Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Had a car accident on the way to school

217 replies

Zaina89 · 09/06/2026 10:08

Was on the way to take my kids to school this morning, exited a roundabout 2nd exit with my left indicator on. I assumed my indicator had turned of because I had turned and I have played back the dash cam footage and can’t hear any indicator. Neither when I was driving could I hear the indicator hadn’t switched off.
was driving 40 on a 40 road. This was 1/2 minutes approx after putting my indicator and exiting round about.
next thing I know driving down this 40mph road a car on a give way on my left with his indicator on turns out in front of me, immediately as I see him turning I slam my brakes on and beep my horn. Because of my high speed you can hear on the dash cam footage the noise my brakes are making because I slammed down. He didn’t even attempt to move back and he hit into the left side of my car. The man wasn’t even getting out of his car he just reversed back. I got out of my car shouting “ what have you done?” “ why did you just do that?”
only then he got out of his car and even then didn’t check his car or mine and just stayed at his drivers door. When I kept asking him “ why did you do that?” He just remained calm, smiled weirdly and said “ you had your indicator on to turn left, I’ve got it all on camera”
my indicator wasn’t on when I immediately got out to check my car, he didn’t even bother to check for any damage on his car and didn’t bother to see mine.
I asked him for his phone number and details and that I would be going to drop my kids off at school because we are now late and they are in shock and upset and he refused and said “ it’s a company car, just take a picture of my reg” and got back in his car. He didn’t even move away from his drivers door, didn’t check the damage, didn’t make any pictures or videos of our cars or the damage. Refused to give me his name and phone number and just said take a picture of my reg and got back in his car and drove away like nothing happened.

im just in complete shock, my son was sat in the passengers side and im just getting a panic attack thinking if I wouldn’t have slammed the brakes as soon as I saw him doing what he did it would have been a bad accident. No one is hurt, my car isn’t badly damaged mostly just bad scratches.
I genuinely did not know my indicator was on ( if it even was!) I can hear when my indicator is on and I couldn’t hear anything even looking back at the dash cam footage you can’t hear the indicator just me and my children casually talking and then you can hear me beeping and slamming down on the brakes and then the collision. If my indicator was on, I’m not sure why it hadn’t turned off or made noise because I exited the roundabout a minute or 2 before the collision.

surely by my speed going 40mph and not slowing down or intending to turn he should have known I was not turning and shouldn’t have pulled out! Trying to remain calm but it’s just so strange he refused to give me his name and number and also very strange he didn’t seem concerned to atleast check his own car and any damage, didn’t even take any pictures or videos!

OP posts:
AllyMacbealmyarse · 09/06/2026 14:12

Iwanttobeafraser · 09/06/2026 14:04

I'm fairly cetain this is not true any more. You saying, on the spot, in a panic, "it's my fault" is NOT accepting liability in any meaningful way, although might add a tiny bit to the process of sorting it out I imagine. For example, if you are driving and something runs into the road and you slam on breaks and the guy behind you drives into you as a resullt, you might, in the moment, say, "I'm so sorry, a dog ran into the raod and I instincitvely slammed on breaks" But the rules are clear - the driver behind is responsible for ensuring there is sufficient space between them and the car in front that in the case of an emergency stop, they will not hit the car in front. So you can feel guilty all you like, ultimately, the person behind who has liability.

At the end of the day, it's usually fairly clear cut in that person x has right of way and person y doesn't. Most accidents are caused because people make mistakes, and that mistake is not mitigated for by the other driver.

A 30 second google came up with this from an insurer https://www.rias.co.uk/news-and-guides/what-should-i-do-if-i-have-a-car-accident/
“Do not apologise or admit you were at fault” plus it’s bloody obvious, especially in the uk where we seem to apologise for things that are not our fault, but can get us in to hot water.

I agree that if you got into the detail a spur of the moment statement might be defeated after the event, but why start from a disadvantaged position of having to do so?

What should I do if I have a car accident?

Experiencing a car accident can be incredibly stressful, regardless of whether it’s a small bump, a serious head-on collision, or whose fault it may be.

https://www.rias.co.uk/news-and-guides/what-should-i-do-if-i-have-a-car-accident/

Zaina89 · 09/06/2026 14:09

DryTerryandJUNE · 09/06/2026 14:06

He prob "acted weirdly" because you were in a bit of a state and asking nonsensical questions. "Why did you do that?" I mean, it's highly unlikely he meant to do it...
In a similar situation, I was very lucky to have the calmest chap as the party at fault. I was very shaken - but not verbally aggressive like you seemed to be - and he made sure we swapped all the details etc.
You phone your insurer with the number plate and they take care of it.

I wasn’t verbally aggressive! I was in a panic and he had just came out into the road and hit into me. Didn’t I have every right to ask him why he’d done it? As in why did you come in front of me? I wasn’t violent or aggressive or shouting aggressive things at him. That was the first thing that came out of my mouth in a stressful situation is asking him why he hit into me.

OP posts:
HelpMeGetThrough · 09/06/2026 14:08

JacquesHarlow · 09/06/2026 12:30

Why wouldn't someone report this incident, @HelpMeGetThrough ..?!

I didn’t say not to report it. Normally on these types of threads you get the over the top nutcases posting this type of thing.

Mumoftwoadults · 09/06/2026 14:06

Zaina89 · 09/06/2026 14:03

It almost feels as if he seems to have got away with it if it a company car and refuses to hand his details over as his company will just deal with and he’ll continue driving the way he does. what I’ve always been told at accidents, you exchange name and details and he refused to do it.

Yes and that's completely unfair. But, you've done all you can for now. Let the insurance company deal with it.

DryTerryandJUNE · 09/06/2026 14:06

He prob "acted weirdly" because you were in a bit of a state and asking nonsensical questions. "Why did you do that?" I mean, it's highly unlikely he meant to do it...
In a similar situation, I was very lucky to have the calmest chap as the party at fault. I was very shaken - but not verbally aggressive like you seemed to be - and he made sure we swapped all the details etc.
You phone your insurer with the number plate and they take care of it.

Reallynosuchthing · 09/06/2026 14:05

Try not to worry, report to insurance. The exact thing happened to me and i was told that even if you were indicating, the person pulling out is always at fault.
Hope you and the kids are ok x

Iwanttobeafraser · 09/06/2026 14:04

AllyMacbealmyarse · 09/06/2026 13:50

The advice from insurers @Zaina89 is always to say as little as possible at the scene to avoid unitnetionally accepting liability, so him saying nothing isn’t by itself suspicious. Also shouting at him doesn’t help, and you saying you weren’t being aggressive doesn’t get you anywhere as shouting is aggressive.

He should have given his details and that is an offence so report to the police, but frankly I would want to misnimise my contact with someone shouting at me especially if I was shaken up by a near miss accident. Especially stuff like why did you do that and what have you done as that’s pushing me to defend myself and take responsibility, which as above the advice is not to do. I would not have given you my phone number- someone hit me once, it was very frightening and a police and ambulance were called, when I tried to get her number the officer told me I was not entitled to have it.

Report and insurance , try to let it go

I'm fairly cetain this is not true any more. You saying, on the spot, in a panic, "it's my fault" is NOT accepting liability in any meaningful way, although might add a tiny bit to the process of sorting it out I imagine. For example, if you are driving and something runs into the road and you slam on breaks and the guy behind you drives into you as a resullt, you might, in the moment, say, "I'm so sorry, a dog ran into the raod and I instincitvely slammed on breaks" But the rules are clear - the driver behind is responsible for ensuring there is sufficient space between them and the car in front that in the case of an emergency stop, they will not hit the car in front. So you can feel guilty all you like, ultimately, the person behind who has liability.

At the end of the day, it's usually fairly clear cut in that person x has right of way and person y doesn't. Most accidents are caused because people make mistakes, and that mistake is not mitigated for by the other driver.

Zaina89 · 09/06/2026 14:03

anothernewname6789998212 · 09/06/2026 13:49

I absolutely understand that. But he wouldn’t have known you weren’t going to harass him as, unfortunately, so many do in these situations so might have been the reason why, as it’s a company car and he therefore had no interest with potentially having to engage with you directly about it.

But that wasn’t the right thing for him to do either way, he shouldve just passed his info over, and you’re the one who’s undoubtedly been wronged here.

It almost feels as if he seems to have got away with it if it a company car and refuses to hand his details over as his company will just deal with and he’ll continue driving the way he does. what I’ve always been told at accidents, you exchange name and details and he refused to do it.

OP posts:
JustMyView13 · 09/06/2026 14:00

SandyHappy · 09/06/2026 13:31

Doesn’t matter if OP was travelling 30/40/60.

