Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my SIL to not visit after 6:30 pm on a Sunday evening?

159 replies

Goinggreymammy · 07/06/2026 16:45

SIL is about 4 years younger than us, doesn't have a partner or children. Has a very busy job with lots of out of hours calls, emails etc. She has friends and sometimes sees them or goes hiking on weekends. She lives about 15 mins drive away and we rarely see her. My 3 children are her only nieces/nephews. She doesn't allow us to visit her house (yes, literally says no..... once my son, 7, wanted to use the toilet and she was giving my son and DH a lift home she said no, he couldn't go in, just drove them home. )
Anyway she does her weekly shop in a place near us and every month or so will arrive around 7pm to visit. If I ask if she had a busy day.... no, just some WFH, etc. We just aren't enough to visit without adding us onto her shopping. My kids are older now but they have sports fixtures on Sundats so need showers before bed. And I try to have some downtime, watch a family show together etc, then do stories. So I find the random 7pm visits annoying. She just messaged to say she would call later, when I queried time - yes.. Around 7.
She organised a meal out for PIL, BIL, herself and my DH and I a month ago and it was on a Sunday at 5pm. Why can't she call here at 5pm?
YABU. Suck it up.
YANBU say something.

OP posts:
CaesarAugusta · 08/06/2026 23:22

Goinggreymammy · 07/06/2026 18:41

Thank you all so far. Why don't I just say its not convenient? Or invite her at a convenient time. Because then Im afraid she would never visit. She's not really comfortable with the kids and not close to my dH. Any time I have ever asked her for a specific time she is too busy. Its on her terms or none. (She makes a huge fuss about being DD1's godmother... this year once again said she would take her out for a day instead of a present.... last year she finally did it about 4 months later, this year she still hasn't done it (7mths on).

My family are all far away - we visit 4-5 times a year if I can. But my DC don't have many relations so I really don't want to annoy her and stop the visits altogether.

So say "Sorry, that's not convenient, but could we fix another time for you to come round for a meal?" of something similar to that.

latenightscrolling · 08/06/2026 22:27

I appreciate I’m going against the grain a bit here, but it’s on average once a month? I think it’s sweet she wants to see the kids. Not a hill I’d be dying on to be honest

Pinkfuchsia · 08/06/2026 22:17

Goinggreymammy · 07/06/2026 16:45

SIL is about 4 years younger than us, doesn't have a partner or children. Has a very busy job with lots of out of hours calls, emails etc. She has friends and sometimes sees them or goes hiking on weekends. She lives about 15 mins drive away and we rarely see her. My 3 children are her only nieces/nephews. She doesn't allow us to visit her house (yes, literally says no..... once my son, 7, wanted to use the toilet and she was giving my son and DH a lift home she said no, he couldn't go in, just drove them home. )
Anyway she does her weekly shop in a place near us and every month or so will arrive around 7pm to visit. If I ask if she had a busy day.... no, just some WFH, etc. We just aren't enough to visit without adding us onto her shopping. My kids are older now but they have sports fixtures on Sundats so need showers before bed. And I try to have some downtime, watch a family show together etc, then do stories. So I find the random 7pm visits annoying. She just messaged to say she would call later, when I queried time - yes.. Around 7.
She organised a meal out for PIL, BIL, herself and my DH and I a month ago and it was on a Sunday at 5pm. Why can't she call here at 5pm?
YABU. Suck it up.
YANBU say something.

I’d carry on with your normal Sunday routine if your DH is home to entertain her. Do bath time, get the kids into bed & sit in your bed with a cuppa & a book while they go asleep.

Wildefish · 08/06/2026 19:54

Livingthebestlife · 07/06/2026 17:08

Some people are thoughtless idiots. I get this often too and the annoying thing is even saying it's too late straight out, they just think you're sitting there with nothing to do. I wish people had a bit more cop on and had some consideration for other people's lives.

I guess people with no children have no idea what it’s like unless explained to them.

Namechangeforthisdilemma1 · 08/06/2026 19:31

Goinggreymammy · 07/06/2026 18:47

Then we would never see her. I feel my DC would lose out having no relationship with their aunt, as my family are all a long distance away.
That said they probably see more of my brother in Texas and are closer to him.

Just ask her to come before the shop?

I don’t get why you’re so hung up on her not coming if you say 7pm isn’t good for you.

you can’t force a relationship.

Justanothermum42 · 08/06/2026 19:18

oh joy! Honestly, I have a single friend who is like that. I can see her on her terms only. She has no family, partner or pets. I have kids, dogs, husband… weekends are so super busy. I could meet her half way (we live an hour on the train away from each other) on a Sunday as it’s less busy than a Saturday. It’s always a ‘no’. It’s her day to chill. We haven’t seen each other in 9 months and she is upset with me. But between kids’ sport fixtures, GCSEs, A levels and uni research I simply cannot give her a Saturday: Because meeting me on a Sunday messes her routine. There is no consideration to my routine though. Argh. It’s a tough one. But please ask her to come before her monthly shop? X

Ethelspagetti · 08/06/2026 19:12

DaisyChain505 · 07/06/2026 16:50

Surely this is your husbands issue to deal with not yours. Tell your husband you don’t want visitors that late and that he needs to talk to her. If he won’t then you just make yourself unavailable whenever she comes. Go off and have a bath, say you’re going out to meet friends.

As for her not wanting people in her house, that could be for a whole host of reasons. She could be a secret hoarder, she could have severe OCD or she could just plain and simple not want kids in her home. Either way it hasn’t really got anything to do with the issue at hand.

