Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Childcare for nephew

244 replies

Childcarehelpneeded · 23/07/2026 20:44

My sister has recently moved house and now lives close to us. She has a son who is 9. My nephew finished the school year at his old school but will be moving to our local primary school that is a 10 minute walk from where live from September for year 5.

My sister works Monday-Thursday, leaving the house at 8am and getting home at 6pm. Her plan was to use before and after school clubs or a childminder for my nephew. She has enquired about them but breakfast club only has space on Mondays and the after school club is full. She says there are only a few childminders that cover our village annd primary school and they are all fully booked.

She has asked if our our nephew can come to our house before school on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday mornings from 8am and after school each day Monday-Thursday, until she gets home at 6pm. He will be walking to and from school himself so we wouldn’t need to actually take him.

We don’t want to commit to doing this. We only have our youngest child at home full time as she is at college and is mostly independent. Our older children are away at university in term time. We both work from home, although I only work 3 days, but often we don’t have to start work til 10am. We sometimes have a lie in and a lazy start to the day and then we work til 6pm ish.

My sister doesn’t feel my nephew is responsible enough to leave the house on time to get himself to school, lock up and be at home for 2 hours by himself after school, which I agree with. She seems to think that as we don’t have to actually take him to school or pick him up, that this is no bother to us at all. I know in reality that won’t be the case as we will have to be up in the morning with him and obviously we wouldn’t ignore him after school. He’ll want to chat, play, have food etc and we need to be working. She says he can watch tv or go on his iPad but inevitably, it will disturb our work and our life.

I have said that this doesn’t work for us, but have offered to do 1 day if she can sort out the other days. I was a SAHM when our children were young so I didn’t have to worry about childcare and don’t know what other options there are. Are there any obvious options we are missing? We don’t have any other family locally and all her friends work full time so have their own childcare to sort out. Her ex is a waste of space and doesn’t see my nephew regularly.

Do childminder spaces become available regularly? The school have said it’s unlikely a space will open up at breakfast club and after school club as they have a long waiting list.

After years of raising our own children, we thought we were free of this and I can’t help but feel annoyed at being made to feel like we have to help. AIBU? Any advice about other childcare options welcome. Thank you.

OP posts:
TerfOnATrain · 24/07/2026 05:06

Childcarehelpneeded · 24/07/2026 00:28

I’m not sure on ratios. She just said none had any spaces.

He would definitely want food. We don’t eat dinner til about 7pm usually but I have visions of my sister turning up to pick him up at 6pm ish and inevitably staying to chat and have a cup of tea and either they’re having dinner with us or we’ll be eating later. We just don’t want it.

No payment offered, not that I would accept.

She wouldn’t want to gibe up her career to be a childminder. 😬

Has she also tried nurseries? My DGD’s nursery has mini buses and do school drop offs and pick ups to about 4 different primaries in the area. I’m not sure whether it is for ex-nursery children though or open to anyone if they have spaces.

Washingforweeks · 24/07/2026 04:59

I don’t think your being unreasonable at all, id even be sceptical about helping temporarily as this will inevitably end up long term. What happens if he gets poorly, you have to rearrange your morning until his mum can collect etc.

DeathNote11 · 24/07/2026 04:54

I'd probably do it, because we're not talking forever here & it's so difficult being an unsupported lone parent (if that's what she is). School need to get more wrap around places organised. There's an obvious demand, & lack of provision disproportionately affects parents like your sister. I do often wonder if some of these village schools, especially those with religious affiliations, only have the minimum to keep themselves inaccessible to anyone except "traditional" families on purpose.

Wheelz46 · 24/07/2026 04:52

Has she contacted any nurseries/pre-schools? They often provide before and after school clubs and do drop offs and pick ups.

Zanatdy · 24/07/2026 04:44

I wouldn’t want to do it either. Mine are all young adults now. I am moving closer to family soon, and my brother had a later in life child who is 4. They have no-one to help, and I don’t mind occasional babysitting but certainly wouldn’t want to commit to 4 days a week. It’s likely you’ll be stuck doing it for 2yrs plus. It is a big ask.

ktopfwcv · 24/07/2026 04:26

Netcurtainnelly · 23/07/2026 23:58

The ex should step up. It's awful. What a shame for the boy, that he's seen as such a problem.
Perhaps your sister could be doing more to get ex to help or his parents and family.
Dosent the exes mother or other family not live nearby and want to help?
All this family breakdown and people not being interested in children they've bought into this world is sad.

