Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s nothing I can do?

35 replies

naanbreadforaxel · 13/06/2026 19:29

Ex-dp has decided he wants 50/50 custody , so he doesn’t have to pay child support. Great, no problem.

he wants to start with week on/ week off, with hand over being a sunday afternoon.

now here’s the AIBU. His weeks will consist of the kids stopping with his new gf of 3 months (they don’t yet live together) and he will see them around his shift work. She will do school runs/meals/bed times he’s not there.

am I right in thinking there’s nothing I can do about this? Everyone I have spoke to have said they wouldn’t be having it or be happy about it and should put a stop to it. To me It’s not right the kids being cared for by another person if their mother is available, but that’s their fathers choice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Divebar2021 · 17/06/2026 18:01

So if you do 50/50 is the expectation that there is one set of everything at each house… like school uniform etc or will he expect you to send everything for his week ?

itsgettingweird · 17/06/2026 17:54

Letsgetreadytorhumble · 13/06/2026 21:39

What is in the court agreement? If it is not currently 50/50 then he hasnt a leg to stand on.

Yes - but also remember he has equal PR and as the OP also doesn’t have a court order she has no more right to any custody than he does.

a court order so always worth it

LizandDerekGoals · 14/06/2026 07:41

Violinorbanjo · 13/06/2026 22:14

What kind of a woman will agree to this? Is she an aupair he got himself involved with?

One with very low self-esteem and poor boundaries.

I would have done handover in a Monday, so one drops off at school and the other picks up.

ohyesido · 13/06/2026 22:41

My goodness I would have hated this arrangement as a child. It’s not fair on them to be left with a stranger

Prunellaprim · 13/06/2026 22:22

naanbreadforaxel · 13/06/2026 21:37

He would have them 2/3 Wednesdays for dinner (his shifts didn’t allow for every Wednesday) then every weekend (depending on his shifts would be fri-mon one week, sat-sun, the next)

Take him to court is how you challenge it. This is in his best interests not the children’s. The courts don't care about his interests only the children’s

Gardenisablooming · 13/06/2026 22:21

Send him an extremely detailed proposed schedule.. Include after school clubs /dentist /Dr /hairdresser /parties /library trips /play dates /detail clothes /shoes sizes as he would be expected to provide these things in his time . Tech also.. As the dc won't be carrying them back /forwards at risk of damage. Suggest he logs the agreement with his solicitor so yours can agree and have iy drawn up as a proper agreement..
Watch him backtrack.

grumpygrape · 13/06/2026 22:16

naanbreadforaxel · 13/06/2026 22:08

Not at all. I wasn’t entirely happy with the previous custody/ visitation agreement and have already had one sitting of mediation. He wouldn’t even talk to me at that appointment via zoom, so most of that meeting was the mediator going back and forth passing on messages, so nothing got resolved. We have another appointment later this month which I am not sure he will attend. For anything to go to court’s mediation has to be tried first, so I am currently in the process, unfortunately it’s not very fast.

At least with the ages of your children they will be able to express their wishes and feelings bro the Court via CAFCASS.

Violinorbanjo · 13/06/2026 22:14

What kind of a woman will agree to this? Is she an aupair he got himself involved with?

naanbreadforaxel · 13/06/2026 22:08

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/06/2026 22:00

It sounds like you quite want this to happen though Op.

Not at all. I wasn’t entirely happy with the previous custody/ visitation agreement and have already had one sitting of mediation. He wouldn’t even talk to me at that appointment via zoom, so most of that meeting was the mediator going back and forth passing on messages, so nothing got resolved. We have another appointment later this month which I am not sure he will attend. For anything to go to court’s mediation has to be tried first, so I am currently in the process, unfortunately it’s not very fast.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/06/2026 22:00

It sounds like you quite want this to happen though Op.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/06/2026 22:00

I would challenge this in court. No way is it in the children’s best interests to spend half their time being looked after being their dad’s new gf or in the home of a parent who isn’t there.

Theyre better off being with a parent who is about, and their dad paying maintenance to make sure you can give them a good standard of living.

naanbreadforaxel · 13/06/2026 21:56

Ashtoo · 13/06/2026 21:48

Ex-dp has decided he wants 50/50 custody, so he doesn’t have to pay child support.

Why does he get to decide?
The childcare he’s providing (by way of GF) doesn’t seem to be in your children’s best interests OP.

Can’t you decide, no, this is not okay?

However, it’s not clear exactly how much childcare GF will be providing as you just say it’s around his shift work. Unless it was for very short time periods I wouldn’t be ok with this.

I have always said he can reduce child maintenance by having them 50/50 so he has taken up this offer. In regards to child care around his shifts. If they are there when he is on
days - she will be doing, wake up, breakfast, drop off and pick up until he’s home at approximately 4pm.
lates- she will be doing pick ups and bed times.
night shift - potentially she won’t have to do anything except be in the house while they sleep if he sleeps while they are at school.

they are staying at her house, with the view for him to move in in July I believe.

OP posts:
lordbaddingham · 13/06/2026 21:55

This is a dreadful situation for your children. I think you have to take him to court to challenge the 50/50. I'm hardly a helicopter parent but a girlfriend of three months, you know nothing about her and she is a stranger to your children. And he's only doing it to avoid paying. Another shit dad.

Loulou4022 · 13/06/2026 21:49

naanbreadforaxel · 13/06/2026 21:35

All those saying you would fight it, what can I actually do. Intercept the children from school? Stand at her doorstep and demand they get in the car? Tell a 40 odd year old man where he can and cannot go? I can tell him I don’t agree until I’m blue in the face but ultimately there’s nothing physically I can do that won’t put the children in a position of witnessing conflict and physically being asked to choose.

This sounds a very mature course of action. The children are old enough to let their dad and you know if they’re not happy. I’d also let school know the arrangements and they can check in with the children to make sure they’re ok on the weeks they’re not with you.

Ashtoo · 13/06/2026 21:48

Ex-dp has decided he wants 50/50 custody, so he doesn’t have to pay child support.

Why does he get to decide?
The childcare he’s providing (by way of GF) doesn’t seem to be in your children’s best interests OP.

Can’t you decide, no, this is not okay?

However, it’s not clear exactly how much childcare GF will be providing as you just say it’s around his shift work. Unless it was for very short time periods I wouldn’t be ok with this.

ViperHalliwell · 13/06/2026 21:47

Is she putting them to bed at his place and staying there with them until he gets home? Or are they actually staying at her place overnight when he's working shifts? If it's the latter, those nights typically would not be counted as part of his total for child maintenance payment calculations (at least in England).

giemepeace · 13/06/2026 21:46

naanbreadforaxel · 13/06/2026 21:35

All those saying you would fight it, what can I actually do. Intercept the children from school? Stand at her doorstep and demand they get in the car? Tell a 40 odd year old man where he can and cannot go? I can tell him I don’t agree until I’m blue in the face but ultimately there’s nothing physically I can do that won’t put the children in a position of witnessing conflict and physically being asked to choose.

I would first go and get legal advice. I imagine the lawyers first step would be to write to your ex objecting to his proposal on the grounds it is not in the best interests of the children to be cared for by an unknown adult. You would discuss with solicitor what you want to say as a counter proposal, ie he has them when off work and that childcare be with familiar adults.

Advice from solicitor about what would be likely if you took this to court to try and prevent it happening. I’d be guided overall by their advice, but if I could fight it I would, I’d be so upset about this.

Are you on speaking terms with your ex? Can you ask him to consider how he’d feel if you had a partner of 3 months caring for your kids?

AnotherDelphinium · 13/06/2026 21:42

You respond to him by email;

”I have considered your new suggestions for having the children and I don’t feel it’s in their best interests. I’m happy to continue with the current arrangements, or move onto mediation/court order if you’d like to formally press ahead with your proposal.

Kind regards,
Naan”

JLou08 · 13/06/2026 21:39

naanbreadforaxel · 13/06/2026 21:35

All those saying you would fight it, what can I actually do. Intercept the children from school? Stand at her doorstep and demand they get in the car? Tell a 40 odd year old man where he can and cannot go? I can tell him I don’t agree until I’m blue in the face but ultimately there’s nothing physically I can do that won’t put the children in a position of witnessing conflict and physically being asked to choose.

You go to school and pick then up as usual. Do you think the school will send them home with some unknown woman over you?

Letsgetreadytorhumble · 13/06/2026 21:39

What is in the court agreement? If it is not currently 50/50 then he hasnt a leg to stand on.

grumpygrape · 13/06/2026 21:38

naanbreadforaxel · 13/06/2026 21:35

All those saying you would fight it, what can I actually do. Intercept the children from school? Stand at her doorstep and demand they get in the car? Tell a 40 odd year old man where he can and cannot go? I can tell him I don’t agree until I’m blue in the face but ultimately there’s nothing physically I can do that won’t put the children in a position of witnessing conflict and physically being asked to choose.

The only thing you can do is go to Court and get a formal Order. It’s a difficult situation but unless you feel the children are not happy or in danger you may just have to go with it.

JLou08 · 13/06/2026 21:37

A GF of 3 months doing school runs and childcare sounds like a really bad idea. Too early to introduce them. Too much expectation on a new partner which could lead to her resenting the DC and not being very nice with them or could lead to them breaking up. There's a good chance they will break up anyway, it's very early, they will still be in the stage of figuring each other out.
I'd refuse 50/50 and let him take it to court. See what happens there. They might separate before it gets in to court, he probably won't be so keen on 50/50 without a woman he can pass the care on to.

naanbreadforaxel · 13/06/2026 21:37

TomatoSandwiches · 13/06/2026 21:29

What was the arrangement before this new nanny with a fanny got duped?

He would have them 2/3 Wednesdays for dinner (his shifts didn’t allow for every Wednesday) then every weekend (depending on his shifts would be fri-mon one week, sat-sun, the next)

OP posts:
naanbreadforaxel · 13/06/2026 21:35

All those saying you would fight it, what can I actually do. Intercept the children from school? Stand at her doorstep and demand they get in the car? Tell a 40 odd year old man where he can and cannot go? I can tell him I don’t agree until I’m blue in the face but ultimately there’s nothing physically I can do that won’t put the children in a position of witnessing conflict and physically being asked to choose.

OP posts:
Larrythecatforpm · 13/06/2026 21:31

Can’t see this lasting longer than a week till she’s pissed off. He doesn’t even know her properly at 3 months what if she’s a pedophile or something?!