Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel uncomfortable about my MIL's behaviour around food?

440 replies

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 13:06

Sorry, this ended up being quite a long post.

I don’t know what advice I am looking for and simply wanted to share this with other people to see if anybody else has ever experienced anything like this?

MIL, who is past retirement age, has a not so healthy relationship with weight and food. There are reasons I say this which I won’t go into, but let’s just say it is off topic for this thread.

I put on weight recently, but my BMI is in the green, right in the middle. This comes after years of being underweight, at times dangerously so, and struggling to put weight on, for reasons that are also off topic here.

MIL is now constantly asking me how the weight loss is going, measuring me up with her eyes, essentially fat-checking me… she does try to be discrete about this but I’ve seen it happen. She will ask whether I have managed to lose any weight since the last time she saw me. She then confirms “but the weight is going down right?”

She herself is not underweight for her age but is on the thin side.

In her fridge and cupboard, she keeps lots of out of date, expired food. Often mouldy. She will tell anybody who listens how she doesn’t gain weight and how proud she is of it, then going into details about how she manages to do that. For example, if she has eaten a lot one day she will try to not to eat very much for several days thereafter.

Unless she eats out, she’d does not eat “real” food, instead snacking on things like tomatoes or biscuits or nuts, or if she decides to have a meal, it will be something like canned soup. My understanding is she doesn’t really know how to cook, but that isn’t something you can judge her for because not everybody does.

She will often go out of her way to make sure her son (my husband) gets food when we are there, but will essentially do the opposite with me. This used to happen even when I was very thin. If we would go out for a meal she would order something “healthy” then try to eat my food and actually verbalise that she won’t take any from her son’s plate because he needs it. She would encourage her son to get the most expensive and substantial option on a menu, and although it has never explicitly been said I always feel that I am supposed to pick something cheap, sometimes based on suggestions she makes but mostly it’s based on experience from eating out with her and the sort of obvious conclusion you can draw from the behaviour when I do get something that isn’t the very cheapest option (she tries to eat my food). Of course it is possible this is all in my head but I am fairly sure it is not.

I feel like there’s an aspect to this which comes from a need to hoard food because food costs money. Or making sure you get your money’s worth (since she paid for the meal). So her son eating is getting your moneys worth, me eating is not. This behaviour extends to other situations but again it’s a bit off topic.

She does offer me what is in her cupboard and fridge but as I say it’s all expired and mouldy. In the same breath she will talk about how to ensure you don’t get hungry by snacking on small amounts of food like sweets and nuts.

On our most recent visit she made her son some food (tinned soup). She did not offer me the same. She then told me to join her while she ran some errands, in what felt like an attempt to distract me from eating. At this point it was late afternoon and I had not had anything to eat all day. She later offered me tomatoes and crackers.

I don’t think I will ever try to “set a boundary” because to some degree it is a lost cause and I don’t want to make her cross, I mostly try to eat before and after seeing her, but sometimes there isn’t time to do that.

OP posts:
illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 19:16

BuckChuckets · 19/05/2026 19:15

The solution would be to stop this behaviour immediately, and make sure your wet wipe husband is fully onside, but the more you post, the less it sounds like you're willing to do that. So I'll reiterate, please don't bring children into this horror show.

I'll try to find a way of doing some kind of planning session about life after kids, to weave these issues into that, thank you for the pushback

OP posts:
goody2shooz · 19/05/2026 19:15

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 19:01

To be honest, we've spoken about various things related to SIL and my wish for there to be more/better/ANY boundaries. Usually the outcome is he feels I'm attacking her or being negative about her and so on. And, like someone just said, he thinks I spend too much time thinking about/analysing her behaviour.

But as many people have said, lots of these behaviours are problematic, and there are many more behaviours like this, which all affect me, often negatively because they simply make me sad. So of course I think about it. And I often think, you know, instead of sitting here, I could (in theory) be with my family who - while they also have their issues - do shower me with love and care (I was spoiled for love as a child). Instead I sat am here and having to be polite to rudeness. I am not sure it is fully appreciated (by them) how much effort I put into trying to be involved in their family, despite the fact that I wish the involvement looked different.

@illtellyouwhat this relationship just gets worse and worse. He puts his family and their feelings before you and how you feel. Shuts you down for talking to him about it. Says you’re being negative. When you’re being treated like this? Frankly my dear, I’d leave. I certainly would never have a child with a husband who wouldn’t support me, or even look out for me. You’re not a team.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 19:15

godmum56 · 19/05/2026 19:12

Op, why do you stay?

hard to convey in this thread without going off topic. but you could call it "the relationship pareto principle", where the 80% of successes make up for the 20% of challenges.

OP posts:
BuckChuckets · 19/05/2026 19:15

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 18:27

What I can agree with you on is that it is not fair to inflict this type of disordered behaviour on children. 100% but I disagree that the solution is to split up or never have kids

The solution would be to stop this behaviour immediately, and make sure your wet wipe husband is fully onside, but the more you post, the less it sounds like you're willing to do that. So I'll reiterate, please don't bring children into this horror show.

godmum56 · 19/05/2026 19:12

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 19:01

To be honest, we've spoken about various things related to SIL and my wish for there to be more/better/ANY boundaries. Usually the outcome is he feels I'm attacking her or being negative about her and so on. And, like someone just said, he thinks I spend too much time thinking about/analysing her behaviour.

But as many people have said, lots of these behaviours are problematic, and there are many more behaviours like this, which all affect me, often negatively because they simply make me sad. So of course I think about it. And I often think, you know, instead of sitting here, I could (in theory) be with my family who - while they also have their issues - do shower me with love and care (I was spoiled for love as a child). Instead I sat am here and having to be polite to rudeness. I am not sure it is fully appreciated (by them) how much effort I put into trying to be involved in their family, despite the fact that I wish the involvement looked different.

Op, why do you stay?

goody2shooz · 19/05/2026 19:09

@illtellyouwhat I can’t get my head round the idea that TWO ADULTS can’t say ‘that’s mouldy - it’s not fit for consumption’ to another adult. And you’re considering having a child with this man? His dm takes food off your plate/drink out of your glass/doesn’t give you food and neither of you can speak up??
You really shouldn’t be considering bringing a baby into such a dysfunctional relationship if neither of you can stand up to this absolute nonsense and appalling bad manners - and you’re a pair of complete wet fish to sit there and let his dm treat you like that.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 19:01

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 19/05/2026 18:50

Important point- why are you nervous to talk to your dh about this ? Have the chat. Make a plan together. If he’s not got your back, he’s not worth hanging on to anyway.

To be honest, we've spoken about various things related to SIL and my wish for there to be more/better/ANY boundaries. Usually the outcome is he feels I'm attacking her or being negative about her and so on. And, like someone just said, he thinks I spend too much time thinking about/analysing her behaviour.

But as many people have said, lots of these behaviours are problematic, and there are many more behaviours like this, which all affect me, often negatively because they simply make me sad. So of course I think about it. And I often think, you know, instead of sitting here, I could (in theory) be with my family who - while they also have their issues - do shower me with love and care (I was spoiled for love as a child). Instead I sat am here and having to be polite to rudeness. I am not sure it is fully appreciated (by them) how much effort I put into trying to be involved in their family, despite the fact that I wish the involvement looked different.

OP posts:
Danascully2 · 19/05/2026 18:57

That all sounds completely mad and like she has major control issues which are linked to food. There are various versions of 'we can't do x or there will be friction/unpleasantness' or 'i can't talk to DH without causing friction'. This may well be true - there is no magic solution that will keep everyone happy. But I think it's really important that you set your own boundaries. Work out what you are not willing to accept (being hungry because you haven't had any food, eating mouldy food) and what is annoying but doesn't actually impact you (MIL telling you what she's eaten). Then make a plan in advance with your husband to eg make sure you eat enough. And grey rock everything else (that's nice MIL, did you see Strictly last night?).
I have an older relative with lifelong food/weight issues. In her case a related element is definitely feeding other people but in her case the food is very nice, not mouldy!... She talks a lot about food eg 'I ate so much at lunch I just had a packet of crisps for dinner'. I ignore that sort of thing. She is really lovely otherwise though and we get on well in general.
Is there any way of seeing your MIL in a different setting that doesn't involve food eg go to the theatre/cinema?

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 19/05/2026 18:50

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 18:42

@FancyBiscuitsLevel

This is why I said to forewarn your DH, he’s not allowed to change his order. He gets to pick what he wants to eat and you will order the same, if he changes his order you will keep changing yours to match his.

I like this idea. I might try it without telling him, although that might come across as antagonistic. Will have to think about it but will for sure do try some version of this - thank you!

Important point- why are you nervous to talk to your dh about this ? Have the chat. Make a plan together. If he’s not got your back, he’s not worth hanging on to anyway.

pizzaHeart · 19/05/2026 18:44

No it’s not normal. Absolutely abnormal and rude.
You need to challenge that but in a subtle way - I mean that your DH should challenge that. You should agree what to do but he should open his mouth and produce the relevant response.
I would do all what @FancyBiscuitsLevel suggested ( I think I got the right poster) i would start from ordering the same as he with his agreement and he shouldn’t change his order, if he changed - you change too.
I wouldn’t tolerate this psychotic nonsense and I wouldn’t have children until it’s tackled ( if you planned to have them) .
No conversations about your weight or similar, if she comments just say her politely that : it’s rude and inappropriate to comment on someone’s weight (and it’s true in UK).
And guard your glass/ plate etc as a hawk. Make sure that you always watch her, if she wants to take something cover it quickly, push away her hand and shout: What are you doing MIL? And remember it’s a rhetorical question- you don’t want to know her reasons you are making a point that she shouldn’t do it.
Start planning your point making during short visits and then move to longer. Don’t give up. It’s indeed like trading a toddler. And it’s a successful strategy. The key is to stay consistent, polite, calm and don’t go into explanations - do short sentences.

AnnaMagnani · 19/05/2026 18:42

With more detail about the wine incident, and that she always gives more things to her children in front of you, she's basically marking her territory.

I don't think you would accept it if she came to your house and cocked her leg in each corner of the lounge, but she is effectively doing this.

You and your DP are going to have to find your backbones.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 18:42

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 19/05/2026 18:20

This is why I said to forewarn your DH, he’s not allowed to change his order. He gets to pick what he wants to eat and you will order the same, if he changes his order you will keep changing yours to match his. Say it’s this or you refuse to go out for dinner again with MIL.

He has to be on board with you trying to change how you play MILs odd game, because (and be clear about this), you need to see if she can change or else she won’t be allowed to be in sole charge of any dcs. That if you have a daughter, you won’t allow MIL to force an eating disorder on her.

Keep calling it “your mums eating disorder”.

And yes, do the “are you ok because that sounds like an eating disorder” to MILs face. British politeness will rein in her reply but she’s unlikely to talk about her amazing diet again!

Be bold. Be brave. Do it for the dd who doesn’t exist yet.

@FancyBiscuitsLevel

This is why I said to forewarn your DH, he’s not allowed to change his order. He gets to pick what he wants to eat and you will order the same, if he changes his order you will keep changing yours to match his.

I like this idea. I might try it without telling him, although that might come across as antagonistic. Will have to think about it but will for sure do try some version of this - thank you!

OP posts:
illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 18:39

butterpuffed · 19/05/2026 18:32

This a very strange thread .

Not only does the MIL appear to have an aversion/ obsession with food but OP is intent on talking about/analysing every single thing connected to her behaviour. about it . Worrying .

Edited

You'd be even more worried if I told you about all the other stuff, but I have spared you. Although I think "intent" is an odd choice of words here, seeing as its a single thread about her behaviour, did you want the thread to end efter 2 posts? Also, it's nice to be able to speak to people who aren't related to her about this for once, is that illegal??? 😂

OP posts:
butterpuffed · 19/05/2026 18:32

This a very strange thread .

Not only does the MIL appear to have an aversion/ obsession with food but OP is intent on talking about/analysing every single thing connected to her behaviour. about it . Worrying .

AliCatWalk · 19/05/2026 18:31

Also bonus points if your UN is a King of the Hill reference 😸i am definitely reading it in Hank Hill's voice

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 19/05/2026 18:27

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 18:20

It was not in her house. The drink was poured to everyone present. Daughter was not present at the time. Daughter then arrives, at which point little is left of the nicer stuff so she poured that, and some of mine, into her daughters drink. I certainly was not helping myself to anything, if I put it that way. SIL didn't like it and preferred the cheaper stuff.

This is just part of a pattern of behaviour where she will sometimes take from me and give to her children. Even after she has offered me something like food or a drink. It's this "get your money's worth" and "hoarding" behaviour coupled with a bit of tribalism.

Could be food, could be dessert, could be a snack, could be TIME. Anything you could think of.

OP in the nicest possible way, you need to find your backbone.

Her behaviour isn’t ok. Your dh probably thinks it’s not ok but has been conditioned to accept it. You haven’t, why are you accepting it?

you need to start making a fuss, it may involve publicly embarrassing her, it definitely will involve your dh being on side that he has to back you not her if he wants your marriage to be a happy one.