How do you force a deadbeat dad to parent?

Wondering as I've been single parenting for 8 years and didn't realise there was an option.

Tinks2026 · 24/07/2026 04:14

Francestein · 24/07/2026 04:10

Are you sure the move to your village wasn’t inspired by the assumption of free childcare? What did she do before she moved?

Yep. As soon as I read she'd moved close to OP I thought incoming CF.

Francestein · 24/07/2026 04:10

Are you sure the move to your village wasn’t inspired by the assumption of free childcare? What did she do before she moved?

waterrat · 24/07/2026 03:42

This is also unfair on your nephew. He needs attention not an ipad every day after school.

She needs to find a student or babysitter or ask other families to share care.

Look up koru kids it's an agency for after school childcare

Parcelpass · 24/07/2026 03:23

As your sister is a single parent she is going to have to request changing her hours and finish at 4pm. Could she make her time up in the evening? Tbh as a single parent I would just speak with my boss and say she is really struggling. She really NEEDS to finish at 4pm.

There's 13 weeks of school holidays. Research holiday camps for your sister.

notatinydancer · 24/07/2026 03:17

TheBlueKoala · 23/07/2026 21:31

@Childcarehelpneeded so much for a village when not even a sister can help her single parent sister. He's 9 so not a toddler.

It’s a massive tie and really cheeky to ask. What if OP wants to go away ?

Tinks2026 · 24/07/2026 03:07

Ignore the sainted self sacrificing twits who will leap in to instruct you that your time and energy are resources to be shared.

The answer is no, of course. And no multiplied by 100 since you're also working.

Don't offer anything, not a single regular day, because you're then locked in and she'll just keep pushing.

LivingTheDreamish · 24/07/2026 02:47

Oh yes this is far too much to take on and completely tone deaf of her to ask. You are also a person with a busy life and you only just came out of the childcare years yourself, you can’t start again with someone else’s child!

Fortunately she’s got all summer to sort something. I wouldn’t be so fast to offer 1 day, it’s better if she locks in a Mon-Fri solution.

FlamingoFloss · 24/07/2026 02:40

Don’t do it. I did this for a friend/neighbour when she went back to work following Covid. It was such a bind and put responsibility upon me when I’d done all my years bringing our own children up. If it was a one off or for x amount of time I might consider it but not like we did again. It was way too much

CountessBinface · 24/07/2026 02:29

Your sister is one of the many who think working at home isn't really work. Tell her to jog on.

RubyFlax · 24/07/2026 02:28

Respectfully, surely this was something that was taken in to account in her decision to move and change his school? At the point where you researched and then register at a new school would you not also be making sure what wraparound is available in the area ?
Also you mention he’s been going to his “old” school for the time being. How has she been managing this if they’ve already moved ?

It’s not your responsibility to pick up the slack. This should have been a deciding factor in her moving and changing his school in the first place and I can’t believe it wasn’t. I’d be very careful that you don’t end up doing more impromptu child care as well… being so close and “available” at home you can bet who’ll get called upon if he’s unwell at school and needs picking up, or she gets stuck at work and so on.

Realistically your sister needs to speak to her employer about flexible working like everyone else has to. It will only be a couple of years until he’s old enough to be on his own anyway, so it’s a relatively temporary problem for her to find a solution to.

ClayPotaLot · 24/07/2026 01:23

Can she work on prepping him to me capable of getting himself there by himself? Maybe invest in some home automation that will remind him to leave and the like. Then sign him up for after school clubs - sport, music, whatever, that are within walking or bussing distance?

Most 9 year olds could do this fine if they were prepped properly, though I appreciate not every 9 year old is most!

catmothertes1 · 24/07/2026 01:15

What about inset days and school holidays? Is she planning for you to have him all day?

Plimtoemin · 24/07/2026 00:54

I think what you've offered sounds fair. My only question is whether by saying you can do it one day a week after school, that kind of says you can work round him. Two mornings and no after schools might be easier to stick to. No, we absolutely can't have him during work hours. Maybe you could relax a bit around not needing to be dressed before he arrive, it would simplify things. I think letting him eat breakfast at yours is a good shout. It would keep him occupied. Food stays in the kitchen though.

