Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you if you’d date this man?

258 replies

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 14:39

To ask if you’d date this man if you found him attractive and in your age bracket and you are heterosexual female?

He is 53. Healthcare worker, interesting hobbies, seems very sensitive and caring. Intelligent. Interesting. Funny. Well travelled. Outgoing.

But…

He’s in the middle of a divorce. His ex has moved out of the family home to a smaller rented home and won’t see him face to face. They haven’t had contact in person for over a year. He lives in what was the family home. Has a teenage child that he doesn’t see. He says she has turned the child against him and she is an abusive narcissist. Nothing comes up on Claire’s law about him. The child apparently has behavioural issues due to his ex’s poor parenting in his view.

OP posts:
LejlaKapovic · 29/06/2026 16:03

I wouldn't, no.

I don't want a man who's not fully divorced.
I don't want a man with children from other women.
I don't trust men whose children don't see them. There must be a reason for it...

Glowingup · 29/06/2026 16:03

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 15:56

I know. I don’t think I’d have believed his ex back then anyway. Selfishly, I’m hoping it helps to steer him towards less antagonistic behaviour and gives him motivation to move the divorce forward. But I would not wish what I’ve been through and am still going through on anyone 😔

I think it could leave you vulnerable to further abuse if you got involved. He sounds like the narcissist here and he could react very badly if he discovered you “warned off” a new partner. Obviously if you think this woman would be at physical risk from him, I’d call the police and let them deal with it. Narcissists will also sometimes engage in financial abuse post-separation, eg letting the house get repossessed or damaging it, just to spite you. So keep focusing on yourself and keep avoiding him like the plague, which it sounds like your child is also doing. Get the house sold and then you can finally be free of him.

Sunshine1500 · 29/06/2026 16:03

JMSA · 29/06/2026 14:43

Hell, no. And aside from the obvious red flags, what kind of man stays in the family home while the wife and child have to move out?

exactly this! I’ve seen it happen so for. The man stays in the home and the children move out with their mum.

MrsPinkSky · 29/06/2026 16:02

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 15:46

Full disclosure. I’m the ‘crazy narcissist’ ex. I’ve just found out he is indeed dating.

I am divorcing him thanks to the wisdom of the women of MN after I posted a few AIBU and was helped to understand his behaviour wasn’t acceptable and I’m getting more used to labelling it as abuse - I’ve been told it was by many people but for some reason I find it hard to accept that label. It’s shameful I guess.

I can not believe that someone is dating him! But then he was completely convincing about his ex when I met him and he’s so convincing that I even believe that I am completely to blame still sometimes. It’s a total mind f**k.

But it’s helpful to know that most of you would see the warning signs. I just hope this woman keeps a healthy scepticism and doesn’t get too embroiled too quickly. Although it took me many many years to clock the issues and I’m not stupid.

Anyway, apologies for the subterfuge. I wanted to hear objective views.

Hmmm you're really not over him are you?

Forget writing about him on internet forums and asking strangers what they think regarding his new relationship.

That's not going to help you get past this.

Just try to phase him out of your brain.

Oranginacatterpilla · 29/06/2026 16:01

I would, but I am not necessarily looking for anything serious, and don’t tend to fall for people, or let my emotions overwhelm me. I can’t tell you the last time I found someone my own age attractive, so the benefits of a fling would outweigh the negatives for me.

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 15:59

outerspacepotato · 29/06/2026 15:57

Glad you got out.

Hardest thing I’ve done. Still hardest time of my life. But zero regrets. And am so glad I had this space to get objective advice. It was the start of the scales falling.

OP posts:
outerspacepotato · 29/06/2026 15:57

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 15:46

Full disclosure. I’m the ‘crazy narcissist’ ex. I’ve just found out he is indeed dating.

I am divorcing him thanks to the wisdom of the women of MN after I posted a few AIBU and was helped to understand his behaviour wasn’t acceptable and I’m getting more used to labelling it as abuse - I’ve been told it was by many people but for some reason I find it hard to accept that label. It’s shameful I guess.

I can not believe that someone is dating him! But then he was completely convincing about his ex when I met him and he’s so convincing that I even believe that I am completely to blame still sometimes. It’s a total mind f**k.

