Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bring back the death penalty in this case

163 replies

ThisWiseRobin · 17/07/2026 11:04

AIBU to wish for the death penalty. How a mother can kill her baby with a hairdryer.
I read this to my husband who asked me to stop and was crying.
I'm Christian and am taught that all but one sin is forgivable.
BUT Our Lord also said that to harm one little one , you are better to have a millstone tied around your neck and be thrown into the sea.
While some interpretations claim it means misleading them, I think it's much more than this.
Today I feel bereft of love for the human race.
Of course this monster will claim Domestic violence, drugs , mental health etc.
I hope, as there is no death penalty, that she spends the rest of her life begging to die.
Sorry right now, all I can say is "Father forgive them. For they know not what they do".....because right now I Can't.

OP posts:
Backedoffhackedoff · 17/07/2026 11:51

araiwa · 17/07/2026 11:25

I'd reintroduce the death penalty for people who start threads about "this one crime" should bring back the death penalty

There's been a few this week already

It’s the American fundamentalist Christian funded bots

Perplexed20 · 17/07/2026 11:50

The states in the us have the death penalty have higher crime rates.

I do not agree with it in any circumstances. What would you do in the case of a miscarriage of justice? And you can't guarantee there would never be one.

Backedoffhackedoff · 17/07/2026 11:50

ThisWiseRobin · 17/07/2026 11:04

AIBU to wish for the death penalty. How a mother can kill her baby with a hairdryer.
I read this to my husband who asked me to stop and was crying.
I'm Christian and am taught that all but one sin is forgivable.
BUT Our Lord also said that to harm one little one , you are better to have a millstone tied around your neck and be thrown into the sea.
While some interpretations claim it means misleading them, I think it's much more than this.
Today I feel bereft of love for the human race.
Of course this monster will claim Domestic violence, drugs , mental health etc.
I hope, as there is no death penalty, that she spends the rest of her life begging to die.
Sorry right now, all I can say is "Father forgive them. For they know not what they do".....because right now I Can't.

this whole post is so weird

“Sorry right now, all I can say is "Father forgive them. For they know not what they do".....because right now I Can't.”

who cares if you can forgive them or not? What’s the importance in your forgiveness?

Backedoffhackedoff · 17/07/2026 11:47

what case? You didn’t link anything

HoppingPavlova · 17/07/2026 11:46

I’m happy to take the death penalty off the table. However, I don’t believe people should be protected in prison. They can take their chances, pretty much like everyone else in society had to take their chances with them and their crimes. Seems fair. That will then pretty much take care of the situation in most cases, problem solved.

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 17/07/2026 11:45

They can’t bring back outdated punishment methods because of ONE book written a REALLY long time ago.

Gandalf says many profound things but we can’t weave them into our legal system.

And what if Enid Blyton had her way? FML.

Murder is abhorrent. But fighting fire with fire has never been the way forward.

Stompythedinosaur · 17/07/2026 11:41

If something is wrong, it's always wrong, even in emotive situations. I believe the death penalty is wrong and that civilised societies don't sanction murder (or torture or mistreatment), even in the face of horrendous crimes.

KnivesAndFawkes · 17/07/2026 11:39

Oh I’d pull the trigger myself. Genuinely.

I actually don’t know how I’d vote if it were ever on the table that we were in a position to bring back hanging. But I read this case - and others like it - and I’d have no issue with them being dispatched. I cannot fathom how anyone can abuse or kill a child

Lifesyoungdream · 17/07/2026 11:30

It’s hard to think that a mother could do that to her baby is beyond any understanding for most caring parents. This so soon after the trial of Jamie Varley is making me rethink about introducing the death penalty even though I have been so against it.

araiwa · 17/07/2026 11:25

I'd reintroduce the death penalty for people who start threads about "this one crime" should bring back the death penalty

There's been a few this week already

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 17/07/2026 11:24

BUT Our Lord also said that to harm one little one , you are better to have a millstone tied around your neck and be thrown into the sea.

Yet in psalm 137
Happy is the one who seizes your infants and dashes them against the rocks.

I don't believe in the death sentence under any circumstances - whether mandated in the Bible or not.

LadyTable · 17/07/2026 11:20

BUT Our Lord also said that to harm one little one , you are better to have a millstone tied around your neck and be thrown into the sea.

So why does 'your lord' put babies on earth just to suffer in pain from cancer and other horrible diseases only to die a few months later?

And you can't randomly apply the death sentence just because it may suit certain public outcries.

YourOliveBalonz · 17/07/2026 11:09

I don’t agree with the death penalty under any circumstances, I don’t believe the state should have the power to murder its citizens. It’s easy to be morally consistent too, as individuals all have their opinions on who deserves it and who doesn’t. If you fundamentally disagree that the state should not have that power then there’s nothing to grapple with.

As a human being we can all feel like we would happily have some horrible individuals killed - wouldn’t you want to do that to anyone who even harmed your own children somehow - but I think law and justice should be above that, protecting everyone from our more primal instincts.

I’m not sure you are as Christian as you would like to believe by the way.