Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scotland is about to get rid of prison for most crime and I am scared about the consequences

78 replies

CurdinHenry · 27/06/2026 09:54

The purpose is to save money because they can't afford to divert cash to build new prisons.

They've found a couple of studies (interviews with 5 individual subjects) they claim support "restorative justice" instead.

This means no prison for most crimes (including if you sack off your community service for the crime). It means shoplifting, mugging, most violent and sexual offences will not result in prison so the only thing stopping the criminal is the social penalty they can expect or their own moral compass.

Punch a nurse, spit on a bus driver, steal a school kid's iPhone at knifepoint all on the same day. No prison.

I know you're probably thinking this is an exaggeration of the policy and I can understand why because it seems too absurd and mad. But it's happening later this year.

(Peter Murrell got 5 years 3 months so they probably think they've dodged that embarrassing parallel but some of their sex offenders got less than that - Jordan Linden etc).

OP posts:
CurdinHenry · 27/06/2026 10:08

AgnesMcDoo · 27/06/2026 10:05

It’s just a consultation at this stage.

It would need to be backed by parliament before implementation

its based on more than 5 case studies

I’m no fan of the Scottish Government but it’s a bit more nuanced than your OP suggests

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c872yr4r12ro?app-referrer=search

I am sorry do you think there is genuinely evidence that society benefits from a standard policy of no prison for attempted rape, knife crime, violent theft? The evidence is literally anecdotal and anonymous, collected by campaigners with extreme bias.

The Greens are prison abolitionists so this will absolutely pass. I assume you must live somewhere fairly remote and don't worry about being marched to an ATM to empty your bank account but burglaries are about to be decriminalised too.

OP posts:
HumberSquid · 27/06/2026 10:08

Well locking people up for petty crime doesnt work either as a deterrent or as rehabilitation so maybe some sort of rethink is needed?

AgnesMcDoo · 27/06/2026 10:05

It’s just a consultation at this stage.

It would need to be backed by parliament before implementation

its based on more than 5 case studies

I’m no fan of the Scottish Government but it’s a bit more nuanced than your OP suggests

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c872yr4r12ro?app-referrer=search

An image of a series of security gates in a prison - with floor-to-ceiling white metal bars. Above the first set it says "E/F Wing" and a prison officer - a bald man in a white shirt and black trousers - is opening the gate. We see him from behind.

Sweeping changes proposed to reduce Scotland's prison population

The changes would see fewer criminals jailed and hundreds of prisoners get out of jail earlier in an attempt to tackle the prisons overcrowding crisis.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c872yr4r12ro?app-referrer=search