It's frustrating that she is asking you to flex both ends of your day but doesn't seem to be considering adjusting her own hours. This is a reason to stand firm. And I agree with you that what you offer temporarily might end up permanent because it's easier than keeping looking for a less convenient to her, more expensive solution.

I think she needs a college or uni student or au pair if she can't or won't change her hours. Someone might want those hours as a nanny, it's not impossible. It might even work out perfectly for someone working locally who works 9-3pm pre-school, or someone working as a TA or lunchtime supervisor. But since she's just moved she doesn't have much of a grapevine yet so this may be tricky to find.

Childcarehelpneeded · 24/07/2026 00:28

NoCommentingFromNowOn · 24/07/2026 00:20

I don’t think 9 year olds are counted in the numbers of children a childminder can have so is it just a case of finding one who is prepared to take on an extra child?

And what’s all this business of feeding him too? He won’t want to go without food until 6pm, is she expecting you to feed him?

What was she offering to pay for the approx 15 hours childcare plus breakfast and snacks?

Worst case scenario, she could become a childminder. I’ve seen that happen twice!

I’m not sure on ratios. She just said none had any spaces.

He would definitely want food. We don’t eat dinner til about 7pm usually but I have visions of my sister turning up to pick him up at 6pm ish and inevitably staying to chat and have a cup of tea and either they’re having dinner with us or we’ll be eating later. We just don’t want it.

No payment offered, not that I would accept.

She wouldn’t want to gibe up her career to be a childminder. 😬

OP posts:
Yetone · 24/07/2026 00:26

Many schools do not allow children to leave on their own until in year 6. There is a reason for this.

Childcarehelpneeded · 24/07/2026 00:22

greenmarsupial · 24/07/2026 00:17

I disagree with this in lots of ways but also feel like you might not know many nine-year-old boys if you would suggest giving them a bowl of cereal on the sofa shudder

😂 I did think that. There would be no milk, it would be dry cereal if it was my nephew eating cereal on our sofas, and even then, I’d be needing to clean up with him.

OP posts:
NoCommentingFromNowOn · 24/07/2026 00:20

I don’t think 9 year olds are counted in the numbers of children a childminder can have so is it just a case of finding one who is prepared to take on an extra child?

And what’s all this business of feeding him too? He won’t want to go without food until 6pm, is she expecting you to feed him?

What was she offering to pay for the approx 15 hours childcare plus breakfast and snacks?

Worst case scenario, she could become a childminder. I’ve seen that happen twice!

greenmarsupial · 24/07/2026 00:17

Rosecoffeecup · 23/07/2026 23:17

Tbh it doesn't really sound like much of an undertaking for you to be up at 8am to let him potter around by himself. The novelty will soon wear off and he won't want to be chatting and playing every day, just set him up on the sofa with a bowl of cereal and leave him to it?

You obviously see it as a huge inconvenience, if you can't get past that in the interests of helping your sister then that's your prerogative but as a PP says, so much for it takes a village hey 🤔

I disagree with this in lots of ways but also feel like you might not know many nine-year-old boys if you would suggest giving them a bowl of cereal on the sofa shudder

Childcarehelpneeded · 24/07/2026 00:13

Capybarachocolate · 24/07/2026 00:03

I don’t think I would do it.

Were there any conversations between your sister and you before the move as it’s quite a big deal to move your child’s school- is it a ‘flee’ to get away or was it thought out (apart from childcare bit)

i think if you say you’ll help all week to begin with then youll be doing it forever whilst he is at a school. You will find she’ll say ‘oh he’s no problem’ or ‘it’s worked so well’ or ‘he really really enjoys spending time with you’ it would then be even harder.

Tell her you’ll do 1 day a week maybe? Tell her your work hours are altered. Tell her you just don’t want to!

As a mom having to work my entire life and work life around my dc’s needs I would NEVER expect anyone - family or whoever to help it’s MY responsibility to find childcare or alter my hours or even change my job.

YANBU

When her and ex split, she did move to get away from him, but she was still about 15 miles from us. The latest move nearer to us was just because she liked the area and means my nephew will hopefully get in a better secondary school. I think she genuinely thought she would find childcare without a problem but unfortunately it hasn’t worked out that way.

I’ve said I’ll do 1 day a week, morning and after school, he can go to breakfast club 1 morning as they have a space but it’s what to do the other 2 mornings and 3 days afterschool.

OP posts: