Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Accidentally made dh think his dm had died but is his reaction too much?

712 replies

accidentallyUpsetHim · 23/05/2026 19:46

I really badly upset dh by accident yesterday and I feel awful but I think his reaction is really over the top? I have ADHD and I really often just blurt things out without even thinking he knows this and it’s how I’ve always been. I totally get that I should have stopped to think but my brain doesn’t work that way.

His mum has been really unwell in and out of hospital for months and currently in HDU very unwell. Her name is Judith.

I was on the phone to my sister yesterday and chatting and had a notification through about Judith chalmers dying. We used to watch the holiday programme as kids and I just blurted out to her ‘oh! Judith’s dead ! I’ve just seen on my phone ‘ to which dh jumped up and went white saying ‘what???’ And I said no no not your mum and apologised as he looked petrified and I felt awful. He went absolutely mad saying I don’t think before I speak and how he’s had enough of me doing things like this.?
He went out and hasn’t come back. He’s staying with his brother as he text me that he needs space and he’s still angry with me?

It was a complete mistake and I know emotions are running high and I feel terrible but I think he’s blown it all out of proportion or do I need to beg and grovel for forgiveness?

OP posts:
NotAnotherScarf · 24/05/2026 22:18

Imdunfer · 24/05/2026 22:11

Ok I shout out that you're mums name and that's she's died whilst looking at my phone, even leaving aside you were actually waiting for the news that your mum has died, you'd be upset..

Only I wouldn't. Because if someone said (there is no suggestion that the name was shouted) "Jennifer is dead", I wouldn't connect that name with my mother because I always call her "Mum" and everyone who talks about her to me calls her "mum", "your mum" or "our mum" and that's how it is in most families that I know.

And my brother in law called my wife's parents by their first name. He was a cock, but it's no unheard of. Plus if she's talking to her sister, the sister won't be calling Judith mum would she, she's nothing to do with her

Imdunfer · 24/05/2026 22:12

changeme4this · 24/05/2026 22:05

Were you reading your phone while talking to your sister ?

People do, you know 😉

Imdunfer · 24/05/2026 22:11

NotAnotherScarf · 24/05/2026 22:04

Ok I shout out that you're mums name and that's she's died whilst looking at my phone, even leaving aside you were actually waiting for the news that your mum has died, you'd be upset.

Noone in the history of the world has ever referred to Judith Chamers by her first name apart from her friends and family. She's not been current on TV for 20 years and I bet the op and her sister never, ever referred to her in 1990 as bloody Judith.

The op has been completely stupid and thoughtless, bugger blaming an illness. She's expecting mil to die and when a message with that name has come up she's jumped in and is trying to cover her stupidity

Clearly this isn't the first time something like this has happened and he's rightly had enough.

Ok I shout out that you're mums name and that's she's died whilst looking at my phone, even leaving aside you were actually waiting for the news that your mum has died, you'd be upset..

Only I wouldn't. Because if someone said (there is no suggestion that the name was shouted) "Jennifer is dead", I wouldn't connect that name with my mother because I always call her "Mum" and everyone who talks about her to me calls her "mum", "your mum" or "our mum" and that's how it is in most families that I know.

changeme4this · 24/05/2026 22:05

Were you reading your phone while talking to your sister ?

NotAnotherScarf · 24/05/2026 22:04

BeRarePlumCrab · 24/05/2026 18:07

Doesnt matter if he was in the same room or not, unless the phone was on loud speaker or it was somehow a 3 way conversation (which if it was, he woukd know they werent talking about his mother), then he was listening in and only getting a piece of the conversation. Hes overreacted. It could all have been straightened out over a few simple sentences and an apology.

Ok I shout out that you're mums name and that's she's died whilst looking at my phone, even leaving aside you were actually waiting for the news that your mum has died, you'd be upset.

Noone in the history of the world has ever referred to Judith Chamers by her first name apart from her friends and family. She's not been current on TV for 20 years and I bet the op and her sister never, ever referred to her in 1990 as bloody Judith.

The op has been completely stupid and thoughtless, bugger blaming an illness. She's expecting mil to die and when a message with that name has come up she's jumped in and is trying to cover her stupidity

Clearly this isn't the first time something like this has happened and he's rightly had enough.

Imdunfer · 24/05/2026 21:52

Imdunfer · 24/05/2026 21:51

Agree, I am nothing like the poster's partner, if anything I am an obsessive declutterer and obsessively tidy because for me everything has to be in its place or I can't find it when I want it.

I am a blurter of inappropriate comments and I do talk to the tv, but I'm also assured by my DH of almost 50 years that I'm very good fun to be around. It does help, I think, that he's ND as well.

ETA, this is all about being compatible. Lots of ND couples are not compatible, it's not unique to ND people with NT partners.

Imdunfer · 24/05/2026 21:51

Agree, I am nothing like the poster's partner, if anything I am an obsessive declutterer and obsessively tidy because for me everything has to be in its place or I can't find it when I want it.

