Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ds wants his dad to visit him but Dh isn’t comfortable

480 replies

heartmyheart · 12/05/2026 09:42

Ds is 20 and has never been particularly close to his dad, a lot of this is due to distance but in 20 years he’s only seen his dad a dozen times but they do chat on the phone.
His dad has another family now and has found it difficult to spend time with him.
However his dad has said he’d now like to come and visit him and ds has agreed.
Ds would like him to come over and see his house and where he lives and spend time with him here but Dh is saying he doesn’t want him to come in and that Ds is old enough to meet him somewhere without him needing to come over which would be uncomfortable for him.

On the other hand this is also Ds home and he wants his dad to come and visit so I am torn while I see both sides I don’t want to make Dh feel uncomfortable in his own home but I also don’t want Ds not to feel he can have his dad to visit in his home especially as he’s never come to see him before and he’s exited that he’s making the effort as it’s only ever been ds going to visit his dad until now.
I feel torn as it’s all of our home and everyone should have a say in who comes here.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Brokentoes85 · 21/05/2026 19:55

I don't think it's up to dh to accommodate ds absolutely useless father. I wouldn't blame him for feeling uncomfortable and resenting his appearance.

Why can't father have your son to visit his house?

He's referred to dh and dh family as not even family? Wow I see he's going out of his way to ingratiate himself.

At 20 years old, this isnt a delicate situation. He still lives at home so has to abide by his parents rules, meaning you and dh not ex. When he gets his own place, he can have deadbeat dad of the year around whenever he wants.

TIA1988 · 21/05/2026 18:55

I'm sorry but no . You need to respect your husbands wishes here .there is no need for your adult son to have him in your house. Id completely see the point from a co-parenting perspective if he where younger but from what you've wrote your ex isn't much of a dad so why now should you accommodate. Your not teaching your adult son healthy boundaries whatsoever. It's his dad's fault for not being present enough to care about his own flesh and blood and has prioritised his other family over your son and has been from the sounds of it breadcruming him .

S0j0urn4r · 16/05/2026 09:31

After the 'not real family' comment I wouldn't let this guy in my home.

DisforDarkChocolate · 15/05/2026 08:47

RainbowMoonbeam · 14/05/2026 20:46

Nope, I've read them. DH feels overlooked in favour of a father that contributed nothing.
DH needs to figure that out and not have it negatively impact DS.
Feeling a certain way in normal, allowing it to negatively impact others is optional.

You can say exactly the same for the DS.

RainbowMoonbeam · 14/05/2026 20:46

WeatherOrNothing · 14/05/2026 20:37

Clearly you have not even bothered to read the thread or the ops updates

Nope, I've read them. DH feels overlooked in favour of a father that contributed nothing.
DH needs to figure that out and not have it negatively impact DS.
Feeling a certain way in normal, allowing it to negatively impact others is optional.

WeatherOrNothing · 14/05/2026 20:37

RainbowMoonbeam · 14/05/2026 20:36

Assuming there's no personal safety reasons why DH doesn't want him there, DH needs to grow up.

Clearly you have not even bothered to read the thread or the ops updates

RainbowMoonbeam · 14/05/2026 20:36

Assuming there's no personal safety reasons why DH doesn't want him there, DH needs to grow up.

ThreadGuardDog · 14/05/2026 09:46

Avoidtheloo · 14/05/2026 06:17

DS strikes me as an inconsiderate thoughtless man

OP seems like a leaf in the wind. “Yeah, whatever”

DH… well, he deserves better than all this

Sums it up nicely.

FairyBatman · 14/05/2026 09:00

heartmyheart · 12/05/2026 19:18

I didn’t mean to ignore but Dh has worked full time and his parents have provided childcare for Ds so they very much felt they were family.
Ex has told Ds that he is the dad and those people are not even family as they are not even related to him.
This has naturally upset Dh.

The would make me significantly less torn. If he can’t at least be polite and respectful acknowledge the role that your DH is taken. I’m bringing him up then I wouldn’t want him in my house regardless of what DS said.

I really think you need to have your DH’s back on this one.

Sunshineandrainmakesrainbows · 14/05/2026 07:44

No chance my ex would be walking in to my home whether DC wanted to or not. At 20, your DS is capable of a relationship with his dad OUTWITH his home.
not sure why ex would want to come in to your home anyway 🥴 never mind the comments to his child (now a grown man!) about how the man and family that have actually seen him grow up “isn’t family”…. Tell the man to take a hike and if your son wishes to see him it has to be outwith!

Witchonenowbob · 14/05/2026 06:26

Avoidtheloo · 14/05/2026 06:17

DS strikes me as an inconsiderate thoughtless man

OP seems like a leaf in the wind. “Yeah, whatever”

DH… well, he deserves better than all this

Agreed, as I said previously I’d be calling into question my relationship with the OP (and the son!).

Avoidtheloo · 14/05/2026 06:17

Witchonenowbob · 14/05/2026 06:15

Agreed! The complacency is unreal! Maybe this is why the DS has such low standards that he thinks it’s acceptable to have the sperm donor in the family home.

The DH thank god, has some standards and given the whole situation a hard no!

DS strikes me as an inconsiderate thoughtless man

OP seems like a leaf in the wind. “Yeah, whatever”

DH… well, he deserves better than all this

Witchonenowbob · 14/05/2026 06:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Agreed! The complacency is unreal! Maybe this is why the DS has such low standards that he thinks it’s acceptable to have the sperm donor in the family home.

The DH thank god, has some standards and given the whole situation a hard no!

Avoidtheloo · 14/05/2026 06:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

labamba007 · 14/05/2026 05:28

If I was your DS dad I would suggest somewhere neutral. It would be strange to enter the home of my ex and her partner when I haven’t seen them in 20 years. Especially that DS is an adult. Who was the one who suggested meeting at your home? I note he’s not welcoming his DS into his home is he?

Newcybrown · 14/05/2026 05:15

heartmyheart · 12/05/2026 19:18

I didn’t mean to ignore but Dh has worked full time and his parents have provided childcare for Ds so they very much felt they were family.
Ex has told Ds that he is the dad and those people are not even family as they are not even related to him.
This has naturally upset Dh.

The ex who hasn't been there for his own son says this about the man and his family who raised him? Yeah I wouldn't want him in my house either! Also he is 20 not a child so no reason he needs to be in the home and seeing his room.
They can absolutely meet in a cafe or something, nice weather doesn't matter.

ThatBlackCat · 14/05/2026 01:45

PixieTales · 14/05/2026 01:36

Your the one obsessing over this thread which again I pointed out upthread.

It’s not healthy.

You can call me whatever names you like but it doesn’t mean anything.

I'm not the one calling a person a 'weirdo' or a 'sad little loser'. Those names you call me are a reflection on you, not me. You're obsessed with me. Please leave me alone.

Selkie33 · 14/05/2026 01:41

heartmyheart · 12/05/2026 19:18

I didn’t mean to ignore but Dh has worked full time and his parents have provided childcare for Ds so they very much felt they were family.
Ex has told Ds that he is the dad and those people are not even family as they are not even related to him.
This has naturally upset Dh.

@heartmyheart I really do wonder if you underestimate what it has taken for your husband to bring up another man's child?

And now, because "you are neutral" you will allow your ex deadbeat to waltz into the home you and your husband have built with your son?

Your son is old enough to meet his Dad on neutral territory, outside, and you should not allow him to barge his way into the safe space that you and your husband have created for your boy.

I am somewhat surprised that you are so passive about it all, can you really not see how and why this is adversely affecting your husband @heartmyheart?

Choose your side very carefully.

