Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How can I turn down uninvited siblings politely from nieces 9th birthday party?

383 replies

ThePetiteMermaid · 25/05/2026 13:29

I changed my user name for this and some details as it’s pretty outing (and a long post sorry - trying not to drip feed) but I need advice please.

My niece has a birthday party coming up this week and my Dsis was originally going to book a party package doing an activity with food and party bags included.
It worked out as far too expensive for her as a package because you need a minimum amount of guests to book and so she decided to take a smaller friend group and pay for them to do the activity individually and then to take them to a fast food place to eat.
She also decided instead of party bags to just do cake to save money and thought the kids might not expect one after an expensive activity and might be too old to be bothered anyway at 9 years old.

My Dsis became ill unexpectedly and had to have an operation which means she’s unable to host the party and her DH is at work so she asked me to do it.
I didn’t want my niece disappointed so have taken over the WhatsApp group to finalise things and I have a friend to help on the day.

I have had two messages from two mums basically saying siblings need to attend as it’s school holidays and not really asking but telling me. There hasn’t been any money offered but one mum put “Lucy isn’t expecting a party bag but I’m hoping you will be able to provide a meal for her”.

The other mums message was a bit more polite saying “Katy can’t come without her sister Jess as I have no one to look after Jess, I hope this isn’t an issue as Katy is really excited about coming to celebrate Amy’s birthday”.

I can’t believe how rude and cheeky this is, surely they aren’t expecting my Dsis to pay for the extra kids?
Even if the parents do offer to pay I don’t want to be responsible for two extra kids who will probably be a different age category anyway.

I want to reply saying that the party numbers are final and we can’t stretch to additional guests financially and also I don’t think two is enough people to safeguard extra children.
I wasn’t sure if I should include the financial part as they might have been expecting to pay for the siblings on arrival.

I was hoping for some help please in writing a response that is polite but firm, my Dsis said one of the mums will possibly try to drop the sibling off anyway as she has form for this.

I don’t have children so feel uncomfortable dealing with this and I was really surprised to hear it’s a common request, I can understand if it was a cheaper venue like a hall party when the kids were younger but not for an expensive activity!

I’m also wondering what to say to kids if they are expecting party bags. With one mum mentioning them in the text I’m thinking others might expect them and kids might ask for one. I don’t have the money or time to provide them and wouldn’t have a clue what to put in them, I don’t want to stress my Dsis when she’s ill and already fretting about pleaving me in charge, surely a slice of cake is enough?!

It would be helpful if someone could also give me a suggestion of what to say if someone does attempt to drop off a sibling please.

I’m ND and not the best with confrontation or awkward conversations and I’m really pissed off I’ve been put in this position and my niece will be really upset if the two girls can’t attend because we can’t include siblings although that maybe can’t be helped.
I wouldn’t have been as keen to volunteer to help if if known I’d be dealing with these cheeky requests and worrying about bloody party bags!

I’ve posted quickly but I have to go out now so I won’t be able to respond much until later.
I just thought I’d better add this in anticipation of people asking “where has the OP gone!”
I will update after I’ve hopefully handled the situation tactfully!

OP posts:
AppleDumplingWithCustard · 25/05/2026 14:57

I would be very brief and to the point. I absolutely would not suggest that it would be possible for the CF parents to pay for siblings and supervise them themselves. That is wide open for them to push the sibling into the main party group to avail themselves of everything on offer. Which they will do as they’ve already established that they’re CFs.

Roulett · 25/05/2026 14:55

Just reply saying “sure they can come the cost is x per head you can pay for them when you arrive”. I’d also if you could afford it and want to organise some party bags the children will definitely want one!!

floatinginacoolpool · 25/05/2026 14:54

savoycabbage · 25/05/2026 14:46

She was always pretty good about just not having anything that she thought she might react to rather than be ill at a party. If there was say an ice cream cake and she had felt unwell or had a reaction after ice cream a different time then she wouldn’t have the ice cream. She wanted to be at the party and having a good time.

Mine have been brilliant too since toddler hood.
But they cant control other children around them . One had a serious reaction after a child (the party hosts child in fact) threw some cheesy wotsits around

It has nothing to do with my children and their ability to take responsibility and everything to do with what I feel is fair to ask other people to take responsibility for.

Sausagesmyarse · 25/05/2026 14:50

krustykittens · 25/05/2026 14:46

I think this is the best message. No 'sorry' and also emphasising that the family has enough stress at the moment and don't need anymore.

The fucking cheek, demanding an extra meal be paid for to accomodate an uninvited guest! You are in the perfect position to tell them all to get to fuck, OP, do it for your sister!

We had one mum who was notorious for turning up with her two feral boys to every party. What one got, the other one had to have and she was too spineless to say no. They also ruined every event with their appalling behaviour, whether or not she stayed, so they were the sole reason class parties ended in two different year groups in that school. Made life a lot easier in the run to just have small parties with kids my children were actually good friends with and their (mostly) reasonable parents.

Party bags can get in the bin as well.

But the OPs sister might not want the school parents knowing she’s had an operation, or that the family is under stress.

The scope for school parent gossip is wide open on that one.

MPforTitipu · 25/05/2026 14:48

When mine were at the party stage fortunately it was highly unusual to be asked if any extras could come. There was one mum at my DCs' school who had 5 children, had seen everything and took no nonsense. She had a party at the local leisure centre and a parent dropped off an uninvited sibling and left. This mum simply refused to have anything to do with the extra child and left her sitting at Reception. The staff even tried to bring the extra DC to the party group and the mum absolutely refused, calling them very irresponsible for asking her to look after a total stranger when she had as many children as she was confident that she and her helpers could safely supervise. The CF mum was livid when she returned and found her child sitting bored at Reception with the staff threatening to call the Police.

The party mum became a legend in the area (she was already impressive) and the Leisure Centre thereafter insisted on a list of attendees and refused to allow any child through the barrier to a party without the express permission of whoever had booked the party.

pigsDOfly · 25/05/2026 14:48

Sausagesmyarse · 25/05/2026 13:35

“I am very sorry but we cannot accommodate siblings. The party venue and food has been booked for a certain number of children.

If you wish to bring older sibling, you can pay for their entry and food separately and you will need to stay to supervise them, they cannot be left with the party group.”

I’ve had the same so many times!!

Edited

Absolutely spot on.

jinglejanglescarecat · 25/05/2026 14:47

also - I find it so rude that parents do this!! Surely they know when they accept.

even will hall parties it’s still rude - but this is really pushing it. It’s the expectation and way it’s written too!

krustykittens · 25/05/2026 14:46

OotontheRandan · 25/05/2026 14:23

I would keep it simple:

"I am helping DSis out as she is recovering from an operation. Unfortunately, I won't be able to look after any siblings, the party has been booked for Niece and her friends only and we will be taking the parry guests for food after. I can't afford to pay for any additional children. Thank you for your understanding!"

People can be incredibly cheeky and entitled!

I think this is the best message. No 'sorry' and also emphasising that the family has enough stress at the moment and don't need anymore.

The fucking cheek, demanding an extra meal be paid for to accomodate an uninvited guest! You are in the perfect position to tell them all to get to fuck, OP, do it for your sister!

We had one mum who was notorious for turning up with her two feral boys to every party. What one got, the other one had to have and she was too spineless to say no. They also ruined every event with their appalling behaviour, whether or not she stayed, so they were the sole reason class parties ended in two different year groups in that school. Made life a lot easier in the run to just have small parties with kids my children were actually good friends with and their (mostly) reasonable parents.

Party bags can get in the bin as well.

savoycabbage · 25/05/2026 14:46

stichguru · 25/05/2026 14:30

THIS, and presumably, had your child been worried about you leaving, like say she's been to the venue previously and reacted to something, you'd have had the brains to ask about staying and siblings, when you let the host know she was coming, not on the morning of the party?!

She was always pretty good about just not having anything that she thought she might react to rather than be ill at a party. If there was say an ice cream cake and she had felt unwell or had a reaction after ice cream a different time then she wouldn’t have the ice cream. She wanted to be at the party and having a good time.

Ilovelurchers · 25/05/2026 14:45

As it's a drop and run party, the parents who are staying that siblings need to attend, make no sense!

Of course they don't.

Say this:

"So sorry but my sister has only booked the activity and the food afterwards for niece's (insert name here) friends. And we don't have enough adults able to supervise, to deal with additional guests.

While siblings are welcome to join the group, we will need you to pay both for the activity and their meal, and to stick around to supervise."

Job's a good'un!

WarmHam · 25/05/2026 14:45

My small children's party hosting days are well in my rear view mirror so I don't have anything to add to what's already been said, @Mermaid, but I did want to say you sound like a diamond sister/ auntie and your sister and niece are SOOOO lucky to have you xxx

jinglejanglescarecat · 25/05/2026 14:45

Sausagesmyarse · 25/05/2026 13:35

“I am very sorry but we cannot accommodate siblings. The party venue and food has been booked for a certain number of children.

If you wish to bring older sibling, you can pay for their entry and food separately and you will need to stay to supervise them, they cannot be left with the party group.”

I’ve had the same so many times!!

Edited

Was coming on to basically say this.

re the party bags. Ignore that comment and don’t worry!

floatinginacoolpool · 25/05/2026 14:43

savoycabbage · 25/05/2026 14:27

My child has anaphylaxis. I would tell the parent she had anaphylaxis when I accepted the invitation. At nine years old I was going in to the venue ten minutes before the party, reading the packets with dd so she would know what she could not eat and then leaving her and her epipen which of course she can jab into her own leg if she needs to.

That's fine if that suited you. I always felt it was far too much to ask the party host to be responsible for on top of everything else so I always stayed on site or nearby as a kindness to the party host as much as anything, they have enough on their plate .

My children have always been very responsible for their allergies but the reality is they have reacted to food from skin contact so birthday parties were high risk occasions

Delphiniumandlupins · 25/05/2026 14:43

"I am hosting Amy's party as her mum (my sister is ill). The party activity and meal afterwards have been booked and paid, for the specific number of children invited. We are not expecting carers to stay and have calculated adult:child ratio accordingly. I'm sorry but we can't accommodate additional siblings. "

If the venue is open to the public and these people could attend with their other DC anyway you could remind them of that. But it's not fair to try to shoehorn unknown kids into your neice's birthday activity. Don't worry about being blunt. You don't know these people and probably won't ever have to see them again.

At 9 years old parents don't expect to stay at a party. Is the venue out of the way and parents feel they have to hang around with their other children? There is obviously a food outlet nearby.

ParmaVioletTea · 25/05/2026 14:43

Sausagesmyarse · 25/05/2026 13:35

“I am very sorry but we cannot accommodate siblings. The party venue and food has been booked for a certain number of children.

If you wish to bring older sibling, you can pay for their entry and food separately and you will need to stay to supervise them, they cannot be left with the party group.”

I’ve had the same so many times!!

Edited

Either this, or

“I can arrange for extra children not invited by my niece, on payment of £30 to cover the cost of the activity and meal. Please send to - give account or PayPal details.

Please transfer the money or come with the cash, otherwise, I will not be able to host either of your children.”

SnappyQuoter · 25/05/2026 14:42

Why do they even need to bring the siblings? If the adults don’t need to stay for the party then they don’t need childcare - they can look after the uninvited sibling at home themselves.

”My sister has organised and paid for the invited children only, and I will be taking them out for a meal afterwards so we won’t be providing food for siblings. It’s not a problem though as since it’s a drop off party, you can drop X at the venue and then head off so no need for siblings to hang around with you.”

