Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my SIL was rude about my clothes?

294 replies

UninterestedInFashion · 31/05/2026 17:12

Over the half term week we saw dh family a few times. A kids birthday party, family bbq and couple of outings to the park and pub.

I admit I’m not very fashionable , don’t really follow it and wear what I like and what suits me. For context this is what I wore each time Kids party : black 3/4 length leggings and striped vest top and converse
family bbq hibiscus pattern dress and sandals
park denim shorts and a vest top and sandals
pub same hibiscus dress (it’s very old I’ve had it years but I love it)

The first time SIL said ‘oh here’s Y2K girl’ and laughed at the dress. The second time I wore it she quietly said to me ‘a spotty dress would suit you better - polka dots are in right now’

When I wore the denim shorts she said ‘you’re brave ! They are very short ! How many years have you had those!’

When I wore the 3/4 leggings she again took me aside and said ‘let’s go shopping one day - you need some wide leg linen trousers not these leggings ! I’m surprised they even still sell them or are they vintage again ‘ and laughed?

I said to her no thanks I’m comfortable and it’s hot so I’m wearing what I like and what keeps me cool. She said ‘come on sometimes we all need a bit of a refresh!’

AIBU to think she was really rude ??? I didn’t feel hurt but just irritated.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JuliaBraverman · 04/06/2026 07:20

JudgeJ · 02/06/2026 20:03

have a girly day out shopping?

Or have root canal surgery, far more pleasant.

Ha ha ha ha

JuliaBraverman · 04/06/2026 07:19

Doone22 · 02/06/2026 20:32

You don't need to be irritated, she's just trying to be nice and you should take it the same way. Why not let her take you shopping and push you out of your comfort zone? Bond over some nice shoes, etc
You should just accept everything life offers with joy instead of negativity. If you don't want to buy new stuff she can't make you, but go out anyway and try something new!

No

Laurmolonlabe · 03/06/2026 22:46

It's very rare for someone to criticise your taste like this because they mean well.
The idea you have had worse things said to you is sad, but completely irrelevant. No one has ever critcised me like this, and I ndon't expect they will- it just isn't normal behaviour- what is it to your SIL that she feels your look is dated, nothing at all.
People , particularly a husband buying clothes for you is not a good sign, he either doesn't find your style attractive (and by extension you) or he is very controlling- neither are good things.
You seem very sure of his motives, but 99% of married men I have met are not in the least interested in clothes, even the clothes their wives buy, it's at the very least, strange.

smallsilvercloud · 03/06/2026 09:53

A taste of her own medicine might work 🫢
but seriously your clothes sound fine, you know what suits your body shape, I’d rather be a bit unfashionable than keeping up with latest trends every season. I think next time confidently say I’m happy with what I’m wearing and not into faddy fast fashion thank you!

dayslikethese1 · 03/06/2026 02:21

SIL has seen Clueless too many times and fancies herself a Cher Horowitz.

maxslice · 03/06/2026 01:19

JudgeJ · 02/06/2026 19:58

Maybe the OP could say 'That's very kind of you, let's take your credit cards for a day at the shops.'

Perfect!

Doone22 · 02/06/2026 20:32

You don't need to be irritated, she's just trying to be nice and you should take it the same way. Why not let her take you shopping and push you out of your comfort zone? Bond over some nice shoes, etc
You should just accept everything life offers with joy instead of negativity. If you don't want to buy new stuff she can't make you, but go out anyway and try something new!

WearyAuldWumman · 02/06/2026 20:31

B1anche · 02/06/2026 17:10

When I was in my mid-twenties, a co-worker (same age) said "oh my mum has that blouse" followed by a smirk and side-eye to her friend. I felt so humiliated.

Some people just have a rotten streak.

Newsenmum · 02/06/2026 20:19

@ToTheRamen so people on here actually dress so that other people can be happy how they look? 🤯

Newsenmum · 02/06/2026 20:18

CrayonCritic · 01/06/2026 22:17

Well, I think you can. I think there’s a difference between looking down on someone (which is what she was doing) and wanting someone you care about to feel their best and take care of themselves.

For example, saying, “You’ve been through a lot lately. I’d love to take you shopping or something if you’d enjoy that. I think you deserve to do something nice for yourself,” comes from a place of care.

That’s very different from, “You always look drab. You need a makeover.” One is about supporting someone and helping them feel good about themselves, the other is just criticism.

But op clearly likes what she wears. She wasnt dragging herself around head down in trackies full of holes and a top that doesnt fit. It’s a dress she likes and leggings with converse.

JudgeJ · 02/06/2026 20:08

ToTheRamen · 01/06/2026 11:44

I think SIL thinks you are very badly dressed and is embarrassed by you. It sounds as though she thinks you are stingy about spending money on clothes and are looking dated and dowdy.
Are you a bit depressed? Have you given up on caring how you look?
Your SIL is tired of seeing your hibiscus dress. She thinks you need a refresh, because you look stale.
( three quarter leggings? Really? I didn’t know they still existed. )

Oh, she'd love me then, I wore a dress earlier this week in the heat which I bought at a Midway in India in 1996! Admittedly it's now only worn in the garden, commando style. Many of my clothes are 20+ years old.

JudgeJ · 02/06/2026 20:03

have a girly day out shopping?

Or have root canal surgery, far more pleasant.

JudgeJ · 02/06/2026 19:58

BunnyLake · 01/06/2026 22:10

I don’t think it is ok to ‘want to spruce someone up’ who never asked. SiL needs to mind her own business.

Maybe the OP could say 'That's very kind of you, let's take your credit cards for a day at the shops.'

MrsWallers · 02/06/2026 18:23

OP ignore her, its utter nonsense, there are way more important things in the world than clothes!
I think your clothes sound absolutely fine, she may genuinely want to "help you" or she may not
I have a lovely striped summer dress 15 years old!
My sister took me shopping once she said it was an absolute nightmare!
I have very little interest in clothes these days but I'm confident that I look absolutely fine!
I work clinically so wear a uniform and gym kit mainly
Occasionally I wear a top and jeans
I have a few lovely bits and people say I look fine and I joke that 2010 called and wants its dress back but I absolutely don't care!
Its rather sad that her confidence may be bound up in her appearance too

MrsWallers · 02/06/2026 18:04

honeylulu · 31/05/2026 19:11

What a rude cow. Denim shorts and black leggings are always around. They aren't high fashion but aren't "dated" either. She sounds a bit of a fashion victim if she thinks women should only wear the latest trends.

Linen trousers, yuck. You might as well tie two creased paper bags together and wear those on your legs. Same effect.

Exactly! Denim and black leggings are just wardrobe staples!
They are absolutely everywhere on everyone!
I wore both these items this week!

B1anche · 02/06/2026 17:10

WearyAuldWumman · 02/06/2026 15:41

When I was a young teacher, I received compliments at work for a new outfit and was asked where I’d bought it.

”The M&S sale.”

My HoD, who wasn’t involved in the conversation: “Oh, M&S is all right if it’s just for work.”

When I was in my mid-twenties, a co-worker (same age) said "oh my mum has that blouse" followed by a smirk and side-eye to her friend. I felt so humiliated.

Monty36 · 02/06/2026 16:11

I get the impression she knows it was rude and what she was enjoying was your discomfort. So downright spiteful and nasty. If that is wide of the mark and she was not enjoying your discomfort she still showed zero emotional intelligence as she was unable to pick up on how it made you feel. Which I suspect would have been evident.
She is either not nice or not very bright. Or possibly both.

WearyAuldWumman · 02/06/2026 15:41

maxslice · 02/06/2026 02:15

It reminds me of a coworker I used to have. She looked at my dress and said, “That’s a good color for you.” I said, “Thanks.” She replied, “ I used to really like that style dress when it was in.”

When I was a young teacher, I received compliments at work for a new outfit and was asked where I’d bought it.

”The M&S sale.”

My HoD, who wasn’t involved in the conversation: “Oh, M&S is all right if it’s just for work.”

Hollybollyhughes · 02/06/2026 15:18

I'll tell her to stop remarking on what I'm wearing as it's so negative. I doubt she trots out looking fabulous anyway or is she Kate Moss? Why do some people offer an opinion and be unkind (unless it's complementary then crack on). She sounds a snotty cow.

Flamingojune · 02/06/2026 15:18

NaiandSeb · 02/06/2026 10:13

All these people calling SIL names and that she's rude - it may not have been what you want to hear but the fact she didn't say these things in front of everyone and suggested a shopping trip together I think means she meant well - maybe next time you see her, take her to one side and thank her for her offer but explain you are happy as you are.
If after that she still continues, then yes she's being a bit of a b*tch but I've had in-laws say far worst things to me, so, unless you're feeling your look is perhaps dated and just needing validation that it's not, I wouldn't worry too much. My husband gets me tops for birthdays, etc, and often my first thought is 'that's not my style/I'd not pick that' but wear them to not be rude and then I find, actually, it works well - just gets me to step out of my comfort zone and try new things. He certainly doesn't do it with malice or because he thinks I don't look good or wants to control what I wear (before people start on that) - he simply sees something he thinks would look nice on me, and 9 times out of 10 he's right! I tell people he's my personal stylist - my problem is I can't picture myself in clothes/outfits without trying them on first - and most of the time I can't be bothered with that kind of fuss - so these 'surprise' outfits allow me to vary my wardrobe without the hassle. Maybe SIL is just trying to encourage a bit of diversity.. and those saying flared linen trousers are awful - I did too, until I tried a pair and then actually found them quite flattering, cooler in the heat and a bit smarter than my usual leggings.. The SIL could've been much ruder if she was so minded.

Does he laugh at your clothes too like op's sil?

Laurmolonlabe · 02/06/2026 14:32

I would tend to make a comment about her clothes "oh that's really in at the moment,but are you sure it suits you?"
Naughty l know, but if they dish it out they have to be able to take it.

Renphoaddict · 02/06/2026 13:45

She’s rude. Maybe you should be a bit rude back?

Dalston · 02/06/2026 13:18

UninterestedInFashion · 31/05/2026 17:12

Over the half term week we saw dh family a few times. A kids birthday party, family bbq and couple of outings to the park and pub.

I admit I’m not very fashionable , don’t really follow it and wear what I like and what suits me. For context this is what I wore each time Kids party : black 3/4 length leggings and striped vest top and converse
family bbq hibiscus pattern dress and sandals
park denim shorts and a vest top and sandals
pub same hibiscus dress (it’s very old I’ve had it years but I love it)

The first time SIL said ‘oh here’s Y2K girl’ and laughed at the dress. The second time I wore it she quietly said to me ‘a spotty dress would suit you better - polka dots are in right now’

When I wore the denim shorts she said ‘you’re brave ! They are very short ! How many years have you had those!’

When I wore the 3/4 leggings she again took me aside and said ‘let’s go shopping one day - you need some wide leg linen trousers not these leggings ! I’m surprised they even still sell them or are they vintage again ‘ and laughed?

I said to her no thanks I’m comfortable and it’s hot so I’m wearing what I like and what keeps me cool. She said ‘come on sometimes we all need a bit of a refresh!’

AIBU to think she was really rude ??? I didn’t feel hurt but just irritated.

SIL wants to take you on as a project. Tell her what you wear is not her concern or anyone else’s. Maybe tell her you’re happy that she’s happy with what she wears!

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/06/2026 12:57

UninterestedInFashion · 01/06/2026 17:35

I love it because it’s comfortable and cool when the weather is hot so I think I love it for how it fits and feels rather than how it looks if that makes sense. It’s just my go to ‘very hot day dress’ as it’s cotton

a cotton hibiscus dress sounds nice to me.

anyhow, if you’re usually getting along I’d probably give her the benefit of the doubt. Maybe she simply wants to bond and thought that you’d go shopping together?

next time she does it you could politely tell her that you find the comments upsetting.

SwatTheTwit · 02/06/2026 12:41

Time to tell her to mind her own business and not everyone wants to wear wide linen trousers

Is everything in her wardrobe neutral by any chance?

Swipe left for the next trending thread