Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Equal bill splitting annoyance

407 replies

Adfreefreezer · 08/07/2026 19:55

Just after some balanced opinions.

Context is that 4 of us old work colleagues meet for dinner 2 or 3 times a year.

We always split the bill equally between us.

Last time we met last week it was noticeable that 2 of us including me ordered a drink at the bar when we arrived and then paid for it ourselves and then found our table and didn't drink any more.

Other 2 ordered all drinks at the table to go on the group tab and had 4 or 5 alcoholic drinks.

I had a main at 15 quid, others ordered mains all about 20 to 22 each, no issue there.

However the bill came to just over 160 plus tip and we all paid about 45 each, it really struck home that 2 of us are massively subsidising the others 2 alcohol !

Don't want to spoil the atmosphere but equally it's irritating !

No one skint , all working

What is a pleasant way to put a stop to this ?! Without being mean or penny pinching

OP posts:
veryoldwoman · 08/07/2026 22:10

Conniebygaslight · 08/07/2026 22:07

I always find these threads interesting. Whenever I go out with girlfriends, we argue over who should pay but it’s always one of us trying to pay for the other one. I’ve never come across anyone trying to take the P out of me, or me them. Just bloody rude…

Same here, in my groups of friends the people who drink alcohol are always very insistent that they pay extra to cover that- where do posters find these friends!

summershere99 · 08/07/2026 22:10

If you don’t drink alcohol they really are being very cheeky. I go out fairly regularly with a group of friends and we are always conscious of making sure the drinks bill is split fairly so that those who drink a fair bit pay more… can’t imagine expecting someone who doesn’t drink to pay for my wine! Next time just ask if you can all pay for drinks separately but split the food. If they are genuinely good friends, they won’t mind!

MasterBeth · 08/07/2026 22:10

OverOrUnderprotective · 08/07/2026 22:03

It's not about the money (though you have to acknowledge that you are quite privileged to not have to worry about the money) but it's the fact that your friends are taking advantage of you. If they really cared why would they want to take advantage of you?

Maybe they are just thoughtless rather than CF but in that case they should be happy if op pointed out to them how unfair this is and should be happy to change it.

If you are privileged enough not to worry about the money, then you are not being taken advantage of. If you value the friendship more than you value the money, it's not a big deal.

If your friends are continually taking from you - financially, emotionally, whatever - and never giving back, then of course your friendship has no future. If you are mutually generous, then it can last a lifetime.

Pinkfluffypencilcase · 08/07/2026 22:09

MasterBeth · 08/07/2026 22:05

The poster you quoted has literally just told us that she's happy "it all balances out" in her friendship group, then you turn it into this transactional conversation about mileage costs.

That to me, is the epitome of penny-pinching and mean thinking.

My point is she splits the restaurant bill saying it all evens out. But how can it if she consistently drives. So I wondered if they shared the cost of her petrol. That’s equally fair no?

it’s not penny pinching if there’s a big discrepancy. .

veryoldwoman · 08/07/2026 22:08

VIII · 08/07/2026 22:07

It doesn't all balance out though. It's always the same people who take the piss and happily let others pay extra. It's not about being transactional it's about not taking advantage of your friends generosity.

Are you talking about your own friendship group or making a general point?

AWeeCupOfTeaAndAnIndividualFruitTrifle · 08/07/2026 22:08

MasterBeth · 08/07/2026 20:08

Unless you can't afford it, you are being mean and penny pinching.

Think of your evening out as a chance to enjoy your friend's company, not a shopping expedition.

But the flip-side of that thinking is that OP's company is not worth anything to her friends... in fact, she has to effectively pay them to socialise with her. That's not a nice prospect to have to realise.

Conniebygaslight · 08/07/2026 22:07

I always find these threads interesting. Whenever I go out with girlfriends, we argue over who should pay but it’s always one of us trying to pay for the other one. I’ve never come across anyone trying to take the P out of me, or me them. Just bloody rude…

VIII · 08/07/2026 22:07

MasterBeth · 08/07/2026 22:05

The poster you quoted has literally just told us that she's happy "it all balances out" in her friendship group, then you turn it into this transactional conversation about mileage costs.

That to me, is the epitome of penny-pinching and mean thinking.

It doesn't all balance out though. It's always the same people who take the piss and happily let others pay extra. It's not about being transactional it's about not taking advantage of your friends generosity.

solvendie · 08/07/2026 22:07

Choose who you dine with more wisely….I’ve never had someone take advantage in a friend group……..or just state you’ll pay separately

outerspacepotato · 08/07/2026 22:05

Separate checks, please.

I don't drink alcohol and it's quite expensive. Why should I pay for someone else's?

You want to drink alcohol when out, fine. You pay for it.

MasterBeth · 08/07/2026 22:05

Pinkfluffypencilcase · 08/07/2026 22:01

Do they contribute towards your petrol?

The poster you quoted has literally just told us that she's happy "it all balances out" in her friendship group, then you turn it into this transactional conversation about mileage costs.

That to me, is the epitome of penny-pinching and mean thinking.

notacooldad · 08/07/2026 22:04

If I go out with just one friend or at a push, maybe two, we divide the bill. It has always been fair.
However if it is a larger group we just ask for our own tab to be opened. It has worked well for years. Everyone is free to eat and drink as much as they want then.

