Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my sister she was unprofessional and inappropriate? * [Content warning: concerns baby loss]

258 replies

Girlsonahill · 02/07/2026 23:36

Without being completely outing, part of my sister's job involves going into lots of people's homes. We have a group whatsapp chat with our mum and although not the closest of sisters, generally talk most days get along fine. Today she posted a short video she filmed of a picture someone had up on their wall of their deceased baby and simply captioned "it's dead". This person was unaware she did this. I was horrified. gently told her I thought it was inappropriate and really unprofessional and I got a barrage of abuse back saying I was being judgemental and did I think I was the moral police. My mum said nothing presumably to keep the peace. She has form for being unable to accept any type of criticism but now I'm left feeling like I'm in the wrong and shouldn't have said anything. AIBU?

OP posts:
Girlsonahill · 03/07/2026 00:39

mondaytosunday · 03/07/2026 00:31

Gross breach of privacy and basic human decency. In some jobs this would mean automatic termination. What does she do? If she's a cleaner or carer she most likely has a non disclosure agreement. At the least she could be subject to a civil suit for invasion of privacy. It could even be a criminal offence. Shame on her.

Neither of these occupations. She is self employed so I guess she feels like she can get away with it more. I do love my sister but she does think she's gods gift. My parents pander to her and her partner does what he's told

OP posts:
lazyarse123 · 03/07/2026 00:35

That is appalling. Your sister is a cunt and anybody saying she isn't is not right in the head. Honestly she deserves sacking and if her service user knew what she'd done that would be her job gone. You were right to tell her.

Cheeseandolivesplease · 03/07/2026 00:35

@SilverTotoro I'm so sorry for your loss. Please never feel that you can't put up photos of your baby if you want to. Just in the same way as we put up photos of the babies and children still with us ❤️
Anybody that would pass judgement on that simply isn't worth knowing.

Dancingsquirrels · 03/07/2026 00:34

SilverTotoro · 03/07/2026 00:25

This makes me so sad. Our first baby was still born and I treasure the pictures we took of him. Your sisters reaction is why I’d never display the pictures in our home, I have a memory box instead. People who haven’t experienced this type of loss can never understand the fact that you’ve lost your child but it’s still the only chance you ever get to hold them and look at their little face so you just want to cling on to that.

I'm so sorry, that's very sad

GrumpyButOk · 03/07/2026 00:33

Speaking as someone who employs carers for my father, I am disgusted by your sister's actions and if I were her employer or any of the people whose homes she enters, I would expect to be informed of this breach of trust, and then I would fire her. If you're still unsure that you may be overreacting, ask her what her employer would say about it.

Dancingsquirrels · 03/07/2026 00:33

Of course she was in the wrong. And she knows it. But people don't usually respond well to criticism

You were absolutely right to challenge her

blythet · 03/07/2026 00:31

Absolutely sickening

mondaytosunday · 03/07/2026 00:31

Gross breach of privacy and basic human decency. In some jobs this would mean automatic termination. What does she do? If she's a cleaner or carer she most likely has a non disclosure agreement. At the least she could be subject to a civil suit for invasion of privacy. It could even be a criminal offence. Shame on her.

Cheeseandolivesplease · 03/07/2026 00:29

@Girlsonahill Did you ask her what possessed her to.do it? I can imagine to that family the photo of their beautiful baby who has passed is so incredibly precious and it ultimately is disrespectful to a) Take a photo of someone else's baby without permission and b) To post it to a group and mock it.
Besides, she shouldn't even be taking photos in other people's homes without express consent.
I would be angry with her too.

Gratitupe · 03/07/2026 00:27

Of course you’re not unreasonable and quite honestly there’s something wrong with people like your sister; a weird almost sociopathic lack of empathy. She sounds awful.

SilverTotoro · 03/07/2026 00:25

This makes me so sad. Our first baby was still born and I treasure the pictures we took of him. Your sisters reaction is why I’d never display the pictures in our home, I have a memory box instead. People who haven’t experienced this type of loss can never understand the fact that you’ve lost your child but it’s still the only chance you ever get to hold them and look at their little face so you just want to cling on to that.

Onthemaintrunkline · 03/07/2026 00:25

What an utterly dreadful thing to do. She absolutely took advantage of the reason she was in someone’s else’s home and then felt entitled to judge and criticize. She’s totally in the wrong.

DRose3 · 03/07/2026 00:22

She’s only upset because you called her out on her bad behaviour. Easier to blame you than have to accept she did something truly awful. People don’t like to feel badly about themselves.

Girlsonahill · 03/07/2026 00:13

Cheeseandolivesplease · 03/07/2026 00:08

@Watchoutfortheslowaraf I understand that. But what I am saying is re the "dead baby" comment. My brother is autistic. As a younger man he didn't really understand the "gravity" of death as a concept. And he also didn't understand the difference between sleeping and having passed away. As a child he would say sleeping dogs on a greetings card, for example, had "died."
I am unsure if the OP meant the baby had already passed when the photo was taken. To me, and having lost pregnancies myself, that is a beautiful and fitting tribute. But my brother may not understand this in the same way and might well think it a bit "unusual" for want of a better way of putting it.

No. She is not autistic. The baby in the photo had died, it looked like a newborn. It made me so sad to look at it and think what those parents would feel if they knew what she had done

OP posts:
OriginalUsername2 · 03/07/2026 00:11

Girlsonahill · 02/07/2026 23:49

Because she genuinely made me feel like I was overreacting. My mum said nothing, and although my partner agreed it was an awful thing to do, said I shouldn't have said anything to keep the peace

Some people don’t react well to shame. Just let it blow over, you’re in the right and she knows it but is attacking because she doesn’t want to admit it.

Inmyuggs · 03/07/2026 00:10

Tell her to her boss and the person who's privacy and trust she broke.
What a utter bitch.

CustardySergeant · 03/07/2026 00:09

How on earth can she try to justify doing such an appalling thing? Why would it even cross her mind to do it in the first place?

Cheeseandolivesplease · 03/07/2026 00:08

@Watchoutfortheslowaraf I understand that. But what I am saying is re the "dead baby" comment. My brother is autistic. As a younger man he didn't really understand the "gravity" of death as a concept. And he also didn't understand the difference between sleeping and having passed away. As a child he would say sleeping dogs on a greetings card, for example, had "died."
I am unsure if the OP meant the baby had already passed when the photo was taken. To me, and having lost pregnancies myself, that is a beautiful and fitting tribute. But my brother may not understand this in the same way and might well think it a bit "unusual" for want of a better way of putting it.

GoodGuessButNotRight · 03/07/2026 00:02

Girlsonahill · 02/07/2026 23:49

Because she genuinely made me feel like I was overreacting. My mum said nothing, and although my partner agreed it was an awful thing to do, said I shouldn't have said anything to keep the peace

She unsettled your peace!

GoodGuessButNotRight · 03/07/2026 00:00

That’s an awful caption to a baby photo. And soooo unnecessary. You’ve done nothing wrong @Girlsonahill and well done for not just accepting a vile message. She should be ashamed of herself.

JellyMouldJnr · 02/07/2026 23:53

That’s what sisters are for - to tell you when you’re doing something out of order. Well done OP.

SNESRainbowRoad · 02/07/2026 23:50

Are you sure she took the photo herself of one of her clients? I can just very well imagine that kind of dark humour being posted in some nursing group chats I’ve seen. It’s still not ok.

RampantIvy · 02/07/2026 23:49

Isn't that a sackable offence?

Girlsonahill · 02/07/2026 23:49

Ohthisheat · 02/07/2026 23:38

Of course not. Why on earth are you asking?

Because she genuinely made me feel like I was overreacting. My mum said nothing, and although my partner agreed it was an awful thing to do, said I shouldn't have said anything to keep the peace

OP posts:
Watchoutfortheslowaraf · 02/07/2026 23:48

Cheeseandolivesplease · 02/07/2026 23:45

That is disgusting, OP. My job involves working within homes too and I would never even consider taking photos of anything within their private property. Unprofessional. And to say that about a baby who has passed? Shocking. Please tell me she doesn't work with vulnerable people or children?
Is your sister autistic and so perhaps doesn't understand social boundaries?

Edited

Autistic people can understand that you don’t go and take a photo of a service users deceased baby and share it on your family WhatsApp