Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another holiday ruined - damaged the hire car - think I’m covered but DP being awful!

136 replies

Whyismycatanasshat · 23/05/2026 22:57

Long story short, we’re on holiday with a hire car and on the way to return it I’ve quite deeply scraped both the alloys down one side, having pulled over very sharply and in to a curb whilst taking evasive action. Genuinely couldn’t avoid doing it, it was that or be crashed into. DP acknowledges that bit.

DP is absolutely furious with me, adamant we’re going to get a HUGE bill and I know he won’t let this one go for the rest of our break - he started the moment we left the drop off; it was after hours drop off so no one to discuss it with.

Given I purchased the zero excess cover and crash damage waiver and the zero excess says

“Zero Excess (ZE) is an optional coverage available to the renter. The purchase of ZE reduces the customers liability to 0 Euro in cases of:

  • Damage to the vehicle's bodywork
  • Damage to the tyres, rims or windscreen of the hire vehicle
  • Theft or attempted theft of the rented vehicle”

I believe I’m right to tell him to shut the hell up, especially given he won’t drive a car abroad and he’s a professional haulier!

OP posts:
AppleKatie · 24/05/2026 09:03

I kind of understand his anxiety- I’d never struggled with holidays until I was suddenly responsible for DCs abroad and now that does make me anxious. Difference is I can acknowledge that and I work really hard to not act like a dick on holidays.

I think I would tell him he need to see someone and take steps to address it or he doesn’t come next time.

An apology this morning to you and the DCs is progress, a day to stew on it might also help him to come to terms with the rest of it.

ChalkOutlines · 24/05/2026 09:01

Whyismycatanasshat · 24/05/2026 08:45

Morning all.
We have had a talk this morning; he says he likes spending the time with the dc and I, but not being away from home. He says he can’t relax and feels on high alert the whole time.

Our eldest dc told him this morning they no longer want him on holiday with us. He said he understood that it’s not pleasant for them either.

He has apologised for the behaviour yesterday to the dc and me but isn’t acknowledging the fact that something triggers him every single time.

I told him that I think this would be the last family trip; we manage without him otherwise. He was quite contrite but didn’t disagree.

We’re off to a water park shortly and I don’t think he’s coming; not a bad thing.

If he really only is like this on holidays, then this is the way forward. If he can’t suck it up , he stays home. His anxiety or learned behaviour, or whatever it is , is his to manage.

I’m very anxious on holiday because if anything goes wrong I will just assume it’s my fault, and everyone will be miserable and hate me and bla bla bla. But I’m awful to myself , not anyone else. So I apologise, look for solutions and then eventually let it go , because neither DH or DD are actually that horrible or bothered and it’s all in my head.

Is it a foreign holiday? Is he the same when you holiday in the UK?

kshaw · 24/05/2026 09:01

My ex used to do this, always something to spoil the holiday. Told me never enjoyed a holiday when was a kid but would always find something to argue about if it wasn't exactly what he wanted to do. Selfish prick

HaveCreditWillShop · 24/05/2026 08:59

Badbadbunny · 24/05/2026 08:52

What does he add to your life. Maybe time to part ways.

suggesting divorce over a holiday strop is a hot take

Badbadbunny · 24/05/2026 08:52

Whyismycatanasshat · 24/05/2026 08:45

Morning all.
We have had a talk this morning; he says he likes spending the time with the dc and I, but not being away from home. He says he can’t relax and feels on high alert the whole time.

Our eldest dc told him this morning they no longer want him on holiday with us. He said he understood that it’s not pleasant for them either.

He has apologised for the behaviour yesterday to the dc and me but isn’t acknowledging the fact that something triggers him every single time.

I told him that I think this would be the last family trip; we manage without him otherwise. He was quite contrite but didn’t disagree.

We’re off to a water park shortly and I don’t think he’s coming; not a bad thing.

What does he add to your life. Maybe time to part ways.

Badbadbunny · 24/05/2026 08:50

Stoicandhappy · 23/05/2026 23:09

Tell him you aren’t driving abroad with him again as he’s such a knobhead.

Nail on the head. Next time he drives or you don’t get a car or you leave him behind. Time to stand up for yourself as he sounds abusive.

Offherrockingchair · 24/05/2026 08:48

What a prince amongst men - not! He would not be getting in that car with me again. He can walk everywhere and find his own way home. Actions have consequences. If you’re such a shit driver, he won’t want to get in another vehicle with you, will he? Play him at his own game! Honestly, OP. What a joke! My DH would have spent the rest of the day telling me what a heroine I was for avoiding a full on accident. Your life is not normal and you need to change it for the sake of your DC.

Splooterer · 24/05/2026 08:47

I read threads like this and feel so utterly sad that some women are in these relationships. It's so depressing.

itgetsthehoseagain · 24/05/2026 08:45

So is he angry because of the type of insurance you purchased? Not because of the damage itself?

Whyismycatanasshat · 24/05/2026 08:45

Morning all.
We have had a talk this morning; he says he likes spending the time with the dc and I, but not being away from home. He says he can’t relax and feels on high alert the whole time.

Our eldest dc told him this morning they no longer want him on holiday with us. He said he understood that it’s not pleasant for them either.

He has apologised for the behaviour yesterday to the dc and me but isn’t acknowledging the fact that something triggers him every single time.

I told him that I think this would be the last family trip; we manage without him otherwise. He was quite contrite but didn’t disagree.

We’re off to a water park shortly and I don’t think he’s coming; not a bad thing.

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 24/05/2026 08:44

Whyismycatanasshat · 23/05/2026 22:57

Long story short, we’re on holiday with a hire car and on the way to return it I’ve quite deeply scraped both the alloys down one side, having pulled over very sharply and in to a curb whilst taking evasive action. Genuinely couldn’t avoid doing it, it was that or be crashed into. DP acknowledges that bit.

DP is absolutely furious with me, adamant we’re going to get a HUGE bill and I know he won’t let this one go for the rest of our break - he started the moment we left the drop off; it was after hours drop off so no one to discuss it with.

Given I purchased the zero excess cover and crash damage waiver and the zero excess says

“Zero Excess (ZE) is an optional coverage available to the renter. The purchase of ZE reduces the customers liability to 0 Euro in cases of:

  • Damage to the vehicle's bodywork
  • Damage to the tyres, rims or windscreen of the hire vehicle
  • Theft or attempted theft of the rented vehicle”

I believe I’m right to tell him to shut the hell up, especially given he won’t drive a car abroad and he’s a professional haulier!

Telling him to shut the hell up is completely unreasonable in the circumstances.

He needs to be told to shut the fuck up.

Well done for avoiding the smash with your quick reactions.

Citadelica · 24/05/2026 08:41

You may not actually get a huge bill. Hire car companies are not that logical I've found.

(This kind of thing is why I've quit ever hiring a car abroad again. )

thetinsoldier · 24/05/2026 08:36

YANBU at all.

What would he rather you had done? crashed into the other car?

I hope you’re ok and not too shaken up.

he either needs counselling to work out why he acts like he does, or he stays at home when you take the dc on holiday.

LakieLady · 24/05/2026 08:35

Whyismycatanasshat · 23/05/2026 23:11

@JustGiveMeReason I honestly think he’d rather be at home when we’re away; he finds something to complain about and goes to town on it and it grinds the DC and I down. I have offered to take the DC and go myself but he insists on a family holiday. My SIL says their Dad was exactly the same. Can’t bear to enjoy themselves.

@TheJuryIsOut He will be worrying about the money side but also he has form for this rubbish.

He sounds like an utter pain to go away with.

What kind of weird mindset must someone have to insist the whole family go away and then make the whole trip miserable for everyone with their moaning and negativity?

susiedaisy1912 · 24/05/2026 08:30

3luckystars · 24/05/2026 06:04

I bet it’s not just on holidays though. At home, have you things set up in such a way that exactly all his needs are being met ?
incase he starts to frown ?

Watch out for this. You need to look at overall behaviour x x

This. Is he happy at home because everything and everyone runs according to his schedule and so on holiday he’s not in control

OhBettyCalmDown · 24/05/2026 08:05

You need to have a very frank conversation with him about how his behaviour is affecting everyone. If you stay quiet and try to make the most of it he’ll never see the impact this is having. I’d be honest and say it’s now affecting the DC. Give him the chance to change over the next few days and say to him if things don’t improve we’re not doing a family holiday again

bafta16 · 24/05/2026 07:55

Holidays? Not worth the stress.

VeneziaJ · 24/05/2026 07:54

We damaged a car we hired from Enterprise last year (our own fault) the side trim came off they were fine as we too had purchased the protection cover and we were not asked to pay anything further.

OneFunBrickNewt · 24/05/2026 07:42

Glad you got the extra cover.
A good bit of advice on Martin Lewis' website is never to buy this directly from the car rental company- it's much cheaper to buy this insurance through another company, sometimes just a few pounds.
I always do this, and when my rented car in France got hit by a flock of birds that scratched the roof they paid up really quickly.

5128gap · 24/05/2026 07:39

He likes the idea of a family holiday. He doesn't like the reality. So he ends up being a mass of disappointment and irritation. The minor incidents give him an outlet.
Next time don't let him 'insist' on a family holiday. Tell him they are stressful and unpleasant for you because you're either dealing with his tantrums or on edge waiting for one, so its a waste of time and money. Tell him that's the last time you're doing it. (In time you could maybe experiment with a short break to check for change.)

rwalker · 24/05/2026 07:36

There’s clearly an issue around holidays
I doubt there’s are fix or more to the point could you be arsed
given everything is normally ok
suck it up and NEVER go on holiday with him again
I must admit I’m not a holiday person ( a concept hardly anyone can accept or understand) I feel there more like an endurance test than this magical experience

Crazydoglady1980 · 24/05/2026 07:22

You need to stop the family holidays , even if it means he stays at home. It’s not fair on your children, and do you want the same for your children’s partners and your grandchildren. As your children may end up being the same when they are adults

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 24/05/2026 07:22

Stoicandhappy · 23/05/2026 23:22

If he’s generally an arse on holiday just stop going with him. Take the DC and leave him at home.

This. And go with your friends without your dc too leave them for him to entertain or take away without a driver to abuse

OneNewLeader · 24/05/2026 06:54

It takes me a few days to get into the swing of a holiday with my family. I think it’s the winding down from work and the change in routine. I could be in paradise and still be annoyed.

I now recognise it and try and manage it. Plus I don’t go for less than 10 days and agree the first few days could happen without me doing too much. My DH and DC would go straight into activities and I’d mooch for a day or so.

I’d still be a bit of a joy suck, but I knew it was a ‘me’ problem.

PartyQuestion30th · 24/05/2026 06:51

(Not the point but you can buy car insurance separately that covers everything)

my DH is similar, but with him the trigger is while we are getting ready to go, for a while ever trip away would start with me in tears as he or I would have lost or forgotten something and instead of being reasonable it would turn 8nto him having a massive go. It took me a while to realise his dad did the same. It’s like he’s super anxious about going away (despite spending years travelling for work) and that outbursts is the outlet.

I’ve just factored it in Now, called him out on it and told him it’s not happening any more. He was oblivious. Holidays start more calmly …for me anyway.

but you nee£ to get your dg to realise his lack of management of his anxiety is affecting you and your kids.