MargaretThursday · 25/05/2026 14:41

HelenaWilson · 25/05/2026 14:36

Can’t see a problem if they’re happy to pay for the siblings activity, food and look after them at the party.

Maybe the birthday child just wants her own friends at her party and doesn't want a lot of extras who might end up outnumbering the invited guests.

It's also that a child of different age often will take relatively more time to look after.

Younger, may need extra support.
Older, may dominate - I remember one party (not my dc's) where an uninvited sibling joined in and won all the games, and jeered at the other children for not winning - he even grabbed the pass the parcel out of the winner's hands, and then had a full on temper tantrum when told to hand it back (he was 8 at the time, so more than old enough to understand).

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 25/05/2026 14:41

SwatTheTwit · 25/05/2026 14:39

Can someone explain to me why are party bags “expected”? Is this a longstanding tradition? What do they entail?

It is a longstanding tradition, yes, but many parents don't like them and they are not mandatory.

They're usually just full of plastic tat that ends up in the bin in any case.

SwatTheTwit · 25/05/2026 14:39

Can someone explain to me why are party bags “expected”? Is this a longstanding tradition? What do they entail?

D0RA · 25/05/2026 14:36

Sausagesmyarse · 25/05/2026 13:35

“I am very sorry but we cannot accommodate siblings. The party venue and food has been booked for a certain number of children.

If you wish to bring older sibling, you can pay for their entry and food separately and you will need to stay to supervise them, they cannot be left with the party group.”

I’ve had the same so many times!!

Edited

I agree this is a clear message but I’ve been burned before even after sending similar.

The party was in a soft play area and there was a private room booked for the food for the guests. When it was time for the meal, the CF parent just brought the uninvited siblings into the room and sat them down at the table. The staff went and got extra chairs for the two of them. Of course there was no extra food provided ( it was on trays in the middle of the table for the kids to help themselves ) but the venue charged me for the 2 extra.

Then the uninvited siblings lined up with the others for party bags, so we were two short. The birthday child didn’t get one at all as she gave it to one of the extras. The other extra child burst into tears and the mum was drawing me dirty looks.

So I ended up paying for two extra meals, my child got no party bag , I was stressed and the CF mum was bitching about me to everyone. So pretty much lose lose for us.

After that I never said “ yes they can stay but you need to pay and supervise etc”. Because you are trusting CF parents not to be CF.

HelenaWilson · 25/05/2026 14:36

Can’t see a problem if they’re happy to pay for the siblings activity, food and look after them at the party.

Maybe the birthday child just wants her own friends at her party and doesn't want a lot of extras who might end up outnumbering the invited guests.

CoverLikelyZebra · 25/05/2026 14:34

It is OK to be a little bit blunt, so long as you are not actually insulting. These people are cheeky fuckers who are after a freebie on the principle of "don't ask don't get" and they are chancing their arm that you will have too little self-esteem to say no.

"I'm sorry but the numbers are finalised and only the invited guest child can attend, not any siblings. It's a shame if you decide that means your child can't come but we cannot take any extras"

WheretheFishesareFrightening · 25/05/2026 14:32

“Just to clarify, I’m not expecting any parents to stay - you can just drop your children off at the venue at [2pm] and collect them again at [4pm]. We won’t be able to accommodate siblings, so you’ll need to take them home with you.

And just to manage expectations, with everything going on with Amy’s mum there won’t be party bags - we’re just doing cake at the fast food place after the meal.

Amy’s looking forward to seeing all her friends there!”

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 25/05/2026 14:32

KrazyKatty · 25/05/2026 14:31

A short very blunt reply is best for cheeky fuckers like that as otherwise they’ll try to argue and cajole.

One that ends in Off, perhaps?!

KrazyKatty · 25/05/2026 14:31

A short very blunt reply is best for cheeky fuckers like that as otherwise they’ll try to argue and cajole.

Swipe left for the next trending thread