Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this view re autism frustrating

483 replies

Pleasenomorespiders · 04/08/2026 19:25

Somebody today tried to argue that autism is simply a 'gift' because people like Einstein supposedly had it, I suppose they're talking about people on the spectrum being more gifted and talented in some areas.
This person must surely realise it's a spectrum and has failed to mention how debilitating autism can be, how much people with it can struggle in every aspect of life and may never be able to have a 'normal' life.

Calling it a 'gift' is nice, they're only thinking about high-functioning individuals who as I say have heightened awareness and notice patterns, artistically or mathematically gifted, or whatever it may be. Autism is simply not 'just seeing the world differently'. Many individuals will never have a job or a relationship.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
TigerRag · 05/08/2026 15:24

Agasagas · 05/08/2026 15:18

So how autism presents differently in women and girls should be ignored and they should be shut out of the diagnosis process as they were before. The late diagnosed and people of colour who were not see before through no fault of their own should not get a diagnosis. We should not recognise that you can have Autism and AdHD or recognise sensory needs although extensive evidence shows otherwise.

This is what It's Frith said. Were apparently jumping on the bandwagon as we're late diagnosed

Agasagas · 05/08/2026 15:22

Onmytod24 · 05/08/2026 15:21

Is that what I said? No it wasn’t.

That is what you’re saying if you say she’s got it right because that’s what she is saying.

Onmytod24 · 05/08/2026 15:21

Agasagas · 05/08/2026 15:18

So how autism presents differently in women and girls should be ignored and they should be shut out of the diagnosis process as they were before. The late diagnosed and people of colour who were not see before through no fault of their own should not get a diagnosis. We should not recognise that you can have Autism and AdHD or recognise sensory needs although extensive evidence shows otherwise.

Is that what I said? No it wasn’t.

Agasagas · 05/08/2026 15:18

Onmytod24 · 05/08/2026 14:50

I think she’s got it bang on. working in schools for the last X number of years ive seen what constitutes autism completely and utterly change

So how autism presents differently in women and girls should be ignored and they should be shut out of the diagnosis process as they were before. The late diagnosed and people of colour who were not see before through no fault of their own should not get a diagnosis. We should not recognise that you can have Autism and AdHD or recognise sensory needs although extensive evidence shows otherwise.

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 15:09

TigerRag · 05/08/2026 15:06

But we don't have anxiety. We have autism

But doesn't the autism cause the anxiety, stress, burnout, shutting down? That was my understanding for the pp in regards to adjustments/ support and is also what i've seen/ heard people say previously.

TigerRag · 05/08/2026 15:06

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 15:03

Mh support isn't pills though and yes am I am replying to this as you are being very rude and I hadn't read this when I posted.

Mh support varies and there's nothing wromg with needing it, many people do. Shutting down in social situations can be supported, likewise anxiety and stress. Lot's of people suffer like this.

You are proving my point for me with your posts.

But we don't have anxiety. We have autism

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 15:04

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 15:03

Mh support isn't pills though and yes am I am replying to this as you are being very rude and I hadn't read this when I posted.

Mh support varies and there's nothing wromg with needing it, many people do. Shutting down in social situations can be supported, likewise anxiety and stress. Lot's of people suffer like this.

You are proving my point for me with your posts.

No, I am not. You are being deliberately ignorant.

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 15:03

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 14:58

Exactly. It's so fucking dismissive to be told "oh, it's your mental health". Like I can just be given some pills and sent away.

Mh support isn't pills though and yes am I am replying to this as you are being very rude and I hadn't read this when I posted.

Mh support varies and there's nothing wromg with needing it, many people do. Shutting down in social situations can be supported, likewise anxiety and stress. Lot's of people suffer like this.

You are proving my point for me with your posts.

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 15:03

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 14:59

I am genuinely interested. I also don't want to upset you any further so please don't reply to me any further if it is.

I'm not upset, I'm frustrated that when I say I don't have MH issues, people still insist on trying to tell me that I do.

I've spent years going back and forth to the doctor because I was misdiagnosed with mental health issues and fobbed off with medication and various "adjustments" that made absolutely no difference because my mental health has never been the problem.

MyDarlingRose · 05/08/2026 15:01

I think ‘doubly exceptional’ is the term used for those with autism and extreme intelligence isn’t it? Because it acknowledges their IQ/ability but also their disability.

x2boys · 05/08/2026 15:00

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 14:43

Well no my ds won't. He has to have 2:1 support to go out and it would be a safeguarding failure for his carers to take him to somewhere like a supermarket as it is documented in his care plan that he shouldn't go.

He won't ever learn to drive, the suggestion is laughable. He will likely have high rate of mobility for as long as PIP is around so no public transport. He's also given sedatives for flying.

What he is exposed to isn't in his hands; where he goes and what he does is decided for him. He isn't taken anywhere new without the environment/ activity being risk assessed first and if something doesn't work for him, we leave.

Similar to my son he does go shopping because he likes it
He likes to sneak stuff into the trolley😂
But we dont tske him to places he cant cope with
He wont ever be able to drive , work , live indepentley
He will need full time care for the rest of his life.

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 14:59

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 14:56

Being able to communicate via a screen is not the same as being able to communicate in real life. If you were having this discussion with me in person I would probably have already gone into verbal shutdown.

I don't think you're really interested in how it impacts me because every time I answer you, you tell me I need MH support. I don't. My mental health is absolutely fine. I need support with my disability. They are two completely different things.

I am genuinely interested. I also don't want to upset you any further so please don't reply to me any further if it is.

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 14:58

TigerRag · 05/08/2026 14:32

But we don't need mental health support

Exactly. It's so fucking dismissive to be told "oh, it's your mental health". Like I can just be given some pills and sent away.

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 14:57

Onmytod24 · 05/08/2026 14:51

You clearly managed without it you didn’t enjoy it, but you managed. So, you don’t need the extra financial boost.

I never said I did need it. Nor do I want it.

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 14:56

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 14:47

But you are quite able to communicate, most of the support you detailed was for mh type needs and sensory needs?

I'm not denying you have a disability what i'm askes is how that impacts you and what you came back with was anxiety, stress, burnout and sensory needs.

Being able to communicate via a screen is not the same as being able to communicate in real life. If you were having this discussion with me in person I would probably have already gone into verbal shutdown.

I don't think you're really interested in how it impacts me because every time I answer you, you tell me I need MH support. I don't. My mental health is absolutely fine. I need support with my disability. They are two completely different things.

Sirzy · 05/08/2026 14:52

Although DS can talk his communication needs are massive and he can actually only communicate with a very limited amount of people at all. He will never live independently and at 16 still needs a massive amount of support with every aspect of life. He had 1-1 throughout school and will have at college even though he is going into a specialist program. He can’t safely be left for even short amount of times.

he still has diagnosed mental health needs severe enough for him to have been on antidepressants since he was 9. He has the added issue that he struggles to access any support and that will get even harder when he turns 18 as the team that have supported him since he was 7 at CAMHs he will age out of so we will have to start again.

Onmytod24 · 05/08/2026 14:51

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 14:50

But I don't qualify for any of that support so what do you think my options are, exactly?

You clearly managed without it you didn’t enjoy it, but you managed. So, you don’t need the extra financial boost.

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 14:50

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 14:43

Well no my ds won't. He has to have 2:1 support to go out and it would be a safeguarding failure for his carers to take him to somewhere like a supermarket as it is documented in his care plan that he shouldn't go.

He won't ever learn to drive, the suggestion is laughable. He will likely have high rate of mobility for as long as PIP is around so no public transport. He's also given sedatives for flying.

What he is exposed to isn't in his hands; where he goes and what he does is decided for him. He isn't taken anywhere new without the environment/ activity being risk assessed first and if something doesn't work for him, we leave.

But I don't qualify for any of that support so what do you think my options are, exactly?

Onmytod24 · 05/08/2026 14:50

Agasagas · 04/08/2026 20:25

Well your friend is pretty ignorant then and clearly misogynistic to boot. The way autistic women and girls present differently is now quite rightly recognised in the autism and adhd diagnosis process and you can now quite rightly be diagnosed with both. Autistic women and girls were very much there in the 90/00s.Uta Frith has been quite rightly criticised and pulled up on her awful misogynistic views by those in the field, researchers and charities.

I think she’s got it bang on. working in schools for the last X number of years ive seen what constitutes autism completely and utterly change

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 14:47

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 14:39

We need the support because we are disabled. Not because we struggle with our mental health. I was fobbed off with poor mental health for YEARS before my diagnosis and it really pees me off. I am not depressed or anxious. I have developmental and communication disability. They are not the same thing.

But you are quite able to communicate, most of the support you detailed was for mh type needs and sensory needs?

I'm not denying you have a disability what i'm askes is how that impacts you and what you came back with was anxiety, stress, burnout and sensory needs.

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 14:43

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 14:35

It's not about not wanting things to be classed as MH support, it's about the fact that your entire post appears to dismiss how much impact living with a disability can have on people.

You talk about not subjecting your DS to a supermarket but at some point he's going to grow up and be an adult who has to, at some point, go somewhere like a supermarket. The same applies to going to noisy places. For example, I had to go and get my car fixed recently which meant I had to be able to navigate a noisy garage with lots of people talking all at once and lots of smells that I didn't like. I was so overwhelmed I genuinely almost fainted. I was SO embarrassed but what choice did I have? I had to get my car fixed so I could do my job.

Or what if your DS never learns to drive and needs to cope with noisy public transport to get to his job?

It's impossible to live your life without ever exposing yourself to things you don't like, and unfortunately when you live with a disability, you sometimes need support to be able to do that.

Well no my ds won't. He has to have 2:1 support to go out and it would be a safeguarding failure for his carers to take him to somewhere like a supermarket as it is documented in his care plan that he shouldn't go.

He won't ever learn to drive, the suggestion is laughable. He will likely have high rate of mobility for as long as PIP is around so no public transport. He's also given sedatives for flying.

What he is exposed to isn't in his hands; where he goes and what he does is decided for him. He isn't taken anywhere new without the environment/ activity being risk assessed first and if something doesn't work for him, we leave.

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 14:39

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 14:36

What support is that you have need that isn't mh or sensory? I really am trying to understand. Much of what the pp listed I would think does come under mh needs? I know this wasn't you but that is the example of support given.

We need the support because we are disabled. Not because we struggle with our mental health. I was fobbed off with poor mental health for YEARS before my diagnosis and it really pees me off. I am not depressed or anxious. I have developmental and communication disability. They are not the same thing.

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 14:36

TigerRag · 05/08/2026 14:32

But we don't need mental health support

What support is that you have need that isn't mh or sensory? I really am trying to understand. Much of what the pp listed I would think does come under mh needs? I know this wasn't you but that is the example of support given.

pinkandwhiteroses · 05/08/2026 14:35

SupernaturalAddict · 05/08/2026 14:30

It wasn't intended as either. I'm trying to understand.

Do you not want some of those to be classed as needing mh support? Some of the sensory suggestions i've made are because we implement them for my son. I won't subject him to a supermarket and do get shopping delivered, why would I take him to somewhere with loud noises knowing it would hurt/ upset him. Surely that's common sense.

It's not about not wanting things to be classed as MH support, it's about the fact that your entire post appears to dismiss how much impact living with a disability can have on people.

You talk about not subjecting your DS to a supermarket but at some point he's going to grow up and be an adult who has to, at some point, go somewhere like a supermarket. The same applies to going to noisy places. For example, I had to go and get my car fixed recently which meant I had to be able to navigate a noisy garage with lots of people talking all at once and lots of smells that I didn't like. I was so overwhelmed I genuinely almost fainted. I was SO embarrassed but what choice did I have? I had to get my car fixed so I could do my job.

Or what if your DS never learns to drive and needs to cope with noisy public transport to get to his job?

It's impossible to live your life without ever exposing yourself to things you don't like, and unfortunately when you live with a disability, you sometimes need support to be able to do that.

x2boys · 05/08/2026 14:33

theneighboureatmysalad · 05/08/2026 14:29

As usual, context matters?

The only people I have ever heard, or read, using the words "gifts and superpower", were mums of SEND kids.

I can't really imagine going to tell them that it's not a superpower and they should stop using that term. People cope how they can.

I have seen lots of memes on social media posting about how its a super power
Also the other very irritating
" its not a disabillity its a different ability "
In fact i have seen posters on here talking about people being differently abled .

Swipe left for the next trending thread