Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel uncomfortable about my MIL's behaviour around food?

440 replies

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 13:06

Sorry, this ended up being quite a long post.

I don’t know what advice I am looking for and simply wanted to share this with other people to see if anybody else has ever experienced anything like this?

MIL, who is past retirement age, has a not so healthy relationship with weight and food. There are reasons I say this which I won’t go into, but let’s just say it is off topic for this thread.

I put on weight recently, but my BMI is in the green, right in the middle. This comes after years of being underweight, at times dangerously so, and struggling to put weight on, for reasons that are also off topic here.

MIL is now constantly asking me how the weight loss is going, measuring me up with her eyes, essentially fat-checking me… she does try to be discrete about this but I’ve seen it happen. She will ask whether I have managed to lose any weight since the last time she saw me. She then confirms “but the weight is going down right?”

She herself is not underweight for her age but is on the thin side.

In her fridge and cupboard, she keeps lots of out of date, expired food. Often mouldy. She will tell anybody who listens how she doesn’t gain weight and how proud she is of it, then going into details about how she manages to do that. For example, if she has eaten a lot one day she will try to not to eat very much for several days thereafter.

Unless she eats out, she’d does not eat “real” food, instead snacking on things like tomatoes or biscuits or nuts, or if she decides to have a meal, it will be something like canned soup. My understanding is she doesn’t really know how to cook, but that isn’t something you can judge her for because not everybody does.

She will often go out of her way to make sure her son (my husband) gets food when we are there, but will essentially do the opposite with me. This used to happen even when I was very thin. If we would go out for a meal she would order something “healthy” then try to eat my food and actually verbalise that she won’t take any from her son’s plate because he needs it. She would encourage her son to get the most expensive and substantial option on a menu, and although it has never explicitly been said I always feel that I am supposed to pick something cheap, sometimes based on suggestions she makes but mostly it’s based on experience from eating out with her and the sort of obvious conclusion you can draw from the behaviour when I do get something that isn’t the very cheapest option (she tries to eat my food). Of course it is possible this is all in my head but I am fairly sure it is not.

I feel like there’s an aspect to this which comes from a need to hoard food because food costs money. Or making sure you get your money’s worth (since she paid for the meal). So her son eating is getting your moneys worth, me eating is not. This behaviour extends to other situations but again it’s a bit off topic.

She does offer me what is in her cupboard and fridge but as I say it’s all expired and mouldy. In the same breath she will talk about how to ensure you don’t get hungry by snacking on small amounts of food like sweets and nuts.

On our most recent visit she made her son some food (tinned soup). She did not offer me the same. She then told me to join her while she ran some errands, in what felt like an attempt to distract me from eating. At this point it was late afternoon and I had not had anything to eat all day. She later offered me tomatoes and crackers.

I don’t think I will ever try to “set a boundary” because to some degree it is a lost cause and I don’t want to make her cross, I mostly try to eat before and after seeing her, but sometimes there isn’t time to do that.

OP posts:
Wauwinet · 19/05/2026 15:04

You need to stop going. If your pathetic husband is going to sit there and, as another poster aptly put it, stuff his face without ever considering you, then remove yourself from the situation.

Your MIL is batshit but it is his responsibility to deal with her and mitigate her lunacy so that it doesn’t impact you. Stop seeing her until he steps up and does that. Right now he’s taking the piss by turning a blind eye to it all and not confronting his mother. That’s what’s easy and comfortable for him even though it’s difficult and uncomfortable for you. You’re going to have to give him a kick up the arse to get him to stop being so selfish.

HazelMember · 19/05/2026 15:00

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 14:53

@HazelMember
"What does your husband do when she tries to eat your food?"

I think @LetsMakeThisMomentLast covered this a bit:

"I can’t believe your husband just gets stuck to his food without wondering whether you are being fed! Then again, he grew up with this woman"

@Feis123
"The most shocking thing of it all is that 'since she's paid for the meal'. You and your dh allow your MIL pay for the meal? Seriously? Why can't YOU and your dh pay for the meal and then order all you want and some more?"

This gets a bit complicated and will quickly take us off topic, but in short, the reason for going out for the meal is so that she can buy us a meal. I think she sees this both as her way of being motherly to her son - taking him out for a meal - and also a way of spending time with us in an organised manner so that "that's done".

@titchy

Do you stay with her? Why did you go all day without food? If you know what she’s like surely you take your own food? And order what the hell you want from a menu. Obvs pay for it, don’t expect her to. She is welcome to her issues but you don’t have to go along with them, so why do you?

We sometimes stay, but very rarely now. More so in the past. Made the food stuff even more difficult to deal with and plan.

There's a tendency to change plans a lot, often at a whim, and also not be totally upfront with what the plan is. So we went there to do [something] and planning for that meant that after that was done there would be free time for me afterwards to get food. But as I mentioned in my original post, once that was done suddenly I got dragged to something else which put a spanner in my lunch plan. I also want to make it clear I don't expect her to pay but it's sort of the expectation/rule here. It is a transactional dance that we all do which is quite frustrating. I think it's important that my husband spends time with his mum, and to some degree that we have times where she gets to spend time with "her son and his wife" as a unit. The alternative here is I become someone who appears to be avoiding her and then it's easy to end up being scapegoated and I don't really fancy being the awful daughter in law who never attends events. She can also be quite amusing to be around so it's not all bad. And of course my husband loves his mum and I want to help make his relationship with her easier.

So it is quite complicated but theres an unwritten rule that she takes us out for a meal and we take that meal from her and then we express thankfulness. Sounds so odd as I type this out but it is what it is.

Edited

So because he grew up with this woman it means he will eat himself while his wife has nothing? You make excuses for him. Yes MIL is not great but clearly she has an eating disorder. Does your husband have a disorder where he just stuffs his face while you have nothing?

AnnaMagnani · 19/05/2026 15:00

For visiting MIL we have rules of:
Always eat out, never let her cater
Pick what you like and ignore her salads are for ladies vibes
It's OK for me to wander upstairs so they can have mum son time and I can eat food stashed in my handbag

Dillydollydingdong · 19/05/2026 14:56

I'd take a pack of sandwiches withe when visiting her, and if you're eating out, just smack her hand when she tries to pinch your food (obviously smile, make a bit of a joke about it). Or tell your DH to take food off his plate and put it on yours if you've only been given a small portion

Itsseweasy · 19/05/2026 14:56

GreenCandleWax · 19/05/2026 13:33

I voted YABU but that is because you have failed to set a boundary between yourself and her crazy and unhealthy behaviour towards you. Be assertive. If she tries to talk about you and food, tell her you don't want to discuss it. Repeat each time. If she tries to take food from your plate, absolutely do not allow it. You could sit as far away as possible from her at a table if that helps. Be firm - it is completely unacceptable to take your food, or comment on your body. As for you having to order cheap dishes in a restaurant - do the opposite, and have something expensive that you'd really like.
Firm upn your resolution not to be treated like this.

Same. I also voted YABU because neither you or your husband has a) pointed out how incredibly rude she is being and had an actual conversation with her about it, or b) done anything to set any boundaries.
I realise this is an advice forum and the whole point of it is to ask for help, but did neither of the above options occur to either of you?
Your husband sounds like an absolute wet lettuce and you’re not far off to go along with it all.
I’d be asking her why she’s doing what she’s doing (using the trusty Mumsnet “did you mean to be so rude”) and if nothing changes I’d be setting firm boundaries (ie your husband can visit by himself).
Also - I simply can not believe you are both sitting there with mouldy/spoiled food and not pointing it out!
Why are you both so scared of her???!
It sounds like she has some serious mental health issues so I wouldn’t expect her to change at all, it will be up to you and your husband to change how you are reacting to this madness.

HelenHywater · 19/05/2026 14:54

My ex MIL was the same - she used to pile my H's plate up and leave mine empty. She'd give my H and his brothers food off her plate. She was obsessed with my weight. (and I think her own, although her sons just used to think she had a bird like appetite I think). Like your husband my exH just used to sit there and accept the extra food and never challenge her (and in fact he and his brothers used to moan about the number of potatoes etc they had).

