Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel uncomfortable about my MIL's behaviour around food?

440 replies

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 13:06

Sorry, this ended up being quite a long post.

I don’t know what advice I am looking for and simply wanted to share this with other people to see if anybody else has ever experienced anything like this?

MIL, who is past retirement age, has a not so healthy relationship with weight and food. There are reasons I say this which I won’t go into, but let’s just say it is off topic for this thread.

I put on weight recently, but my BMI is in the green, right in the middle. This comes after years of being underweight, at times dangerously so, and struggling to put weight on, for reasons that are also off topic here.

MIL is now constantly asking me how the weight loss is going, measuring me up with her eyes, essentially fat-checking me… she does try to be discrete about this but I’ve seen it happen. She will ask whether I have managed to lose any weight since the last time she saw me. She then confirms “but the weight is going down right?”

She herself is not underweight for her age but is on the thin side.

In her fridge and cupboard, she keeps lots of out of date, expired food. Often mouldy. She will tell anybody who listens how she doesn’t gain weight and how proud she is of it, then going into details about how she manages to do that. For example, if she has eaten a lot one day she will try to not to eat very much for several days thereafter.

Unless she eats out, she’d does not eat “real” food, instead snacking on things like tomatoes or biscuits or nuts, or if she decides to have a meal, it will be something like canned soup. My understanding is she doesn’t really know how to cook, but that isn’t something you can judge her for because not everybody does.

She will often go out of her way to make sure her son (my husband) gets food when we are there, but will essentially do the opposite with me. This used to happen even when I was very thin. If we would go out for a meal she would order something “healthy” then try to eat my food and actually verbalise that she won’t take any from her son’s plate because he needs it. She would encourage her son to get the most expensive and substantial option on a menu, and although it has never explicitly been said I always feel that I am supposed to pick something cheap, sometimes based on suggestions she makes but mostly it’s based on experience from eating out with her and the sort of obvious conclusion you can draw from the behaviour when I do get something that isn’t the very cheapest option (she tries to eat my food). Of course it is possible this is all in my head but I am fairly sure it is not.

I feel like there’s an aspect to this which comes from a need to hoard food because food costs money. Or making sure you get your money’s worth (since she paid for the meal). So her son eating is getting your moneys worth, me eating is not. This behaviour extends to other situations but again it’s a bit off topic.

She does offer me what is in her cupboard and fridge but as I say it’s all expired and mouldy. In the same breath she will talk about how to ensure you don’t get hungry by snacking on small amounts of food like sweets and nuts.

On our most recent visit she made her son some food (tinned soup). She did not offer me the same. She then told me to join her while she ran some errands, in what felt like an attempt to distract me from eating. At this point it was late afternoon and I had not had anything to eat all day. She later offered me tomatoes and crackers.

I don’t think I will ever try to “set a boundary” because to some degree it is a lost cause and I don’t want to make her cross, I mostly try to eat before and after seeing her, but sometimes there isn’t time to do that.

OP posts:
goody2shooz · 19/05/2026 17:08

@illtellyouwhat are you actually saying that your dh eats mouldy or out of date food because his mother gives it to him? He’s not able to say ‘no thanks’ or ‘it’s mouldy/out of date’? ?

Dressfinder · 19/05/2026 17:05

I would be arriving at her house with a lunchbox for myself. Making sure it's healthy portions of delicious food. And sharing none of it.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 17:02

thepariscrimefiles · 19/05/2026 16:55

Do you think that she'll actually give you some proper food if you get pregnant?

Good question, have made a mental note to look out for this!

OP posts:
Thundertoast · 19/05/2026 16:57

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:41

There are a couple of comments about this. First of all, sometimes he does seem a bit clueless. I think he reverts to a sort of child state around her, which a lot of people do when they are with their parents, me included.

