Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you if you’d date this man?

258 replies

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 14:39

To ask if you’d date this man if you found him attractive and in your age bracket and you are heterosexual female?

He is 53. Healthcare worker, interesting hobbies, seems very sensitive and caring. Intelligent. Interesting. Funny. Well travelled. Outgoing.

But…

He’s in the middle of a divorce. His ex has moved out of the family home to a smaller rented home and won’t see him face to face. They haven’t had contact in person for over a year. He lives in what was the family home. Has a teenage child that he doesn’t see. He says she has turned the child against him and she is an abusive narcissist. Nothing comes up on Claire’s law about him. The child apparently has behavioural issues due to his ex’s poor parenting in his view.

OP posts:
LBFseBrom · 29/06/2026 17:04

No.

Chilly80 · 29/06/2026 17:02

No 🚩🚩🚩

NovaF · 29/06/2026 16:59

I have questions.

He’s in the middle of a divorce. - who instigated the divorce? I'm guessing the ex wife. Why are they divorcing?

They haven’t had contact in person for over a year. What ownership is he taking about his communication that they have not spoken for a year?

His ex has moved out of the family home to a smaller rented home and won’t see him face to face. Why was she the one that had to move out? With their teenage child? Why is it so acrimonious she will not speak to him?

Has a teenage child that he doesn’t see. Teenagers have their own working brains. What did the child witness and experience that means they do not want to talk to their dad?

He says she has turned the child against him and she is an abusive narcissist. - he is telling you what he is here. No court in the land would award custody to an obviously abusive parent. While it obviously does happen, why was he spending so little time with his child that someone could turn the child against him?

Nothing comes up on Claire’s law about him - that just means he has not been reported with the former

The child apparently has behavioural issues due to his ex’s poor parenting in his view. - this pisses me off the most. Why was she the only person parenting their child? If he was that concerned why did he not intervene and parent their child? Maybe the child has behavioural issues because his dad is a deadbeat that blames his wife for everything.

And if you are his next wife you can expect the same. Run. RUN!

Ok just saw the update. Oh OP, I am so glad you are out of his orbit and free now x

Pointynoseowner · 29/06/2026 16:54

Never

AMurderofMurderingCrows · 29/06/2026 16:53

This man has more red flags than a Communist Party rally. If I were single I wouldn't go near him 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩

I'm glad you're out of it now OP ❤️

sunseasand25 · 29/06/2026 16:52

Busybeemumm · 29/06/2026 15:13

What kind of man stays in the family home while his wife and son move out causing lots of instability for the son. This is a huge red flag. Run fast and don't look back!

My ex did and he was extremely abusive. He was also in a new relationship so quickly and acting all hard done by.

fivepastmidnight · 29/06/2026 16:48

He’s in the middle of a divorce. Nope

His ex has moved out of the family home to a smaller rented home and won’t see him face to face. Nope

Has a teenage child that he doesn’t see. Nope
He says she has turned the child against him and she is an abusive narcissist. Nope
The child apparently has behavioural issues due to his ex’s poor parenting in his view.Nope - just his ex's poor parenting I assume his was absolutely perfect?

even if any of what he says is true which I seriously doubt -Nope

NotBluebutCerulean · 29/06/2026 16:48

A no strings affair, maybe. Just for the sex.
But if his DD ever came back into his life you would be side-lined. would she ever accept you? - Very unlikely.
Next!

Ponderingwindow · 29/06/2026 16:47

Thank goodness. There is a woman out there without any sense, but at least it is not OP.

WhatTheHellsGoingOn · 29/06/2026 16:41

So he admits he had fuck all to do with raising his child if their behaviour is down to his ex’s parenting - what was he up to while she was bringing him up 100% alone in their house?

edit - just seen it’s a reverse - my point still stands with him blaming you, OP - he’s admitting he had no input - no excuses for being a shit dad

Namechangeforthisdilemma1 · 29/06/2026 16:40

Sunshine1500 · 29/06/2026 16:03

exactly this! I’ve seen it happen so for. The man stays in the home and the children move out with their mum.

My dad fleeced my mum out of the family home. And fiddled the child maintenance to only pay her £5 per week. And got aggy when he had to pay his FIVE! pounds until I was 19 (stayed in education). Oh and he recently signed up to some awful equity release scheme on his paid off mortgage, so out of that fleecing of my mum, he will leave nothing to their children. And wonders why I don’t stay in touch that often 🤔 🤣🤣

And I am sure he genuinely believes my mum “turned me against” him not his many other strange actions!

Pistachiocake · 29/06/2026 16:38

Yes, if it's not his fault. Anyone of us could end up in this situation. Some parents do awful things, like tell their kids their mum/dad hasn't turned up-when that parent really wanted to.
At this point you don't know what's true, but innocent until proven guilty.

Namechangeforthisdilemma1 · 29/06/2026 16:34

🚩 🚩 🚩

No way!!

Crunchymum · 29/06/2026 16:28

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 14:49

The child has chosen and is old enough to have their wishes prioritised. He says the ex has manipulated the child to refuse contact.

I know things have moved on and this is a weird reverse BUT there is no way on Earth I'd get involved with anyone in the process of a "messy divorce" and that is taking aside the fact the child doesn't want to see him and he is still in the family home (I know there are reasons the wife wouldn't want to be in the family home and I know in this instance the family home is being sold but in general a man who keeps the home and lets the kid/s move out is an utter bastard)

Pinkflamingo10 · 29/06/2026 16:25

No chance.

Crochetandtea · 29/06/2026 16:24

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 14:46

He says he’s desperate to be in his child’s life.

Actions not words!

toomuchfaff · 29/06/2026 16:23

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 15:46

Full disclosure. I’m the ‘crazy narcissist’ ex. I’ve just found out he is indeed dating.

I am divorcing him thanks to the wisdom of the women of MN after I posted a few AIBU and was helped to understand his behaviour wasn’t acceptable and I’m getting more used to labelling it as abuse - I’ve been told it was by many people but for some reason I find it hard to accept that label. It’s shameful I guess.

I can not believe that someone is dating him! But then he was completely convincing about his ex when I met him and he’s so convincing that I even believe that I am completely to blame still sometimes. It’s a total mind f**k.

But it’s helpful to know that most of you would see the warning signs. I just hope this woman keeps a healthy scepticism and doesn’t get too embroiled too quickly. Although it took me many many years to clock the issues and I’m not stupid.

Anyway, apologies for the subterfuge. I wanted to hear objective views.

Good to see you got out.

Dont be too concerned about the new woman, you're not obligated to warn her, you'll feed the narrative that youre the crazy ex.

YorkshirePuddingsGreatestFan · 29/06/2026 16:22

According to my ex, I'm a crazy narcissist who turned his child against him.

In reality, he kept getting drunk, beating me up and smashing things in the house, so I divorced him for domestic violence.

He then continued to be abusive through our child on access visits so it went back to court and they withdrew his access altogether.

Ohthisheat · 29/06/2026 16:20

Words are cheap. He's blaming his ex for him not persevering with keeping contact. Best avoided.

MageKing · 29/06/2026 16:19

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 16:07

No. I’m not over him but not in the missing him sense. Or not wanting him to move on sense. I’m still recovering. And still being mistreated in numerous ways. So no. Not over it at all. But not in a sad, wistful way. I was just curious and a little sad for the woman who won’t have a clue how things might pan out.

I think this is a really good description. I've seen people on threads like this saying this sort of thing - just forget about it, move on, etc. And of course, they're right. But it's hard.

In this specific case, there are a lot of women who haven't learned about these kind of men so they fall for the stories. Look at how many of the people on this thread did not doubt that you really were planning to date this man... we know women get taken in.

Shalamar · 29/06/2026 16:19

Let me translate for you:

He’s in the middle of a divorce - messy, rebound
His ex has moved out of the family home to a smaller rented home and won’t see him face to face - because he is abusive.
They haven’t had contact in person for over a year - because he's abusive.
He lives in what was the family home - terrible father allowing his child to be uprooted.
Has a teenage child that he doesn’t see - says it all about his fathering skills.
He says she has turned the child against him and she is an abusive narcissist - DARVO
Nothing comes up on Claire’s law about him - yet.
The child apparently has behavioural issues due to his ex’s poor parenting in his view - DARVO.

So may red flags.

MyMilchick · 29/06/2026 16:15

cupfinalchaos · 29/06/2026 16:07

Just from another perspective, my dh was still living in his family home when I met him (albeit in a cottage in the grounds) and his dd didn’t speak to him. Turns out she had cut him off in order to get some money out of him when they reconciled, which worked a treat.

im just saying each situation is different. Had I posted here I’d have been told to run a mile. He now has an excellent relationship with his dd and someone else would be with my incredible dh instead of me.

You can take the advice here but no one understands your particular situation as well as you.

Yes exactly. Unfortunately there are abusive, horrible people of both sexes.

Anyway OP, glad you've come out the other side

CabbageWater · 29/06/2026 16:14

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 14:46

He says he’s desperate to be in his child’s life.

There's what he says and what he does.

I wouldn't date him, like most people have said:

  • what a messy, horrible sounding drama to get involved in
  • the old "crazy, narc ex" chestnut is a massive red flag. He may not be lying, but I wouldn't take the chance, too fucking risky

(Posted before reading all OP's update, what a rookie mistake! Sorry! I'm glad you out OP!)

cupfinalchaos · 29/06/2026 16:07

Just from another perspective, my dh was still living in his family home when I met him (albeit in a cottage in the grounds) and his dd didn’t speak to him. Turns out she had cut him off in order to get some money out of him when they reconciled, which worked a treat.

im just saying each situation is different. Had I posted here I’d have been told to run a mile. He now has an excellent relationship with his dd and someone else would be with my incredible dh instead of me.

You can take the advice here but no one understands your particular situation as well as you.

BlueSandals · 29/06/2026 16:07

MrsPinkSky · 29/06/2026 16:02

Hmmm you're really not over him are you?

Forget writing about him on internet forums and asking strangers what they think regarding his new relationship.

That's not going to help you get past this.

Just try to phase him out of your brain.

No. I’m not over him but not in the missing him sense. Or not wanting him to move on sense. I’m still recovering. And still being mistreated in numerous ways. So no. Not over it at all. But not in a sad, wistful way. I was just curious and a little sad for the woman who won’t have a clue how things might pan out.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread