Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel uncomfortable about my MIL's behaviour around food?

440 replies

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 13:06

Sorry, this ended up being quite a long post.

I don’t know what advice I am looking for and simply wanted to share this with other people to see if anybody else has ever experienced anything like this?

MIL, who is past retirement age, has a not so healthy relationship with weight and food. There are reasons I say this which I won’t go into, but let’s just say it is off topic for this thread.

I put on weight recently, but my BMI is in the green, right in the middle. This comes after years of being underweight, at times dangerously so, and struggling to put weight on, for reasons that are also off topic here.

MIL is now constantly asking me how the weight loss is going, measuring me up with her eyes, essentially fat-checking me… she does try to be discrete about this but I’ve seen it happen. She will ask whether I have managed to lose any weight since the last time she saw me. She then confirms “but the weight is going down right?”

She herself is not underweight for her age but is on the thin side.

In her fridge and cupboard, she keeps lots of out of date, expired food. Often mouldy. She will tell anybody who listens how she doesn’t gain weight and how proud she is of it, then going into details about how she manages to do that. For example, if she has eaten a lot one day she will try to not to eat very much for several days thereafter.

Unless she eats out, she’d does not eat “real” food, instead snacking on things like tomatoes or biscuits or nuts, or if she decides to have a meal, it will be something like canned soup. My understanding is she doesn’t really know how to cook, but that isn’t something you can judge her for because not everybody does.

She will often go out of her way to make sure her son (my husband) gets food when we are there, but will essentially do the opposite with me. This used to happen even when I was very thin. If we would go out for a meal she would order something “healthy” then try to eat my food and actually verbalise that she won’t take any from her son’s plate because he needs it. She would encourage her son to get the most expensive and substantial option on a menu, and although it has never explicitly been said I always feel that I am supposed to pick something cheap, sometimes based on suggestions she makes but mostly it’s based on experience from eating out with her and the sort of obvious conclusion you can draw from the behaviour when I do get something that isn’t the very cheapest option (she tries to eat my food). Of course it is possible this is all in my head but I am fairly sure it is not.

I feel like there’s an aspect to this which comes from a need to hoard food because food costs money. Or making sure you get your money’s worth (since she paid for the meal). So her son eating is getting your moneys worth, me eating is not. This behaviour extends to other situations but again it’s a bit off topic.

She does offer me what is in her cupboard and fridge but as I say it’s all expired and mouldy. In the same breath she will talk about how to ensure you don’t get hungry by snacking on small amounts of food like sweets and nuts.

On our most recent visit she made her son some food (tinned soup). She did not offer me the same. She then told me to join her while she ran some errands, in what felt like an attempt to distract me from eating. At this point it was late afternoon and I had not had anything to eat all day. She later offered me tomatoes and crackers.

I don’t think I will ever try to “set a boundary” because to some degree it is a lost cause and I don’t want to make her cross, I mostly try to eat before and after seeing her, but sometimes there isn’t time to do that.

OP posts:
illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:49

Elsvieta · 19/05/2026 14:45

She asks you how the weight loss is going... when you've never said you're trying to lose weight? Bloody hell. I'd just say "Huh? I'm not trying to lose weight". Repeat as necessary, perhaps peering at her as if in concern that she's getting forgetful and mixing you up with someone else, and don't answer any other weight questions. Ick.

I have to clarify, for full transparency, that I did mention to her once, during a meal, about a year ago, that I was a bit frustrated that none of my clothes fit because I had put on a bit more weight than I wanted to.

Which perhaps is my fault. I think it was a defensive move from me to avoid a situation where she looks at me and says I've got a bit fat. I thought best to tell her myself!

OP posts:
pizzaHeart · 19/05/2026 15:48

Sorry if I missed this but do you have / plan to have children?

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 19/05/2026 15:48

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:21

The thing about bringing my/our own food is that it also is a problem because it means money was wasted on buying food when she has "perfectly good food" in her house.

One time my husband and I nipped out to eat our after a long day, and when we returned she made a point to announce to everybody else in the family that [our names] just went to [fast food chain] even though I have perfectly good [vaguely similar cupboard food] in my cupboard!!!

and then after telling everybody she went to retrieve this item out of the cupboard and waved it around for us to see. And yes, I say item because she had just one portion of this, so it would have been for us to share, or maybe for me to have a few forkfuls and leave the rest to my husband... 😂

OP... so what if they make comments about you eating at a food chain?
That's actually more embarrassing for MIL that you had to do that, rather than for you... and it's presented as if its an insult to her.... but normal people wouldn't even stop to think about it.. Its hardly the crime of the century. Laugh at her ridiculousness.

I can sense its hurtful to you but try to stop letting it get to you and see it for the nonsense that it is. She says it in front of you to the rest of the family... are they agreeing with her? or just politely saying nothing. Does anyone else really care about this issue. The silence might feel like disapproval but its probably because they don't know what to say - Its hardly rational conversation.

Surely they have all noticed this is bonkers themselves and perhaps have to undergo the same the same behaviour? Even if it feels like they agree with her... so bloody what? Who cares what any of them think. You are adults and can eat what you like, when you like and you don't need any of their permission for anything.

I suspect it hurts because its not about you eating out, but just another pathetic feeble attempt at criticising you. Also...what is DH doing whilst all this is going on. Ask him to speak up and back you up. He was at the fast chain too after all.

Teenagers are great at dealing with stuff like this. Just keep saying a mental or even an out loud "So what?" and a shrug to all of it. She will quickly run out of steam if you answered "So?" to every statement of this nature. Roll your eyes and sigh heavily like a fed up teen. That's all these comments deserve. I mean the fact she had to go to her cupboard to wave around a packet of what ever it was to prove your sin of extravagance to them.... is just laughable. You should just laugh out loud at this because its such utter nonsense.

Our relative is getting on now and so the strange behaviour is more pronounced but at the same time, because they are getting on in age, it has lost a lot of its effect.. as they don't have the energy to be "in charge" anymore... but that is another story.

Isitme2026 · 19/05/2026 15:48

I am a polite daughter in law, and turn a blind eye to a few things, but I could not tolerate this more than a couple of times. I'd get too hangry for a start.

But even the health tips from people who obviously have distorted eating... also drives me nuts.

I'm not sure what you're looking for at this stage OP? Is it validation rather than ways to deal with it?

Feis123 · 19/05/2026 15:48

Dillydollydingdong · 19/05/2026 14:56

I'd take a pack of sandwiches withe when visiting her, and if you're eating out, just smack her hand when she tries to pinch your food (obviously smile, make a bit of a joke about it). Or tell your DH to take food off his plate and put it on yours if you've only been given a small portion

You don't have to make a joke about it - be firm - I have a few friends who think it is OK to say 'I am just going to take this bit' and then they proceed to take the bit they want. I say loudly, to embarrass them - please do not do that, I am awfully squeamish, we don't share toothbrushes, do we? why do you think it is OK for your fork to go into my food?' I am glad to say I have cured some of them of their ghastly habits. Same goes for cf-ers, who go 'you are not going to finish it, are you, and proceeding to fork the food of my plate' - the same spiel applies about not sharing toothbrushes and me being squeamish. Don't be apologetic, just make them embarrassed.

Sunisgettinganewhaton · 19/05/2026 15:46

My ex mil was similar. The contest of Who Eats The Least was a weekly event.. I was vegetarian which absolutely fumed her to the core.. I once asked fil if he could use a clean pan for my fried egg and not where he had fried bacon and sausage and he actually threw a pan at me.
Mil was enraged once when weaning ds refused a bowl of cold mash she had saved from Sunday lunch. She took his toys away and told him he could sit on her knee with a cup coaster to play with..

NamelessNancy · 19/05/2026 15:45

When DH and I were first together (decades ago now) MIL used to serve penis portions. He'd get a plate plied high with the best bits of the roast and lots of everything whilst I got some scrappy bits in the middle of a nearly empty plate. Every single time, without fail, we'd share and equalise the portions there and then. She got the idea eventually. There's no way my DH would have just tucked into his big-strong-man portion and left me with nothing. That's where your problem really lies.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:41

Esmeraldathe3rd · 19/05/2026 14:00

Your husband just sits there eating while his mother either takes food off your plate or refuses to feed you altogether?
Er yeah... There's your problem.

There are a couple of comments about this. First of all, sometimes he does seem a bit clueless. I think he reverts to a sort of child state around her, which a lot of people do when they are with their parents, me included.

We have been together for quite a long time. I've tried to talk to him about setting boundaries with his mother. I don't think he knows how to do that - with her or with anyone else. It also makes him feel stuck in the middle, which he expresses to me. So whether I have to appease her quirks or tell him to set boundaries, and then try to explain how boundaries are set or what a boundary even is, it's still me doing the leg (and brain) work.

It comes down to: how do you teach a grown man to set boundaries, with his mother no less, without creating friction in their relationship?

OP posts:
WhatterySquash · 19/05/2026 15:37

OP I have a mum who can be very difficult in lots of ways including being rude, hurtful and controlling. I was always scared to upset her by pulling her up on it as she would cry, accuse me of being oversensitive or mean, get really childish etc. Until one day I realised she doesn't give a shit about upsetting me, so why am I so accommodating?

I started just being straightforward and assertive and calmly saying how I felt. If she accused me of things I didn't deny it. In your case this might look like,

"MIL when you try to control what I eat or make me feel I should eat less, I find it hurtful and annoying"

Her - blah blah don't be mean to me or whatever or why are you so oversensitive

"I'm sorry you don't like it, but I don't want to discuss food with you. And if I'm not offered a reasonable amount of food I will just bring / order and pay for my own."
"I may be sensitive about it, maybe that's because it's quite hurtful."
"This is how I feel and what I'm going to do"

Her - blah blah you can't do that this is my treat / my house whatever

"Yes I can. It's important to me to eat normally and healthily."

And if she keeps trying it on:

"MIL as I've said I'm not willing to discuss food or weight with you."

And repeat like a stuck record/get up and leave as needed. It has really worked on my mum, she reins it right in because she hates being pulled up on it and presented with the bald fact that it's an unpleasant way to treat someone and they don't like it.

If your H objects ask him why he's OK with her treating you badly, and point out that if he is OK with it, you have to deal with it on your own.

breastcancerpanic · 19/05/2026 15:36

You describe behaviour that is a bit bonkers, and so I think you need to start responding to it with that in mind. When you say things like 'well, I tried doing [sensible obvious thing like bringing food] - but then she did [unreasonable response]', it sounds like you're in an impossible situation. But I think that's because if you keep trying to respond to her with full politeness and respect for her viewpoint then you are in an impossible situation, and that's driving you to be unable to eat in front of her etc. You're just going to have to crash your way,through her disapproval, being a bit impolite if need be - because it really doesn't matter if she disapproves - because she's a bit bonkers.
I've been on a related journey with my dad. When I describe what he has said and done, everyone just agrees that he's impossible. I keep trying to work around things and keep him happy, but my brother just crashes through and sorts things out the way he thinks they should be done, and I've come to realise that this is actually the best approach.

HelenHywater · 19/05/2026 15:34

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:13

Funny you mention this - once, while I was cooking quite a large a meal, I offered her some, and she seemed very annoyed and just said they are all independent individuals in their family and will eat what and when they want to 😂

except for your husband who needs his soup warming up for him.

Honestly I wouldn't visit - I stopped visiting my MIL after she made a really unpleasant comment about my weight.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:31

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 19/05/2026 15:17

I hear you OP. Our relative was obsessed with people's weight and wealth and had a fridge full of expired food. In the days when they used to cook it was all Marguerite Pattern style performative display food and they would do things like put out and offer three different puddings with pouring cream.
I think they actually had a love/hate relationship with food.
Once our baby was on solids.. they proudly showed us into a room which had been covered in a large area of protective sheeting (a la Dexter) with a lonely ancient wooden high chair in the middle... about 2 metres from the rest of the family at the table. At first glance I thought they were about to paint the room, but I suppose they thought tiny DC would generate a large splatter area. I was indicated to stand (forgoing any lunch myself now I was a mother) in the centre of the sheeting feeding DC at a "safe" distance from the rest of them.Anything to avoid triggering the horror of "mess".
DH never wanted puddings at home so he would have "A bit of everything" there's was never any comment about that.. but if I or the DC took even one pudding that was being pressed on us.. we got comments like "Are/nt you on a diet?" or "Are you sure you ought to be eating that?" as the pouring cream was poured on regardless despite requests not to.
Anything we cooked was evaluated in the manner of their favourite TV Chef.. eg they'd pick up quiche and examine it to see if it could be classed as having a soggy bottom. (ARGGGHHH!)
It was Food Issue Central. Happy Days

Edited

This made me lol.

OP posts:
wordler · 19/05/2026 15:30

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:21

The thing about bringing my/our own food is that it also is a problem because it means money was wasted on buying food when she has "perfectly good food" in her house.

One time my husband and I nipped out to eat our after a long day, and when we returned she made a point to announce to everybody else in the family that [our names] just went to [fast food chain] even though I have perfectly good [vaguely similar cupboard food] in my cupboard!!!

and then after telling everybody she went to retrieve this item out of the cupboard and waved it around for us to see. And yes, I say item because she had just one portion of this, so it would have been for us to share, or maybe for me to have a few forkfuls and leave the rest to my husband... 😂

The thing is she’s bonkers and everyone will see that. So let her crack on with waving her cupboard food around - just smile and grey rock it.

You are letting her bully you into matching her disordered eating. You won’t change her but you can change whether you go along with it and internally fume.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:23

Sassylovesbooks · 19/05/2026 14:40

Your husband needs to step up here. Instead of sitting there stuffing his face, he should be telling his Mum to stop. You should be ordering what you want off a menu when you're out...if it's too much for your MIL, then pay for your own meal!! When you're at her home, your husband should be the one to tell his Mum that she needs to stop, leave you alone and let you eat what you want.

Is your MIL the sort who feels a woman should be thin as possible 'for her husband'???? It's a very old fashioned view point, but a possible one.

Your MIL has a distorted view of food and her relationship with it is poor. However, she shouldn't be pushing her views onto you.

@Sassylovesbooks

Is your MIL the sort who feels a woman should be thin as possible 'for her husband'????

Interestingly no: everybody should be as thin as possible! For themselves!

OP posts:
illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:21

alexdgr8 · 19/05/2026 13:28

Just be more straightforward.
Don't shilly shally around as if you are in the wrong.
You don't have to make any comment about her or her habits.
Simply be yourself and state your needs.
So if out with her say
I need to eat now.
? Is this cafe OK for you or do you prefer the one across the road.
A bit like with toddlers dressing. ?green shirt or blue.

If going to her house bring food with you or order a takeaway to be delivered.
? Indian or Chinese mother ?
Any comments about your weight just say
I'm not trying to lose weight. ?how are the begonias.
All the best.

The thing about bringing my/our own food is that it also is a problem because it means money was wasted on buying food when she has "perfectly good food" in her house.

One time my husband and I nipped out to eat our after a long day, and when we returned she made a point to announce to everybody else in the family that [our names] just went to [fast food chain] even though I have perfectly good [vaguely similar cupboard food] in my cupboard!!!

and then after telling everybody she went to retrieve this item out of the cupboard and waved it around for us to see. And yes, I say item because she had just one portion of this, so it would have been for us to share, or maybe for me to have a few forkfuls and leave the rest to my husband... 😂

OP posts:
wordler · 19/05/2026 15:19

@illtellyouwhat Just stop playing along.

Order whatever you want when out - don’t let her take your food. At her first attempt offer to call the waiter back to get her, her own portion.

Or agree beforehand that DH will police this behaviour and dump some of his food on her plate instead.

Always pack a lunchbox of food when going to her house.

Tell DH to refuse mouldy and old food.

Tell her that you’re not ima diet and she is to stop talking about weight to you.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 19/05/2026 15:17

I hear you OP. Our relative was obsessed with people's weight and wealth and had a fridge full of expired food. In the days when they used to cook it was all Marguerite Pattern style performative display food and they would do things like put out and offer three different puddings with pouring cream.
I think they actually had a love/hate relationship with food.
Once our baby was on solids.. they proudly showed us into a room which had been covered in a large area of protective sheeting (a la Dexter) with a lonely ancient wooden high chair in the middle... about 2 metres from the rest of the family at the table. At first glance I thought they were about to paint the room, but I suppose they thought tiny DC would generate a large splatter area. I was indicated to stand (forgoing any lunch myself now I was a mother) in the centre of the sheeting feeding DC at a "safe" distance from the rest of them.Anything to avoid triggering the horror of "mess".
DH never wanted puddings at home so he would have "A bit of everything" there's was never any comment about that.. but if I or the DC took even one pudding that was being pressed on us.. we got comments like "Are/nt you on a diet?" or "Are you sure you ought to be eating that?" as the pouring cream was poured on regardless despite requests not to.
Anything we cooked was evaluated in the manner of their favourite TV Chef.. eg they'd pick up quiche and examine it to see if it could be classed as having a soggy bottom. (ARGGGHHH!)
It was Food Issue Central. Happy Days

Lottapianos · 19/05/2026 15:17

OP, I have read your updates about the rules and the script that you all follow and the unspoken expectations and I absolutely get it. People will say 'why don't you just...' but it's not that simple. I understand, I really do

That said, please rest assured that your MIL's behaviour around food is highly disordered and it's important that you don't just go along with it. I have some sympathy for your husband because he has grown up in a very messed up and rigid environment and what is objectively batshit may well seem 'normal' to him. HOWEVER, you both need to start asserting yourselves and challenging 'the rules' and the extreme level of control your MIL has been enforcing. And never, ever go hungry just to keep the peace. Believe me when I say that this will be really corrosive to you over time, emotionally as well as physically

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:13

coronafiona · 19/05/2026 15:05

“I thought I’d bring lunch for us all here today! You’re always so generous with paying.”
and proceed to unpack a buffet/ whatever, make yourself at home in her kitchen and tell her to sit down and tuck in.
you can take leftovers back with you or stack her fridge, chucking I it whatever’s has gone off I. The process.
I think that generation were brought up to be super frugal with food and money and it leaves some people weirdly obsessive and judgemental about others.

Funny you mention this - once, while I was cooking quite a large a meal, I offered her some, and she seemed very annoyed and just said they are all independent individuals in their family and will eat what and when they want to 😂

OP posts:
illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:10

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

So what actually happens, when you go to hers and she makes him food and not you? I can't actually imagine this situation...does he just say thanks and eat his soup while you just sit there with nothing?

There is a lot of whizzing around that happens. On this particular occasion we had just got back in. My husband had to do a work call whereas I didn't. So upon entering the house, she whizzed around to the kitchen to magic up something to eat for him, then whizzed back to the front door where him and I were still standing, offered the tin, whizzed back to the kitchen to heat it up. By the time I had taken off my shoes and gone inside, he had gone to take his call and she told me "come on we're going to go on some errands". So I said "oh okay" 😂

@DrinkFeckArseBrick
The whole thing is a bit batshit. What do you actually want to happen? Her behaviour is unlikely to completely change (she will likely always be weird around food). Do you want to avoid eating around her? Do you want her to stop trying to eat your food when you're out? Absolutely no way would I be wanting to discuss my weight, or eat a tomato and crackers for lunch. I'd also not be wanting to accept her paying for a meal out if she thinks she has control over what I eat. But what boundaries do you want to put in place?

