Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this email from my exes solicitor is just absolutely laughable

112 replies

Esmeraldathe3rd · 31/07/2026 12:09

DSs dad is on an increasing schedule of contact during our court process, started with supported and he's now on one-one. (Contact originally stopped because social services though he was a danger, before what he had alternate weekends plus some extras in hols)

Last weekend was his first full day. He was 3hrs late because he forgot about it. Now I get an email off his solicitor requesting we agree outside of court 5050 shared care or they'll take me to court over 1.unrelated and 2. Completely in my favour, financial issues. Essentially threatening me that if I don't agree it'll cost me. Also threatening to take MY allegations of rape against him, further, like how? You raped me, I agreed not to press charges, what are you going to do?

I just cannot imagine being so arrogant that I would be 3 hours late to see my son and then demand shared care?! CAFCAS is not reccomeding shared care. The judge scoffed at the last hearing when he said he was insisting on shared care. In what world would I agree to that?

And honestly why would his solicitor support that, they seem like the most incompetent people I've ever met, it baffles me.

OP posts:
Prawnlover · 31/07/2026 20:10

He lives in my house free of charge and I've made no issue of it.

But in actual fact… the consent order stipulated that this property will transfer wholly to him once the mortgage is paid off. And he is paying the mortgage off.

So… it is not your house and he’s not living in it free of charge!

Prawnlover · 31/07/2026 20:08

So he is obviously keeping this topped up so is essentially paying the mortgage off,

you said he was living in it rent free?

Prawnlover · 31/07/2026 20:08

Esmeraldathe3rd · 31/07/2026 19:46

😂😂 I guess it's not really about that for me. It's the audacity of emailing me threatening me , demanding 5050 when you were just hours late for handover.

The house is complicated. We owned two houses, both were in my sole name. But we ran a company together so my money was his money essentially. And we were married so they're joint assets anyway. One had no mortgage and stayed as my own home. The other is worth twice as much but had a small mortgage on it in my sole name. From before we married. He has not at any point been added to either the land registry or mortgage. The financial order stated I kept the smaller one and that he had to pay off the mortgage of the bigger one for that to be transferred to him. The mortgage is paid from a joint account I now have no access to whatsoever. So he is obviously keeping this topped up so is essentially paying the mortgage off, just at a monthly rate which will clear in 2031 at which time I'll transfer it to him. I am in no need of buying another house ATM so paying to take him to court to force this is just a waste of money. It could burn down tomorrow, I don't care. I don't care if he stops paying the mortgage and they repossess it. Even if that destroys my credit rating. I don't need a loan or mortgage for anything so I really don't care what happens to it. I have informed the mortgage lender, they don't care as long as the mortgage gets paid. So I just find it insane that he's using that as a stick to beat me with over my actual child. Like ok, take me to court, pay the mortgage off and I'll sign the house over to you. Or don't take me to court, pay the mortgage and I'll sign the house over, who gives AF? Not me.

Your abusive ex is living for free in one of your properties? Mind blowing.

What does your husband think about that?

Esmeraldathe3rd · 31/07/2026 19:46

Prawnlover · 31/07/2026 18:12

I meant biggest drip!

😂😂 I guess it's not really about that for me. It's the audacity of emailing me threatening me , demanding 5050 when you were just hours late for handover.

The house is complicated. We owned two houses, both were in my sole name. But we ran a company together so my money was his money essentially. And we were married so they're joint assets anyway. One had no mortgage and stayed as my own home. The other is worth twice as much but had a small mortgage on it in my sole name. From before we married. He has not at any point been added to either the land registry or mortgage. The financial order stated I kept the smaller one and that he had to pay off the mortgage of the bigger one for that to be transferred to him. The mortgage is paid from a joint account I now have no access to whatsoever. So he is obviously keeping this topped up so is essentially paying the mortgage off, just at a monthly rate which will clear in 2031 at which time I'll transfer it to him. I am in no need of buying another house ATM so paying to take him to court to force this is just a waste of money. It could burn down tomorrow, I don't care. I don't care if he stops paying the mortgage and they repossess it. Even if that destroys my credit rating. I don't need a loan or mortgage for anything so I really don't care what happens to it. I have informed the mortgage lender, they don't care as long as the mortgage gets paid. So I just find it insane that he's using that as a stick to beat me with over my actual child. Like ok, take me to court, pay the mortgage off and I'll sign the house over to you. Or don't take me to court, pay the mortgage and I'll sign the house over, who gives AF? Not me.

