Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to consider a third child in hopes of a girl?

829 replies

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 13:35

I'm posting here as it tends to get the most responses and I am trying to make a hard decision.

I have 2 beautiful little boys (2 and 8 weeks) I love them more than I ever thought I could love anyone. However, I feel a constant feeling of wanting to have a little girl. I have spoken to my partner about having a 3rd in 2 years or so and he has agreed but I can't quite bring myself to commit the thought in my mind.

Part of me thinks my partner is agreeing to it as he knows its what I want but he isn't overly invested in the 2 we have currently so I'm not sure.

I am also very concious that I could have a 3rd and it would be another boy (I would love him dearly but would I then want a 4th to try for a girl again)

Thirdly I am very aware that the world is bloody expensive and I am trying really hard not to work (or not more than very part time at a minimum wage job) during my boys childhood. We could technically afford 3 without me working/part time but it would be a very basic life for their entire childhood with very little outings or trips etc.

I know in my heart I want more children but would it be unreasonable given the above?

OP posts:
OneShyQuail · 12/05/2026 15:22

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 14:39

Out of curiosity how did you find such a big age gap between your 1/2 and your 3rd. I have considered not having him get a vasectomy and just waiting to see what life is like in 5 or so years but I worry the big age gap will suck!

6 years between my two girls. Its been fab. Eldest was capable of helping when sister was a baby, and as they both grew eldest helped more, taught her sister things, I honestly think its made her more mature and also my youngest is super independent now.
Age 12 and 6, both up and ready for school themselves from age 10 and 4, they both go downstairs and start sorting cereal and fruit and doing their packed lunches.
By the time we get downstairs they are eating breakfast its fabulous. Makes mornings a breeze....my youngest learnt so much from my eldest and they have a lovely bond

Its nice too as my 12 year old still plays with her sister, so it keeps her young and innocent

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 15:20

TeaPot496 · 12/05/2026 15:18

I feel you are being completely sexist and unreasonable. Children are whole, sentient beings in their own right. You said yourself not to stretch yourself financially. Your boys deserve the best.

Childbearing isn't a game of Pokémon.

Edited

They are 100% beings in their own right. That doesn't change wanting both?

OP posts:
TeaPot496 · 12/05/2026 15:18

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 14:03

I actually wanted a boy first not a girl. Was always my hope to have at least 1 boy first to be the big brother looking out for the little ones (silly I know but I had dreamt of kids for over 10 years)

I feel you are being completely sexist and unreasonable. Children are whole, sentient beings in their own right. You said yourself not to stretch yourself financially. Your boys deserve the best.

Childbearing isn't a game of Pokémon.

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 15:18

LondonPapa · 12/05/2026 15:17

Yes! Thank you!! I firmly agree with you.

As stated previously not suffering with postpartum depression.

GP posed the question about my partner having a vasectomy to avoid me having to be on contraception I don't handle well. It has created a discussion point and something I am thinking a lot about (I am an overthinker)

OP posts:
LondonPapa · 12/05/2026 15:17

Upstartled · 12/05/2026 13:40

At the risk of being patronising, you have an 8 week old baby and this yearning for a girl, as if the boy in your arms is the booby prize, sounds a bit like post partum depression.

Yes! Thank you!! I firmly agree with you.

Amberkitten7654321 · 12/05/2026 15:15

Controv but I was the same as you after 2 boys and didn’t feel complete. We had a 3rd and it was a girl and I 100% felt complete and definitely would never ever consider another baby! I wonder how I’d feel if it was another boy - we would never have had a 4th but I wonder if I’d never have felt totally complete?
She is amazing and completed our family but I am def much closer to/ have more in common to my sons. But it was never about “having a girl” so much an experiencing both? Maybe this will change as they get older (all still primary) but just to say I understand exactly how you feel.

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 15:15

ThisHeartyQuoter · 12/05/2026 15:13

You said he wasn't invested in the two you have. That sets huge alarm bells ringing for me

He loves my boys dearly but he isn't as motivated to parent as I am. He has got hugely better since ds2 came along and he had 7 weeks off for paternity leave.

Being a dad hasn't come naturally for him. But he is improving and trying and that is the important part. If he wasn't improving or trying then yes I would be very concerned!

OP posts:
VickyEadie · 12/05/2026 15:14

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 13:43

Honestly? I don't know. I always dreamed of having lots of children but having my 2 is hard when its mainly me parenting 90% of the time so I don't think I would want 4-5 kids like I planned.

However when my mind is very consumed by the idea of having a girl its hard to know if thats the reason I want more or if I genuinly still want more children.

I'm the girl in between 2 boys. I knew that mum very much wanted me to be a girl - but I'm afraid I was definitely NOT the girl she'd imagined. of the 3 of us, I was by far and away the least close to her (we really didn't get on, if truth be told). I always felt like I was a massive disappointment to her, despite achieving very highly (much higher than my brothers) in my academic life and my career.

I'm telling you this because you clearly have some vision of what this imagined daughter would be like. I spent my life not living up to my mother's expectations and she only told me she loved me when she was close to death.

redskyAtNigh · 12/05/2026 15:13

OP - you seem to have a fairy tale dream about your future family.

Forget it. This is real life and not a dream. Your children are small at the moment and you have total control over them. That will not last. They will become their own people and not the people you have dreamed of them being.

Think about practicalities - you have little money at the point your children are the cheapest they will ever be (if you're not paying childcare). Your partner works 6 days a week and is uninvolved with the children. (based on him getting more involved during paternity leave it does sound like this is due to lack of time rather than inclination). You don't want to work because you dream of spending time with your children, so that won't change.

ThisHeartyQuoter · 12/05/2026 15:13

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 15:06

My partner is the sole earner to allow me to be with the boys and comprimises on the lifestyle he would like for us all to allow me to do that.

So whilst yes its hard to do 90% I don't resent him for it.

You said he wasn't invested in the two you have. That sets huge alarm bells ringing for me

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 15:13

blackbirdcheesecake · 12/05/2026 15:10

I know someone wanted a girl after two boys. They had the sperm analysed and discovered it was boy heavy (whatever the medical term is for that I don’t know) so they went through the hassle and expense of getting the sperm treated in some way, or spun? - anyway whatever the process it was it meant the the remaining sperm would be 80% girl 20% boy.

Their third child was a boy 🤦‍♀️ The mother was very upset. Even though they knew there was still a 20% chance it would indeed be another boy.

I'm not desperate enough for a girl to go through all that 🙈

OP posts:
vellat · 12/05/2026 15:12

blackbirdcheesecake · 12/05/2026 15:10

I know someone wanted a girl after two boys. They had the sperm analysed and discovered it was boy heavy (whatever the medical term is for that I don’t know) so they went through the hassle and expense of getting the sperm treated in some way, or spun? - anyway whatever the process it was it meant the the remaining sperm would be 80% girl 20% boy.

Their third child was a boy 🤦‍♀️ The mother was very upset. Even though they knew there was still a 20% chance it would indeed be another boy.

What is this procedure!?

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 15:12

LeastOfMyWorries · 12/05/2026 15:06

I'm more worried you are talking about part time work, maybe giving up work, and still referring to "partner". You are making you position more and more vulnerable as time goes on. I'd think about protecting yourself and the children you already have before i thought about another.

And thats without thinking about how he isn't particularly invested? My husband works many many hours that is not an excuse not to be a loving and involved parent.

I am already in part time but will likely have to quit after maternity due to my partners days changing and them requiring him to be flexible.

He is getting lots better. Being a dad hasn't come naturally to him but believe me he has improved so so much!

OP posts:
blackbirdcheesecake · 12/05/2026 15:10

I know someone wanted a girl after two boys. They had the sperm analysed and discovered it was boy heavy (whatever the medical term is for that I don’t know) so they went through the hassle and expense of getting the sperm treated in some way, or spun? - anyway whatever the process it was it meant the the remaining sperm would be 80% girl 20% boy.

Their third child was a boy 🤦‍♀️ The mother was very upset. Even though they knew there was still a 20% chance it would indeed be another boy.

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 15:10

SpiceGirlsNeedAComeBack · 12/05/2026 15:05

Why would you want a 3rd child with someone whose a shit dad? YABU on both accounts.

He isn't shit! He has improved massively with relaxing and enjoying our eldest. He changes nappies, takes DS1 out on his off (or we all go out together) he will try to help out with other stuff depending on how much sleep etc he has. Just because I do 90% of everything (as I don't work) doesn't mean he is shit.

OP posts:
Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 15:08

Thistimearound · 12/05/2026 15:04

Are you planning to get married? Giving up your job and not earning puts you in a very vulnerable position if not married unless he is trying to make sure you are protected - eg house is in both names so you are accruing equity even when not working, putting savings in your name etc.

We are going to get married eventually. I need to sort it out. House is in a joint name. But house is the only real asset. Barely any pensions etc to share so I don't feel too rushed to sort it but I will get around to it.

OP posts:
LeastOfMyWorries · 12/05/2026 15:06

I'm more worried you are talking about part time work, maybe giving up work, and still referring to "partner". You are making you position more and more vulnerable as time goes on. I'd think about protecting yourself and the children you already have before i thought about another.

And thats without thinking about how he isn't particularly invested? My husband works many many hours that is not an excuse not to be a loving and involved parent.

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 15:06

ThisHeartyQuoter · 12/05/2026 15:03

Well maybe your lazy partner needs to step up

My partner is the sole earner to allow me to be with the boys and comprimises on the lifestyle he would like for us all to allow me to do that.

So whilst yes its hard to do 90% I don't resent him for it.

OP posts:
SpiceGirlsNeedAComeBack · 12/05/2026 15:05

Why would you want a 3rd child with someone whose a shit dad? YABU on both accounts.

Thistimearound · 12/05/2026 15:04

Are you planning to get married? Giving up your job and not earning puts you in a very vulnerable position if not married unless he is trying to make sure you are protected - eg house is in both names so you are accruing equity even when not working, putting savings in your name etc.

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 15:04

HideousKinky · 12/05/2026 14:52

he isn't overly invested in the 2 we have currently

Doesn't this concern you OP? Both in itself, and in terms of having more children?

He has improved a lot. He isn't an overly emotional person and he has come a long way. Equally he works and allows me not to even if it means we don't have a lot of money so I do a lot of everything. So whilst sometimes its hard, he is improving and I get he is stressed too.

OP posts:
ThisHeartyQuoter · 12/05/2026 15:03

Karma1387 · 12/05/2026 13:43

Honestly? I don't know. I always dreamed of having lots of children but having my 2 is hard when its mainly me parenting 90% of the time so I don't think I would want 4-5 kids like I planned.

However when my mind is very consumed by the idea of having a girl its hard to know if thats the reason I want more or if I genuinly still want more children.

Well maybe your lazy partner needs to step up

BunnyLake · 12/05/2026 15:01

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 12/05/2026 14:59

I understand your desire for a girl as I have two boys who I absolutely adore and wouldn’t change at all but do sometimes feel like there is certain things I will miss out on by not having a girl but then at the same time I will get so much from my boys, there’s no guarantee the girl would fit the picture I have in my mind and actually if I was to have a third I think a strong part of me would want it to be a boy to play with my existing boys and because my boys are amazing. Ultimately I just think I am so lucky to have them.

if you have another child make sure it’s because you want another child and not because you want a girl.

What do you feel you’ve missed out on? I ask because I have two sons (both adult now) and I never felt I had missed out on anything. Not judging, just genuinely curious.

forgotmyusername1 · 12/05/2026 15:01

I know someone who did this (mother of an ex boyfriend) - she ended up with 5 boys. She has though got 4 granddaughters and 4 grandsons so she got her girls by proxy the generation after. I have two boys - I would love a grandaughter one day but what will be will be

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 12/05/2026 14:59

I understand your desire for a girl as I have two boys who I absolutely adore and wouldn’t change at all but do sometimes feel like there is certain things I will miss out on by not having a girl but then at the same time I will get so much from my boys, there’s no guarantee the girl would fit the picture I have in my mind and actually if I was to have a third I think a strong part of me would want it to be a boy to play with my existing boys and because my boys are amazing. Ultimately I just think I am so lucky to have them.

if you have another child make sure it’s because you want another child and not because you want a girl.

Swipe left for the next trending thread