It was a nightmare.

I don't have to see her now but my children do. I just talk to them about how ridiculous she is so hopefully they don't think she's normal.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 14:53

HazelMember · 19/05/2026 14:35

What does your husband do when she tries to eat your food?

@HazelMember
"What does your husband do when she tries to eat your food?"

I think @LetsMakeThisMomentLast covered this a bit:

"I can’t believe your husband just gets stuck to his food without wondering whether you are being fed! Then again, he grew up with this woman"

@Feis123
"The most shocking thing of it all is that 'since she's paid for the meal'. You and your dh allow your MIL pay for the meal? Seriously? Why can't YOU and your dh pay for the meal and then order all you want and some more?"

This gets a bit complicated and will quickly take us off topic, but in short, the reason for going out for the meal is so that she can buy us a meal. I think she sees this both as her way of being motherly to her son - taking him out for a meal - and also a way of spending time with us in an organised manner so that "that's done".

@titchy

Do you stay with her? Why did you go all day without food? If you know what she’s like surely you take your own food? And order what the hell you want from a menu. Obvs pay for it, don’t expect her to. She is welcome to her issues but you don’t have to go along with them, so why do you?

We sometimes stay, but very rarely now. More so in the past. Made the food stuff even more difficult to deal with and plan.

There's a tendency to change plans a lot, often at a whim, and also not be totally upfront with what the plan is. So we went there to do [something] and planning for that meant that after that was done there would be free time for me afterwards to get food. But as I mentioned in my original post, once that was done suddenly I got dragged to something else which put a spanner in my lunch plan. I also want to make it clear I don't expect her to pay but it's sort of the expectation/rule here. It is a transactional dance that we all do which is quite frustrating. I think it's important that my husband spends time with his mum, and to some degree that we have times where she gets to spend time with "her son and his wife" as a unit. The alternative here is I become someone who appears to be avoiding her and then it's easy to end up being scapegoated and I don't really fancy being the awful daughter in law who never attends events. She can also be quite amusing to be around so it's not all bad. And of course my husband loves his mum and I want to help make his relationship with her easier.

So it is quite complicated but theres an unwritten rule that she takes us out for a meal and we take that meal from her and then we express thankfulness. Sounds so odd as I type this out but it is what it is.

OP posts:
Crunchymum · 19/05/2026 14:51

On our most recent visit she made her son some food (tinned soup). She did not offer me the same. She then told me to join her while she ran some errands, in what felt like an attempt to distract me from eating. At this point it was late afternoon and I had not had anything to eat all day

Well for a start you make sure you take your own food if you know she isn't going to feed you. Going hungry all day seems unnecessarily martyr-ish given you know how she behaves.

As for the restaurant behaviour, order what you want (offer to pay - that might shame her) or better still leave your DH to go with his mum.

Any time she makes a comment on your weight or feed shut it down. "I don't want to talk about weight / food" should suffice.

Next time she takes your food (or tries to) tell her no - like a bloody toddler.

I can't believe the amount of nonsense you have already put up with, if kids are planned in the future then you either sort this out now with clear, firm and unwavering boundaries or you go very low contact to ensure she doesn't pull this shit with any DC you have.

Your DH also needs to get his act together and you need to present united boundaries.

Elsvieta · 19/05/2026 14:45

She asks you how the weight loss is going... when you've never said you're trying to lose weight? Bloody hell. I'd just say "Huh? I'm not trying to lose weight". Repeat as necessary, perhaps peering at her as if in concern that she's getting forgetful and mixing you up with someone else, and don't answer any other weight questions. Ick.

AnnaMagnani · 19/05/2026 14:43

My DM is very elderly now but loves nothing better than to talk about how much she wants to lose weight and how revolting her friends are for eating cake, ever. Despite knowing i have zero interest in the subject.

My MIL does the same living on snacks, saving half a piece of carrot thing as OP's MIL. She also does the male and female portion thing.

DH notices some but not all of her behaviour. He has noticed she starts every restaurant meal with a long spiel about whether she can eat that much. He hadn't noticed she will always have the chicken or fish as they are suitable lady meals while encouraging him to have steak.

If it's normal to you it is harder to notice. But someone really did a number on generations of women and their relationship with food.

VanquishedColston · 19/05/2026 14:42

I can't believe your husband sits there eating food she's made him knowing that she's offered you nothing?!! That's bizarre behaviour from him, how rude.

I think if you're not going to call it out in some way then all you can do is always make sure you've eaten before you see her and don't see her over mealtimes.

Tabarnak · 19/05/2026 14:42

MIL is now constantly asking me how the weight loss is going, measuring me up with her eyes, essentially fat-checking me… she does try to be discrete about this but I’ve seen it happen. She will ask whether I have managed to lose any weight since the last time she saw me. She then confirms “but the weight is going down right?”

She has a very unhealthy relationship with food, you and DH are supporting it, and she is extending it to you by proxy by restricting what you eat.

She has no right to carry on like this and I really hope you do not have Dc listening to it.

If she starts just say "I'm a healthy weight and that's all that matters and all I have to say on the subject" and change the subject
"We've had that conversation - nothing more to say"
"Oohh, missus, how very personal!" and change the subject
"Personally I don't find it useful to discuss weight - mine or anyone elses"

And where the hell is your DH when she is feeding him and not you? I would be mortified and horrified if my Mum treated my DH like that and would either say "Here - share mine if there isn't another tin" or "DW needs lunch too, Mum, she doesn't live on scotch mist!"

Out for dinner? ick what you like, say "this sounds delicious and I'm looking forward to it all to myself" Or have DH say "Are you having a steak? - its your favourite"

I know you said you don't want to set boundaries but bloody hell, you are going hungry, being subjected to her own food issues, it must be seriously affecting your relationship with her. Just be you, do your thing and don't put up with being pigeonholed as her unhealthy eating wing woman.

Sassylovesbooks · 19/05/2026 14:40

Your husband needs to step up here. Instead of sitting there stuffing his face, he should be telling his Mum to stop. You should be ordering what you want off a menu when you're out...if it's too much for your MIL, then pay for your own meal!! When you're at her home, your husband should be the one to tell his Mum that she needs to stop, leave you alone and let you eat what you want.

Is your MIL the sort who feels a woman should be thin as possible 'for her husband'???? It's a very old fashioned view point, but a possible one.

Your MIL has a distorted view of food and her relationship with it is poor. However, she shouldn't be pushing her views onto you.

HazelMember · 19/05/2026 14:38

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 13:06

Sorry, this ended up being quite a long post.

I don’t know what advice I am looking for and simply wanted to share this with other people to see if anybody else has ever experienced anything like this?

MIL, who is past retirement age, has a not so healthy relationship with weight and food. There are reasons I say this which I won’t go into, but let’s just say it is off topic for this thread.

I put on weight recently, but my BMI is in the green, right in the middle. This comes after years of being underweight, at times dangerously so, and struggling to put weight on, for reasons that are also off topic here.

MIL is now constantly asking me how the weight loss is going, measuring me up with her eyes, essentially fat-checking me… she does try to be discrete about this but I’ve seen it happen. She will ask whether I have managed to lose any weight since the last time she saw me. She then confirms “but the weight is going down right?”

She herself is not underweight for her age but is on the thin side.

In her fridge and cupboard, she keeps lots of out of date, expired food. Often mouldy. She will tell anybody who listens how she doesn’t gain weight and how proud she is of it, then going into details about how she manages to do that. For example, if she has eaten a lot one day she will try to not to eat very much for several days thereafter.

Unless she eats out, she’d does not eat “real” food, instead snacking on things like tomatoes or biscuits or nuts, or if she decides to have a meal, it will be something like canned soup. My understanding is she doesn’t really know how to cook, but that isn’t something you can judge her for because not everybody does.

She will often go out of her way to make sure her son (my husband) gets food when we are there, but will essentially do the opposite with me. This used to happen even when I was very thin. If we would go out for a meal she would order something “healthy” then try to eat my food and actually verbalise that she won’t take any from her son’s plate because he needs it. She would encourage her son to get the most expensive and substantial option on a menu, and although it has never explicitly been said I always feel that I am supposed to pick something cheap, sometimes based on suggestions she makes but mostly it’s based on experience from eating out with her and the sort of obvious conclusion you can draw from the behaviour when I do get something that isn’t the very cheapest option (she tries to eat my food). Of course it is possible this is all in my head but I am fairly sure it is not.

I feel like there’s an aspect to this which comes from a need to hoard food because food costs money. Or making sure you get your money’s worth (since she paid for the meal). So her son eating is getting your moneys worth, me eating is not. This behaviour extends to other situations but again it’s a bit off topic.

She does offer me what is in her cupboard and fridge but as I say it’s all expired and mouldy. In the same breath she will talk about how to ensure you don’t get hungry by snacking on small amounts of food like sweets and nuts.

On our most recent visit she made her son some food (tinned soup). She did not offer me the same. She then told me to join her while she ran some errands, in what felt like an attempt to distract me from eating. At this point it was late afternoon and I had not had anything to eat all day. She later offered me tomatoes and crackers.

I don’t think I will ever try to “set a boundary” because to some degree it is a lost cause and I don’t want to make her cross, I mostly try to eat before and after seeing her, but sometimes there isn’t time to do that.

On our most recent visit she made her son some food (tinned soup). She did not offer me the same. She then told me to join her while she ran some errands, in what felt like an attempt to distract me from eating. At this point it was late afternoon and I had not had anything to eat all day. She later offered me tomatoes and crackers.

Your DH just sat and ate while all this happened? Does not care about you at all? Yes MIL's behaviour is appalling but I would be more disappointed in my DH if he behaved like this.

gamerchick · 19/05/2026 14:38

You have a weird husband problem OP and your pandering to her hasn't helped either.

Stop eating out with her or pay. Take a packed lunch with you when you go to visit and wave it at your husband when he's eating something gross and not sticking up for you.

Or stop seeing her completely. Have the row.

HazelMember · 19/05/2026 14:35

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 13:06

Sorry, this ended up being quite a long post.

I don’t know what advice I am looking for and simply wanted to share this with other people to see if anybody else has ever experienced anything like this?

MIL, who is past retirement age, has a not so healthy relationship with weight and food. There are reasons I say this which I won’t go into, but let’s just say it is off topic for this thread.

I put on weight recently, but my BMI is in the green, right in the middle. This comes after years of being underweight, at times dangerously so, and struggling to put weight on, for reasons that are also off topic here.

MIL is now constantly asking me how the weight loss is going, measuring me up with her eyes, essentially fat-checking me… she does try to be discrete about this but I’ve seen it happen. She will ask whether I have managed to lose any weight since the last time she saw me. She then confirms “but the weight is going down right?”

She herself is not underweight for her age but is on the thin side.

In her fridge and cupboard, she keeps lots of out of date, expired food. Often mouldy. She will tell anybody who listens how she doesn’t gain weight and how proud she is of it, then going into details about how she manages to do that. For example, if she has eaten a lot one day she will try to not to eat very much for several days thereafter.

Unless she eats out, she’d does not eat “real” food, instead snacking on things like tomatoes or biscuits or nuts, or if she decides to have a meal, it will be something like canned soup. My understanding is she doesn’t really know how to cook, but that isn’t something you can judge her for because not everybody does.

She will often go out of her way to make sure her son (my husband) gets food when we are there, but will essentially do the opposite with me. This used to happen even when I was very thin. If we would go out for a meal she would order something “healthy” then try to eat my food and actually verbalise that she won’t take any from her son’s plate because he needs it. She would encourage her son to get the most expensive and substantial option on a menu, and although it has never explicitly been said I always feel that I am supposed to pick something cheap, sometimes based on suggestions she makes but mostly it’s based on experience from eating out with her and the sort of obvious conclusion you can draw from the behaviour when I do get something that isn’t the very cheapest option (she tries to eat my food). Of course it is possible this is all in my head but I am fairly sure it is not.

I feel like there’s an aspect to this which comes from a need to hoard food because food costs money. Or making sure you get your money’s worth (since she paid for the meal). So her son eating is getting your moneys worth, me eating is not. This behaviour extends to other situations but again it’s a bit off topic.

She does offer me what is in her cupboard and fridge but as I say it’s all expired and mouldy. In the same breath she will talk about how to ensure you don’t get hungry by snacking on small amounts of food like sweets and nuts.

On our most recent visit she made her son some food (tinned soup). She did not offer me the same. She then told me to join her while she ran some errands, in what felt like an attempt to distract me from eating. At this point it was late afternoon and I had not had anything to eat all day. She later offered me tomatoes and crackers.

I don’t think I will ever try to “set a boundary” because to some degree it is a lost cause and I don’t want to make her cross, I mostly try to eat before and after seeing her, but sometimes there isn’t time to do that.

What does your husband do when she tries to eat your food?

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 14:34

@SnappyQuoter "The only reason this woman is in her life is because she married her husband"

I have to remind myself of this all the time. Amusingly, I think she has to do the same: remind herself why I am in her life. And who knows, maybe that is part of what drives some of these behaviours, maybe it is a coping mechanism for wishing her son had found someone better or more up to her standards, even though I do agree, the behaviours appear very ingrained.

@TheSandgroper
"Wonder about how she was brought up by her parents (who would have been Depression/war children). Generational trauma is a thing and can manifest itself in funny ways."

This is also something that I reflect on and which helps me be less judgemental. On the other hand, and this makes all this even more strange to me on a personal level, my parents are the opposite and will offer you more food than you could possibly want or need. Certainly would never dream of withholding food.

OP posts:
Yellow2024 · 19/05/2026 14:33

My MIL is similar so you have my sympathy. I have tried over the years to stop discussing food/weight around me or my children. However the difference is my husband will also tell her to stop.

It has come to a head this week as my girls have now said they really hate ot when nanny comments on their weight or food consumption.
She will also add an unnecessary comments about people's weight while chatting totally out of context. My husband rang her this week and told her to stop completely, she has denied ever commenting on people's weight. If im in a bad space I avoid seeing her. I will be seeing her next week and will just say enough is enough and give her examples so she can not deny it. Im not sure if she is totally unaware.
I think my MILs comments come from jealousy not that she isn't slim herself but she hasn't really lived much of a life so the comments are always about family members who have had exciting news or going on lovely holidays ect she will always get in a jab about their weight. It's incredibly frustrating. You have my sympathy, its not easy to navigate.

Tulipsriver · 19/05/2026 14:31

She sounds crazy but why on earth aren't you more angry with your husband?

You visit and he happily sits and eats knowing you haven't been offered anything? That's absolutely inexcusable.

hihelenhi · 19/05/2026 14:30

JengaCupboard · 19/05/2026 14:07

My ExMIL was very similar, just obsessed with weight and 'fatness' and the amount of food that people ate. She would very openly make comments about not being able to believe how much food we ate, giving instructions for portions on stuff like breakfast cereal etc.

Once we were hiring sports equipment that they had sorted in advance of our arrival, and said something to me along the lines of 'I gave your weight at 60kg but you'll just have to tell them it's more when we go in to collect'.

She wasn't a bad person, and maintained being very fit for her age, but living in a hot country she resembled a skinny, well worn leather sofa. She is still my inspiration for wearing sunscreen regularly despite not seeing her for over a decade.

Needless to say I never took any notice :)

My 79 year old mother does as well, as does my best friend's mother. She's chilled out a bit now (had a bit of a scare when she started losing even more weight after my dad died so now can't stuff the pies in fast enough, but my god. When she was younger, for instance, she was almost proud of the fact she once fainted at the station in front of a crowd of people bc she was so thin and hadn't eaten.)

Our conclusion is that a LOT of 60s generation women have that mindset around food.I don't think it's from their wartime parents; I think it was the 60s 'skinny' ethos. I've honestly never known so many women comment on other's weight and obsess about food and portion sizes so judgementally in one generation, and that includes the health & 'clean eating' freaks in ours and younger.

But yes, OP, it is of course a sign your MIL has some kind of eating disorder, but mostly it's extremely rude and controlling and you & your DH are going to have to stand up to her and set boundaries. It's an unhealthy dynamic whichever way you look at it and what you eat and your weight is none of her damn business. She needs to know that you won't put up with it.

MyThreeWords · 19/05/2026 14:25

It sounds so extreme that I would try not to feel angry about it -- she clearly has some sort of major issue. I think your DH is at fault for lacking curiosity about it and failing to make sure that your need to eat a decent meal is met when his is (and for failing to show concern for his mum).

I'd be tempted to rehearse some frank but not hostile phrases to respond with when she badgers you with her concerns about weight, or when you need a decent option when eating out.

Timeforaglassofwine · 19/05/2026 14:22

Its toxic and unhealthy. My dd actually did a paper on this when she studied psychology, and it's interesting. So in brief, during and just after WW2, women were encouraged to eat less to give their men more, it was drilled into them that carrying weight meant they were morally bankrupt and greedy, taking food away from those who most needed it, ie the men. The men were given the larger portions and better cuts, whilst the women and girls had what was left. My grandma was a child during ww2 and very much carries these ideals, my grandparents, both sets, would openly laugh at people, including 14yo me, who carried even healthy weight. Both my mum and mil are boomers, raised essentially by women who were brainwashed. They both talk about foods in terms of how naughty they are, and being good by not having treats. I even heard talk like that at Slimming World meetings, patronising little stories about "Ivy Beengood".
You have to shut it down. I find unsolicited questions and comments about my weight rude and offensive, and I don't mind shutting them down as such.

Gustavo1 · 19/05/2026 14:19

You’re putting up with way too much here.
Her attitude and behaviour is wrong but I think you already know that.
If you can avoid her or at least avoid eating with her, do that. Never leave her alone with any of your children either. Especially if they are girls. Talk like that is very dangerous for children in their formative years.
If you cannot avoid her and she asks about your weight, size or diet, say “my body isn’t up for discussion” then change the subject or walk away.
Take food of order food. Pay for your own meals if you are out and or just order whatever you want. Ignore the looks and comments. She is in the wrong. Not you. If she asks to have some of your food, tell her you’re really enjoying it so will order her a portion if she’s hungry. Immediately look around to wait staff or get up to the bar, she’ll soon back down.

Sadly, this is one of those situation where politeness and niceties won’t win. Be firm. Tell your DH that it upsets you and that he is to speak up as well. He isn’t to eat if you aren’t eating. If he is fed and you aren’t, he is to ask why and share his meal. He needs to be behind you in this or he’ll end up visiting alone.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 14:19

Wow. First, thank you all for your thoughts and responses. I will try to get back to as many as possible by answering the replies with questions in them first. If two replies are similar I will answer the one that has more points/questions in it, otherwise I'll end up clogging up the thread with my answers 😬

OP posts:
AWeeCupOfTeaAndAnIndividualFruitTrifle · 19/05/2026 14:15

Your husband is a disgrace to take what she gives him (the nice stuff at the restaurant, at least) and not ask her what you're going to have, or even treat it like he assumes it's to share between you and gives you half.

Every time she mentions your weight and hounds you about losing it, as though it's taken as a given and well understood by all that you do need to lose it (even though you obviously don't), I'd just ask her how she is doing with her own situation - has she had any chance to clear out the mouldy old food and get some fresh/in date stuff in, so that she can start preparing proper healthy meals for herself and not have to keep relying on snacks?

I'm not suggesting you argue or try to shame her in any way for her disorder - just ask matter-of-factly and calmly out of genuine concern, opening up the conversation that SHE chose to start (as always). At the moment, she is quite persistently challenging you about an imagined 'problem' that you don't have, whilst you're deliberately avoiding responding and raising the problem that she does have with her! She knows she has a problem, so why let her keep deflecting it on to you?

Either she shuts up about it when she realises that she doesn't get to take the imagined upper hand; or even better, she acknowledges that she has a problem and seeks help for it.