We have been together for quite a long time. I've tried to talk to him about setting boundaries with his mother. I don't think he knows how to do that - with her or with anyone else. It also makes him feel stuck in the middle, which he expresses to me. So whether I have to appease her quirks or tell him to set boundaries, and then try to explain how boundaries are set or what a boundary even is, it's still me doing the leg (and brain) work.

It comes down to: how do you teach a grown man to set boundaries, with his mother no less, without creating friction in their relationship?

Can I just say something.

You say 'teach a man to have boundaries'

What you need, NEED to mean is.
'DH needs to put in the work to proactively research/learn the things he needs in order to set boundaries. If DH isnt very good at something, it is his responsibility to proactively learn more about it and practice'

There are so, so many resources online about learning how to set boundaries, the impact of eating disorders on the individual and the people around them. He needs to go off and do his research, like he would do at a job, a new job, a new bit of tech.

Let's not fall into the trap many people do of going 'my partners not good with emotions they never learnt' nobody pops out of the womb able to drive, or read, or operate a mobile phone, but they learn to do these things by proactively learning and practising, because they need them to navigate life. Dont let yourself get fooled here.

Also, if he wants to be an actually good father, as opposed to just a father who is nice to his kids and gets a medal for it, he needs to be able to navigate this as its exactly the kind of talk that people with lifelong eating and self esteem issues report experiencing from family members.

thepariscrimefiles · 19/05/2026 16:55

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 16:02

That is in the pipeline. She took us out for a meal some time ago to tell us to make some!

Do you think that she'll actually give you some proper food if you get pregnant?

LoremIpsumCici · 19/05/2026 16:51

yanbu to be bothered by it, but given that you said there are reasons why she is like this, which I presume are trauma based, then you would be unreasonable to expect her to change.

You know you won’t be offered food and all her food is mouldy and expired, so don’t go to her house hungry. Eat beforehand. Your DH is accepting food to humour her…I think he has short end of the stick having to choke down something well past its use by date.

Reduce the time with her so there’s not the conversations about weight all the time.

If/when you have children, do not ever in a million years leave them with her either at your home or hers.

Lottapianos · 19/05/2026 16:51

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 16:32

What exactly is it we should try to work out? Whether she can give them food? Or what do you mean?

Ok, fair questions. I would say that you're both far too focused on her and her rules and expectations. You both need to learn to tune in to what YOU want. In relation to food, you both need to eat when you're hungry, until you feel satisfied, and then get on with your day. Do not get drawn into conversations about food and portions and weight and all the rest of it.

Going hungry because you (correctly) sense her discomfort/ disapproval is MADNESS, OP, and it can't continue. You will need to put your foot down and set very clear boundaries when children come along - for example, we eat when we're hungry and we stop when we're full, MIL. No comments about food or portions MIL. And you will need to remind her of this regularly, and you and DH will absolutely have to be on the same page. You need to start taking back some control and asserting yourselves now

And if you both find this really challenging and don't know where to start, that's totally understandable - I highly recommend working with a psychotherapist who will help you both to understand the impact of MIL's behaviour on you both, and how you can challenge it in a way that feels manageable

PopcornKitten · 19/05/2026 16:47

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 16:32

What exactly is it we should try to work out? Whether she can give them food? Or what do you mean?

I’d imagine the poster means you’re both pussyfooting around his DM to preserve their relationship and not put him in the middle.
for whatever reason, her behaviour around food and towards you (and maybe DH) is controlling and unhealthy. If this isn’t dealt with your resentment is likely to grow. Any DC are learning unhealthy habits and behaviours and you and ash aren’t on the same page to protect them.
sounds like everyone tips toes around not to rock the boat with DM. No one stands up to her. Just because they’re used to it doesn’t make it ok though it explains how the situation has got to where it is. Nothing will change unless you incite a rebellion.

Wauwinet · 19/05/2026 16:46

Do not have children with a selfish man that puts his mother above you and won’t stand up to her. There are hundreds of threads on here from women who did just that and live miserable lives as a result.

First he needs to shape up and address the issues he has. Or you need to see her less. It sounds like you spend entirely too much time together in the first place and that’s probably at least half the problem. If she’s known you since you were young and you’re always around her then of course she’s not going to want to let either of you grow up and have control of your own lives. Can you move further away?

ViciousCurrentBun · 19/05/2026 16:46

I remember my MIL calling me stocky once. I was a size 8 to 10 at almost 5ft 5.

She has disordered eating and hides it by being very healthy. She will only eat veg, fruit, eggs and meat and that being only chicken and fish with a little gluten free bread and a little skimmed milk. She is definitely underweight. She goes on about SIL being overweight, she is but it’s awful.

I had about 18 years of her rubbish and then after my DD died Ijust didn’t care anymore and told her to fuck off and refused to see her for about 6 months. She has behaved well towards me since since then. DH refusal to tackle his Mothers and sisters behaviour has been the one bugbear in our marriage and almost caused us to break up.

breastcancerpanic · 19/05/2026 16:38

Ask yourself this question: when DC watch us respond to MIL, what will they learn? Will they learn that women should be very thin? Will they learn that women deserve less food than men? Will they learn that (as a woman) it is important to have everyone approve of you, even at the expense of your own well-being and comfort? I'd say some changes are needed in your and DH's responses to MIL so that you can model the right sorts of things for your DC. (And indeed, if you have a DD, you might now want to practice making sure you get fed, so that later you can make sure that she gets fed!).

breastcancerpanic · 19/05/2026 16:34

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 16:32

What exactly is it we should try to work out? Whether she can give them food? Or what do you mean?

I'm imagining - your MIL's attitude and your (you and DH's) response. V likely you can't change the attitude, so the response needs work from you both! Several steps on this journey I think, but as a step 1 DH could take it upon himself to make sure that whenever he is eating at MILs you are also eating and you get to eat the same amount as him (or as much as you want) and you get as much freedom of choice as he gets.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 16:32

Lottapianos · 19/05/2026 16:30

I get it. However, I cannot emphasise enough how crucial it is that you and DH get on the same page BEFORE any children come along. You won't change MIL's behaviour, but you will need to be much more robust in managing it, together. It's head out of sand time for DH

What exactly is it we should try to work out? Whether she can give them food? Or what do you mean?

OP posts:
Lottapianos · 19/05/2026 16:30

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 16:26

@DuckbilledSplatterPuff
"Your DH is really relieved that he's escaping the full force of this behaviour and he's keeping his head down so that he doesn't attract any more flak."

I think this sums it up fairly well. And is essentially how their whole family operates.

Edited

I get it. However, I cannot emphasise enough how crucial it is that you and DH get on the same page BEFORE any children come along. You won't change MIL's behaviour, but you will need to be much more robust in managing it, together. It's head out of sand time for DH

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 16:26

@DuckbilledSplatterPuff
"Your DH is really relieved that he's escaping the full force of this behaviour and he's keeping his head down so that he doesn't attract any more flak."

I think this sums it up fairly well. And is essentially how their whole family operates.

OP posts:
Greengage1983 · 19/05/2026 16:23

AnnaMagnani · 19/05/2026 13:18

She may well have a life long eating disorder which she has just about kept underwraps by not being too thin and using socially acceptable behaviour such saving money and men eating bigger portions.

Only these behaviours aren't as acceptable now and they are driving you up the wall.

OP order what you like and tell her that you know she cares but nowadays it's rude to talk about weight.

That's what I was thinking. Definitely sounds like an eating disorder, and also the sort of behaviour that may have passed for borderline acceptable 40 years ago (if my own older relatives are anything to go by).

OP, I think you need to be firmer and also bring snacks when you go to hers. Your husband also needs to share his bloody food/make sure you are fed!

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 19/05/2026 16:16

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:41

There are a couple of comments about this. First of all, sometimes he does seem a bit clueless. I think he reverts to a sort of child state around her, which a lot of people do when they are with their parents, me included.

We have been together for quite a long time. I've tried to talk to him about setting boundaries with his mother. I don't think he knows how to do that - with her or with anyone else. It also makes him feel stuck in the middle, which he expresses to me. So whether I have to appease her quirks or tell him to set boundaries, and then try to explain how boundaries are set or what a boundary even is, it's still me doing the leg (and brain) work.

It comes down to: how do you teach a grown man to set boundaries, with his mother no less, without creating friction in their relationship?

Your DH is really relieved that he's escaping the full force of this behaviour and he's keeping his head down so that he doesn't attract any more flak.

Stuck in the middle? He's sitting on the sidelines, happy not to even be on the pitch!!!

Stop appeasing her quirks.... in fact... Damn her Quirks.. Giving into them isn't working for you is it?
He's her son let him deal with her Quirks!!! He had to before you came along.

Try "well why don't we ask DH what he thinks"... he's the one who decided to go to the food chain you didn't go on your own did you? draw him into the conversation every single time... "Do you agree that I'm xyz DH? "What's your opinion DH, we are all dying to know what you think? " I had to do this because DH completely opted out of all conversation and I had to do that job too.

I think a bit of friction in the relationship is exactly what's needed. Your DH is going to continue to sit there quietly keeping out of the line of fire for as long as he can get away with it. If he feels the friction he might start actually setting those boundaries, such as speaking up more, or visiting less or just ignoring the commandments and eating when and where you want.

As I see it, you have a choice between speaking and feeling/being awkward, or continuing to put up with it. You are not the one being rude here.
If you feel you are being singled out for criticism.. you may as well earn it. You are being presented as being awkward anyway - without feeling the benefit of doing so.
( I'm not telling you off OP, I feel for you in this situation)

ToSayYouHaveNoChoiceIsAFailureOfImagination · 19/05/2026 16:15

And about her taking food from your plate. If you can't face being direct and telling her to stop it, when you're ordering encourage your DH to also order a side or a starter for himself to be brought out with his main course.

When your MIL eats half of your sad children's portion sized chicken breast salad, turn to your DH and say
"Oh love, I'm still peckish, would you mind if I shared yours please?"

Obviously you shouldn't need to go to these lengths, being direct and assertive would be much better, but it's hard to change existing patterns and dynamics overnight.

But you absolutely do need to put your own basic needs ahead of your MILs crazy ideas

BrownBookshelf · 19/05/2026 16:13

If DC are on the cards soon, you actually do both need to start asserting boundaries around this stuff soon. You're going to gain a lot of weight, pregnancy hunger is no joke, you'll probably be visibly fatter for a while after the birth and if you choose to breastfeed your calorie requirements will be higher then. This is all going to be much less fun around someone with an eating disorder that she wants to involve you in.

And perhaps more importantly, there's a 50/50 chance you'd have a girl. She would need to be protected from this.

ToSayYouHaveNoChoiceIsAFailureOfImagination · 19/05/2026 16:03

Your MIL is absolutely crazy with regards to food, control of her son's and your eating habits, weight etc . You know that. What you don't seem to know is that you don't have to drink the kool aid. Only you can change things because you can't force your MIL or your DH to change or do anything differently.

You've given examples of when you challenged her rules

  1. You suggested sharing your home cooked leftovers. She reacted with hostility
  2. You ate fast food on the way back to her house and she embarrassed you in front of relatives.

You didn't do anything objectively wrong in either of these examples. A normal person would not have a problem with this. Just because your MIL is crazy, it still doesn't make you in the wrong. Just because she has rules, doesn't mean you have to accept them and conform to them. She can be hostile towards you or try to publicly humiliate you, you don't have to accept either. It's all her problem, not yours, but you're making it yours because you're going along with it all.