OP posts:
Aiming4Optimistic · 31/07/2026 18:21

How is he living in your house? Why are you not taking steps to get him evicted?

Prawnlover · 31/07/2026 18:12

Prawnlover · 31/07/2026 18:00

He lives in my house free of charge and I've made no issue of it.

this is one of the highest drips I have ever seen on mumsnet

I meant biggest drip!

Gardenisablooming · 31/07/2026 18:07

Ex had his solicitor write to me demanding I remove my newly fitted blinds as he could no longer see into my home.
He tried to get me charged with assault when I shut the back door on him when he had wedged his foot inside..
I told the police quite earnestly if I had meant to assault him I would have used a pan.

pizzaHeart · 31/07/2026 18:07

Likeiloveyou · 31/07/2026 12:49

I would reply to the solicitor several times asking different questions, a few days apart, so ex incurs additional costs each time solicitor has to contact you.

I love your style!

TisEye · 31/07/2026 18:06

NotAnotherScarf · 31/07/2026 12:31

A true story to illustrate that solicitors are just there for the money

I was a claims manager we sent the customer vouchers to settle a claim. She changed her mind and sent them back in thd normal post . They got lost. As she didn't take any care and had no proof we said nothing could be done and closed the claim.

A solicitor wrote . I replied pointing out she didn't exercise reasons care and had no proof so there was nothing we could do and she couldn't make a second claim as insurance has an implied and case law supported rule that you always act as if uninsured.

Solicitor wrote back threatening legal action. On the same day we got another letter from a different solicitor repeating what solicitor one said in their first letter.

Clearly solicitor one told her I was right...but still took the money to write to me again.

I simply photocopied all of the letters and sent them to both solicitors with a brief note explaining i was right

So op just write back to the solicitor tell them to go ahead and pointing out that given your ex forgot contact its very very unlikely any court would find in his favour and that social services have already intervened in contact. Re the rate (and I am really sorry that happened to you) remind him that any action would take place in open court and that his name would forevermore be linked to a rape case.

I would also tell the solicitor that you know they are just representing their client but just because its a letter from a solicitor you are not concerned about the contents because you all know its absolutely ridiculous.

Don't ever be afraid of solicitors...they are human and most actually don't know all that much about the law

I love this.

It took until I was about 35 to realise that 95% of people - especially professionals - are winging it and hoping nobody notices. I firmly include myself in this.

OP stick to your guns, you know the truth, you know this guy is a bellend and the court will see that too.

It's all smoke and mirrors. Stay focussed on your children.

Prawnlover · 31/07/2026 18:00

He lives in my house free of charge and I've made no issue of it.

this is one of the highest drips I have ever seen on mumsnet

Prawnlover · 31/07/2026 17:58

Why did you agree not to report the rape? Presumably the solicitor refers to him pursing a libel or slander claim?

Proteinpudding · 31/07/2026 17:55

Op, take this as a gift.
The ex has already got on the wrong side of the judge by the sounds of it, and this is just going to add to that, making your life easier in the long run. Please don't confuse the solicitor sending the letter with evidence that the solicitor believes or supports him, they're there to do a job. Usually they'll try an advise their client against something but it sounds like your ex isn't one who would take the advice!

AnnoyedAsAllHeck · 31/07/2026 17:52

Esmeraldathe3rd · 31/07/2026 13:37

@AnnoyedAsAllHeck no, he is. He lives in my house free of charge and I've made no issue of it. The financial order states that he has to pay me the sum of the mortgage so the mortgage can be paid off and then I have to transfer him the house. He has not paid the mortgage off. I have had the documents sent to him from the mortgage lender with a date and an amount that needed to be paid twice. And he has refused. So there is literally nothing I can do.

I've presented recordings to the judge of all sorts, they don't care, I literally showed that he had submitted forged evidence to court. They don't care.

DS is struggling. His dad uses every contact visit to update him on the court proceedings. About how I am stopping him from spending more time with him. How I'm telling the courts when DS tells me stuff. So he comes out of contact upset. But legally I am court ordered to let him or I could lose him all together.