I am a blurter of inappropriate comments and I do talk to the tv, but I'm also assured by my DH of almost 50 years that I'm very good fun to be around. It does help, I think, that he's ND as well.

kkloo · 24/05/2026 21:45

QuintadosMalvados · 24/05/2026 13:14

Imagine having your day ruined because a simple task was not completed by your spouse. A task a typical 10-year-old could do in minutes.

Imagine piles of empty bottles just strewn about the living room after you've cleaned it. In spite of there being a bin next to the bottles!
Imagine having to navigate your way through the hallway of your home because the junk they meant to take to the recycling centre is STILL there weeks later.
Imagine having to live in chaos because there's not one corner of your home they haven't managed to make a mess of.
Or if there is a room you have free of shit, you have to constantly defend it from encroachment of their stuff.

Imagine having a hole in your roof pissing water through the ceiling because in spite of you giving them half the cash and money is very much available to fix it and them saying they'd call the roofer but haven't so you get into a big argument because they get annoyed if you say you'll do it.

And then, after another day of this, you can't even watch your favourite TV show cause they talk all the way through it.
F*ing endlessly.

You can say it's nobody's fault and I'd agree. Nobody should have to tolerate this behaviour from another adult in a marriage, though.

They don't have to tolerate it, they can end the relationship if they can't deal with it, instead of playing the martyr.

SayWhatty · 24/05/2026 20:59

QuintadosMalvados · 24/05/2026 13:14

Imagine having your day ruined because a simple task was not completed by your spouse. A task a typical 10-year-old could do in minutes.

Imagine piles of empty bottles just strewn about the living room after you've cleaned it. In spite of there being a bin next to the bottles!
Imagine having to navigate your way through the hallway of your home because the junk they meant to take to the recycling centre is STILL there weeks later.
Imagine having to live in chaos because there's not one corner of your home they haven't managed to make a mess of.
Or if there is a room you have free of shit, you have to constantly defend it from encroachment of their stuff.

Imagine having a hole in your roof pissing water through the ceiling because in spite of you giving them half the cash and money is very much available to fix it and them saying they'd call the roofer but haven't so you get into a big argument because they get annoyed if you say you'll do it.

And then, after another day of this, you can't even watch your favourite TV show cause they talk all the way through it.
F*ing endlessly.

You can say it's nobody's fault and I'd agree. Nobody should have to tolerate this behaviour from another adult in a marriage, though.

This is ridiculous projection. I'm sorry if you have experienced that, but it doesn't mean that this is standard for someone with ADHD.

Gwenna · 24/05/2026 20:57

SayWhatty · 24/05/2026 20:50

What's your point, caller?
People with ADHD are awful to be around?
You are entitled to your view, probably best you don't have friendships or relationships with neurodivergent people.
The OP's husband can make his own decision on what works for him.
What isn't needed is people piling on to tell the OP blurting things out is inconsiderate, and that she should think before speaking. What's next? Make a list and you won't forget anything?

Great points made 👍

Gwenna · 24/05/2026 20:56

CaesarAugusta · 24/05/2026 09:47

You really don't know how you would feel in this situation. I simply don't believe it would be as easy as that to get over it, because it would feel like a massive shock which has physical effects in terms of heart rate etc, and can feel literally as if you've been hit. And in this situation, you wouldn't just say "phew" and forget about it, because you would know perfectly well that it's only a matter of time before the real thing happens.

I’ve been in that or very similar situations throughout my life many times, hence my viewpoint 🙂

SayWhatty · 24/05/2026 20:50

QuintadosMalvados · 24/05/2026 11:46

Nope.
I am always reminded of a TV show I watched- think it was House - and the advice to a warring couple was: sometimes two people just don't get on.

She can't change but he shouldn't be expected to tolerate it, either.

The enormous stress of living with her will probably send him to an early grave if he continues to do so.
This was probably an 'enough!' moment.
(Interesting how his relatives's just taken him in. They must be aware of how it is for him.)

Constant chaos and misunderstandings.

A day that goes as planned is a rare event.
Peace is a rarity. Simple pleasures impossible in their presence.
No just settling down to watch TV feet up in peace.

What's your point, caller?
People with ADHD are awful to be around?
You are entitled to your view, probably best you don't have friendships or relationships with neurodivergent people.
The OP's husband can make his own decision on what works for him.
What isn't needed is people piling on to tell the OP blurting things out is inconsiderate, and that she should think before speaking. What's next? Make a list and you won't forget anything?

cornflakecrunchie · 24/05/2026 20:26

I feel sorry for OP.
Obviously there was no malice intended!

Blades2 · 24/05/2026 20:06

Have you tried medicating your adhd? I know what you mean by blurting things out, try not to feel so bad, you were on the phone to your sister, not even talking to him.
When Ozzy Osbourne died I got a notification and blurted out to my partner “oh no Ozzys died” he knew exactly who I was talking about due to my love of metal music, so the nit pickers saying nobody would just call her Judith, uhm you’re wrong😊

OhThePotential · 24/05/2026 19:27

Wildefish · 24/05/2026 19:24

hmmm…a little strange you referred to her as Judith. Something doesn’t add up here tbh.

As I’ve already said, I don’t believe this happened. If it by tiny chance did, it was a deliberate attempt to create drama.

Wildefish · 24/05/2026 19:24

accidentallyUpsetHim · 23/05/2026 19:46

I really badly upset dh by accident yesterday and I feel awful but I think his reaction is really over the top? I have ADHD and I really often just blurt things out without even thinking he knows this and it’s how I’ve always been. I totally get that I should have stopped to think but my brain doesn’t work that way.

His mum has been really unwell in and out of hospital for months and currently in HDU very unwell. Her name is Judith.

I was on the phone to my sister yesterday and chatting and had a notification through about Judith chalmers dying. We used to watch the holiday programme as kids and I just blurted out to her ‘oh! Judith’s dead ! I’ve just seen on my phone ‘ to which dh jumped up and went white saying ‘what???’ And I said no no not your mum and apologised as he looked petrified and I felt awful. He went absolutely mad saying I don’t think before I speak and how he’s had enough of me doing things like this.?
He went out and hasn’t come back. He’s staying with his brother as he text me that he needs space and he’s still angry with me?

It was a complete mistake and I know emotions are running high and I feel terrible but I think he’s blown it all out of proportion or do I need to beg and grovel for forgiveness?

hmmm…a little strange you referred to her as Judith. Something doesn’t add up here tbh.

WhatNoRaisins · 24/05/2026 18:37

OP I think what this comes down to is that your OH is going through a very difficult time and likely feels very vulnerable. It doesn't sound like you meant any harm but even if he acknowledges that the consequences are still there. There can be the rational part that understands the reasons why another person can behave as they do but there is also the part that wants to avoid hurt whether it's intentional or not.

He isn't unreasonable to want some space and to stick to people who are less likely to to hurt him during this difficult time with his mum.

MrsPositivity1 · 24/05/2026 18:34

Am I the only one who really did laugh out loud. Sorry OP

SemiRetiredLoveGoddeess · 24/05/2026 18:29

If this wasn't so serious it sounds like something out of Withnail and l .

You know where they accidentally went on holiday by mistake.

Anyway it didn't seem to bother your MIL too much and she understands.
She seems like a good ,forgiving type.

Lucky for you.

loislovesstewie · 24/05/2026 18:28

Because he's extremely worried about his mum and wasn't thinking rationally. He heard his wife say 'Judith's dead' and thought she was talking about his mum. He had a moment of panic. In addition he's probably used to the OP just blurting things out without thinking.
And if she doesn't want others listening to her conversation then she could go into a different room. It's impossible to not listen if a person is talking in the same room.

independentfriend · 24/05/2026 18:23

He shouldn't have been listening to your conversation. And should know better than to react to something like that.

He's on an edge - of course it's obvious it wouldn't be his mum you'd be talking about because if it was her somebody from the hospital or another relative would have phoned him.

So it's about something bigger - sometimes thinking before you speak is important, but you could agree to take phone calls in separate spaces so he can't hear you so you have freedom to talk as you wish.

Imdunfer · 24/05/2026 18:13

PoppinjayPolly · 24/05/2026 18:03

No, they were in the same room.. op shrieks… “Judith’s died!”

To quote the OP, she said, in the middle on a conversation to her own sister

‘oh! Judith’s dead ! I’ve just seen on my phone ‘

Why on earth would her husband think that she had just seen on her phone that his mother had died? Is he even one of the small proportion of men who call their own mother, or discuss her with others, using her first name? If I said "Mary's dead, I've just seen it on my phone" to someone on my phone my DH would not associate that name with his mother, he called her Mum and everyone talking to him about her called her "your mum". That's normal I think.

TicklishMauveUser · 24/05/2026 18:10

If it makes you feel any better, when I was a teenager, my mum came into my room desperately upset, woke me up in tears to tell me Diana had died. She meant Princess Diana….. however my best friend was called Diana, so obviously I thought it was her. It was only until I asked how (and the crash details came out) that I connected the dots as I knew my bestie wasn’t in France. In the moments before the realisation I was very shocked and upset. Mum obviously omitted the “princess” part of her name. It’s easily done.

Try not to beat yourself up. Your husband will settle down and process his shock and rollercoaster of emotions that were triggered in that split second moment of misunderstanding, and hopefully you can both have a calm, kind chat and repair once the heat has died down xx

BeRarePlumCrab · 24/05/2026 18:07

PoppinjayPolly · 24/05/2026 18:03

No, they were in the same room.. op shrieks… “Judith’s died!”

Doesnt matter if he was in the same room or not, unless the phone was on loud speaker or it was somehow a 3 way conversation (which if it was, he woukd know they werent talking about his mother), then he was listening in and only getting a piece of the conversation. Hes overreacted. It could all have been straightened out over a few simple sentences and an apology.

Jorge14 · 24/05/2026 18:07

I can see why he was initially upset but you didn’t mean it, you corrected it immediately & he has massively over reacted to this in my opinion.