PixieTales · 14/05/2026 01:36

ThatBlackCat · 14/05/2026 01:29

If you haven't read Talk Guidelines you shouldn't be posting on this site. Your posts come across as extremely aggressive, disrespectful and very unhinged. Which is why I imagine you've been reported. You sound like you need anger management help.

" you sad little loser"

"weirdo"

Your words certainly are very aggressive and full of anger and hate. There is no need to be so abusive and nasty. Nor obsess over me.

Edited

Your the one obsessing over this thread which again I pointed out upthread.

It’s not healthy.

You can call me whatever names you like but it doesn’t mean anything.

ThatBlackCat · 14/05/2026 01:29

PixieTales · 14/05/2026 01:22

I wouldn’t be aware of the ‘guidelines’ but I’ve read all your posts and you come across as aggressive and disrespectful which is why you stood out to me like a similar poster on this same thread.

If you haven't read Talk Guidelines you shouldn't be posting on this site. Your posts come across as extremely aggressive, disrespectful and very unhinged. Which is why I imagine you've been reported. You sound like you need anger management help.

" you sad little loser"

"weirdo"

Your words certainly are very aggressive and full of anger and hate. There is no need to be so abusive and nasty. Nor obsess over me.

Happyjoe · 14/05/2026 01:26

heartmyheart · 12/05/2026 19:18

I didn’t mean to ignore but Dh has worked full time and his parents have provided childcare for Ds so they very much felt they were family.
Ex has told Ds that he is the dad and those people are not even family as they are not even related to him.
This has naturally upset Dh.

I wonder why he's your ex!
I would be rather concerned that he is up for developing a relationship with your son if he's like this.

PixieTales · 14/05/2026 01:22

ThatBlackCat · 14/05/2026 01:10

It isn't even physically possible to change your name mid thread on Mumsnet. They will tell you. And, that is troll hunting which is against the guidelines on Mumsnet. All you've done is post unhinged abuse and attacks and accusations.

I wouldn’t be aware of the ‘guidelines’ but I’ve read all your posts and you come across as aggressive and disrespectful which is why you stood out to me like a similar poster on this same thread.

ThatBlackCat · 14/05/2026 01:10

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

It isn't even physically possible to change your name mid thread on Mumsnet. They will tell you. And, that is troll hunting which is against the guidelines on Mumsnet. All you've done is post unhinged abuse and attacks and accusations.

PixieTales · 14/05/2026 01:07

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

AcrossthePond55 · 14/05/2026 01:02

sittingonabeach · 13/05/2026 15:03

We don’t know how the DS reacted to that comment that his dad made. And if dad does visit the home it will be pretty obvious what impact the DH has had on the son’s life.

@AcrossthePond55 but cannot you see that this son could have similar trauma to an adopted child. One parent has pretty much given him up and made a nice new shiny family which he is not part of. As far as we aware he is not rejecting DH’s part in his life (again OP hasn’t said anything about that).

If OP hasn’t seen dad for over 20 years (for all we know they didn’t really have a relationship) the son might not really see him as an ex of mum, just his dad. So not really picking up why it could be awkward. He just wants to show his dad his home. He may not realise the dad may have an ulterior motive.

And in respect of the dad’s comment, how many threads on MN do we see posters with a similar attitude especially in respect of step grandparents saying they are not family. If a stepdad is on the scene and dad is around even if only on the end of the phone, then stepdad isn’t dad. Again we don’t know how the son views DH and his parents

I don't believe that adopted = trauma 100% of the time. Perhaps myself, my brother, my 2 adopted cousins, and 1adopted aunt are unusual in that none of us feel we have experienced any 'trauma' at being adopted.

As far as 'other threads' this is not a case of either the step-dad or his parents not accepting and treating DS as 'one of their own' per OP's own words ("Dh has worked full time and his parents have provided childcare for Ds so they very much felt they were family"), so those threads aren't really relevant.

You're right, we don't know how the son views DH and DH's parents. But we know how they feel about him.