It is the fact that her behaviour is unlikely to change that is the challenge. I think mostly I wanted to know what other people's reaction to this was, just to get some reassurance maybe. If I speak to my parents too much about her behaviours, who are not like this at all, there is a risk that I create issues between them which I don't think would be helpful to anybody. There are obvious problems talking to my husband about this because he has never known anything different and she is his mother so I don't want to be upsetting him too much, even though we obviously have had our fair share of arguments about things like this and lots, lots of other issues related to his mother.

I'm just trying to find a balance really.

Worth mentioning that I don't really allow anyone else to push me around like this, and I think she knows that.

OP posts:
persisted · 19/05/2026 15:10

I couldn't be bothered with all this.
'Soup for lunch is it? lovely stuff, is there another can of that there, doesn't look like there's enough for all of us. Not to worry then lets make sandwiches as well. I bought this lovely fresh bread and stuff on the way for a treat. Don't be so silly, of course I'm having some'

I will not be shamed for eating, and it will be a relentless steam roller of positivity until I get what I need. I wouldn't be putting up with that crap from DH either, he certainly doesn't get any lunch if I don't. And frankly he knows better, he would not enjoy himself.

My own MIL is batshit in different ways but I just won't engage with it. I'm polite, clear, assertive, bit like at work really.

cupfinalchaos · 19/05/2026 15:06

When you say you feel she wants you to order the cheapest option on the menu, who is paying the bill? Just curious.

TorroFerney · 19/05/2026 15:06

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 14:34

@SnappyQuoter "The only reason this woman is in her life is because she married her husband"

I have to remind myself of this all the time. Amusingly, I think she has to do the same: remind herself why I am in her life. And who knows, maybe that is part of what drives some of these behaviours, maybe it is a coping mechanism for wishing her son had found someone better or more up to her standards, even though I do agree, the behaviours appear very ingrained.

@TheSandgroper
"Wonder about how she was brought up by her parents (who would have been Depression/war children). Generational trauma is a thing and can manifest itself in funny ways."

This is also something that I reflect on and which helps me be less judgemental. On the other hand, and this makes all this even more strange to me on a personal level, my parents are the opposite and will offer you more food than you could possibly want or need. Certainly would never dream of withholding food.

Whilst I get that’s it’s interesting or normal to wonder why and perhaps try and justify her behaviour it really doesn’t matter why all that matters is that you shouldn’t be putting up with it and neither should your husband. Now perhaps he’s been trained from an early age that women only exist to look nice for men and be thin but he needs to pick his side and, if he telling him unless he wants things to go downhill very rapidly then that side is you.

MajorProcrastination · 19/05/2026 15:06

There's obviously something bigger and deeper going on. I would be clear about saying (in a polite way) "please could I have some soup as well Sheila?" or take your own food with you when you visit "hi Sheila, they had an off on these pasties/I've got some leftovers we need to eat up so I've brought it over to warm up" or why don't you two pay for the food when you're out? "don't worry Sheila, our treat today. I'll have the whitebait to start and the mushroom risotto, what are you having?" All with a smile. "I don't want to talk about weightloss thanks Sheila" etc.

coronafiona · 19/05/2026 15:05

“I thought I’d bring lunch for us all here today! You’re always so generous with paying.”
and proceed to unpack a buffet/ whatever, make yourself at home in her kitchen and tell her to sit down and tuck in.
you can take leftovers back with you or stack her fridge, chucking I it whatever’s has gone off I. The process.
I think that generation were brought up to be super frugal with food and money and it leaves some people weirdly obsessive and judgemental about others.