Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I need the most annoying toy for a 5 year old

263 replies

IrritatingToy · 11/06/2026 17:56

My sister and I are in a war of annoying toys, she bought my 3 year old a set of mini bagpipes.. I need the most annoying but equally awesome for the child at 5 years old. I want something that she’s going to despise and he’s going to love. Budget about £100. I’m not unreasonable but she was to buy mine bloody bagpipes!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
18
Womanofcustard · 16/06/2026 18:04

An echo mike. Like a pink megaphone.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 16/06/2026 17:55

PlumpHobbit · 16/06/2026 10:17

Not quite as the eyes arent silver but it looks VERY similar as does the movement so effectively is the monkey, minus the horrible glittery silver eyes

It was snapped up on Vinted, maybe as exorcism practice? 😂

Howling here! Exorcism practice 🤣

Floofle · 16/06/2026 11:10

Soubriquet · 11/06/2026 18:12

I’m still traumatised by this fucking bear my dd had a baby and she’s 13!!!

I can still hear the song

“I’m a friendly light up bear
ill teach you
one two three
a sleepy hungry happy bear
hey come and hug me”

Oh my God we had that bear, I'd blocked it out forgotten!
DH binned it eventually 😅

tartyflette · 16/06/2026 10:27

I was quite irritated with a ‘friend’ who bought six year old DS a pair of boxing gloves…

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 16/06/2026 10:19

Do they have a dog as you could also treat that to a goggle ball....ultra annoying. i know from experience :)

PlumpHobbit · 16/06/2026 10:17

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 16/06/2026 09:55

Is this the monkey?!

Not quite as the eyes arent silver but it looks VERY similar as does the movement so effectively is the monkey, minus the horrible glittery silver eyes

It was snapped up on Vinted, maybe as exorcism practice? 😂

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 16/06/2026 09:55

PlumpHobbit · 15/06/2026 20:16

I only have a one year old but ive rapidly discovered i hate:

Over excitable voiced toys usually sounding like an American child

Repetitive loud songs

High pitched sounds effects

Hateful annoying songs that get stuck in your head even though you hate them and stay there

A perfect combination of these is Toot Toot. We have the firestation

"Im a Toot toot fire engine look at me go"
"Fighting fires is my job"

Die. Fortunately theres an off switch. I dread when he finds that and removes it from the off setting...

Also annoying:

A toy mobile phone from the in laws. Annoying sounds and i dont want to replicate playing with a mobile phone

A leapfrog book. I used to think this was acceptable until he button mashed it a few times so we had an amalgamation of animal noises on repeat

One of those old fashioned things where they press it and the characters go round inside like on a roundabout. "Clunk clunk clunk creeeaakkk" drives me demented.

This farting monkey that looked like it was possessed. You'd press its hand, it would then fart and jerk around with a gleeful cackle. It was sent on its way on vinted, as I got chucky/anabelle vibes. Creepy silver eyes too. Both of the above were in law specials.

When we were looking for birthday presents for said 1 year old husband kept eyeing up a baby xylophone. I refused to allow it 😂

Is this the monkey?!

I need the most annoying toy for a 5 year old
Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 16/06/2026 09:52

PlumpHobbit · 15/06/2026 20:16

I only have a one year old but ive rapidly discovered i hate:

Over excitable voiced toys usually sounding like an American child

Repetitive loud songs

High pitched sounds effects

Hateful annoying songs that get stuck in your head even though you hate them and stay there

A perfect combination of these is Toot Toot. We have the firestation

"Im a Toot toot fire engine look at me go"
"Fighting fires is my job"

Die. Fortunately theres an off switch. I dread when he finds that and removes it from the off setting...

Also annoying:

A toy mobile phone from the in laws. Annoying sounds and i dont want to replicate playing with a mobile phone

A leapfrog book. I used to think this was acceptable until he button mashed it a few times so we had an amalgamation of animal noises on repeat

One of those old fashioned things where they press it and the characters go round inside like on a roundabout. "Clunk clunk clunk creeeaakkk" drives me demented.

This farting monkey that looked like it was possessed. You'd press its hand, it would then fart and jerk around with a gleeful cackle. It was sent on its way on vinted, as I got chucky/anabelle vibes. Creepy silver eyes too. Both of the above were in law specials.

When we were looking for birthday presents for said 1 year old husband kept eyeing up a baby xylophone. I refused to allow it 😂

My mum’s neighbours regifted her annoying DCs toys to my mum for her grandchildren. So:-

ice cream cart which sings and talks. The ice cream bits like toppings, ice cream, cornets get lost easily.
Farm barn with different separate animal noises (chicken, pig).
keyboard with microphone and noises like meow/club music heavy bass lines.
fire station with sirens (loud and flashing)

These seem tame to sons of the other options.

I bought the toddler when a baby, a rolling moving noises ball toy. Eg animals, colours. It’s not that bad! Lives at my mum’s house as I gave it to him there.

Mum offered to give these to my DB and his wife and their kids and they declined the kind gifts. So they live at my mum’s house. The kids love them all though. Any signs of giving toys away is greeted with “no, we still play with it/love it”.

PlumpHobbit · 15/06/2026 20:16

I only have a one year old but ive rapidly discovered i hate:

Over excitable voiced toys usually sounding like an American child

Repetitive loud songs

High pitched sounds effects

Hateful annoying songs that get stuck in your head even though you hate them and stay there

A perfect combination of these is Toot Toot. We have the firestation

"Im a Toot toot fire engine look at me go"
"Fighting fires is my job"

Die. Fortunately theres an off switch. I dread when he finds that and removes it from the off setting...

Also annoying:

A toy mobile phone from the in laws. Annoying sounds and i dont want to replicate playing with a mobile phone

A leapfrog book. I used to think this was acceptable until he button mashed it a few times so we had an amalgamation of animal noises on repeat

One of those old fashioned things where they press it and the characters go round inside like on a roundabout. "Clunk clunk clunk creeeaakkk" drives me demented.

This farting monkey that looked like it was possessed. You'd press its hand, it would then fart and jerk around with a gleeful cackle. It was sent on its way on vinted, as I got chucky/anabelle vibes. Creepy silver eyes too. Both of the above were in law specials.

When we were looking for birthday presents for said 1 year old husband kept eyeing up a baby xylophone. I refused to allow it 😂

Byron1990 · 15/06/2026 07:44

@franksmama omg my dad bought this for two of the grandchildren on Christmas Day. Two of them simultaneously flashing and that song playing made for quite the Christmas lunch

user1492757084 · 15/06/2026 05:09

Electric drum with pom pom stick and highland band boots.

ProfessorBinturong · 14/06/2026 22:08

Were all those from the same person? And if so, what in earth had you done to offend them?!

Wooky073 · 14/06/2026 13:02

Other suggestions of annoying gifts we have received

  • a poo catapulting game (went straight to the charity shop before it was even played with)
-a stink bomb making kit (sadly my child insisted on wanting to make this and hoping for STEM impact I agreed - it was quite revolting. -Pie flinging game (straight to charity shop in horror) but if the kids get to see it they will want to do it.

The bagpipes only offended the ears. You could go full assault on ears, nose and eyes

Wooky073 · 14/06/2026 12:54

One of those dino masks that you wear and when you open your jaw the mask also opens its jaw and roars very loudly. The child will live in it and instead of conversations it will be loud roars. We had the velocoraptor one which was very loud and very annoying. You can also get a chewbacca one but I dont think thats as annoying

DoubleShotEspresso · 14/06/2026 12:53

Digital drumsticks.!

Wooky073 · 14/06/2026 12:52

Luckyforsome23 · 11/06/2026 22:16

A microphone that distorts his voice. You can get ones that also play music to sing along to.

You can also get toy megaphones that distort your voice / change your voice as well as amplify it - great fun :)

Tamtim · 14/06/2026 12:40

I haven’t read through all the responses so don’t know if someone’s already suggested a set of cymbals. There should be some budget left over for a nice big box set of glitter and one of those giant slime buckets.

Love that she got your kid bagpipes. 😆

AlwaysRoomForGin · 14/06/2026 12:30

Not had time to read full thread yet but some excellent suggestions in early pages....My DC are all older now (how?!) but the things I'm STILL traumatised by:
Worm Farm
Ant Farm
Those plaster digging sets with dinosaur/fossil type things embedded somewhere inside - nothing other than a jack hammer could actually release and the mess-fall out ratio = extreme
loom bands - so innocuous looking but the cause of so many arguments amongst youngest DC....not to mention DDogs eating them and the bloody things messing up roller blades of vacuum
And probably worst offender: The Furby - that I couldn't ever switch off for some reason...and always seemed to go into the horrible mode at bed time, traumatising DD and me stabbing randomly at the buttons to try and get it back from the psychotic function....I need a lie down in a dark room just thinking of that evil fu**er!! 👿

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 14/06/2026 10:35

MyFairLady22 · 14/06/2026 08:35

Ahhh, posted this on the wrong thread!! Not sure how to remove it!! 😂

Annoying toys… anything musical and repetitive should do the trick! Add in flashing lights. Fabulous fun, for all the family.

My son is 25 now. The worst toy he was given was a Bop It. I had to remove the batteries and pretend it was broken.

My SIL ensures anything loud and annoying mostly stays with the givers. A couple of loud and annoying toys have slipped through the net to their house though. Garages where you press something and siren comes on.

MyFairLady22 · 14/06/2026 08:35

Ahhh, posted this on the wrong thread!! Not sure how to remove it!! 😂

Annoying toys… anything musical and repetitive should do the trick! Add in flashing lights. Fabulous fun, for all the family.

My son is 25 now. The worst toy he was given was a Bop It. I had to remove the batteries and pretend it was broken.

MyFairLady22 · 14/06/2026 08:17

I once received a small brown jug. Smaller than an iPhone.

I had my step kids visiting after Xmas. We’d bought thoughtful choice gifts for them, tokens if you like. They’re all adults. So, my son and (now) exH were given their gifts. All wrapped in Christmas paper. Books, I think. Choices personal to them. Lovely! And I just sat there smiling like a crazy woman and feeling so embarrassed! Nothing for me…

Then, step daughter rummages to the bottom of the bag and pulls out the tiny brown jug. Unwrapped. She gave it to me and I was astonished. Of course, so as not to be ungrateful (his kids never really accepted me in a 17yr relationship) I said “Oh, thanks so much”. Underneath, on the label, it said DO NOT USE FOR POURING FLUIDS. So… A small brown rustic, unwrapped, unusable… jug.

Clearly, they’d got me nothing and grabbed this off a shelf and chucked it in the bag. “That’ll do”.

I don’t think they liked me 😂 🤔

I need the most annoying toy for a 5 year old
NannaKaren · 14/06/2026 08:09

Randomchat · 11/06/2026 18:03

There is nothing more annoying imo than a kid with a mouth organ. You could buy loads for £100 so he's always got one within arms reach

😂😂😂

Wheelz46 · 14/06/2026 07:59

Soubriquet · 11/06/2026 18:12

I’m still traumatised by this fucking bear my dd had a baby and she’s 13!!!

I can still hear the song

“I’m a friendly light up bear
ill teach you
one two three
a sleepy hungry happy bear
hey come and hug me”

Aw I absolutely loved this for mine, I can hear the little tune now.

Although it did freak me out when it kept randomly going off in the toy box like a possessed Chucky 😆

PieonaBarm · 12/06/2026 20:53

oliviaAustin · 11/06/2026 18:37

Tickle Me Elmo. Haunting in its laughter.

When I was at uni I had a friend who spent a year in France and she had a French one. I can still hear it now it started “ooh la la…..”