Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think dismissal during probation was unfair given autism adjustments?

585 replies

SereneRoseRobin · 03/06/2026 15:37

I’m looking for honest views because I’m not sure whether I’m being unreasonable or whether this was genuinely unfair.

I was recently dismissed from a graduate/analyst role after my probation was extended. I am autistic, and my employer knew this. I had raised the need for clear written instructions, defined objectives, examples of similar work, timelines, and timely/direct feedback. Some support was put in place, including coaching, but I don’t feel the actual adjustments were properly embedded or reviewed before the decision was made.

The difficult part is that the concerns raised about me seemed mainly to focus on communication style, professional behaviour, asking for clarification, Teams messages, and quality assurance under pressure — rather than on whether I could actually do the analytical work. Some recent written feedback said my analytical skills were good, that my work did not contain relevant errors, that I was taking ownership, and that I sought support appropriately. Another person said I had picked up on a complex project well.

The project I was criticised on was not straightforward. I was a first-year graduate with no prior experience in that sector, and I was assigned open-ended/data-heavy modelling work with a lot of ambiguity and short deadlines. Some outputs were expected within hours or by the next day, so there was not much time for structured review. I also didn’t always get timely feedback while I could still act on it. Some feedback came months after the work had ended.
My probation extension was meant to allow support and coaching to take effect, but I was dismissed before the extension period had fully ended. I had submitted evidence of improvement the day before the decision, but I don’t feel it was properly discussed or considered.
The coaching report apparently said the benefit of coaching should be assessed after a longer period, because performance can dip while new strategies embed.

I’m appealing because I think they didn’t properly separate disability-related communication issues from actual capability, didn’t give recent improvement enough weight, and didn’t consider alternatives such as letting the extension run, providing clearer QA/communication frameworks, assigning more standard analyst work, or redeploying me to a more suitable team.

I’m not saying I was perfect. I know there were areas to improve. But I feel like I was assessed against unclear expectations, on complex work, without the timely feedback and structure that had already been identified as necessary for me.

AIBU to think this was unfair and potentially linked to disability discrimination/failure to make reasonable adjustments? Or is this just how probation works, and I should accept it and move on?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
plsdontlookatme · 04/06/2026 13:59

I'm not really sure why it is beyond the comprehension of some posters that people might be more casual and more frank on an anonymous online forum than they are in the workplace? In much the same way as I pay my landlord on time and in full every month despite my belief that housing is a human right, I go to work and am agreeable, productive and professional regardless of how I feel about disability discrimination (and again, I'm lucky enough to have a nice enough job and nice enough employer at the moment, so zero bitterness here).

Taztoy · 04/06/2026 13:57

Branleuse · 04/06/2026 13:47

That's pretty common for autistic people sadly.

With the right adjustments and the right support it doesn't have to be that way.

Yeah but you seem to be ignoring the issue of recording someone without their consent.

Branleuse · 04/06/2026 13:57

Stoneycold12 · 03/06/2026 21:10

The OP doesn't sound like she's making any effort to 'adapt in a world of neuro typical people' though - nearly nine months into the job and she's still looking for a huge amount of support and feedback.

She has had significant accommodations, but won't apologise to the colleague she recorded, as she believes she should have been able to. We all of us have to curb our natural impusles in the workplace, and try to play nicely. OP sounds as if she believes this doesn't apply to her.

She's unsuitable for her role, and repeatedly asking for advice on MN isn't going to change that. She can of course bring a discrimination case, or she could look for a job that suits her better, and try to understand the social norms of the next workplace.

Yeah 9 months into a job, she really should have stopped being autistic now, or at least be able to act neurotypical?!

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 04/06/2026 13:56

Branleuse · 04/06/2026 13:54

Did op ask for micromanagement or hand holding or for the whole organisation to restructure itself around her?

Were they the adjustments asked for?

Read the OP posts, it’s quite self explanatory when you read her posts.

plsdontlookatme · 04/06/2026 13:54

Taztoy · 04/06/2026 13:33

The em dash and phrasing gives away AI

How soon after the recording incident were you let go @SereneRoseRobin ?

I use em-dashes copiously and I have never once used AI. I just read classic lit.

Branleuse · 04/06/2026 13:54

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 03/06/2026 22:47

The Equality Act requires employers to make reasonable adjustments, but it does not mean a whole organisation must reorganise itself around one person.

If adjustments have already been put in place and the underlying issue is that the employee still cannot meet deadlines or core project requirements, the employer is not expected to extend timelines or change service levels for one individual.

They are not required to handhold or micromanage.

I am dyslexic and my company has made reasonable adjustments for me to be able to do my job.

However, it is still my responsibility to carry out my role. It is not my employer’s job to micromanage me every step of the way or to take over tasks that I am expected to perform.

Workplaces have clients, targets and delivery commitments, and they cannot pause operations because one person needs more time.

Reasonable adjustments are intended to help someone meet the same standards as everyone else, not to remove those standards.

Did op ask for micromanagement or hand holding or for the whole organisation to restructure itself around her?

Were they the adjustments asked for?

Branleuse · 04/06/2026 13:47

MesLunettes · 04/06/2026 10:38

Because there’s a pattern. This isn’t the first time she’s been let go.

That's pretty common for autistic people sadly.

With the right adjustments and the right support it doesn't have to be that way.

Taztoy · 04/06/2026 13:33

The em dash and phrasing gives away AI

How soon after the recording incident were you let go @SereneRoseRobin ?

Preppyprepper · 04/06/2026 13:27

I would say it is fairly obvious you used AI to write your OP.

Do you use it as you struggle with written communication? Unfortunately people can tell, and it looks unprofessional to be using it to send work emails.

Locutus2000 · 04/06/2026 13:23

manova366 · 03/06/2026 23:28

Back in the day, training in social skills for autistic people was considered appropriate and helpful; but now that kind of thing is regarded as ableist. "Masking" is seen as traumatic when it's actually what everyone does to some extent.
Now workplaces are expected to adapt to the condition, rather than the other way around. And here we are.

Back in the day, training in social skills for autistic people was considered appropriate and helpful

When was that? I remember it being an abusive and abhorrent program akin to conversion therapy.

"Masking" is seen as traumatic when it's actually what everyone does to some extent.

'What everyone does to some extent' is always used in the context of minimising and questioning disabilities. Just say what you mean.

SereneRoseRobin · 04/06/2026 13:15

MinglyMadly · 04/06/2026 13:13

I think this OP. If you are communicating in a written style like this at work I could see that as being a problem.

Writing full sentences and capitalising the first word would be a start and make a big difference as to how you come across.

Perhaps you were doing that at work and are just being relaxed here?

i was communicating better at work but people complained i used ai outputs since the outputs were so polished lmao

OP posts:
MinglyMadly · 04/06/2026 13:13

VaultandSinagain · 03/06/2026 19:13

Were you like this in the workplace? Rude? Abrupt? Expecting people to help you? Just thinking about what you need? Can you express yourself in a professional manner?

I think this OP. If you are communicating in a written style like this at work I could see that as being a problem.

Writing full sentences and capitalising the first word would be a start and make a big difference as to how you come across.

Perhaps you were doing that at work and are just being relaxed here?

SilverLining77 · 04/06/2026 12:34

@Branleuse 'We are entitled to this. '

This illustrates my point earlier on.

There is a fine line between requesting adjustment and demanding one because I'm entitle to it regardless.

plsdontlookatme · 04/06/2026 12:15

Smoosha · 04/06/2026 08:51

What is the matter with you? I’m autistic and I’m not in a high powered job. You know why? Because I can’t do it. I don’t even know if it’s because of my personality or autism. I used to think it was my personality back before I knew I was autistic. I know for a fact that no amount of training or adjustments could make me a brilliant sales person. So I don’t work in sales. I also don’t like tons of responsibility. So I don’t work as a manager to people or in a job where everything falls on me. Now I’m thinking about everything you’ve said maybe I should start applying for sales jobs where I don’t need to sell anything or a managers job where someone else does the managing part as an adjustment. I could get loads more money!