Agreed.

jjW29 · 08/06/2026 19:02

Sounds to me like she’s got nothing to do and as you said is tagging a visit to you on to her shopping trip.Could she not visit around lunchtime before the shopping or would that not suit you either? She’s what I call an opportunist ie visiting you only when there’s nothing else to do and she’s in the area anyway so killing 2 birds with 1 stone.On the other hand maybe a bit lonely and dreads Sunday evenings

JJMama · 08/06/2026 19:00

KellyJonesLeatherTrousers · 07/06/2026 16:50

Why wouldn’t you (or DH for that matter) just open your mouth and say, 7pm doesn’t work for us!

This. A simple “no that doesn’t work for us” should suffice.

She’s not shy about saying no to you in her house.

PinkEasterbunny · 08/06/2026 18:55

PepsiBook · 08/06/2026 17:24

Just explain that'd not suitable for you and the family, but you'd love to still see her. When else is she free?

This. If she is genuinely bothered, then surely she can find another time?

andthat · 08/06/2026 18:48

Goinggreymammy · 07/06/2026 18:44

She isnt close to my Dh. He isnt great for keeping up relationships with his family. But my ILs are the only extended family my DC have that arent 5 hours away, and I'd like them to know their aunt.

Which is great @Goinggreymammy, but it seems she is less bothered.

Just tell her… ‘kids would love to see you but can’t do Sunday evenings.. how are you fixed Saturday/sunday before 6?’

if she can’t come back with another time you and your kids are just not a priority so I’d focus my energy elsewhere.

LongDarkTeatime · 08/06/2026 18:31

Next time she messages reply with something like ‘That’s great, 7-8pm is bathtime around here. So while I do that can you do X, Y and Z? That’s for your help x’

GoldenGail · 08/06/2026 18:13

murkydepths · 07/06/2026 17:09

I don't really understand how she's combining this with a shopping trip as virtually everywhere closes at 4 or 5pm on a Sunday.

Not everyone lives in England. Some of our big shops are open 24/7

jdb9803 · 08/06/2026 18:07

PullTheBricksDown · 07/06/2026 17:03

'Sorry, that's too late tonight as we're getting ready for the week. We'll see you soon'

Then, if she still shows up - which is quite likely - you can turn her away at the doorstep because she's been warned.

especially when she won't let them in her house at all!!

PepsiBook · 08/06/2026 17:24

Just explain that'd not suitable for you and the family, but you'd love to still see her. When else is she free?

Monty36 · 08/06/2026 12:40

Just ask her why doesn’t she come a bit earlier ? There is a reason she comes only once a month or so, lives 15 mins away but always comes around 7pm.
Whatever the reason, you have to let her know it isn’t suitable.

Alliod40 · 08/06/2026 12:00

No wonder no families talk to each other in the UK if this is the way you behave with each other..don't call at 7pm because I'm watching a movie with your nieces/nephews christ almighty what has the world come too...

Dancingintherain09 · 08/06/2026 11:38

Surely just a polite. That doesn't work for us as we're settling kids down at that time, you are welcome to pop over earlier during the day. 😊

Seagoats · 08/06/2026 11:38

HedgehogsOnTheWall · 07/06/2026 16:53

Can she not just sit and watch the show with you, chat a bit, maybe read them their stories and then disappear before bedtime?

Im not sure i could relax with someone i dont see that often

It seems a bit one sided.

Speak up OP.

"7 is a bit late sorry sil, youre welcome over at 4/5 though "

BruFord · 07/06/2026 23:28

I had to set out some boundaries with one of my SIL's and her DH, who used to turn up whenever they felt like it, stay for ages, and expect to be fed. She was abit miffed for a while but got over it.

They moved closer to her DH's family a few years ago and seem to have fallen out somewhat with his siblings...I suspect similar behavior! With some people, you just have to make it clear what works for you and what doesn't.

Spanglemum02 · 07/06/2026 21:46

She sounds incredibly rigid and like she doesn't understand life with children.

You have to be clear and unambiguos and invite her(which you are doing).

Good luck OP.

MrCollinsandhisboiledpotatoes · 07/06/2026 21:35

Mumandcarer80 · 07/06/2026 21:30

She has no issue telling you, you or DC aren't welcome in her home. Just tell her this isn't a good time to visit. Where does she shop on a Sunday that's open until nearly 7pm anyway?

The OP is in Ireland

Mumandcarer80 · 07/06/2026 21:30

She has no issue telling you, you or DC aren't welcome in her home. Just tell her this isn't a good time to visit. Where does she shop on a Sunday that's open until nearly 7pm anyway?

MrCollinsandhisboiledpotatoes · 07/06/2026 21:28

Goinggreymammy · 07/06/2026 21:19

Hello.
You are all right - I need to put on my big girl pants and deal with this. Tonight wasn't the night though, it is my sons birthday tomorrow and my PIL usually come for a little tea party for birthdays, but they are away so I was facilitating this so he didn't feel forgotten (he has SEN).
I just cleaned up the kitchen when I got back and even hoovered the floor, and she had to talk to DH. They get on OK, just don't make much effort.
My SIL was quite chatty tonight; she is well meaning but a bit clueless, so i have decided to proactively invite her over for a barbecue some Sunday afternoon in the next month. And then to lunch another day. And hopefully say then about the Sunday nights.
Thanks all. You have helped me "cop onto myself" as we say here or "give my head a wobble" as you say in UK.

"Cop onto myself" is so much better than "give your head a wobble" that phrase irritates the hell out of me xx

Goinggreymammy · 07/06/2026 21:20

MoodyMargaret11 · 07/06/2026 21:13

Your posts arent making any sense. This is all entirely your own doing, you want to keep her in your children's life as a token gesture aunt = keep sucking it up!
You dont want to bother with her visits = tell her Sorry doesnt work, or let your DH deal (or not deal) with his own sister.
Hardly a rocket science.

Yes, I can see that now.

OP posts: