Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel like I cannot become a substitute daughter for my elderly uncle?

155 replies

Blaainey · 21/05/2026 17:35

My uncle has been on his own since my aunt died 8 years ago. He has cancer and I know life is very difficult for him emotionally, more than anything. He does manage day to day, but he is clearly lonely. He has two adult sons but they both live quite far away and don’t seem very involved.

One of the sons bought him a mobile phone and now I seem to have become permanent tech support, emotional support and daily company all rolled into one. From morning into late evening I get a constant stream of messages asking how features work, whether messages are spam, screenshots of random things, articles, photos and general chat. He is also always asking how I am and being very kind, so I feel awful even writing this.

What makes it harder is that he has said a few times that he always wanted a daughter. I know he means it affectionately, but I sometimes feel like I am slowly being pulled into that role emotionally. I do care about him very much, but I also have my own family, responsibilities and pressures.

He also lives hundreds of miles away, so it is not even as though I can pop in and see him regularly. The relationship exists almost entirely through constant messaging and calls throughout the day.

The truth is that other family members seem to keep their distance because he is very needy emotionally and can become upset if people do not respond quickly enough. One time he actually called my mum because I had not replied quickly to a completely non-urgent message.

I do try to encourage him to contact his sons more, but he says they are busy. I have even found local groups and befriending schemes for him but he is not interested in any of them. I texted his sons saying their dad really needs more contact and support, but neither replied.

The problem is that I feel emotionally worn down by the constant messages every single day. I have tried gently creating boundaries a few times and he backs off briefly, but within days it starts all over again.

I feel terribly guilty because he is elderly, widowed and ill, but at the same time I don’t think I can realistically fill the role of daughter, companion and support system indefinitely

OP posts:
QuickBrown · 21/05/2026 17:53

Be busy too. There's nothing to suggest he's been like a Dad to you, he wants the benefits of a father / daughter relationship without putting in any of the effort.

Batties · 21/05/2026 17:53

Did he used to tell you that he wished he had a daughter before he needed extra support?

CanaryLibra · 21/05/2026 17:48

You need set a time to reply to his messages or call him, say half a hour twice a week, and ignore everything until then.

You’ve said he phoned your mum when you didn’t reply to a message. Let him. He’s her brother/BIL so let her deal with him when you’re unavailable.

You really don’t know how much contact and support he’s getting from his sons and you talk about family “distancing themselves” when really it just sound to me like they have better boundaries than you.

7238SM · 21/05/2026 17:47

You sound lovely to have coped this long! Has he had an adult social services review? How is he coping with self care, cleaning, shopping, cooking etc? He 'might' qualify to have a carer/MacMillian in which would give him someone else to talk to.

I'd change the ringtone on our phone so his is different to everyone else
Make it clear that you have work/family/whatever and you can't be helping ALL day long
Don't answer or take longer and longer to or say you will give him a call at 9am on Saturday
Its sad, but I'd be stepping back for your on sanity and let the sons know more often about the constant calls/texts etc.

HiCandles · 21/05/2026 17:42

Presumably he feels it acceptable to put this on you because you are female and therefore 'should' in his mind be caring for him, unlike his sons.
Except you're not actually doing any physical caring, I suppose. What will happen when he needs carers organising, meal deliveries, conversations with social workers etc.. doesn't sound like the sons will be stepping up..
That much contact from anyone would be a lot, really. Given that this is all virtual and he doesn't actually need your physical care for his safety, I'd be tempted to hugely reduce my contact back. Wait a day before replying, be vague, don't have the answer, be useless basically.