Loads is the matter with me, but that's besides the point - I also know my limits and work in a non-managerial, low-status job, and it's fine. I always joke that I wouldn't be able to sell someone a bottle of water in the desert! I've repeatedly said on this thread that I don't think reasonable adjustments for autism are usually a recipe for success, and that unfortunately it's better to bow out of companies and sectors that don't work for you rather than forcing people to implement reasonable adjustments that they resent, because it doesn't have a happy ending. I just say this because I'm being realistic.

Lunalara · 04/06/2026 11:37

Cars4Gov · 04/06/2026 11:35

There must also be acceptance of an individuals own abilities and fit for the role. Communication in consultancy would be a key skill so if this is an area lacking then it's not the right fit.

A relative with ASD, on leaving Uni was highly aspirational about her career and initially saw every sign of non progression through the lens of prejudice/discrimination. This didn't help her at all and she was nearly sacked...thankfully she met a partner in work, who was able to advise that she move into certain roles which are analytical but repeatable and lower requirement for communication/people management. It's a win/win. The employer gets a competent worker and she has a job she can do without stress.

She has also let go of her unrealistic aspirations to be CEO. Just because someone has good academics doesn't mean they are leaders or should be in client facing roles.

So employers can help but ultimately some roles are not right..maturity is understanding that and finding what will work for you.

I second going into a more analytical role. This is what I am attempting to do for myself. Communication heavy jobs usually tire ND people a lot. It’s not worth it as long as less communication heavy roles exist.

Cars4Gov · 04/06/2026 11:35

Branleuse · 04/06/2026 10:25

Op, I think that even if you move on to a different job, I don't think that means you should not make any fuss over this.
A huge percentage of autistic people are not in gainful employment, and often keeping a job is harder than getting a job.
We are so often apparently 'not a good fit'.
Stressed to burn out by workplace cultures that are full of unspoken rules, and being good at the actual work itself is not good enough. It's indirect discrimination.

It is degrading to keep being told to find something else when it's a job you can do fine even if you need a bit of support or adjustments.
We are entitled to this. Most of us want to work.

There must also be acceptance of an individuals own abilities and fit for the role. Communication in consultancy would be a key skill so if this is an area lacking then it's not the right fit.

A relative with ASD, on leaving Uni was highly aspirational about her career and initially saw every sign of non progression through the lens of prejudice/discrimination. This didn't help her at all and she was nearly sacked...thankfully she met a partner in work, who was able to advise that she move into certain roles which are analytical but repeatable and lower requirement for communication/people management. It's a win/win. The employer gets a competent worker and she has a job she can do without stress.

She has also let go of her unrealistic aspirations to be CEO. Just because someone has good academics doesn't mean they are leaders or should be in client facing roles.

So employers can help but ultimately some roles are not right..maturity is understanding that and finding what will work for you.

Lunalara · 04/06/2026 11:33

It’s a tough world out there for ND people. A lot of us get judged by our communication style even though we do not want to cause trouble. I understand because I went through this in my previous career (teaching). My advice is to learn how to break things down better, and then do whatever is in your control. Easier said than done though I know.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 04/06/2026 11:33

Branleuse · 04/06/2026 10:34

I think that her whole opening post was clear about it.
The OP has protected characteristics and the employer has not put reasonable adjustments into place.
OP has followed the steps and provided evidence of improvement and I think that I'd be speaking to my union, because there are procedures that should be followed.

It doesn't sound like a great place to work sadly for an autistic , but I think if we want a society where people can work and contribute and support themselves, then workplaces need to do their part. Probationary periods don't cancel out the equality and anti discrimination legislation

I completely disagree with this. The employer did put reasonable adjustments in place, including coaching and support.

The level of adjustment the OP was asking for would have required constant oversight and hand holding, which goes beyond what can reasonably be expected in that role.

The OP was not the right fit for the post. She was unable to work independently or meet deadlines, whether due to her communication system, her understanding of the projects, or her general approach to the work.

There were also concerns about her professional conduct after she recorded colleagues without consent and then refused to apologise, which showed little regard for company policy.

Probationary periods do not override equality or anti discrimination legislation, but they also do not prevent an employer from deciding that someone cannot meet the core requirements of the job.

Reasonable adjustments are meant to remove barriers, not to fundamentally change the nature of the role.

StillNotDoingIt · 04/06/2026 11:24

SereneRoseRobin · 04/06/2026 08:57

some of the replies here r not in good faith

I agree, so why are you doing it?

People are likely getting the impression that you respond to anything you dislike by acting like a surly teenager, and it will of course colour their responses.

You may have to accept that unless you can learn the right lessons from this then you will never be capable of developing a professional career.

May I ask, what have you learned from (as I understand it) failing your accountancy exams?

Velumental · 04/06/2026 11:12

SereneRoseRobin · 03/06/2026 15:56

why do u think its a poor fit

I work as a clinician, I'm fairly confident I'm neurodivergent, my direct manager comments on 'you'll hate this change because of your ADHD' but she genuinely is just acknowledging that I find some things harder.

I'm clinically brilliant and patients love me.

What I struggle with is multiple computer systems, letters to patients and referring, recording information while seeing patients. Ultimately taking my verbal communication and recording it to communicate it onwards. Now what is very helpful is that my manager has identified those things and put it into words for me.

I go in early, I stay late to finish paperwork because sometimes I can't do it during clinic and I need to go away because I feel overwhelmed, have a coffee and come back and complete it then.

Several of our team are like this in 1 way or another and we've become this bunch of people who can go 'x is t going to respond to that text message, Y won't access the spreadsheet, z isn't going to make a phone call...' etc etc and we all just work with each other on it. It's actually lovely. I'm 25 years into a career though and it was years before I understood myself.

I job hopped a fair bit to find an environment that worked, op you need to find the role that works for you. That may mean starting on a lower salary, it may mean doing something that's a sidestep from what you thought you'd do. By all means if you were discriminated against feel free to complain and she or whatever but also life is long! Find a job that doesn't feel like torture.

My current role has enough daily change that I don't get bored and grind to a halt, enough routine that I don't get overwhelmed, enough understanding that I'm not afraid to ask questions and enough leadership and expectations that I can't the piss. Try on a few different roles, you'll get there

Skybluepinky · 04/06/2026 10:53

You aren’t what they are looking for, you don’t have the skills required to do the job, get another job where your skill set fits.

Laura95167 · 04/06/2026 10:51

SereneRoseRobin · 04/06/2026 08:57

some of the replies here r not in good faith

Wdym?

Taztoy · 04/06/2026 10:44

MesLunettes · 04/06/2026 10:38

Because there’s a pattern. This isn’t the first time she’s been let go.

From memory it’s the second - the first being a big 4 consultancy firm.

Taztoy · 04/06/2026 10:44

Branleuse · 04/06/2026 10:35

Is this your thread now?

No. I’m autistic and I’m trying to understand why you think the op has a good case, given that she commited what would be a gross misconduct in most orgs.

ShetlandishMum · 04/06/2026 10:43

I have been employed in a company where the staff in one of the departments started to resign because the management did not understand what it meant to keep adapting to one individual's needs.

Other employees cannot keep compensating, helping and explaining things for one individual.

It destroyed a department to adapt to one person's individual needs and it took a long time to rebuild it.

Employees other than for example an autistic person also have the right for a reasonable working environment.