But it’s helpful to know that most of you would see the warning signs. I just hope this woman keeps a healthy scepticism and doesn’t get too embroiled too quickly. Although it took me many many years to clock the issues and I’m not stupid.

Anyway, apologies for the subterfuge. I wanted to hear objective views.

Glad you got out.

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 15:56

Glowingup · 29/06/2026 15:53

Sounds like you’re way better out of it. Yes my big red flag would be that you’re not wanting anything to do with him and that you chose to move out into rented accommodation to get away. Narcissistic people would want the exact opposite.
I guess the new woman will find out the hard way. After all, you were hoodwinked too when you met him. Nothing that you can do about it sadly.

I know. I don’t think I’d have believed his ex back then anyway. Selfishly, I’m hoping it helps to steer him towards less antagonistic behaviour and gives him motivation to move the divorce forward. But I would not wish what I’ve been through and am still going through on anyone 😔

OP posts:
Glowingup · 29/06/2026 15:53

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 15:46

Full disclosure. I’m the ‘crazy narcissist’ ex. I’ve just found out he is indeed dating.

I am divorcing him thanks to the wisdom of the women of MN after I posted a few AIBU and was helped to understand his behaviour wasn’t acceptable and I’m getting more used to labelling it as abuse - I’ve been told it was by many people but for some reason I find it hard to accept that label. It’s shameful I guess.

I can not believe that someone is dating him! But then he was completely convincing about his ex when I met him and he’s so convincing that I even believe that I am completely to blame still sometimes. It’s a total mind f**k.

But it’s helpful to know that most of you would see the warning signs. I just hope this woman keeps a healthy scepticism and doesn’t get too embroiled too quickly. Although it took me many many years to clock the issues and I’m not stupid.

Anyway, apologies for the subterfuge. I wanted to hear objective views.

Sounds like you’re way better out of it. Yes my big red flag would be that you’re not wanting anything to do with him and that you chose to move out into rented accommodation to get away. Narcissistic people would want the exact opposite.
I guess the new woman will find out the hard way. After all, you were hoodwinked too when you met him. Nothing that you can do about it sadly.

Stella1366 · 29/06/2026 15:52

No, the whole thing sounds like a disaster and he's right in the thick of it. Stand well back.

Additup · 29/06/2026 15:51

JMSA · 29/06/2026 14:43

Hell, no. And aside from the obvious red flags, what kind of man stays in the family home while the wife and child have to move out?

One whose wife walked out on him?

QuintadosMalvados · 29/06/2026 15:50

cluckinell2 · 29/06/2026 15:29

I’ll go against the grain. There is a lot of stereotyping about men using the ‘crazy ex’ stuff but spiteful, unpleasant women do exist. I would find out more about the situation before making a decision. If you like him and he’s a good guy it seems a bit over zealous to end it all because he’s going through a messy divorce. Obviously we all have boundaries of what we want/are willing to tolerate in a relationship and some people can’t be doing with anything that can be perceived as drama which is fair enough.

But having lived through my own fair share of drama I know it doesn’t define me as a person or partner.

I'm sure that you are correct, however, who wants to be the next victim of a jealous narcissist who's angry that you're with 'their' man.

Even if the woman broke it off, she still feels ownership over her victim forever.
It's just what narcissists are like.

Normal people are like, 'Oh I broke it off with him he's with somebody else now' and either won't care or be pleased that he's met someone else- either out of care or to alleviate guilt.

arethereanyleftatall · 29/06/2026 15:50

For once, I am very pleased this was a reverse.

BauhausOfEliott · 29/06/2026 15:48

Periperi2025 · 29/06/2026 15:29

I agree, but in these situations whether the crazy ex is male or female it is all the more important for the 'victim' to take their time to heal and have the space to navigate the shit show without the complication of a new romantic relationship.

So if the bloke OP was considering was divorced and a couple of years down the line, i think it would be harsh to discount him completely based on what she has said, rather than approaching with caution and pragmatism like she would (hopefully) do in any new relationship.

My new partner has a similar back story but is a couple of decades out the other end of it. I was/am still cautiously sceptical, but judge him by his behaviour and actions with me.

Yes, I agree with all of this.

I'm really not saying that the OP should date him - as a PP said, even if he has escaped an abusive relationship, why would you invite that level of drama into your life?

My argument was really more with the people who are implying that any man who says his ex was abusive or unstable is obviously lying and/or that any conflict must obviously have been his fault because men are cunts and women are never abusive.

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 15:46

Full disclosure. I’m the ‘crazy narcissist’ ex. I’ve just found out he is indeed dating.

I am divorcing him thanks to the wisdom of the women of MN after I posted a few AIBU and was helped to understand his behaviour wasn’t acceptable and I’m getting more used to labelling it as abuse - I’ve been told it was by many people but for some reason I find it hard to accept that label. It’s shameful I guess.

I can not believe that someone is dating him! But then he was completely convincing about his ex when I met him and he’s so convincing that I even believe that I am completely to blame still sometimes. It’s a total mind f**k.

But it’s helpful to know that most of you would see the warning signs. I just hope this woman keeps a healthy scepticism and doesn’t get too embroiled too quickly. Although it took me many many years to clock the issues and I’m not stupid.

Anyway, apologies for the subterfuge. I wanted to hear objective views.

OP posts:
Cardamomandlemons · 29/06/2026 15:46

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 15:14

Things got volatile between them and they had a massive row. That was the trigger.

One row wouldn't have messed up a great relationship. He needs to take accountability.

toottoot3 · 29/06/2026 15:45

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 14:46

He says he’s desperate to be in his child’s life.

Well that is instantly proved isn't it. Messages, emails, lawyers, support groups, etc he can really easily show you how he has been desperately trying to gain contact. Long list of unanswered messages from him to them..... Some might be private and you shouldn't read them, but at a glance you can see if he's attempting contact. My male friend did get stopped from seeing his kids, took a few weeks but he was see them again as he went through lawyers and no issues to stop him apart from difficult break up, quickly sorted

ScaredButUnavoidable · 29/06/2026 15:44

So where was he when his ex was doing all this awful parenting that led to their child having behavioural issues?

Or was he the perfect dad for the child’s entire life and it’s just in the last year whilst the child has been “turned against him” that these behavioural issues have emerged and the refusal to see his dad has come out of nowhere?

What a coincidence….. 🙄

TamarindCottage · 29/06/2026 15:43

Run

Dweetfidilove · 29/06/2026 15:42

No ma'am.

At almost 45 years old and long-term single, I have worked hard to build a very serene life. I'm not inviting anyone with any form of drama into my space. Nope!

I wouldn't even take him on as a lover. A glass of wine, a sigh, a what's up; and his problems become 'sofa/pillow talk'.
Nope! I haven't the capacity for any of that.

UrOutdoors · 29/06/2026 15:42

No, I wouldn’t.

Triskellion75 · 29/06/2026 15:41

Oh no, not the old 'she's turned the kid(s) against me' line. No.

QuintadosMalvados · 29/06/2026 15:40

Girlwithavibe · 29/06/2026 15:33

Tricky one !!!
I wouldn't take too much on other people opinions because he may be telling the truth he may be still hurting and lashing out (bad mouthing ex)
Or on the other hand he could be a bastard the only way u will know is if U go in with your EYES WIDE OPEN !!
Go with your gut and don't let him love bomb u it shouldn't take long to see the truth especially if U have strong boundaries and u stick to them !
The reason I say there are 2 sides I have seen what my son's ex did to him and in the beginning he was super angry and hurt ! And he did mad mouth her (no children involved thou and why isn't he getting social involved if she is such a bad parent )

Strong disagree. She needs to stop it before she gets too attached.

Beamsss · 29/06/2026 15:39

What is his plan for somewhere to live when his house sells? What was his response when you made it clear it won't be with you?

As a comfortably placed homeowner, I have found you learn a lot by telling men how much you love having your own place and how you have no intention of sharing it with amyone ever again.

QuintadosMalvados · 29/06/2026 15:38

Yes, it's sad if he is the victim here (a big if) but having experienced similar, see my post above, I feared for my own safety thus sadly had to say goodbye.

I have seen him out and about and he appears to be in a good relationship now and I'm pleased for him.
I wasn't going to risk getting attacked by a jealous psycho ex, though.

I think in OP's case, whichever scenario is true, she's best off out of it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread