Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think some trending threads might be AI generated?

83 replies

Taytoface · 14/06/2026 07:42

Just looking at trending now. I am thinking at least three of the threads are potentially AI generated.

All of them are mumsnetty type topics, involving housing, education, parenting. All of them have lots of quite intricate details. High engagement from the OP with other posters. Can't figure.out the advanced search function too well, but seems like user names are relatively new.

Any other tips to spot the slop? It's one thing to waste time with a troll, it's a whole other kettle of fish wasting time on robot generated slop.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheAutumnCrow · 14/06/2026 20:12

Sesquioxides · 14/06/2026 08:21

Oh I agree it's suspicious (and annoying) but I just don't know that it's necessarily AI.

The ones that are irritating me are the "I'm really young and it's clearly my first day on planet Earth and I didn't grow up with parents/grew up in care and WIBU to wear matching shoes/say hello to my MIL/cook and eat lunch at lunchtime/I did this obvious thing that you just don't do and anyone who has lived on this Earth for 5 minutes would know you don't do" and posters are either falling over themselves to placate the person or castigate them depending on the mood. They're just so tedious and I resent wasting time reading them.

Yep. I could actually give you a list of those exact threads right now, but it’s probably against those good old ‘talk guidelines’.

LindorDoubleChoc · 14/06/2026 20:06

You reckon???

BeatriceMontgomeryHoward · 14/06/2026 20:05

Taytoface · 14/06/2026 08:53

I have seen lots of anti immigrant sentiment being seeded on this forum and others.

Reform have the biggest election war chest ever collected.£100m. They will totally be spending money on spreading content on sites like this.

MN has long been viewed as an important platform for politicians, and has always leaned left. Imagine what a coup it would be for reform to shift the dial on here. They will be spending money on this.

but then groups etc would have always done this, its just todays tech is better

Littledidsheknow · 14/06/2026 19:40

Taytoface · 14/06/2026 18:55

Interesting perspectives on here. I have never been one for troll hunting. I suspect some of the funniest threads on here over the years to be the work of trolls, but I have also been wrong RIP @catthiefkeith. I don't mind wasting time on someone with a good imagination and a distinctive writing style. Not something I think AI can replicate as yet.

I think some of the classics are very unlikely to be true, but you can’t say anything about the old favourites or you’ll get beaten up.

That said though, you’re right: at least there’s some “merit” in creative writing; there’s absolutely none in using AI.

Taytoface · 14/06/2026 18:55

Interesting perspectives on here. I have never been one for troll hunting. I suspect some of the funniest threads on here over the years to be the work of trolls, but I have also been wrong RIP @catthiefkeith. I don't mind wasting time on someone with a good imagination and a distinctive writing style. Not something I think AI can replicate as yet.

OP posts:
AWeeCupOfTeaAndAnIndividualFruitTrifle · 14/06/2026 12:18

I bet there's a MN user out there whose real name is Alexandra Imogen Sloppe - and she's going to get so upset and feel bullied and inexplicably hated if she happens across this thread!

Differentforgirls · 14/06/2026 11:53

AWeeCupOfTeaAndAnIndividualFruitTrifle · 14/06/2026 10:42

It's very sad that we've come to a point whereby people who have competent language skills and/or take the time to check what they've written before posting are thus suspected of being 'too good to be human'. It doesn't say a lot about us as a species, does it?

Don't forget that not everybody posts using a phone - I read on my phone, but 95% or more of what I post is done on my laptop... and we now also have the edit function, for when you read back after posting and spot the typos that have crept in.

It’s a bit scary actually if you write well then you must be a robot 😱

faw2009 · 14/06/2026 11:45

AWeeCupOfTeaAndAnIndividualFruitTrifle · 14/06/2026 09:53

Some people don't have the gift of brevity - or maybe don't want to be later accused of drip-feeding! This may also include neurodiverse people, who might have a 'must include everything' writing style that's maybe less common in NT people - but neurodiverse people are obviously still 100% people.

I do agree with you, though, when hours or even days go by and the OP never returns. Sometimes it's because the thread didn't go the way they hoped, meaning that "everybody is wrong and stupid"; but I concede that it may well suggest AI.

I still don't actually get the point of AI starting threads on a forum for humans, though. Is it just for AI to post, and AI to read and respond, and then there's no point in any of us being here at all? What does that achieve? Can AI 'enjoy' using MN? Why does it even need advice on anything if it supposedly already knows it all anyway?!

I mentioned this earlier- one reason is so that human replies can be used to teach AI to write more naturally.
Another (my kids told me) for Reddit at least, is to get more karma and enhance the reddit profile, which can then be sold off to (I don't know who) to gain access to special reddit groups. Sounded so weird to me.

InterestedDad37 · 14/06/2026 11:10

Ashtoo · 14/06/2026 11:09

What other indicators of regionality are you looking for?

Other words, turns of phrase. Anyway, I've "gotten" busy, so I have to leave this now.

mumofoneAloneandwell · 14/06/2026 11:09

GisGasGus · 14/06/2026 11:07

3'words in shouty capitals, a fine contribution to the discussion indeed

About AI slop? Hardly a highbrow topic, your majesty 🤷‍♀️

Ashtoo · 14/06/2026 11:09

InterestedDad37 · 14/06/2026 09:24

Duh! I know regionally it's a possibility - but I'm referring to situations where there's no other indication of regionality.

What other indicators of regionality are you looking for?

InterestedDad37 · 14/06/2026 11:09

GisGasGus · 14/06/2026 10:58

Didn't he copy that from something much older?

Not sure.

GisGasGus · 14/06/2026 11:07

mumofoneAloneandwell · 14/06/2026 10:59

I used several, can you not read??

Having a go at my gifs, GET OVER IT

3'words in shouty capitals, a fine contribution to the discussion indeed

Littledidsheknow · 14/06/2026 11:01

InterestedDad37 · 14/06/2026 10:08

😂. Don't take it so seriously - I was simply putting it forward as a possible indicator of Ai-generated text, in examples where it doesn't fit neatly with the rest of the text.

I use “gotten”. I’m Scottish!
I know the thread you mean. I’ve been reading it this morning; unless there’s more than one gotten user at large at the moment.

In the one I saw, though, the OP also makes a few grammatical mistakes (e.g. using “myself” instead of me) which would make me think the poster was human.

Unless, of course, throwing in the odd SPAG error is part of AI now, to throw us off the scent!

mumofoneAloneandwell · 14/06/2026 10:59

GisGasGus · 14/06/2026 10:55

Stupid gifs everywhere, use your words

I used several, can you not read??

Having a go at my gifs, GET OVER IT

Matt Leblanc Wow GIF by NowThis
GisGasGus · 14/06/2026 10:58

InterestedDad37 · 14/06/2026 10:28

Like your username - Warren Zevon would be proud. 🐺

Didn't he copy that from something much older?

GisGasGus · 14/06/2026 10:55

mumofoneAloneandwell · 14/06/2026 10:14

AI SLOP EVERYWHERE

Stupid gifs everywhere, use your words

InterestedDad37 · 14/06/2026 10:51

AWeeCupOfTeaAndAnIndividualFruitTrifle · 14/06/2026 10:49

You may indeed know a lot of stuff, but it does make you look a bit foolish if you then extrapolate that confidence to include other stuff about which you clearly aren't all that knowledgeable - and to actually make proclamations based on that assumption.

Fair enough 🙂

AWeeCupOfTeaAndAnIndividualFruitTrifle · 14/06/2026 10:49

InterestedDad37 · 14/06/2026 10:27

😂😂😂 I didn't phrase it accurately enough in my first comment, that's fair to say 😃 But without outing my identity, I really do know my stuff in this area, and have written/published about it extensively 🙂

You may indeed know a lot of stuff, but it does make you look a bit foolish if you then extrapolate that confidence to include other stuff about which you clearly aren't all that knowledgeable - and to actually make proclamations based on that assumption.

AWeeCupOfTeaAndAnIndividualFruitTrifle · 14/06/2026 10:42

Gladystheimpaler · 14/06/2026 10:16

I think Mumsnet try to be proactive and identify AI posts, but there's going to be ones that slip through the net.

A clue I always use is, is this too well written? Most people are posting in a gap in a busy day, or under emotional stress, and so you'd expect posts and responses to have some spelling or grammar errors, or that the OP might not be clear and clarification might be needed later. If the OP feels highly structured, with a beginning middle and end, that sets my alarm going too.

It's very sad that we've come to a point whereby people who have competent language skills and/or take the time to check what they've written before posting are thus suspected of being 'too good to be human'. It doesn't say a lot about us as a species, does it?

Don't forget that not everybody posts using a phone - I read on my phone, but 95% or more of what I post is done on my laptop... and we now also have the edit function, for when you read back after posting and spot the typos that have crept in.

DeepRubySwan · 14/06/2026 10:40

I think you're being paranoid. Honestly who would bother?

finelylined · 14/06/2026 10:39

Ah remember the good old days when users were desperate to be the one to spot the troll poster and rather than engaging with anything some people seemed more interested in reporting anything and everything that they suspected as being by a troll. Apparently there were all sorts of 'clues' like having a one word user name with numbers after it (something that I actually had at the time). But it was a very popular way for people to feel clever and superior.

Now that's not cool anymore it seems and it's moved onto AI and everyone thinks they can spot the 'AI generated' posts - whatever that actually means. I don't think anyone even cares what it means as long as they can say 'Oh I've spotted at least 3 AI posts in trending. They must be AI because although they're on perfectly mundane topics the OP engages and gives lots of details and it's really well written' - like WTAF? How on earth does that prove anything?

I have seen people called out for obviously using AI to organise their post and they've admitted they ran it through ChatGPT before posting, which is fair enough if the post is written in that very particular layout - but deciding half the board is AI for spurious reasons is as tedious as the troll hunters were.

If you think it's AI then don't engage, personally I couldn't care less. The soaps aren't real either incase you hadn't noticed but plenty of people engage with them.

WerewolfOfLoudon · 14/06/2026 10:38

InterestedDad37 · 14/06/2026 10:35

I might be one of those. I wasn't accurate enough. Anyway, I'm leaving this now - I've suddenly gotten busy with other stuff 😂

🤣 You're safe, the Strawberry Moon is still a couple of weeks away. Ah-Hooooo!

cloudtreecarpet · 14/06/2026 10:37

LuckyHazelFox · 14/06/2026 10:07

That might be the case in Makefield but if you think that will happen nationally, you are kidding yourself.

So what do you think will happen nationally?

BatterseaBadger · 14/06/2026 10:36

InterestedDad37 · 14/06/2026 07:49

One thing I've noticed is threads that point towards a UK poster, writing about a UK situation, but throwing in the word 'gotten' as though that's typical of British English (it isn't).

Not every person who's is "UK poster" talking about a "UK situation" grew up with "British English" as their language. Even those that did, modify and adapt, picking up stylistic things such as 'gotten'.