Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel anxious after requesting a Clare's Law disclosure?

55 replies

Yournextdoorfriend · 17/06/2026 15:39

Hi all,
I met someone online on a dating app a few months ago. In a different town we message/talk regularly. More like friends right now but we get on. Will see how things go if anywhere. More my call if anything. He mentioned he had a voluntary restraining order at the start - I asked why his marriage ended, what his reasons were, what his partners reasons would be. He has the 2 of the 3 children who are boys the daughter lives with the mum. According to him he asked for a non molestaiom order for himself to counteract the allegations his ex wife was making and to stop any more being made. Yes I know tale as old as time in reflection. I didn't really think to question it, have had no reason to question anything about his character since - have met several times. The only reason I even considered making a CLR was curiosity to see how it worked. I have since had a phone call asking to meet me to discuss.
im anxious even though i knew it would be this if he was telling the truth. I dnt know how to feel.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheHateUGive · 18/06/2026 18:52

ExplodingSmittens · 18/06/2026 18:33

The OP hasn’t said that he has signed an Undertaking though. What’s she’s said is that he has a Restraining Order against him.

The said a voluntary restraining order. That can be a promise to stay away from the other person. If you violate that, it works as evidence for a non-molestation order.

ExplodingSmittens · 18/06/2026 18:33

TheHateUGive · 18/06/2026 07:33

It's called an undertaking

The OP hasn’t said that he has signed an Undertaking though. What’s she’s said is that he has a Restraining Order against him.

TheLurpackYears · 18/06/2026 07:37

Goodness me, don’t speak to his ex, don’t speak to him, be done with it.
At the very least, join the Burned Haystack fb group to strengthen your boundaries and get confident around red flags, and definitely consider taking the Freedom Programme.

TheHateUGive · 18/06/2026 07:33

It's called an undertaking

ExplodingSmittens · 18/06/2026 07:07

I’ve just read you’re opening post again @Yournextdoorfriendand the last sentence is a little baffling.

He did tell you the truth when he told you that he had a Non-Molestation Order. As PPs have said he did this to test your boundaries.

Lots of Women on hearing this would make their excuses shortly after and leave and then block him on everything.

The fact that you haven’t means that you’re ignoring red flags and don’t have boundaries to protect yourself and that’s just what abusive men like.

I can almost guarantee that saying he has a Non-Molestation Order is the only truth he’s told you and he hasn’t even told you the truth about how that came into place. There is no such thing as a voluntary Non-Mol. As many posters have said, has has the Non-Mol because he poses a serious risk of harm to his ex.

Whatever you do, do not mention that it was the fact that he told you he has a Non-Mol that triggered you to do a Clare’s Law request. He will just learn to not tell Women on the future and will become better at pretending to be a decent human being.

And definitely don’t mention that you’ve done a request or ask to speak to his ex, you are putting her in real danger.

I’ll hoping that the information from the Police will be enough for you to end the relationship but I fear from your posts on this thread that you are convinced by his lies and will stay.

Keep posting on here about what you decide and how you’re getting on if you can, hopefully it will help to protect you.

Blimms · 18/06/2026 03:00

PollyBell · 18/06/2026 01:40

How does it protect women? it advises if there is a record only

Do you genuinely need me to answer that question?

ktopfwcv · 18/06/2026 01:53

I thought you had to be in a romantic relationship with or an ex of someone to submit a CLR? You're not in a relationship and never were. I'm surprised you were allowed to do one to "see how it works" and also that you want to contact his previous victim if it comes to fruition.

(I know you can submit on behalf of friends too)

PollyBell · 18/06/2026 01:40

Blimms · 18/06/2026 01:35

Stand a chance at what? Getting away with pretending to be decent men? Are you sad that women are better able to protect themselves from abusive men?

How does it protect women? it advises if there is a record only

Blimms · 18/06/2026 01:35

YourShyLion · 17/06/2026 22:58

Men don't stand a chance these days, it's completely ridiculous!

Stand a chance at what? Getting away with pretending to be decent men? Are you sad that women are better able to protect themselves from abusive men?

scoobysnaxx · 17/06/2026 23:31

YourShyLion · 17/06/2026 22:58

Men don't stand a chance these days, it's completely ridiculous!

Care to elaborate??

YourShyLion · 17/06/2026 22:58

Men don't stand a chance these days, it's completely ridiculous!

ArchbishopOfBanterbury · 17/06/2026 22:54

He is not a safe man. He has a restraining order, a non-mol.

Claire's law will tell you what you already know. No excuses matter. You already have all the facts you need.

He's dangerous. And you can absolutely do better.

Myfridgeiscool · 17/06/2026 22:46

A voluntary restraining order does not exist.
A restraining order is put in place when there is a high risk of harm.
Leopards don’t change their spots OP…they just move on to the their next victim.
You should run for the hills regardless of what the police say in response to your Clare’s law application.

PollyBell · 17/06/2026 22:43

If you cant work out why this relationship is a bad idea yourself in the first place STOP DATING

Iarthar · 17/06/2026 22:35

Shinyredbicycle · 17/06/2026 18:39

Honestly, you don't sounded grounded enough in yourself to be embarking on a relationship, let alone one with someone with a N-M Order, 3 children and a recent ex.

You've let him know that you are vulnerable by not running for the hills as soon as he told you about the NM-whatever he means by it, and given him plenty of time to concoct a story by telling him about the CL request.

Exactly. Ask yourself why someone would voluntarily tell you they have a non-molestation order against them, OP. They’re screening you. When you don’t immediately say ‘We’re done here’, they know they’ve found someone gullible.

ExplodingSmittens · 17/06/2026 22:30

Shinyredbicycle · 17/06/2026 18:39

Honestly, you don't sounded grounded enough in yourself to be embarking on a relationship, let alone one with someone with a N-M Order, 3 children and a recent ex.

You've let him know that you are vulnerable by not running for the hills as soon as he told you about the NM-whatever he means by it, and given him plenty of time to concoct a story by telling him about the CL request.

I agree with this. No matter what the Police tell you, you need to end the relationship and have some time away from dating whilst you figure out what it is that you want and why you don’t back away from Men with serious red flags.

Pinkflamingo10 · 17/06/2026 19:15

thesealion · 17/06/2026 18:21

I’m really quite alarmed and baffled that anyone would continue to date someone who disclosed they had a restraining order, “voluntary” or otherwise

Saaame !
surely you would run and never look back

LemonSorbetCone · 17/06/2026 19:10

The 3rd story? Are you ok?!!!
hes clearly a walking red flag. You can tell cos he can’t see one of his children. You realky didnt need CL for this. You throw ppl like this back in the pond. The fact that you’re not even considering this is baffling. Stop waisting resources by making CL applications with no intention of following through.

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 17/06/2026 19:10

.

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 17/06/2026 19:10

Baffled by this thread.

Look at his childcare situation...
He has the 2 of the 3 children who are boys the daughter lives with the mum.
So far so (ab)normal.

His "voluntary" restraining order....

He'd have been dumped long before a clares law.

And now it comes back you want to have a nice big chat??? And do more "information gathering" and consensus build.....

It defies belief....

What do you need?

film footage showing him abusing his ex?
the extended version so you can see she didnt "provoke" him.amd "make him".

Did you ever stop to consider the fact that by insisting on talking to his ex (via him) for a "3rd opinion" you are potentially putting HER in danger through your willful disbelief of your own reality????

mcmuffin22 · 17/06/2026 19:02

scoobysnaxx · 17/06/2026 17:49

If the police share anything that is of concern you dump him and move on. Don’t get involved and try to figure out the truth between them. Plenty of men with zero accusations or police involvement tied to their name. Throw this one back.

I agree with this. What's the point in carrying on?

PillsBox · 17/06/2026 18:48

Yournextdoorfriend · 17/06/2026 17:40

I think I will ask him to let me speak to his ex.

Firstly, he doesn't get to 'let' you speak to anyone.

Secondly, why on earth do you think this woman is going to want to be dragged into her ex's dating scene?

Leave the woman alone and work it out for yourself.

bittertwisted · 17/06/2026 18:41

Yournextdoorfriend · 17/06/2026 17:48

i don't know? Which is why I posted I guess.

You know the process and rules are on the police website surely?

bittertwisted · 17/06/2026 18:39

Yournextdoorfriend · 17/06/2026 17:45

Yes if the police share anything that is of concern I would want to hear the 3rd version of the story

You are not allowed to tell anyone
imagine the danger you could put her in if he found out

it’s a really serious process, not Only because of the privacy breach, but because you couLd put yourself and other victims in an incredibly dangerous position. Do you think abusive men wouldn’t mind?? They would go ballistic, he may not even know about exes talking to the police, it shows all complaints, not just convictions