In either of the examples, when she challenged you, you could lean into it and own what you've done.
"I cook a lovely shepherds pie, but if you don't want any that's fine, more for me!"
or
"Yes we got a bargain bucket from KFC and I had extra popcorn chicken. Sometimes you just fancy something greasy don't you. Oh you have a birdeye chicken burger in the freezer? That's kind of you to iffer. Well if I'm hungry later I'll let you know, "

You don't have to be rude, disrespectful or confrontational. But you can assert yourself, and it's the only way to change anything

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 16:02

pizzaHeart · 19/05/2026 15:48

Sorry if I missed this but do you have / plan to have children?

That is in the pipeline. She took us out for a meal some time ago to tell us to make some!

OP posts:
SpaceRaccoon · 19/05/2026 15:59

You're a more tolerant woman than me. I'd expect DH to put his foot down and make sure I was fed/didn't have my food stolen, or I'd stop spending any time with her.

Also, DH doesn't revert to a child state when with his parents at all so that is something else your DH should probably work on. The whole thing is just ridiculous.

BrownBookshelf · 19/05/2026 15:58

breastcancerpanic · 19/05/2026 15:36

You describe behaviour that is a bit bonkers, and so I think you need to start responding to it with that in mind. When you say things like 'well, I tried doing [sensible obvious thing like bringing food] - but then she did [unreasonable response]', it sounds like you're in an impossible situation. But I think that's because if you keep trying to respond to her with full politeness and respect for her viewpoint then you are in an impossible situation, and that's driving you to be unable to eat in front of her etc. You're just going to have to crash your way,through her disapproval, being a bit impolite if need be - because it really doesn't matter if she disapproves - because she's a bit bonkers.
I've been on a related journey with my dad. When I describe what he has said and done, everyone just agrees that he's impossible. I keep trying to work around things and keep him happy, but my brother just crashes through and sorts things out the way he thinks they should be done, and I've come to realise that this is actually the best approach.

I agree. Ideally you would also get DH on side for this process.

But if you need to build up to that, put food in your handbag and eat it in the car, pretending you need the bog or whatever. Don't go to her house with no food knowing you won't be fed properly though.

HazelMember · 19/05/2026 15:56

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 15:41

There are a couple of comments about this. First of all, sometimes he does seem a bit clueless. I think he reverts to a sort of child state around her, which a lot of people do when they are with their parents, me included.

We have been together for quite a long time. I've tried to talk to him about setting boundaries with his mother. I don't think he knows how to do that - with her or with anyone else. It also makes him feel stuck in the middle, which he expresses to me. So whether I have to appease her quirks or tell him to set boundaries, and then try to explain how boundaries are set or what a boundary even is, it's still me doing the leg (and brain) work.

It comes down to: how do you teach a grown man to set boundaries, with his mother no less, without creating friction in their relationship?

This is beyond a bit clueless and reverting to a childlike state.

Why is he stuck in the middle if MIL gives him food and you nothing? He tucks in happily while you have nothing. He is a grown adult who does not seem to care about you. I would be more concerned about him than MIL.

DierdreDaphne · 19/05/2026 15:54

Your DH just HAS to share his plate of food with you, if she hasn't given you any. Or, obviously, ask where yours is. How rude of him otherwise!

I would absolutely blank any remark about 'how is the weight loss going. It's birdsong, don't dignify it with a response. If she gets arsey and persists, just say 'I don't think its very nice to discuss other people's weight'. But again, don't actually discuss your weight whatsovever.

She clearly has an eating disorder (my MiL has one too and can be very stingy with portions - but not to this batshit extent). Her beliefs won't change but she is not too old to learn that some things aren't acceptable.

But honestly, why are you eating in her presence? Why do your visits include meals at all? It is just an opportunity for her to luxuriate in her batshittery as far as I can see. "you obviously find mealtimes stressful MiL we'll feed ourselves /just come for the afternoon/whatever"