Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think we shouldn’t worry about an increase in c-sections?

352 replies

PancakeCloud · 14/06/2026 23:13

I came across an instagram post earlier where someone had shared data indicating the UK’s c-section rates have increased significantly in the last five or so years. The commenters almost universally consider this to be ‘tragic’ and think it is ‘so so sad’ that some women are electing to deliver via section. There are also a whole bunch of commenters who think if only women were properly informed they would push for a natural birth even if drs are recommending inductions etc.

I accept the UK’s maternity system is under strain and needs improvement, but really isn’t the point that we have healthy mothers and babies not that women give birth via one method or another.

There are downsides of attempted vaginal births, because of course not all of them go to plan! There is an increased risk of severe birth trauma or hypoxic brain injury to baby vs choosing a c section. For women, tears and pelvic floor injury are very common. While C-sections come with their own risks, these are well known and often presented without acknowledgement that vaginal births have downsides too.

For the NHS I understand planned c sections are cheaper than other births, given so many of them end in emergency sections anyway and because of payouts when things go horribly wrong.

Are we not looking at this all wrong? The goal should be healthy mothers and babies irrespective of how those babies get out. Why are people so fixated on reducing the c section rate?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
AnneLovesGilbert · 14/06/2026 23:25

Well how many are elective vs emergency? I’ve had one of each and the elective was still medically necessary because of the nature of the first one and it still went wrong and I got a big internal injury. I’d have loved a vaginal birth, that’s what I thought I was doing until the shit massively hit the fan and it took me a long time to come to terms with the whole thing.

Rates of sections are increasing due to maternal age and obesity from what I remember reading so that’s not to be celebrated because women are having major intervention through necessity rather than choice. Safe, calm deliveries and healthy happy mums and babies are obviously the goal and if that means surgery rather than not that’s what should happen and no woman should be denied an elective section.

EeewDavid12 · 14/06/2026 23:22

I had my first c section as my baby was breach and then a 2nd because the first one went well and I still didnt know a single person that had a positive natural birth story! With the endless articles on understaffing and dangerous scenarios giving birth it wasn’t something I wanted to gamble with. Some people are extremely pro natural birth and that’s fine but I don’t blame people for having a c-section over risking damage or having a traumatic experience.