Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to object after my ex criticised my ring and writing?

587 replies

Lilifer · 22/06/2026 23:01

My ex husband turned up unannounced at my house tonight. No warning, just my 20year old DS appearing at the top of the stairs saying “Dad’s downstairs, he wants a word.” I had just got home from our youngest son’s school Leavers ceremony which had been pretty emotional for me, and I was in the middle of getting changed into my slouchy gear and thinking about dinner and relaxing with a quiet evening.

i went down to see him, a bit puzzled as had only seen him minutes before around at the school where we had talked a bit, what I got was being told that I am an embarrassment, that people are talking about me, and that I need to change my ways. Specifically:
The ring. I still wear my engagement ring on my ring finger. Not my wedding ring, just the engagement ring. I wear it because it’s valuable, I don’t want to leave it in a jewelry box where it could be stolen, it only fits that finger, and I don’t want to lose it. Ex husband has decided that this is a problem and that other people, friends, mutual friends, possibly family members, he was quite vague about his sources, are apparently commenting on it and finding it strange and something to be criticised for.

When I pointed out that I don’t know anyone who goes around looking at other people’s hands, he said “you’d be surprised.” He suggested I put it in a safety deposit box. In his shop. I declined.

Writing on Medium. I write on Medium, about my life, (nothing about him) current affairs, personal essays. Ex husband has decided this is also A Problem because I am apparently “putting my whole life out there.” He cited people who had apparently told him not to read my piece about his father’s funeral because it would upset him. He has not read it. He does not know what is in it. The piece was a tribute to a man I loved and had known for over twenty five years. I referred to him as my father-in-law because that is what he was to me for most of my adult life. Apparently this was overstepping.

The funeral. This is not the first time this has come up. His father died a couple of years ago. I loved his father and his father loved me. I am the mother of his grandchildren. I made sure my kids were all turned out well in good suits and outfits at short notice, I made sure they did their grandfather proud, and I sat approximately a third of the way down the church. Not the front row. Not beside my ex and our children. A third of the way down. Apparently I should have been at the back.

We have been over this before and he doubled down tonight.
For additional context:

  • I had a frightening health episode just days ago that he was aware of. He did not ask how I was. Not once.
  • I spent weeks putting together a box of duplicate family photographs for him, his travels before we met, photos of the children growing up, carefully sorted and labelled. He never acknowledged it. Not a text, not a word.
  • He has a partner.
  • I live in his hometown, surrounded by his people, his business, his family, his influence. He is a big personality in the town. I have built my own life here but it is not easy.
  • We are three months away from our financial agreement ending completely.

So. AIBU to keep wearing the ring? And also AIBU to think that turning up unannounced to deliver all of this on the evening of your son’s Leavers Mass is not okay?
Asking for a friend. That friend is me. 😅

OP posts:
Aluna · 24/06/2026 22:03

CamillaMcCauley · 24/06/2026 21:50

It seems to me that a lot of people on this thread can’t recognise control issues when they see them, including their own.

Or some people have never been to small town Ireland.

If her ex was continuing to wear his wedding band despite divorce and the fact she’d prefer him not to, that would be labelled a control behaviour of itself.

Ilikesundays · 24/06/2026 22:03

JLou08 · 22/06/2026 23:15

It sounds like his partner is jealous and getting on at him.
It is a bit odd to wear the ring. I sold my old engagement ring after separation. Wearing it does give off a signal that you're still clinging to the relationship.

Though as Mae West said, in similar circumstances,”My sentiments towards the ring haven’t changed.”

Lilifer · 24/06/2026 21:59

@CamillaMcCauley it was only when I left my marriage that I could see the control that had been there for so long 😔

OP posts:
CamillaMcCauley · 24/06/2026 21:50

Lilifer · 24/06/2026 21:41

That’s how I feel about it too!

It seems to me that a lot of people on this thread can’t recognise control issues when they see them, including their own.

Lilifer · 24/06/2026 21:41

Arkhamasylum · 24/06/2026 20:16

I can’t believe the number of people on this post who are saying he has a point. Wear your ring, write your blog - you’re divorced from him, what you do is no longer his business. He has a right to be pissed off, sure, but you should no longer have to hear about it or care about it.

That’s how I feel about it too!

OP posts:
Lilifer · 24/06/2026 21:40

@Littlemisssavvyyes I’ve been thinking of composing some kind of message to that effect, to draw a line under this and make things clear

OP posts:
Littlemisssavvy · 24/06/2026 21:03

I think your ex is being VERY unreasonable and can only think the new partner is in his ear all the time.

My DH Ex attended his Dad’s funeral, she still keeps in touch with his Mum, we are both totally fine with it even though it’s been nearly 30 years. There are children/grand children so its much better when everyone is civil and grown up.

If you like and want to wear the ring, then that’s entirely up to you. I wore my original engagement ring from Ex on my my right hand for years as I loved it. My now husband asked me to stop wearing it so now my daughter has it.

I wonder if you should send him a message to set out a response ie in reflection you think he is being v unreasonable, ask him not to turn up unannounced etc

BlueMum16 · 24/06/2026 21:03

liamharha · 24/06/2026 20:32

Well I disagree . So . It was given to her by him as a symbol of his love and commitment to her . It symbolic and sentimental and Im sure holds memories of a proposal and wedding . It's not just a gifted piece of jewellery . Alot of couples use passed down engagement rings for their symbolism .Maybe I'm petty and pedantic ,,different horses for different courses ,but yeah I wouldn't like it . Id think it was weird and cringe if my partners ex did it and it and id find it creepy and unerving of my ex husband still wore his wedding ring cos it was valuable and he liked it 😬👍

Stop talking complete and utter bolloxks.

liamharha · 24/06/2026 20:32

blacksax · 24/06/2026 20:24

It is not his engagement ring. It stopped being his ring at the very second he gave it to her when they got engaged.

Well I disagree . So . It was given to her by him as a symbol of his love and commitment to her . It symbolic and sentimental and Im sure holds memories of a proposal and wedding . It's not just a gifted piece of jewellery . Alot of couples use passed down engagement rings for their symbolism .Maybe I'm petty and pedantic ,,different horses for different courses ,but yeah I wouldn't like it . Id think it was weird and cringe if my partners ex did it and it and id find it creepy and unerving of my ex husband still wore his wedding ring cos it was valuable and he liked it 😬👍

blacksax · 24/06/2026 20:24

liamharha · 24/06/2026 16:26

I hinjnthis exactly what her umhusband is trying to say to her in a round about way . Mad the way this thread the ex husband can have no views or boundaries at all about things that affect his private family life yet it's perfectly fine for op to wear his engagement ring (that's a statement )on her ring finger and turn up at HIS family gatherings (he needs to address that invitation situation with his family ) . Disrespect the request he made of her at HIS father's funeral . Alot of you would be calling him creepy as fuck as fuck and sighting red flag behaviour if this was the other way round .

It is not his engagement ring. It stopped being his ring at the very second he gave it to her when they got engaged.

Arkhamasylum · 24/06/2026 20:16

I can’t believe the number of people on this post who are saying he has a point. Wear your ring, write your blog - you’re divorced from him, what you do is no longer his business. He has a right to be pissed off, sure, but you should no longer have to hear about it or care about it.

Lilifer · 24/06/2026 20:15

Thanks for all the opinions both agreeing and disagreeing with me. It’s been interesting reading all the views. I am happy with my own choices, apart from my article which I regret posting without running it past him first. Now that’s removed. As far as the ring is concerned, I may well get it re-made into something new, but I will do that in my own time, not because I feel brow beaten into it. I’m happy wearing it the way I do for now, and I really don’t care what others think about that. Nor do I regret how I conducted myself ant his fathers funeral. Judge if you like, you’re perfectly entitled to do so. And I won’t be allowing him into my home again, unless I’ve specifically invited him for a kids 21st or something like that. I’m learning boundaries, and I’m learning to listen to myself.

OP posts:
FireandBrimstone · 24/06/2026 20:13

Sell the ring when your financial settlement completes. Still to be wearing it IS odd tbf.

The time and care spent on the photos is really thoughtful but does kind of come across like you still have feelings of attachment.

Hands-down, it’s the partner who’s been reading your Medium and has put their foot down on all of this. That’s not to say he has a right to have made the demands on you or done so in the way he did - he doesn’t.

But you need to cut the ties once and for all, for your own future happiness.

WoosMama13 · 24/06/2026 18:45

BudgetBuster · 22/06/2026 23:06

Fuck it... I'd wear my wedding dress next time i had to see him 😂

Sounds like hia new life is fairly crap if he's still so invested in yours.

Yes, this! And re-hang wedding photos, play the wedding video on the TV!!
He wants to be petty, meet him and raise it.

Apologies, peri rage and idiotic people make me petty.
Wear it. It's yours to do as you wish. Nobody can tell you, an adult, what to do, especially your ex husband!
Hope you're feeling okay after your scare too.

Goatblu · 24/06/2026 18:37

As it's an expensive ring, I'd sell it and buy a lovely new one and wear it wherever I damn well pleased. At least then there would be no attachment to him (apart from children obvs).

BudgetBuster · 24/06/2026 18:34

Lilifer · 24/06/2026 12:08

@BudgetBusteri may have to!

In typical Irish style I'd go with "Era, John... go away and fuck off and stop looking at my hands. I've taken the post down now. Off you trot"

NeelyOHara · 24/06/2026 18:33

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 24/06/2026 18:27

I guarantee that if @Lilifer didn't attend the funeral of her FIL or skulked at the back of the church in a small Irish village after a 20+ year marriage to his son her life wouldn't be worth living and he'd have thrown that in her face instead.

He's just a dick, remind yourself of that and don't give it the headspace. Remind your kids that while he is their father, it is not an open door policy and as awkward as it is you don't want him in the house.

Why would he be angry at her sitting at the back? That is why he asked her to do.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 24/06/2026 18:27

Auntiebenita · 24/06/2026 18:21

I believe you when you say you had a wonderful, deep relationship with your FIL. But surely you can appreciate that it won’t have been on the same level as the relationship someone has with their parent. Great to go to the funeral but I think you were wrong not to respect ex's wishes for where you should sit. He may have been being unreasonable but it was his father's funeral and his wishes should have trumped yours. As far as I can see you had no reason not to do what he wanted other than that you wanted to demonstrate that he can’t control you. But that was not the right occasion on which to make a stand.

I'm afraid I agree with the PPs who have said that if it was an ex-husband behaving in the way you are, still coming to a woman's family occasions etc., refusing to sit where she asked him to sit at her parent's funeral, making a point of wearing a meaningful piece of jewellery in a meaningful place (when it could easily be resized to fit elsewhere if you really must wear it), people would be responding very differently.

Your ex sound incredibly irritating, but in my opinion you’re fanning the flames by your actions, and I suspect quite a lot of people in your life see this.

I guarantee that if @Lilifer didn't attend the funeral of her FIL or skulked at the back of the church in a small Irish village after a 20+ year marriage to his son her life wouldn't be worth living and he'd have thrown that in her face instead.

He's just a dick, remind yourself of that and don't give it the headspace. Remind your kids that while he is their father, it is not an open door policy and as awkward as it is you don't want him in the house.

Auntiebenita · 24/06/2026 18:21

Lilifer · 24/06/2026 15:28

I’d push back on you assuming that because you can’t imagine doing something, there must be a hidden motive behind it. Not everything is a statement. I’m wearing it because it fits that finger and I don’t want to lose it.

And I knew my father-in-law for twenty-five years and am the mother of his grandchildren. The suggestion that the depth of that relationship ‘isn’t there’ is presumptuous from someone who knows nothing about it.

I believe you when you say you had a wonderful, deep relationship with your FIL. But surely you can appreciate that it won’t have been on the same level as the relationship someone has with their parent. Great to go to the funeral but I think you were wrong not to respect ex's wishes for where you should sit. He may have been being unreasonable but it was his father's funeral and his wishes should have trumped yours. As far as I can see you had no reason not to do what he wanted other than that you wanted to demonstrate that he can’t control you. But that was not the right occasion on which to make a stand.

I'm afraid I agree with the PPs who have said that if it was an ex-husband behaving in the way you are, still coming to a woman's family occasions etc., refusing to sit where she asked him to sit at her parent's funeral, making a point of wearing a meaningful piece of jewellery in a meaningful place (when it could easily be resized to fit elsewhere if you really must wear it), people would be responding very differently.

Your ex sound incredibly irritating, but in my opinion you’re fanning the flames by your actions, and I suspect quite a lot of people in your life see this.

DimwittedSkater · 24/06/2026 17:30

Lilifer · 24/06/2026 09:20

I don’t think they will have kids, she’s 50 and he mid fifties - he said something like he didn’t want two women running around the town wearing his engagement rings 😣

But your ring is not "his" engagement ring. It's yours, and it's no longer an engagement ring.

It's clear that he seems himself as the centre of everything. And you let this prince go??

Seriously, who gives a rat's furry arse what he thinks.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/06/2026 16:54

Lilifer · 24/06/2026 09:20

I don’t think they will have kids, she’s 50 and he mid fifties - he said something like he didn’t want two women running around the town wearing his engagement rings 😣

So he does want to give it to her, then?

Cheap way of shutting her up, I guess.

liamharha · 24/06/2026 16:26

blacksax · 24/06/2026 10:54

Two words should suffice when dealing with insufferable exes:

Fuck off.

I hinjnthis exactly what her umhusband is trying to say to her in a round about way . Mad the way this thread the ex husband can have no views or boundaries at all about things that affect his private family life yet it's perfectly fine for op to wear his engagement ring (that's a statement )on her ring finger and turn up at HIS family gatherings (he needs to address that invitation situation with his family ) . Disrespect the request he made of her at HIS father's funeral . Alot of you would be calling him creepy as fuck as fuck and sighting red flag behaviour if this was the other way round .

Peterdottir · 24/06/2026 15:56

OP i've been catching up with your posts and noticed you said all of your children are at least 18. That being the case you don't actually need to have any contact with each other (apart from major life events) so there is absolutely no need for him to come to your house apart from droppping off children.

I've seen my ex-husband once since our son turned 18 which was at his graduation. If our son gets married then i will see him then but otherwise don't expect to. Our son is almost 26.

We don't live in the same place and you've said where you live is small so you can't help bumping into each other. However there is no need now for you to interact regularly regarding your children as they can make their own plans to see their Dad?

Lilifer · 24/06/2026 15:28

GiveMeCoffee637281 · 24/06/2026 15:00

YABU.

Wearing the engagement ring on the wedding ring finger is a statement. If jewellery was just for fashion without any meaning, there wouldn't be engagement and wedding rings. At least get it resized and wear it on the other hand.

And you may have been close with your FIL but he was NOT your father. The depth of the relationship isn't there. If an ex wrote about my own parent's funeral, I'd be fuming.

He may be a controlling knob but I have to say, especially if you live in a smaller village where everyone knows each other, it reads as if you are REALLY trying very hard to get his attention and shitstirring.

I’d push back on you assuming that because you can’t imagine doing something, there must be a hidden motive behind it. Not everything is a statement. I’m wearing it because it fits that finger and I don’t want to lose it.

And I knew my father-in-law for twenty-five years and am the mother of his grandchildren. The suggestion that the depth of that relationship ‘isn’t there’ is presumptuous from someone who knows nothing about it.

OP posts:
GiveMeCoffee637281 · 24/06/2026 15:00

YABU.

Wearing the engagement ring on the wedding ring finger is a statement. If jewellery was just for fashion without any meaning, there wouldn't be engagement and wedding rings. At least get it resized and wear it on the other hand.

And you may have been close with your FIL but he was NOT your father. The depth of the relationship isn't there. If an ex wrote about my own parent's funeral, I'd be fuming.

He may be a controlling knob but I have to say, especially if you live in a smaller village where everyone knows each other, it reads as if you are REALLY trying very hard to get his attention and shitstirring.

Swipe left for the next trending thread