Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sean McCann, swimmer

222 replies

TheAverageJoanne · 25/07/2026 18:03

I noticed the swimmer Sean McCann is being described in every news story as Madeleine McCann's brother. AIBU to think this is unfair to the guy who's trained, qualified and got into the final? It feels very unfair.

OP posts:
MrsEmmelineLucas · 28/07/2026 09:53

Velumental · 28/07/2026 09:51

I was almost an adult at the time and working class and I can tell you the feeling where I'm from was, if they weren't doctors the authorities would have taken the twins for that behaviour. And honestly that probably is the case, at the very least they'd have been removed pending investigation

Yes, I remember a lot of anger and disgust at the time. Many of us parents of young children who wouldn't have taken such risks.

Velumental · 28/07/2026 09:51

Pippinrobin · 28/07/2026 09:01

Yes I remember at the time most people were very sympathetic to them, this anger towards them has come about more over time as peoples norms have changed

I was almost an adult at the time and working class and I can tell you the feeling where I'm from was, if they weren't doctors the authorities would have taken the twins for that behaviour. And honestly that probably is the case, at the very least they'd have been removed pending investigation

Ved · 28/07/2026 09:51

Maninasuitcase · 28/07/2026 09:44

He is too young to even remember Madelieine.

And yet, she has completely dominated his life, and always will. Not her fault of course, but he will always be 'Madeline McCann's brother.'

itsgettingweird · 28/07/2026 09:49

Velumental · 28/07/2026 09:06

And if you pay for baby listening AND you walk around yourself that's fairly constant surveillance. Also 2 and 3 yr olds are not babies. There's no way children that age should be unsupervised at all, let alone in a strange environment. It's terrible. As someone who struggled to have children like Kate McCann did, the idea that I'd just leave them unsupervised and go for dinner is wild to me.

It’s wild to me now!

But at the time that was the norm in these holiday centres for the middle classes.

And just because you wouldn’t have done it back then doesn’t mean a large percentage of the parents on this type of holiday don’t or wouldn’t.

It was she main selling point.

kids were in crèche (open 8-6) whilst parents sailed including their high tea in crèche. They were put to bed, parents went to the restaurant and they were “supervised” through baby listening.

Ved · 28/07/2026 09:49

JacquesHarlow · 28/07/2026 08:40

I'm grateful for contribution to medical science but this is where I feel the whole problem is with this "story" -

If the faces were different lets say, and both were unemployed, and the events were someone nipping across to their neighbour's balcony on the estate to have a drink in the summer....and their poor child was abducted? Well it would be immediate calls for social services, the responses would be wildly different.

This country is still obsessed with class, and we believe anyone with erm, "traditional" backgrounds, in "professions" to have some sort of superior judgement which exonerates them in a way other more "recent" arrivals don't. If I look a certain way, am well connected, but I drive my car off a road by accident into people, I will be given understanding and protection. If I commit the same acts but I wear a hijab, I will be relentlessly profiled in the media, and there will be immediate calls for "why aren't you sharing the name and background" etc.

100% agree with this, ^

AutumnHazel · 28/07/2026 09:46

Pippinrobin · 28/07/2026 07:07

Agree, this poor family has been sent to hell and back for a combination of a misjudgment & awful bad luck in a totally different time and place from the norms of 2026 UK. Good on them for this and nice to see the family having some joy at last

I agree with you, except that I don’t think the norms haven’t really changed much since 2009…. 1979, maybe, but not 2009. That’s irrelevant though really.

NeelyOHara · 28/07/2026 09:46

Twiglets1 · 28/07/2026 08:24

Agree.

It was not unusual for people to leave their children alone at the time. Some people did, some people didn't. Times have changed.

Anyway, this thread is about Sean so think we should return to that.

I don’t know anyone who did, ever.

Maninasuitcase · 28/07/2026 09:44

He is too young to even remember Madelieine.

MrsEmmelineLucas · 28/07/2026 09:38

Bunnycat101 · 28/07/2026 09:33

The thing is even if he’d changed his name, it will always come up when his parents watch him compete etc. He was a very young child now having to live in the shadow of his murdered sister and that was clearly nothing to do with him. I feel sorry for him that his achievements will be associated with an extremely traumatic event for his family. The media should pipe down and let him be.

"The media" will do whatever they want to in order to get the clicks.

Bunnycat101 · 28/07/2026 09:33

The thing is even if he’d changed his name, it will always come up when his parents watch him compete etc. He was a very young child now having to live in the shadow of his murdered sister and that was clearly nothing to do with him. I feel sorry for him that his achievements will be associated with an extremely traumatic event for his family. The media should pipe down and let him be.

deeahgwitch · 28/07/2026 09:31

NCForOneNightOnly · 26/07/2026 17:54

Especially poor of the media considering the lengths the parents have had to go to protect their children. It wasn’t that long ago the crazy polish woman was bombarding the kids with calls and messages.

And this 💯

deeahgwitch · 28/07/2026 09:29

TheFairyCaravan · 25/07/2026 18:12

DH and I said the same.

I wish the press would just fuck off and leave him alone. He doesn’t need this noise at all. Good luck to him.

This 💯

Violinist64 · 28/07/2026 09:28

DeftGoldHedgehog · 28/07/2026 06:42

Oh yeah, there's Kate and Gerry in the crowd. They can't resist drawing it to everyone's attention.

Of course they are. As would any other parents be. Why should they not be proud of their son? What a fantastic achievement to make it to the Commonwealth games. Whatever happened to his sister and whatever we might think of how the McCanns and their friends behaved at the time has no bearing on Sean's achievements.

Bejazzled · 28/07/2026 09:28

TheAverageJoanne · 25/07/2026 18:03

I noticed the swimmer Sean McCann is being described in every news story as Madeleine McCann's brother. AIBU to think this is unfair to the guy who's trained, qualified and got into the final? It feels very unfair.

Totally agree. We were discussing that very thing.

IonianNerveGrip · 28/07/2026 09:28

dnadiscoveryquery · 28/07/2026 09:24

It doesn’t though. It’s the same for the Olympics, Football, Rugby etc. You can compete for either the country you were born in or the country/countries of your parents. It’s been the same for a very long time.

Yeah it's just the normal workings of international sport. Most of the time you can qualify through your own birthplace, residence for a set number of years, birthplace of a parent and in some sports a grandparent. Sean is by no means the only member of the Scottish team to have been born and live elsewhere and qualify for Scotland through a parent. Was the same on their recent world cup team too. McTominey is from Lancashire.

dnadiscoveryquery · 28/07/2026 09:24

Screamingabdabz · 28/07/2026 08:55

Gerry is. My point still stands.

It doesn’t though. It’s the same for the Olympics, Football, Rugby etc. You can compete for either the country you were born in or the country/countries of your parents. It’s been the same for a very long time.

MrsEmmelineLucas · 28/07/2026 09:23

Calliopespa · 28/07/2026 09:21

Agree.

Let's not pick a happy moment to shreds.

Unfortunately, his sister's story is still larger than his. I honestly hope they get some closure on this.

Calliopespa · 28/07/2026 09:21

IonianNerveGrip · 28/07/2026 09:18

Yep. And it's not as if the Internet suffers from a shortage of places to discuss the McCann parents behaviour.

I agree with various pp that it's inevitable he's going to be referred to as brother of Madeline unless and until he becomes so successful that his medals become the story. But people can still give over about the whys and wherefores on this one specific thread and have those discussions somewhere else instead.

Agree.

Let's not pick a happy moment to shreds.

Calliopespa · 28/07/2026 09:19

CrazyMidget · 28/07/2026 09:16

I don't follow tennis.

I follow tennis, and I do - but only dimly, now it has been raised again - remember he was connected.

Mostly he's just Andy Murray, more connected to Wimbledon than Dunblane in my mind. Actually, I do also tend to connect his mum's face to Andy's name a lot!

IonianNerveGrip · 28/07/2026 09:18

x2boys · 28/07/2026 08:47

But this is about
Sean now you are agsin making it all about what hsppened to Madeleine
Both Sean and Amelie have a right to their own lives

Yep. And it's not as if the Internet suffers from a shortage of places to discuss the McCann parents behaviour.

I agree with various pp that it's inevitable he's going to be referred to as brother of Madeline unless and until he becomes so successful that his medals become the story. But people can still give over about the whys and wherefores on this one specific thread and have those discussions somewhere else instead.

NototerrorismIntheUK · 28/07/2026 09:18

The press are pathetic and nasty. They need more censorship. He is himself and should be known for his own achievements.

CrazyMidget · 28/07/2026 09:16

KidsDoBetter · 28/07/2026 08:47

It’s quite widely spoken about

I don't follow tennis.

Pippinrobin · 28/07/2026 09:16

itsgettingweird · 28/07/2026 08:53

True.

but the service only does what the group did.

I know because I worked for Sunsail whom offered the same.

Crèches staff got a free dinner (in the restaurant with the guests that included the same guests signed up for the service) in exchange for walking around the hotel every half an hour, listening at the door and if they heard anything to contact the parents.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

I remember employing a babysitter for early mornings I’d seen advertise in a local newsagents in the early 2000s, not because I loved my babies any less but we were much more trusting and relaxed back then. Turned out she was a genuinely lovely girl. Still have young children now (large age gaps) and wouldn’t dream of using anyone who wasn’t a contact or fully vetted etc we are much more wary about absolutely everything now from the moment we conceive. People are far more judgemental now as to how good a parent you are being whereas the attitude back then was that it was the perpetrator who was at fault not the parent for not being careful enough and accidents were just considered unfortunate. There weren’t the awful things said about parents on social media that happen now unless had been deliberate abuse then of course people
back them would of been horrified. The one thing people did judge you on back then was how well your child behaved and how clean and tidy they looked, people are much more understanding of children’s needs and behaviour now which makes things easier as a parent!

dnadiscoveryquery · 28/07/2026 09:15

WildLeader · 28/07/2026 08:46

You can correct it by clicking other one

I’ve just looked to try on both browser and app, and despite being still open, it doesn’t change.

MrsEmmelineLucas · 28/07/2026 09:09

Pippinrobin · 28/07/2026 09:01

Yes I remember at the time most people were very sympathetic to them, this anger towards them has come about more over time as peoples norms have changed

Although, when it first broke, the people I worked with were somewhat critical of the parents' behaviour.