Cosyblankets · 08/07/2026 22:03

If i was leaving early I'd say I've had steak and I've already paid for my drinks so here's £25 or whatever

OverOrUnderprotective · 08/07/2026 22:03

Blushingm · 08/07/2026 21:57

You’re friends. Would you really worry about it? None of you are skint. If you’re paying an extra £20 3 times a year that’s £60 so £5 per month……

It's not about the money (though you have to acknowledge that you are quite privileged to not have to worry about the money) but it's the fact that your friends are taking advantage of you. If they really cared why would they want to take advantage of you?

Maybe they are just thoughtless rather than CF but in that case they should be happy if op pointed out to them how unfair this is and should be happy to change it.

Pinkfluffypencilcase · 08/07/2026 22:01

TheChosenTwo · 08/07/2026 20:25

I honestly just accept that in time it balances out in my friendship group.
Less in my favour as I’m always the driver (not a big drinker because I get awful hangovers so i tend not to bother) and being on MJ means I have a main and nothing else, no starters or sides or puddings. But always happy to split the bill equally. I can afford to be generous with my friends and I’m not bothered that I’ve massively overspent compared to what I consumed. Every now and then someone will offer to pay for mine but I pay my share. We enjoy each others company and enjoy catching up.
If you’re not happy about it just say you’re paying for yourself as you don’t want to contribute to their alcohol.

Do they contribute towards your petrol?

Adfreefreezer · 08/07/2026 22:01

Actually next time, I will take cash and leave a generous amount to cover my.order say 20 for a 15 meal and leave them to it when I leave

OP posts:
Justanopinionnothingmore · 08/07/2026 22:00

Blushingm · 08/07/2026 21:57

You’re friends. Would you really worry about it? None of you are skint. If you’re paying an extra £20 3 times a year that’s £60 so £5 per month……

I do not subsidise my friend's drinking habits.

Luckily, I have friends who don't take the piss. If someone had an extra drink or a starter, yes we don't care about that. It's a few quid. We go split the bill on things like that no issue.

What I would have an issue with is someone decided to order many expensive alcoholic drinks and others hadn't, then expected everyone to pay the same. How can anyone think that is okay. Especially with the cost of living, how do you know that people can afford it!

Justanopinionnothingmore · 08/07/2026 21:57

Gardenisablooming · 08/07/2026 21:54

Well it's obvious why the cfers turn up. Huge meal at bargain price!.
Would rather appear penny pinching than a robbing bastard!!

Can tell there is a few on here by the responses. 🤣🤣🤣

Blushingm · 08/07/2026 21:57

You’re friends. Would you really worry about it? None of you are skint. If you’re paying an extra £20 3 times a year that’s £60 so £5 per month……

Gardenisablooming · 08/07/2026 21:54

Well it's obvious why the cfers turn up. Huge meal at bargain price!.
Would rather appear penny pinching than a robbing bastard!!

firstofallimadelight · 08/07/2026 21:54

One friend once said to me to look at the bill as the cost of the night rather than individual items. This was after both the friend and myself had spent £45 on a meal that should have cost £15.

id either state at the beginning you will pay for yourself (or settle up at the bar if possible) or say to make it fairer let’s just split food. Or make sure your drinks go on the bill too

OverOrUnderprotective · 08/07/2026 21:54

Blackbirdsandrats · 08/07/2026 20:04

You need to disrupt the pattern.
At the start of the meal before the menu if possible, say something along the lines of I'm going to pay for myself rather than split the bill because I want to feel free to treat myself to whatever I fancy and I'm uncomfortable doing that when I know I'd be passing the cost onto you 3.
They can't argue much because you've said you don't like it, rather than it's not fair.

Fantastic idea. You are a genius!! 🌹

Maybe this one time you could order a dessert or have ah expensive item from the menu to make it make sense but then hopefully from next time on you can just say you'd like to continue with paying for yourself. Good luck 🤞

MasterBeth · 08/07/2026 21:53

Justanopinionnothingmore · 08/07/2026 21:51

There is generous and there is taking the piss. I wouldn't dream of having a non alcohol drinking friend pay £30 extra for our alcohol of I had any. How is that being generous or caring to them? It's cf behaviour expecting your friends to pay for your alcohol intake. A few pound here and there is nothing, thirty pound is way too much!

Correct.

You are thinking generously.

MasterBeth · 08/07/2026 21:51

OhBettyCalmDown · 08/07/2026 21:35

It funny to me that you think allowing your friend to subsidise your night out each time you meet is acceptable. None of that is the behaviour of someone who cares in my opinion.

Generosity goes both ways. It’s no good saying it all comes out in the wash over the course of a friendship because it doesn't if you’re the person that doesn’t drink alcohol. You spend a life time paying far more than your share

Hmm, I haven't said that

I have suggested that, if you can afford it, it pays to think generously. Allowing your friend to subsidise you is the opposite of that.

Again, I find it dispiriting that so many people are prepared to value friendships via the transactional cost of whether or not you had a starter or a soft drink when you split a restaurant bill.

Justanopinionnothingmore · 08/07/2026 21:51

MasterBeth · 08/07/2026 20:53

It's funny to me that some people can't grasp the idea of being generous to your friends, the people who you are supposed to like and care for.

There is generous and there is taking the piss. I wouldn't dream of having a non alcohol drinking friend pay £30 extra for our alcohol of I had any. How is that being generous or caring to them? It's cf behaviour expecting your friends to pay for your alcohol intake. A few pound here and there is nothing, thirty pound is way too much!