Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

HS2 isn't worth it

54 replies

Globules · 27/06/2026 19:03

I'm having a holiday in the Midlands.

I know the area pretty well, so have been appalled at the way HS2 has carved up the landscape. It looks awful.

Now that I've landed in my hotel, I've been reading up on HS2.

The minimum projected cost is £87.7 BILLION.

This is an absolutely shocking amount. What is the benefit? Is it that important that people arrive in Birmingham about 10 mins earlier?

Do you think we should cut our losses now and stop throwing cash that our country doesn't have at this money pit?

YABU - it'll be of huge benefit to the country
YANBU - we need to stop the work now and try to repair the damage already caused.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/cz6e0vplgldt?app-referrer=search

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TooHotMyIcecreamHasMelted · 27/06/2026 19:25

It’s honestly grotesque - not just the cost in pure cash terms but the carving up of the beautiful countryside, the disruption etc. It should have been abandoned but no-one wants to make that decision due to the cost sunk already. But it’s throwing even more money at an already very bad situation

CraftyNavySeal · 27/06/2026 19:25

The point never was about people getting to Birmingham 10 minutes earlier, it’s to increase capacity so that more trains can run across the network.

The project has been a complete shambles but the actually reasoning for it is sound.

MyNeedyLilacBird · 27/06/2026 19:21

The whole thing is a disgrace but that was clear from the start. I think i read something that said if they were to stop now it would probably cost them more than finishing it

Jellyofftheplate · 27/06/2026 19:15

Where have you been since this shambles of a project started?! Of course it's not worth it. I don't think anyone is defending it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread