Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Uncomfortable with new manager but colleague disagrees

84 replies

MManchesterrain · 11/06/2026 21:04

We’re getting a new manager next week. I’m a manager myself, working alongside 7/8 others, and we will be reporting in to him.

He is moving across from another part of the business. There is always gossip in our company and it’s a fairly small town we work in so lots of people know each other.

Anyway, it’s known that he went through a disciplinary process recently during which he was suspended, and people were surprised he kept his job. What happened is something people are aware of, and he is being moved across not through his choice.

4 of us are women and would feel uncomfortable being managed by him. 3 of us want to speak to our senior manager to see explain this and that we are uncomfortable being managed by him, but the other is strongly against this and thinks it will mark our cards and make us appear difficult.

Would it be wrong to proceed against her wishes?

OP posts:
OneThreadOnlybyN · 12/06/2026 12:05

swqa · 12/06/2026 11:54

I can't quite fathom why you left this very important bit of info out of your OP 😳

because It's actually irrelevant to the OP's situation.

whether it was well handled or badly handled is a separate issue entirely.

He has been trf to become OP's manager. They dint have to approve of his affair, but as long as he's good at his job what's the actual problem here? He's hardly likely to make a move on any of them & even if he did, 4 adult women should be perfectly able to refuse his advances.

swqa · 12/06/2026 11:54

MManchesterrain · 11/06/2026 21:24

Sexual relations with a direct report (who appears to have left the company, unsure if by her own accord or dismissed)

I can't quite fathom why you left this very important bit of info out of your OP 😳

Monzo1ss · 12/06/2026 11:53

To be honest I’m not sure what you want your company to do with him in this situation. You said he’s been under investigation, disciplined and moved away from previous team to rectify the situation. Presumably he wasn’t investigated for being a risk to women in general, hence why he isn’t restricted from managing female colleagues now? You said he didn’t want to move so it’s not like he personally sought your team out, it was probably seen as a “suitable enough” placement for him.

I think it’s a leap, based on what you’ve shared here, to put in some group concerns. The majority of your information is gossip and comes from each of you egging each other on and riling each other up. There’s every chance he may come into this role with a view to keeping his head down and leaving asap, I doubt he gives a shit about you.

WarthogWoman · 12/06/2026 11:52

Her being moved on is a poor reflection of the company but you don’t know the details. Otherwise are you worried you will accidentally have sex with him? Because I can’t see what relevance it has

FasterMichelin · 12/06/2026 11:51

YABU. There’s no indication you’ll be at risk of his charm or that he’ll want to try it on with you. He had a workplace affair with another adult. The only people who should be worried about that are his ex wife and any new partner.

poetryandwine · 12/06/2026 11:49

As a woman , the gossip predisposes me against friendship with this guy. Like @Ritasueandbobtoo9 I am struck by the apparent fact that the affair cost the woman her job, but he retained his.

However I would not want you speaking on my behalf. This isn’t about racism, homophobia, sexism, ageism or ableism in the workplace and it isn’t even grounded in known fact.

@Whatado says she would thank you for coming to her with your concerns. I suspect that is her courteous dismissal meaning ‘but you needn’t have bothered’. She says herself she would then expect you to get on with it.

Obviously if the guy is a sexual harasser everything changes but I cannot see anything in the sordid little story you’ve presented to suggest that he is more likely than any other man to be one.

UpDownAllAround1 · 12/06/2026 11:48

uncomfortable? About what?

Bambiwithlonglegs · 12/06/2026 11:42

Not at all. Speak up

OneThreadOnlybyN · 12/06/2026 11:40

@Rooroobear

posted before I saw your comments.

I don't blame you for wanting to let people know. But you'll just get yourself banned & they'll carry on!

OneThreadOnlybyN · 12/06/2026 11:38

Why does him having an affair. Even with a younger colleague, make you uncomfortable reporting to him? Seriously. He had AN affair, doesn't mean he's going to try it on with you 3. I'm with your 4th colleague.

Rooroobear · 12/06/2026 11:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Rooroobear · 12/06/2026 09:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SummerFleurs · 12/06/2026 06:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This is exactly what I was thinking

HighHeelsRedLips · 12/06/2026 06:57

Gazelda · 11/06/2026 21:11

While I understand you don’t wish to be managed by him (presumably there was some sort of sexual harassment or discrimination element to the disciplinary) the senior manager is likely to frown on you for gossiping.

and you absolutely shouldn’t speak with anyone on behalf of the fourth member of the group. You have no right to speak on her behalf or imply that she might be part of the complaining group. I’d take a very dim view if I was a manager and some of the team came to me with an argument which started with “we’ve heard that x and we all agree y”.

its a difficult situation. But you need to address it professionally, particularly as you are in a management role.

Edited

Totally agree with this. You don’t want to be managed by this new manager based on the gossip you’ve heard. You don’t know the full facts of why he was suspended, that’s supposed to be confidential. Senior manager won’t be impressed by gossip and it will definitely look bad on you. Crack on with raising your concerns if you must but leave your colleague who doesn’t want to be involved out of it.

Rooroobear · 12/06/2026 06:48

Also yes, I’ve reported it

Lifestooshort71 · 12/06/2026 06:46

WilfredsPies · 11/06/2026 23:17

I’ve either forgotten or didn’t see the other thread, have you reported it Roo?

What’s making you think it’s the same poster? Was talking to her like pulling hen’s teeth as well?

So many troll/rage bait threads on the go. Yawn 🥱

Rooroobear · 12/06/2026 06:46

WilfredsPies · 11/06/2026 23:17

I’ve either forgotten or didn’t see the other thread, have you reported it Roo?

What’s making you think it’s the same poster? Was talking to her like pulling hen’s teeth as well?

I’m not sure if it’s the same poster but the op of the other thread had to start a new one (as it got full) and had a name change fail. She updated the thread often until the new one revealed her actual mn name and people started looking at her posting history (as some so) and were calling her out on the things she previously posted (at the same time she was meant to be going through all this with her husband) her husband was the one who bought the sex chair when he’d been caught messaging this women. As soon as she was called out for her name change fail and previous posts she disappeared

GreyCarpet · 12/06/2026 06:44

OK. So he had a relationship of sorts with a direct report who was younger than him whilst married.

I'd imagine he's being moved mainly because he has lost credibility and authority in his previous department.

As long as you all understand that you don't have to have sex with him if you don't want to - even if he flirts or makes advances, that won't happen to you.

If he does flirt or make advances and no one reciprocates then you can deal with that as it arises under sexual harassment. If there are concerns about his management style or approach to staff in general, then raise it then.

However unpalatable it might be to you, the company has chosen to continue his employment and given that none of you has been told officially what has happened, all you have is gossip.

SinicalMe · 12/06/2026 06:43

Extra marital affairs at work between 2 consenting adults used to happen all the time in my ‘90s workplace and no-one battered an eyelid.

Are you and your colleagues attractive Op and think he’ll want to start an affair with one of you?

Glitchymn1 · 12/06/2026 06:39

I voted YABU. What’s your actual concern OP? You realise you need one.

I thought he had abused or harassed a staff member. Sounds like he had an affair- sounds like you’ve embellished and listened to gossip. I’m not surprised your colleague wants nothing to do with your ‘concern’.

notthatoldchestnut · 12/06/2026 06:32

People have affairs all the time. You’re not the moral police. Many of those happen in the workplace.

unless he’s trying to instigate an affair with you, YABU. He is there to do his job.

JeremiaBoogle · 12/06/2026 06:02

Whats your concern? Whilst it might be morally questionable, if the affair was consenting.it has no bearing on you surely, unless you work in marriage guidance or something similar?

You have to also consider that he was disaplined, the process completed and the decision made to retain him. Likely he was suspended (with pay?) due to gross misconduct if he conducted the affair using company time/assets. If he does similar again, a second disaplinary process is likely to result in dismissal.

Mind you, cynically, if he was suspended without pay, it was clearerly very serious, The fact that he’s back now and seemingly fine suggests that, for whatever reason, he could be untouchable.

PollyBell · 12/06/2026 05:17

MManchesterrain · 11/06/2026 22:55

They were at it in the office which is why there was a disciplinary. A bit different to happening in hotels etc.

So 2 consenting adults shagged at work? sure if he wants to shag one of the current people I get someone feeling odd about it but what is so amazing about the current people that makes everyone thinks he wants to shag them?

HelmholtzWatson · 12/06/2026 04:34

Christ have you never been attracted to anyone before? They were both consenting adults and it's not like she wouldn't have known he was married. "They were at it in the office" just sounds like gossip.

You'd be wise to concentrate on the job you're being paid to do rather than gossiping.

Sunshineandgrapefruit · 12/06/2026 04:06

If it was consensual then none of your business.