It absolutely does matter if OP was breaking the law and speeding, and that WILL change the outcome of liability for insurance purposes if it can be proved she was speeding at the time of the accident, not only can she be party liability she could also be charged with a crime.

if your driving falls below the minimum standard expected of a competent and careful driver, you can be charged with careless driving

As it happens she wasn't, so it doesn't matter in this case.

It’s almost impossible to prove, and it doesn’t change liability. You can’t just be pulling out on cars - speeding or otherwise - and putting in insurance claims.

Isobel201 · 09/06/2026 13:55

You've got his reg, that's enough for your insurance company, they can do the rest. I regularly pull out on a road where people don't cancel their indicators after a roundabout, and I'm very used to this, but yes make sure your indicator was cancelled in future.

WimbyAce · 09/06/2026 13:51

It doesn't even matter if it was left on, if you weren't slowing and turning then he shouldn't have pulled out.

AllyMacbealmyarse · 09/06/2026 13:50

The advice from insurers @Zaina89 is always to say as little as possible at the scene to avoid unitnetionally accepting liability, so him saying nothing isn’t by itself suspicious. Also shouting at him doesn’t help, and you saying you weren’t being aggressive doesn’t get you anywhere as shouting is aggressive.

He should have given his details and that is an offence so report to the police, but frankly I would want to misnimise my contact with someone shouting at me especially if I was shaken up by a near miss accident. Especially stuff like why did you do that and what have you done as that’s pushing me to defend myself and take responsibility, which as above the advice is not to do. I would not have given you my phone number- someone hit me once, it was very frightening and a police and ambulance were called, when I tried to get her number the officer told me I was not entitled to have it.

Report and insurance , try to let it go

anothernewname6789998212 · 09/06/2026 13:49

Zaina89 · 09/06/2026 13:12

But I wasn’t violent, aggressive or planning to harass him or having a go at him. He pulled out and hit into me and my son was in that side of the car. I was obviously very upset and panicked. I had 3 kids in the car not just my son, my girls were in the back one of whom is only 2 and he pulled out and hit into me. I was upset and panicked and only asked him why did he do that ( as in why did he pull out and hit me) and what have you done.

I absolutely understand that. But he wouldn’t have known you weren’t going to harass him as, unfortunately, so many do in these situations so might have been the reason why, as it’s a company car and he therefore had no interest with potentially having to engage with you directly about it.

But that wasn’t the right thing for him to do either way, he shouldve just passed his info over, and you’re the one who’s undoubtedly been wronged here.

Ohthatsabitshit · 09/06/2026 13:40

You’ve reported to the police, and to your insurance, now you wait. I’m not sure what you are looking for?

oliviaAustin · 09/06/2026 13:35

He was probably under the influence so wanted out of there.

Zaina89 · 09/06/2026 13:33

kombuchabucha · 09/06/2026 13:26

Also I think your response was tame, OP. If someone hit my car with my kids in it I would struggle to manage such a controlled reaction. I would have wanted to shout and scream at him for putting my babies at risk and I would have wanted to make him apologise to them directly for scaring them.

Honestly past me would have just burst into tears and cried like a baby but I stood up for myself and asked him what he was doing and why did he do that. As you said my children were in the car and they were put at risk, this could have been so much worse and I feel I did have every right to be panicked and upset and even angry because my children could have been seriously hurt, I know I raised my voice a bit because I was in shock and panicked but I was by no means aggressive or violent!

this whole incident is putting me off driving now, honestly within the past week how many people I have seen pulling out with small gaps and dangerous driving is really scary especially when you know your driving with your children in the car. It doesn’t seem to matter how careful you are with driving these days there is always someone.

OP posts:
SandyHappy · 09/06/2026 13:31

JustMyView13 · 09/06/2026 13:11

Agree. Liability for insurance is the act that causes the accident. Doesn’t matter if OP was travelling 30/40/60. It’s the responsibility of the person exiting the junction to check it is clear to do so.

Doesn’t matter if OP was travelling 30/40/60.

It absolutely does matter if OP was breaking the law and speeding, and that WILL change the outcome of liability for insurance purposes if it can be proved she was speeding at the time of the accident, not only can she be party liability she could also be charged with a crime.

if your driving falls below the minimum standard expected of a competent and careful driver, you can be charged with careless driving

As it happens she wasn't, so it doesn't matter in this case.

WhatsAWeekend · 09/06/2026 13:30

Solaitt · 09/06/2026 12:56

Yes she does! She’s stated several times on this thread re: the footage.

Have you commented on the wrong thread?

Apologies.
thought at some point she said she didn’t
clearly she does
my mistake !

MyDogClive · 09/06/2026 13:28

A company car can be driven by someone who is self employed. It doesn’t need to be a high status individual within a big corporate. Although I guess, Mr should have looked where he was going might have been more upset if he would be bearing the increased insurance costs.

Wetcoatsandmudagain · 09/06/2026 13:27

SandyHappy · 09/06/2026 12:54

What is the possible scam though? He is liability for failing to give way.

This sort of scam only works if there are other vehicles involved that can claim off each other once the original instigator has left the scene.

They take a chance you haven’t got dashcam, no witnesses. Come back later having totally rewritten the narrative. Claim they left the scene because you were aggressive etc. it’s a minor collision and no one hurt so insurance companies don’t bother investigating. Fighting it often causes more agro than people want to deal with so they get away with it. I knew someone who managed to find a house that caught the accident on ring doorbell and you could see they were sitting waiting for someone to pull into the road.

kombuchabucha · 09/06/2026 13:26

Zaina89 · 09/06/2026 13:12

But I wasn’t violent, aggressive or planning to harass him or having a go at him. He pulled out and hit into me and my son was in that side of the car. I was obviously very upset and panicked. I had 3 kids in the car not just my son, my girls were in the back one of whom is only 2 and he pulled out and hit into me. I was upset and panicked and only asked him why did he do that ( as in why did he pull out and hit me) and what have you done.

Also I think your response was tame, OP. If someone hit my car with my kids in it I would struggle to manage such a controlled reaction. I would have wanted to shout and scream at him for putting my babies at risk and I would have wanted to make him apologise to them directly for scaring them.

Olderbutt · 09/06/2026 13:26

Zaina89 · 09/06/2026 12:26

The car was a 2025 Range Rover. He said it was a company car but I have reported it to the police because he was so hesitant and refused to hand over his name and details,personally also if it was me especially if it was a company car and a brand new car at that I would have been even more panicked and in a rush to check the damage of my car and took pictures/videos so it is very strange and weird to me he didn’t check the damage, give his details or take pictures videos as surely dash cam footage only points straight and he couldn’t have got my registration or details as I was on his side view? Does dash cam record the side traffic? so it does make me think was he insured to be driving the company car but we’ll see, how he behaved and acted showed he was very calm and not overly bothered by the incident and in a hurry to get it over with. We’ll see what happens I guess.

reported it to the insurance company but I do want to make a claim as he drove in to me and he or his company should be liable to fix the damage to my car, but let’s see what is going to happen because it is all so strange.

Yes absolutely claim . If he isn't insured it will be dealt with by the Motor Insurance Bureau. I was hit by an uninsured driver and it was swiftly dealt with by my insurer and the MIB.

ShallWeDance · 09/06/2026 13:24

ijustwanttoworkout · 09/06/2026 10:33

You left your indicator on, 40mph is a limit not a target and you should’ve been paying better attention. A scary lesson to have learned.

It doesn't matter.

kombuchabucha · 09/06/2026 13:20

This sounds so scary OP, I'm glad no one was hurt.

He's in the wrong for pulling out on you, even if your indicator was on. So his smarmy little comment about it being on camera is irrelevant. Insurance companies say that indicating is a signal of intent, not a guarantee, and the person who pulls out is at fault.

I never, ever pull out at a junction even if the car is indicating and appears to be slowing down to turn for this very reason. I only go when they have actually started to make the turn. This is because a few weeks after passing my driving test someone pulled out on me because my indicator was on (I'd just come off a mini roundabout and there was a side street almost immediately afterwards, my indicator hadn't had chance to turn off automatically and I hadn't turned it off manually myself). Luckily I was going slowly enough to avoid hitting them, but it was still a good lesson learned early on in my driving career!

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/06/2026 13:15

He's pulled out of a give way onto the major road, without giving way to you, causing you to brake sharply - even if there had been no collision, he is at fault.

Indicators and minor speed quibbles are irrelevant here (so whether you were doing 5 miles under or even 5 miles over the speed limit) the cause of the collision was him not giving way. (Yeah I watch Big Jobber!)

Your insurance co. should deal with it but I would not be surprised to find his behaviour is due to him being an uninsured or possibly even banned driver, rather than it being a company vehicle, because if it is a company vehicle, why not just hand over the details? I also wonder if his reluctance to step away from his vehicle is because he was trying to avoid appearing on your dash cam.