they take your complaint seriously.

I made a recent complaint to my GP surgery after a GP completely dismissed something my 1 year old ended up needing surgery for and I had to go private to be taken seriously. They didn’t deal with my complaint properly but i will just refuse to see that GP again.

TheGoldenOwl · 06/08/2026 06:44

mitsicar · 05/08/2026 23:31

A GP will not touch it apparently. My friend, who has been a GP for 31 yrs said he sends all cases like this to a&e when it is right next to the ear drum as they are the only people with specialist tools to remove it. A referral to ENT takes weeks.

Our GP has said she cant do anything on an urgent basis and sends most people to A&E.

Are posters really suggesting that you shpuld wait a two to three months for an GP triggered ENT referral?

You were right to be in A&E, ideally minor injuries if there is one, which is where you were.

The nurse/receptionist was wrong.

Reallyneedsaholiday · 06/08/2026 06:43

I’d head back to the minor injuries unit first thing this morning. Shift change at 7, so the nurse will have gone home, and it’ll be a lot quieter now, than it was last night. GP won’t be able to remove it, and frankly, shouldn’t try. The most they will do, is give a “referral” to avoid you being sent home again. Good luck

Iocanepowder · 06/08/2026 06:38

JMSA · 06/08/2026 04:30

Seriously? 😂 Jesus …

I was going to suggest putting a complaint in as well. What is the point in working there if the nurse acts like that with patients who need treatment? Especially if op sees the gp today and gets sent back to the same place. Everyone’s time has been wasted.

Op speak to the gp this morning and then just do what they ask. If any more staff are rude to you, get their name and advise you’ll be complaining to PALS.

And yes do bring snacks and water if you get sent back to hospital as you’ll be waiting hours.

Snooples · 06/08/2026 06:35

Straight back to miu. Don’t waste a GP appointment as you’ve already been referred by 111. You caught a nurse on a busy day but that doesn’t mean you start the process again. Follow the advice 111 gave, your hearing might thank you for it.

Ineffable23 · 06/08/2026 06:29

I think the GP will send you back to minor injuries. The hotness and pain is worrying. Please keep a careful eye and go back if you're worried. You can't mess about with potential infections in ears/eyes etc.

Goditsmemargaret · 06/08/2026 06:22

What a horrible woman.

I remember going for chemo right at the start of COVID. I had advanced blood cancer. I was about six weeks into my regime so had gotten familiar with the staff. The usual woman came over and was setting me up then noticed on my file I'd been sent to a&e earlier that week with a fever so asked me about it. I told her what happened then commented it was crazy seeing a&e so quiet (due to lockdown), empty seats and beds.

It was just an observation of another big change during lockdown.

She immediately stopped what she was doing and conspiratorially leaned in.
"I agree with you, it's ridiculous how busy it is otherwise and just goes to show how many people are abusive the system normally. There is nothing, wrong with them - nothing! I worked there for years. Yet they are piling into a&e simply because they want some attention."

I heavily disliked her after that. Some months later I was sent to a&e again. A different nurse was checking me in, she was chatting as she did so and said something along the same lines; "look at all the people here, and its the same people showing up. They just have nothing to do so they are in here annoying the staff "

I don't feel sorry for a&e staff anymore. Nobody is forcing them to be there and the times I was there I had no choice and was repeatedly subjected to hours and hours of waiting followed by rude staff

BlackRowan · 06/08/2026 06:20

You need to advocate for yourself and not just leave because of one nurse. You should have told her about your pain that got significantly worse and that you consulted 111 who told you to go there.

having said that you might get faster help from the GP. If a GP can’t remove an object they have become completely useless

PersephoneParlormaid · 06/08/2026 06:19

A GP doesn’t have the equipment to remove the foreign object, they will refer you to minor injuries or A&E. You’d have been better ignoring the rude nurse, telling her you were told to go there by 111, and staying put. Now you’re going to use a GP appointment and then end up going back to hospital.

OvernightBloats · 06/08/2026 05:54

I had a similar problem - a bit of a silicone earplug fell apart and got stuck in my ear. I went to the GP explained the problem and the practice nurse immediately tried to get it out. She couldn't. I was then referred to ENT at the local hospital. Think the appointment was a couple of days later (can't exactly remember).

The 111 service gave you the wrong advice and I would have told the nurse in A&E that this had happened. She needs to know that you had only been following their advice. Sorry she was rude, that is uncalled for, but it must be one hell of a stressful job.

Try your GP first, to save you another long wait at A&E. Good luck.