Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex wants me to lie to DS

190 replies

Magpiesinthegarden · 16/06/2026 10:22

DS has broken his phone screen and it’s £200 to fix it. Ex and I have agreed that we will go 50/50 to pay for it to be fixed. Ex will take the phone in and I’ll send him the money.

Ex has said not to tell DS he’s paying me half towards it as DS wouldn’t like that his Dad is giving me money. So ex wants to lie to DS and say I paid the whole amount.

AIBU to be uncomfortable about lying to DS and should I either pay the whole amount or tell DS it is from us both?

OP posts:
SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 16/06/2026 13:45

Magpiesinthegarden · 16/06/2026 10:55

He’s 14 and lives with his Dad now. Long story but there’s alienation and enmeshment with Dad, he would despise the idea of his Dad helping me in any way. His dad pleads poverty to DS (he earns 4 times more than I do!) He regularly tells DS how poor he is now because I left him. DS is strongly binded to his Dad.

Do not play this game and dont reward these little fuckers (father and sons) bad behaviour.

Let him and his dad pay for the phone he allegedly broke. Is it even broken???

I'd also cancel thst phone contract once the term is up

You are being an absolute mug.

If i couldnt take it and repair it myself no way would I pay for this. You must see this is all nonsense ... none of these lies even makes sense...

PrincessScarlett · 16/06/2026 13:45

This is heartbreaking. Your ex has completely poisoned your son against you. How much contact do you have with your son? You need to try and repair the damage now before it's too late. And don't ever lie for your ex as it will come back to bite you.

MikeRafone · 16/06/2026 13:41

Your helping your son as is his dad

neither of you are helping each other over this

chocoluv · 16/06/2026 13:36

Are you still receiving CB and UC for DS even though he lives with his dad?

Do you pay his dad maintenance?

ZoeCM · 16/06/2026 13:33

OP, I really feel for you. Your son is already an MRA at fourteen.

People are advising therapy, but how do therapists handle situations such as this? Your son may hide his attitude to women and give the therapist a completely false image of the situation. And if he's upfront about how he views women, and the therapist calls him out, won't he just stop attending?

99bottlesofkombucha · 16/06/2026 13:33

Magpiesinthegarden · 16/06/2026 12:04

I thought it was a lot to be honest, I’ve only got ex’s word that it costs that much, it does seem extortionate! He’s taking it to some obscure phone shop miles away, I don’t know the name of the shop either.

No way. Tell your ex actually he can pay it unless you pick the shop and get the reciept. He’s not on your side one bit ahd you shouldn’t trust him if he tells you what time it is.

or just get a quote at your local shop, share ir with your ex and say I’ll pay half of this. And I’ll tell ds the truht because last time you had me lie to him about you contributing you took it out of maintenance.

im so sorry op, he’s taking your son from you.

Feelfreee · 16/06/2026 13:30

Your son needs to see a therapist. He sounds like an incel. You wouldn’t want him to repeat this with a future girlfriend and children. Do something before it’s too late. Don’t pay a penny for your son’s phone repair - your son doesn’t respect you.

Mcdhotchoc · 16/06/2026 13:26

Nope.
Ds, the phone is £200,to fix. I have £100:and your Dad will pay £100. Do you want that to happen or would you rather have a broken phone?

Millytante · 16/06/2026 13:25

Magpiesinthegarden · 16/06/2026 10:29

He’s heavily enmeshed/loyalty binded with his Dad and doesn’t like to think of his dad “helping” me out in any way.

Isnt it the other way around though, if you are sending the 50% to exP?
I’d tell the kid that either his parents split the cost, or his phone screen remains bust. If he’s old enough for such an expensive device, he’s old enough to process such an arrangement.
Assuming this lad has expressed such a cavil in the first place of course, and this isn’t exP’s attempt to look, in DS’s eyes, like the sole generous parent.

99bottlesofkombucha · 16/06/2026 13:23

Magpiesinthegarden · 16/06/2026 10:41

Exactly! This is one of my worries! So I am in charge of paying for his phone contract, any upgrades etc so DS might see it as my responsibility to pay for the screen. But his dad wanting to hide his contribution makes me uncomfortable. It’s happened before, ex gave me money (bank transfer) for a meal for the two of us on a holiday and said DO NOT tell DS I’ve given you anything as he would be very angry. He then listed the money as child maintenance 🙈

Well that’s that then. ‘No dickhead ex, last time I did that you took it out of maintenance. I’m just going to tell our son the truth and you can tell him 1. The money is for his phone not for me to buy myself flowers, and 2. Real men help out their kids mum anyway.’

anon4net · 16/06/2026 13:17

@Magpiesinthegarden This is a very hard situation. Your ds gets angry when women receive help from men? It's worrying if this is what he believes about mothers and I think likely must believe some very problematic things about women in general to hold these views. He's being groomed to be abusive towards women.

Can you speak with pastoral lead at school? I suggest that as with him living with Dad you may not be able to get outside of school supports. I wonder if there's anything in the PHSE curriculum that could help address this? If you speak to school I wouldn't share it as a custody issue/problem with your ex as they won't want to be involved, I'd talk about his growing increasing hostility towards women and wondering (especially in light of the announcement about new strategies to address misogyny in schools) whether there's any current supports that could be directed towards his class, year group etc.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 16/06/2026 13:15

HumberSquid · 16/06/2026 13:11

Good God I sooo hope you're not a parent. This child is already being emotionally abused by his father, and now you want his mother to join in too? His problem is not immaturity, its a toxic home environment.

He is emotionally abusing his mother now. How many adult sons kill their mother? Usually after years of using and abusing them.
Should she continue to let him wipe his feet in her, threatening to piss and shit on her photo? He is past helping, he hates her. He can hate her from a distance.
Yes, I am a parent and I would not tolerate this kind of hate aimed towards me. He has a choice, he might be 14 but only he can choose to be a decent human and not a woman hater.
There are many young boys who grew up with similar fathers and didn’t copy the behaviour.

WhatYouWearing · 16/06/2026 13:14

The OP is being so manipulated it’s beyond depressing. Pay nothing without a receipt. I suspect your ex has brainwashed your son and is now gaslighting you too. You all need counselling.

HumberSquid · 16/06/2026 13:11

EmeraldShamrock000 · 16/06/2026 13:08

What on earth has it got to do with DS? He needs to grow up. This thread is traumatising to read. My goodness, your DS is disgraceful. I understand his father plays a role here.
I am sorry OP. Biological child or not, I’d tell him to fuck off. Not all children are a blessing.
I would pay monthly maintenance like many fathers do and not a penny more.

Good God I sooo hope you're not a parent. This child is already being emotionally abused by his father, and now you want his mother to join in too? His problem is not immaturity, its a toxic home environment.

HalzTangz · 16/06/2026 13:09

Why is your ex scared of parenting, he should just tell your son he pays half for anything son related. He should also pay half of the contract and upgrades (unless you use maintenance payments for that)

Ohdearnotthisagain · 16/06/2026 13:09

Pinkdayss · 16/06/2026 13:01

You are being scammed by him.
Why would you trust him in anything he does or says?
He's a proven liar to you.
Pay nothing.
Ring a shop yourself.
I also wouldn't dream of paying anything towards a phone when you are held in sucb contempt.

This 💯

EmeraldShamrock000 · 16/06/2026 13:08

What on earth has it got to do with DS? He needs to grow up. This thread is traumatising to read. My goodness, your DS is disgraceful. I understand his father plays a role here.
I am sorry OP. Biological child or not, I’d tell him to fuck off. Not all children are a blessing.
I would pay monthly maintenance like many fathers do and not a penny more.

Inmyuggs · 16/06/2026 13:05

How can a child dictate how parents work out costs or plans.
Buy a 2nd hand refurb phone!

Blondeshavemorefun · 16/06/2026 13:03

Magpiesinthegarden · 16/06/2026 12:04

I thought it was a lot to be honest, I’ve only got ex’s word that it costs that much, it does seem extortionate! He’s taking it to some obscure phone shop miles away, I don’t know the name of the shop either.

He’s def conning you. Say you will transfer half the money once he’s done it and sent you the receipt

WhosGotTheKeysToMyBimma · 16/06/2026 13:03

I don't understand why you're paying anything at all

It happened on Ex's watch at ex's house.

Entirely his responsibility to pay for repairs.

HumberSquid · 16/06/2026 13:02

looselegs · 16/06/2026 13:00

He's not helping you out,he's helping husband son.
Your son should be happy he's getting it fixed without having to pay for it himself!

Bit mean to make him pay for it himself if his little brother broke it but that's hardly the chief concern here.

Pinkdayss · 16/06/2026 13:01

You are being scammed by him.
Why would you trust him in anything he does or says?
He's a proven liar to you.
Pay nothing.
Ring a shop yourself.
I also wouldn't dream of paying anything towards a phone when you are held in sucb contempt.

DeathstarDarling · 16/06/2026 13:00

This is abusive manipulative behaviour to both you and your child, Your ex is lying to both you and your child, and expecting you to lie for him too.

If the phone was damaged in ex's care, it is his responsibility to fix it. If he wants you to contribute he needs to be open and honest about this and give you a copy of the invoice. If he then takes any of the money out of your maintenance then you have effectively paid for it anyway.

My feeling is do not play along with these games, ever. Its like you are giving bullets to a man with a gun and then complaining about getting shot.

Just be honest, in a 'grey rock' style with both of them. Your ex will manipulate and lie as a given, do not give him more ammunition. Tell your son you love him, and you know he loves his dad, but the truth is the truth, and cannot be bent to fit his or his dad's preferred view of the world.

And therapy, if this can be arranged or he will turn out like his dad.

looselegs · 16/06/2026 13:00

Magpiesinthegarden · 16/06/2026 10:29

He’s heavily enmeshed/loyalty binded with his Dad and doesn’t like to think of his dad “helping” me out in any way.

He's not helping you out,he's helping husband son.
Your son should be happy he's getting it fixed without having to pay for it himself!

JHound · 16/06/2026 12:59

Magpiesinthegarden · 16/06/2026 12:14

I am concerned yes. He shows a high level of contempt for me now and has been exposed to ex’s hostility towards women. DS has even talked about destroying photos of me and “pissing/shitting on them” It’s awful.

I’ve posted about ex before incorrectly listing the child maintenance (we have another child that lives with me) putting down our sons DLA as child maintenance among other things.

Ex has also (during handovers) given me a bag of groceries for our youngest which seems like a nice thing to do but he always says DO NOT tell DS about the groceries etc.

It’s a mess and I agree, DS needs therapy now.

I am concerned yes. He shows a high level of contempt for me now and has been exposed to ex’s hostility towards women. DS has even talked about destroying photos of me and “pissing/shitting on them” It’s awful.

Just reading your posts and was wondering if your son is becoming a misogynist given his thoughts on maintenance. Honestly I think you are focused on the wrong issue. The issue is your son’s father turning him into a misogynist.

Swipe left for the next trending thread