So, you are paying the mortgage for him to live in your house? That's crazy as hell!
The courts are screwy when they allow this crap to happen.

I am sorry that your ex is such a twat-waffle and is hurting your DS and you with his out of control, immature, hateful behavior.

HowardTJMoon · 31/07/2026 17:38

My ex managed to get a solicitor to write me a snotty letter demanding more contact with our DCs and threatening court if I didn't comply. I wrote back saying that I'd be happy to consider increasing contact once their client could be arsed to turn up for the contact schedule that had already been agreed. I helpfully included the log I'd kept of the huge amounts of contact had been missed along with the records of exactly what my ex had done to cause our DCs to end up on the child protection register and for them to be living with me full time.

When I didn't hear anything back I sent another letter to the solicitor and, quelle surprise, it turned out my ex was no longer instructing her. I can only imagine my ex was less than honest about the background of the case.

NameChangeAgain48 · 31/07/2026 17:26

Esmeraldathe3rd · 31/07/2026 16:32

Well the thing is, I fully expect this kind of thing from him. Not a thing has surprised me, from HIM. But these are educated, sensible people surely. How are they this idiotic. To send me an email after he's just forgot about his scheduled contact to demand 5050 and threaten me with my own rape "allegations" my own car, my own house and his measly child maintenance. I know he's this stupid and arrogant and quite frankly an abusive bully, but I'm surprised that they are happy to slap their name on that drivel.

They will send you whatever he instructs them to send you. He is their client.

PsychoHotSauce · 31/07/2026 17:23

Aviarythebird · 31/07/2026 16:58

Yes but solicitors are regulated by the SRA and paralegals must be actively supervised by solicitors. Solicitors can’t send misleading threats in letters. They can’t just write whatever their client tells them to. We have a code of conduct. Solicitors really don’t like complaints and threats of referrals to the SRA and if you think they’ve breached their professional duties you should make a complaint- first to the firm and then if necessary to the SRA.

You would be surprised. In some firms, 'supervision' is reduced to 'sign off/take the blame if it goes wrong', and despite a lot of scrutiny around SLAPPs, aggressive yet baseless litigation (read: 'who has deeper pockets' bullying), and acting in the public interest after the Post Office/Horizon scandal, the SRA won't be interested in a report like this.

Just today there was an article where Mitch Winehouse got slapped with the other side's costs because the judge deemed the approach from his solicitors to be needlessly aggressive. But it's Winehouse's bill to pay...

"He was advised by London media law firm Russells, which he told the auctioneers were “the finest and most aggressive attorneys in London”.
Judge Clarke recounted: “Within days of the 2021 auction, he instructed his solicitors to bombard the defendants with aggressive letters making serious allegations of deceit and dishonesty and continued in a similar vein up to and including the trial.”
Mr Winehouse “deliberately turned this case into large-scale and expensive litigation, in circumstances calculated to exert commercial pressure on the defendants to settle on his terms”."

https://www.legalfutures.co.uk/latest-news/judge-hits-out-at-unpleasant-approach-of-winehouse-solicitor

Judge hits out at "unpleasant" approach of Winehouse solicitor

The High Court has strongly criticised the solicitor to Amy Winehouse’s father for the “aggressive and unpleasant way” they pursued an unsuccessful claim on his behalf.

https://www.legalfutures.co.uk/latest-news/judge-hits-out-at-unpleasant-approach-of-winehouse-solicitor

TheMimsy · 31/07/2026 17:19

How old is DS because at some point - the child’s opinion starts to mean something. For my son it was when he was 11. He just refused to go. Good luck.

Aviarythebird · 31/07/2026 16:58

NotAnotherScarf · 31/07/2026 16:47

As I've said most know little or nothing of the law... believe me I was in insurance claims for 10 years. I've also, when I walked away from the corporate bollocks, had to help a lady in her 90s sort her late husband's will because the solicitor was sooooo shite.

Sorry to all you professional solicitors out there but we know that a lot of the work is passed to para legals many of whom have no qualifications.

Everyone bows to solicitors...most of them are crap.

Yes but solicitors are regulated by the SRA and paralegals must be actively supervised by solicitors. Solicitors can’t send misleading threats in letters. They can’t just write whatever their client tells them to. We have a code of conduct. Solicitors really don’t like complaints and threats of referrals to the SRA and if you think they’ve breached their professional duties you should make a complaint- first to the firm and then if necessary to the SRA.

NotAnotherScarf · 31/07/2026 16:47

Aviarythebird · 31/07/2026 13:12

Solicitors shouldn’t just do what their clients tell them to. It sounds as if that letter - with potential threat about action against you in relation to the rape allegation - if you don’t do what their client wants for child arrangements - may well have crossed a line. There was a recent case of a family solicitor being struck off for misleading the in person other party with threats of issuing proceedings (that were fictional).
You might want to consider making a formal complaint to the firm about the solicitor in relation to this threat and also the conflation of financial and children matters in an inappropriate way.
If they don’t resolve it you could consider a complaint to the SRA.
I’m a family solicitor and it’s depressing to read about such poor practice.

As I've said most know little or nothing of the law... believe me I was in insurance claims for 10 years. I've also, when I walked away from the corporate bollocks, had to help a lady in her 90s sort her late husband's will because the solicitor was sooooo shite.

Sorry to all you professional solicitors out there but we know that a lot of the work is passed to para legals many of whom have no qualifications.

Everyone bows to solicitors...most of them are crap.

BauhausOfEliott · 31/07/2026 16:43

My guess is that it's not so much a case of his solicitor being crap and/or fleecing him, but a case of him telling his solicitor a load of bollocks. You'd be amazed how many people will give their lawyer a completely twisted account of their situation - it's almost as if they think that by telling a solicitor that something happened a certain way, it will magically become true. It happens in family law and also in criminal law.

I'm really sorry you're having to go through this shit, but at least it's pretty clear that any judge is likely to laugh in his face.

KellyK2026 · 31/07/2026 16:42

Honestly? Let him hang himself. Don’t do anything. I have a close family member who got full custody and he didn’t have to do anything, he just let his ex sabotage herself in court as she got caught up in her own web of lies and the court saw straight through it. What’s the saying? Don’t interrupt when someone is making an idiot of themselves. If I was you I’d sit back and enjoy the show.

Esmeraldathe3rd · 31/07/2026 16:36

pimplebum · 31/07/2026 16:32

Are you able to move further away so that its harder for him to get to you ?

I did a few years back. Apparently he's moving to where I live. Despite me getting notifications every month that his personal and business bank accounts are in unnarranged overdraft, knowing full well how much he is working and how much he is earning, which is not alot. And I own the house he lives in so he can't sell that. I don't believe he is moving, he is refusing to allow CAFCAS to do a home visit but they're still reccomending overnights. But I also can't fathom that he would be arguing for the level of contact that he is if he isnt moving because it would be a nightmare for both him and DS. But then I am fully aware he will choose to punish DS and himself, so long as it also punishes me.

OP posts:
Yesiamtiredactually · 31/07/2026 16:33

From what you’ve described, that letter isn’t really on. Solicitors aren’t allowed to use their position to take advantage of others, for example, use scary legal sounding letters to threaten things like ‘agree to this out of course or else it’ll cost you’. I’d suggest speaking to the SRA and see what they think of the letter. They might not be too happy about it at all.

Esmeraldathe3rd · 31/07/2026 16:32

Safarisagoody · 31/07/2026 16:10

I’m not sure the solicitor is swindling him and I’m bemused you’re blaming rhe solicitor. The solicitor is acting on instruction from the client, they are likely advising low likely hood or in advisable etc but you’ve no idea what he’s telling rhe solicitor.

this is your ex. He’s the one to blame. This is not the solicitor,

Well the thing is, I fully expect this kind of thing from him. Not a thing has surprised me, from HIM. But these are educated, sensible people surely. How are they this idiotic. To send me an email after he's just forgot about his scheduled contact to demand 5050 and threaten me with my own rape "allegations" my own car, my own house and his measly child maintenance. I know he's this stupid and arrogant and quite frankly an abusive bully, but I'm surprised that they are happy to slap their name on that drivel.

OP posts:
pimplebum · 31/07/2026 16:32

Are you able to move further away so that its harder for him to get to you ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread