Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to object after my ex criticised my ring and writing?

587 replies

Lilifer · 22/06/2026 23:01

My ex husband turned up unannounced at my house tonight. No warning, just my 20year old DS appearing at the top of the stairs saying “Dad’s downstairs, he wants a word.” I had just got home from our youngest son’s school Leavers ceremony which had been pretty emotional for me, and I was in the middle of getting changed into my slouchy gear and thinking about dinner and relaxing with a quiet evening.

i went down to see him, a bit puzzled as had only seen him minutes before around at the school where we had talked a bit, what I got was being told that I am an embarrassment, that people are talking about me, and that I need to change my ways. Specifically:
The ring. I still wear my engagement ring on my ring finger. Not my wedding ring, just the engagement ring. I wear it because it’s valuable, I don’t want to leave it in a jewelry box where it could be stolen, it only fits that finger, and I don’t want to lose it. Ex husband has decided that this is a problem and that other people, friends, mutual friends, possibly family members, he was quite vague about his sources, are apparently commenting on it and finding it strange and something to be criticised for.

When I pointed out that I don’t know anyone who goes around looking at other people’s hands, he said “you’d be surprised.” He suggested I put it in a safety deposit box. In his shop. I declined.

Writing on Medium. I write on Medium, about my life, (nothing about him) current affairs, personal essays. Ex husband has decided this is also A Problem because I am apparently “putting my whole life out there.” He cited people who had apparently told him not to read my piece about his father’s funeral because it would upset him. He has not read it. He does not know what is in it. The piece was a tribute to a man I loved and had known for over twenty five years. I referred to him as my father-in-law because that is what he was to me for most of my adult life. Apparently this was overstepping.

The funeral. This is not the first time this has come up. His father died a couple of years ago. I loved his father and his father loved me. I am the mother of his grandchildren. I made sure my kids were all turned out well in good suits and outfits at short notice, I made sure they did their grandfather proud, and I sat approximately a third of the way down the church. Not the front row. Not beside my ex and our children. A third of the way down. Apparently I should have been at the back.

We have been over this before and he doubled down tonight.
For additional context:

  • I had a frightening health episode just days ago that he was aware of. He did not ask how I was. Not once.
  • I spent weeks putting together a box of duplicate family photographs for him, his travels before we met, photos of the children growing up, carefully sorted and labelled. He never acknowledged it. Not a text, not a word.
  • He has a partner.
  • I live in his hometown, surrounded by his people, his business, his family, his influence. He is a big personality in the town. I have built my own life here but it is not easy.
  • We are three months away from our financial agreement ending completely.

So. AIBU to keep wearing the ring? And also AIBU to think that turning up unannounced to deliver all of this on the evening of your son’s Leavers Mass is not okay?
Asking for a friend. That friend is me. 😅

OP posts:
aeon418 · 25/06/2026 22:20

Lilifer · 22/06/2026 23:57

I write for Medium under my maiden name. Someone somehow has found me under that name, (most people would not know me from that name as I moved here from hundreds of miles away)I never thought he would hear of it or see it, but even then, mentioning the funeral was a small part of a larger article about Irish funerals and mourning. I can’t wear the ring on my other hand as it doesn’t fit any of my fingers so would have to try and resize it.
I will think about what i can do. But I wouldn’t dream of telling anyone else what to do with their body, be that jewellery piercings or whatever and certainly him coming in to my home and telling me all the things I’ve done wrong isn’t really helping things, we are divorced, it’s my ring to wear how and where I want!

Edited

I would wear that ring on your middle finger and show it to him anytime you see him. 😝

Lilifer · 25/06/2026 22:13

@ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm A

As for whether you should continue to wear it, I guess it comes down to what you think an engagement ring is - a gift of jewellery or
a tag signifying ownership, like some kind of poultry leg ring

This analogy is comedy gold 😂 👏🏻👏🏻

OP posts:
ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 25/06/2026 22:06

And here’s me thinking it’s perfectly normal for the fingers on your non dominant hand not to be the same size as the other. My wedding ring (don’t have an engagement ring) also doesn’t fit on the other hand.

As for whether you should continue to wear it, I guess it comes down to what you think an engagement ring is - a gift of jewellery or
a tag signifying ownership, like some kind of poultry leg ring. I also can’t imagine paying much attention to what finger someone was wearing a ring on. But as I said, I don’t have an engagement ring and I bought my own wedding ring, to satisfy tradition (and because I wanted something sparkly). Myself and my husband think that marriage is more than jewelry.

WearyAuldWumman · 25/06/2026 22:06

PyongyangKipperbang · 25/06/2026 21:39

You do realise that she didnt need his permission, right?

Yes the rest of it was odd but she didnt need to ask his permission!

That's a moot point in this case - they were all his photographs, though he didn't realise that they'd been left behind in the attic of what had been their marital home before she acquired a boyfriend.

I'd say that - at the very least - she might have asked if he was okay with her destroying comments made by his mother and his cousins. The photographs were never hers, though I acknowledge that DH should have realised that he'd left them behind.

In his defence, DH was dealing with finding his own place to live as well as the trauma of his first wife's affair.

We assumed that the ex had come across the photographs when she cleared out the attic. She also returned his mother's sewing machine (with a significant component missing).

The photographs of his grandfather were from WW1. There were also photographs of his great-grandparents. One was an even older photograph on a glass plate. The glue destroyed the image.

Now, if they'd been joint family photographs taken during the marriage, then that would have been a different matter entirely in my view.

I suppose that a court might have designated it all joint marital property.

Lilifer · 25/06/2026 22:06

Jllllllll · 25/06/2026 21:59

It’s weird that you’re wearing the ring still yes. Sell it if it’s valuable don’t wear it.

yeah except I don’t care if people think it’s weird, I’ll suit myself thanks

OP posts:
DryadsRest · 25/06/2026 22:00

It seems the OP likes the ring very much so shy shouldnt she wear it - doesn’t sound like she’s missing the marriage!

Jllllllll · 25/06/2026 21:59

It’s weird that you’re wearing the ring still yes. Sell it if it’s valuable don’t wear it.

DryadsRest · 25/06/2026 21:58

most People if they noticed an engagement ring would have a fleeting thought and leave it at that!

DryadsRest · 25/06/2026 21:58

Lilifer · 25/06/2026 21:32

With a bit of distance from this now (it Happened on Monday) I have decided that I will never let him in the house like that again. If he wants to speak to me about something important it’s will be either via e mail or over phone, no need for in person. I will tell him this and my kids too. One thing I am glad of is that for probably the first time since our divorce I at least stood up for myself, stood my ground and told him to leave once he started getting shitty about it. Previously I would have tried to reason with him, thinking that if I could only explain my side of things that he would understand. He doesn’t want to understand, I’m done being civil and reasonable, he will never get to do that again.

I think you should carry on as you are, you’re clearly a well liked person by his family or they wouldn’t include you. My parents both attended the funerals of my grandparents to pay their respects to their respective parents in law - and that’s what funerals are for.

I suspect you’ll find out in time that actually his new partner has a problem with you being so liked and welcomed by his family, and is causing problems in her mind that your ex husbands pride won’t admit to. She probably stalked you and googled your maiden name etc and is jealous of you for some reason!

(Furthermore perhaps people are not appreciating the dynamics of Irish country life especially where people may have lived for generations)!

carry on as you are 😀

PyongyangKipperbang · 25/06/2026 21:39

WearyAuldWumman · 25/06/2026 21:23

Without my husband's permission, his ex stuck a load of historic family photos from his side into an album - a ring file binder with sheets of plain white paper in it.

The photographs were not in any particular order, but were glued in - including some from WW1 and some that predated that.

The result was that she'd concealed the handwritten inscriptions on the back. She'd rewritten them on the paper next to the photos.

In some cases, she'd written names next to the photos - the wrong names.

One photograph was correctly identified as my husband's foster-sister - but she incorrectly stated that the girl had been disowned by the family. DH was so upset when he read that - his foster-sister had married at 16 against family wishes - but she hadn't been disowned. (The adoption society approved the marriage.) She had also died of a brain tumour at the age of 27.

To this day, I cannot decide whether the ex was being helpful or malevolent. Even her DIL has described her as 'jealous and controlling'. [NB The ex is currently with her 4th partner and had a partner had the time that she made up the album.]

You do realise that she didnt need his permission, right?

Yes the rest of it was odd but she didnt need to ask his permission!

PyongyangKipperbang · 25/06/2026 21:37

Re-read the thread and its coming across as "Why didnt you go back to your maiden name? My fiance doesnt want to be Ms Madeupname when you are too"

Lilifer · 25/06/2026 21:34

Startrekkeruniverse · 25/06/2026 21:28

Very odd wearing the engagement ring on your ring finger still.

And writing about his dad’s funeral, also very odd.

I don’t agree. Funny how we’re all different isn’t it 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Lilifer · 25/06/2026 21:32

With a bit of distance from this now (it Happened on Monday) I have decided that I will never let him in the house like that again. If he wants to speak to me about something important it’s will be either via e mail or over phone, no need for in person. I will tell him this and my kids too. One thing I am glad of is that for probably the first time since our divorce I at least stood up for myself, stood my ground and told him to leave once he started getting shitty about it. Previously I would have tried to reason with him, thinking that if I could only explain my side of things that he would understand. He doesn’t want to understand, I’m done being civil and reasonable, he will never get to do that again.

OP posts:
gingercat02 · 25/06/2026 21:28

Crunchymum · 25/06/2026 20:15

@Lilifer I asked many pages back, why don't you wear it on your other hand? Why do you still wear it on your wedding finger?

Edited

My rings don't fit my right hand, I checked

Startrekkeruniverse · 25/06/2026 21:28

Very odd wearing the engagement ring on your ring finger still.

And writing about his dad’s funeral, also very odd.

WearyAuldWumman · 25/06/2026 21:23

MaturingCheeseball · 25/06/2026 19:30

For me it’s the photos… I don’t know any ex-wife who would do all this for their ex. At best they’d send old photos round in a bin bag (and at worst…snip snip…). But they certainly wouldn’t be spending time curating photos of his travels!

It really does come across as if you would step right back in in a heartbeat.

Without my husband's permission, his ex stuck a load of historic family photos from his side into an album - a ring file binder with sheets of plain white paper in it.

The photographs were not in any particular order, but were glued in - including some from WW1 and some that predated that.

The result was that she'd concealed the handwritten inscriptions on the back. She'd rewritten them on the paper next to the photos.

In some cases, she'd written names next to the photos - the wrong names.

One photograph was correctly identified as my husband's foster-sister - but she incorrectly stated that the girl had been disowned by the family. DH was so upset when he read that - his foster-sister had married at 16 against family wishes - but she hadn't been disowned. (The adoption society approved the marriage.) She had also died of a brain tumour at the age of 27.

To this day, I cannot decide whether the ex was being helpful or malevolent. Even her DIL has described her as 'jealous and controlling'. [NB The ex is currently with her 4th partner and had a partner had the time that she made up the album.]

pimplebum · 25/06/2026 21:21

ValueofNothing · 22/06/2026 23:08

He thinks he owns you. Tell him to do one.

Yes your mistake was listening to any of this

have you told him since he is not allowed to turn up unannounced?

did. You tell him to fuck off ???

NaiceCupOTea · 25/06/2026 21:20

There are lots of differing opinions on here and I'm not sure where I sit on any of them

What I am sure of though is that he can get to fuck if he thinks he can come into YOUR HOME and berate you about anything at all. You should not entertain that nonsense. Why was he even in your house in the first place? Do not let him in, tell the kids to not let him in. If he wants a rant, he can do it on the doorstep so you can shut the door in his face. What a twat.

Booboobagins · 25/06/2026 21:15

Ignore the knobhead.

You do you, he can choose to do him.

NotAtMyAge · 25/06/2026 21:11

Crunchymum · 25/06/2026 20:26

Sorry I missed that being said (I've skimmed read the OP's replies but there are loads and they are quite wordy)

On to my my next question/s. How can it not fit? Can it be resized? Can it go on middle finger (although assume its too small not too big?)

Am baffled about how the finger can be vastly different sizes on each hand.

Edited

Most people have one dominant hand, usually the right, which does a lot more work than the other and usually ends up bigger and stronger. Looking at my own hands, there's no way any of my rings would fit my right hand.

NameChangeAgain48 · 25/06/2026 21:07

Fuck him. Fuck them all.

He thinks he's Mr big balls and can still boss you around and control you.

You should have asked him to leave. He came into your house uninvited to chat shit.

I understand that you want to keep things amicable but that doesnt mean you keep the peace at all costs. Your home is your safe space I wouldnt allow him in it ever

Tell him:
You are not welcome in my home unless I specifically invite you.

As for the ring. You need to practice phases.

That's your opinion. I dont agree.
Im not discussing my jewellery.
We are going to have to disagree on that.

Id also practice
I've made my position clear.
This isn't up for discussion.

CamillaMcCauley · 25/06/2026 21:03

I think it’s crazy how many people seem to think you should just dump an entire family (who are blood relatives of your children) just because your relationship with one of them didn’t work out.

I’m still friends with the mother of an ex from 20 years ago! Granted, he and I are still pals too, but my friendship with his mother is quite separate to my friendship with him. We message each other through the year, see each other occasionally when we are in each other’s city and she sent me gifts for the births of my children with another man entirely! Even if my ex and I never spoke again, I’d stay in touch with her… and you better believe that when she passes, I’ll be at her funeral.

Beaniebabe1 · 25/06/2026 21:00

Can I just say you sound bloody marvellous! You are completely right that no one - especially an EXDH gets to tell you what to wear. I have fabulous ring which was given to me by my DH. If we divorced I would still think the ring was fabulous and wear it. Your ex’s obsession with what you’re doing is now fortunately nothing to do with you and you can ignore. Stay strong and classy (which you clearly are)

NotAtMyAge · 25/06/2026 20:58

Lilifer · 24/06/2026 15:28

I’d push back on you assuming that because you can’t imagine doing something, there must be a hidden motive behind it. Not everything is a statement. I’m wearing it because it fits that finger and I don’t want to lose it.

And I knew my father-in-law for twenty-five years and am the mother of his grandchildren. The suggestion that the depth of that relationship ‘isn’t there’ is presumptuous from someone who knows nothing about it.

OP I am very much with you on your genuinely deep and loving relationship with your late father-in-law, as I was blessed with a similar one with my dear FiL, who sadly died when he was only 60. My DH and I are still married, but the relationship I had with his father was between him and me, as two adults who liked each other at first meeting and grew to love and respect each other very much. It seems to me that your ex's mother understands that and has no problem with it, so I would take my lead from her in your relationship with her and her other children.

ETA I wrote a blog anonymously for several years and really loved the writing and the interaction with readers. Now in old age, I value the thoughts and experiences I captured in those posts and reread the best from time to time.

WearyAuldWumman · 25/06/2026 20:56

Lilifer · 24/06/2026 10:24

Same surname yes. I think that’s pretty normal though when you have kids. Some of his family mentioned the article and liked it. It was written over a year ago now, I had forgotten about it really but it’s gone now. I don’t think he’s that impressed I’m writing at all.

Yes, my husband's ex kept the surname. I've always just assumed that it's so she has the same surname as her kids.