You simply can’t allow a child to see their mum being treated this badly, so MIL can’t be part of any future child’s life. It’s a kindness to teach her now that you have had enough and won’t tolerate this behaviour anymore.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 18:27

HazelMember · 19/05/2026 18:17

Obviously comments like just leave him or don't have kids with him aren't super helpful

You and DH have been putting up this nonsense for years. It wouldn't be fair to inflict this on kids since neither of you are taking action.

What I can agree with you on is that it is not fair to inflict this type of disordered behaviour on children. 100% but I disagree that the solution is to split up or never have kids

OP posts:
fantam · 19/05/2026 18:24

Bring over a few brownies and one Space Cake. Make her eat the "edible" one and you eat the non cannabis version. She'll get the munchies after that and won't care what the heck you all eat.

Make it a habit every time you visit. You could have great fun with this. 😊

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 19/05/2026 18:20

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 17:22

@FancyBiscuitsLevel

I'll try that for restaurants. But, and I'm really not trying to be difficult - I promise - if I do this they will just change their order. There's an established rule about not ordering the same food.......

Also next time she says she has an amazing diet plan, you need to speak up “actually MIL are you ok because that sounds like an eating disorder.

This is a serious subject but the idea of doing this really made me crease up

This is why I said to forewarn your DH, he’s not allowed to change his order. He gets to pick what he wants to eat and you will order the same, if he changes his order you will keep changing yours to match his. Say it’s this or you refuse to go out for dinner again with MIL.

He has to be on board with you trying to change how you play MILs odd game, because (and be clear about this), you need to see if she can change or else she won’t be allowed to be in sole charge of any dcs. That if you have a daughter, you won’t allow MIL to force an eating disorder on her.

Keep calling it “your mums eating disorder”.

And yes, do the “are you ok because that sounds like an eating disorder” to MILs face. British politeness will rein in her reply but she’s unlikely to talk about her amazing diet again!

Be bold. Be brave. Do it for the dd who doesn’t exist yet.

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 18:20

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 19/05/2026 18:12

Have I told you about the time she poured some of my drink into her daughters glass, because she (her daughter) "had had less" (real reason: I had poured the last bit of the more expensive drink into my glass before her daughter arrived and she wanted her to have it, said I could drink refill with the other bottle (cheaper stuff)

Whose house was this in? She may have simply considered it entirely rude that you had helped yourself though most English people would have simply ensured that next time if they were saving a glass of something special for a family member that the bottle was put to one side while everyone moved onto something less £££. Actually pouring it back out of your glass is pretty odd behaviour and even weirder that your SIL presumably then drank it?

None of this is normal.

I would be unapologetic about ordering the same food - it's what you want to eat and laugh it off as they are welcome to the odd family challenge of covering the entire menu in one sitting just to tax the restaurant staff.

I would go out to buy a sandwich / arrive with groceries or go out to get some if there is no suitable food. If she is batshit about food, you can equally be so on your insistence that you need some..... in date preferably.

It was not in her house. The drink was poured to everyone present. Daughter was not present at the time. Daughter then arrives, at which point little is left of the nicer stuff so she poured that, and some of mine, into her daughters drink. I certainly was not helping myself to anything, if I put it that way. SIL didn't like it and preferred the cheaper stuff.

This is just part of a pattern of behaviour where she will sometimes take from me and give to her children. Even after she has offered me something like food or a drink. It's this "get your money's worth" and "hoarding" behaviour coupled with a bit of tribalism.

Could be food, could be dessert, could be a snack, could be TIME. Anything you could think of.

OP posts:
AnnaMagnani · 19/05/2026 18:19

It sounds as if over the course of the thread you have reaslied it's a game she plays: partly to manage her own diet, partly to manage the diet of everyone around her and partly to show she is the dominant woman present.

The best way to approach this is not to join in the game.

You experience 'a vibe' that you shouldn't order a big or expensive meal in a restaurant - ignore it and order what you like
She offers you something mouldy - you point out it's mouldy and refuse to eat it
She doesn't offer you any food at all - you take out your own food or just leave and go home

She is being phenomenally rude. You don't want to upset her but she doesn't care at all about upsetting you.

Just imagine her nitpicking at you about when you will lose the baby weight, or going on about your baby girl getting fat. It has to stop now.

HazelMember · 19/05/2026 18:17

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 18:12

Haha yes, well it's important to be polite, otherwise you might end up being rude!!

Not so much avoiding answering as I'm trying to read the different views and comments about his role in this, and reflect a bit so that I have something concrete to reply with. Obviously comments like just leave him or don't have kids with him aren't super helpful and not much to reply to that but I do appreciate people taking the time to say even that. It's a view, you know. All views welcome.

Your question is very easy to answer though. We're in our mid 30s and met in our early 20s

Obviously comments like just leave him or don't have kids with him aren't super helpful

You and DH have been putting up this nonsense for years. It wouldn't be fair to inflict this on kids since neither of you are taking action.

AliCatWalk · 19/05/2026 18:13

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 17:58

Yes and no. Yes because I have to see Aunty Joan sometime in the future and I'm unable to say "well MIL didn't really let me have any lunch so I was absolutely starving" (although maybe next time I will) because it's a numbers game, one person vs a family and I don't want to make it awkward. I mean really the more I write about this the more I'm getting pissed off with myself for being this stupid and playing this game with them.

Anyway, then it feels like they don't have the complete picture and I look unreasonable for going out to eat when MIL had food (or so she said).

No, because on some level I actually don't care but I care because it's my husbands family. Not sure if this makes sense but it's the best way I can explain it.

Like, would I eat meals with any one of them if it weren't for the fact we have this imposed relationship - probably not. A drink? Yes no problem 99% of the time.

@illtellyouwhat As a fellow passive person with my own mum having food issues, I can't imagine not at least "jokingly" protesting to most of these behaviors! Super rude of your MIL to commandeer your food & drink - in the examples you've provided, I don't think I would even be able to help myself from making a "umm wtf was that" face 😂& being like "what are you doing?!?" but laughing at the same time if that makes sense? I also wouldn't find it hard or unusual to [ask to] look at the expired food containers when she offers bad food and say, "oh wait, this is actually expired, do you have any that's in-date?" or something like that. It's not coming from a bad place, would even be arguably helpful for her, & it's a completely normal reaction, so you have nothing to feel shy or guilty about 🤷🏻‍♀️

As for any weight-related comments, I'd just give a non-committal "hmm" with a tone of annoyance/botheredness and then change the subject 😅 or just say "yeah, mmhmm, I actually don't really like talking about it" which would be a true statement & totally justified. Also would you ever be so bold as to intentionally order the same thing as someone else? Say, "I usually don't like to order the same thing, but that option looks so good, I think I'll get that too!"?

Again, I know this type of thing is all easier said than done, but I consider myself passive to a fault and am able to manage these types of phrases. They're true, coming from a rational & well-meaning place, & hopefully will get the message across enough to keep things moving along smoothly 😸good luck 💐

illtellyouwhat · 19/05/2026 18:12

Wauwinet · 19/05/2026 18:01

Well that explains some things. Are you American? Americans are absolutely lovely people but they are extremely polite (more so than we are in my experience), anxious to not offend anyone, and easily imposed upon.

@illtellyouwhat I know that you’re avoiding answering questions and engaging with anyone that mentions your husband but how old are the two of you and how old were you when you met?

Haha yes, well it's important to be polite, otherwise you might end up being rude!!

Not so much avoiding answering as I'm trying to read the different views and comments about his role in this, and reflect a bit so that I have something concrete to reply with. Obviously comments like just leave him or don't have kids with him aren't super helpful and not much to reply to that but I do appreciate people taking the time to say even that. It's a view, you know. All views welcome.

Your question is very easy to answer though. We're in our mid 30s and met in our early 20s

OP posts:
TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 19/05/2026 18:12

Have I told you about the time she poured some of my drink into her daughters glass, because she (her daughter) "had had less" (real reason: I had poured the last bit of the more expensive drink into my glass before her daughter arrived and she wanted her to have it, said I could drink refill with the other bottle (cheaper stuff)

Whose house was this in? She may have simply considered it entirely rude that you had helped yourself though most English people would have simply ensured that next time if they were saving a glass of something special for a family member that the bottle was put to one side while everyone moved onto something less £££. Actually pouring it back out of your glass is pretty odd behaviour and even weirder that your SIL presumably then drank it?

None of this is normal.

I would be unapologetic about ordering the same food - it's what you want to eat and laugh it off as they are welcome to the odd family challenge of covering the entire menu in one sitting just to tax the restaurant staff.

I would go out to buy a sandwich / arrive with groceries or go out to get some if there is no suitable food. If she is batshit about food, you can equally be so on your insistence that you need some..... in date preferably.

Swipe left for the next trending thread