Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angela Raynor still doesnt get it.

512 replies

ThisDandyWriter · 11/05/2026 08:08

I’ve just read Angela’s Raynor’s statement about why Labour did so badly and what they need to do to change….aibu to think SHE STILL DOESNT GET IT!! Nothing mentioned about welfare, nothing mentioned about immigration-these are 2 subjects most talked about as the reasons why people didn’t vote for Labour.
she might not like it-but id they want to stay in power, they MUST tackle these subjects and not just ignore them because they dint fit her narrative.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 12/05/2026 10:14

Thefastandthecurious5 · 12/05/2026 10:02

You also appear to have forgotten her getting trouble with HMRC not once but twice, lying in public, lying about politics to kids in a school, her thuggish outburst in the House of Commons etc etc.

What did she say to kids in a school? And she didn’t lie to HMRC twice.

Could I politely suggest that you read up a bit more on topics before you make such confident but incorrect assertions? You’ve done it several times now. And if you want to quote something I’ve said you can put an asterisk directly at the beginning and end of the text you are quoting to make it bold.

She’s had issues with not paying the correct stamp duty in her flat in Hove and a capital gains tax issue on her properties in Stockport. Despite having access to the best tax advice there is. We have to ask if it is deliberate fraud or unbelievable incompetence?

She also visited a school and was filmed lying about Reform policies to children which breaks the law in political impartiality and non partisan requirements in schools.

spectator.com/article/the-angela-rayner-tax-row-deepens/

Happyjoe · 12/05/2026 10:04

BananaPeels · 12/05/2026 08:36

Lots of companies would volunteer to pay their employees more. I work at one of them. We sat and went through all the finances working out how we could do the annual rises. We couldn’t though. Why? Business rates increased by £10k. That was on top of the extra % on Ni a couple of years ago. All our potential pay rises got absorbed into extra government tax. Had that council tax bill not come in we would have paid that to our employees. Gutting honestly. I know people on mumsnet think that businesses are the bogeymen and the fat cats are creaming off the profits but in my limited experience in a lot of small businesses, most want to pay their employees well and employ lots of people but the grind of every increasing taxes mean it hasn’t been possible for a while. Allowing lower wages for some employees would mean we could employ more young people to gain experience. At the moment we have 1 when a few years ago we’d have had 3/4.

Edited

Your business may be decent, a heck of a lot are not. Business are there to make a profit and the bigger the profit the happier they are.

Many companies offer zero hour contracts, min wage for pretty much all of the hospitality sector, no pay rises for years for many companies (my partner for example works at a well-to-do company that turns over millions and no pay rise for 6 years for any of the staff).

While I agree it is getting difficult for businesses, businesses don't value their workers, these issues were happening before Labour came into power.

Thefastandthecurious5 · 12/05/2026 10:02

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 12/05/2026 07:14

Apart from most of your list being unproven allegations - the major difference here is that she was Deputy Prime Minister and he isn’t.

You also appear to have forgotten her getting trouble with HMRC not once but twice, lying in public, lying about politics to kids in a school, her thuggish outburst in the House of Commons etc etc.

She wasn’t even fit for office she held as her failure to pay tax due - ‘saint’ she is not.

You also appear to have forgotten her getting trouble with HMRC not once but twice, lying in public, lying about politics to kids in a school, her thuggish outburst in the House of Commons etc etc.

What did she say to kids in a school? And she didn’t lie to HMRC twice.

Happyjoe · 12/05/2026 09:55

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 12/05/2026 07:14

Apart from most of your list being unproven allegations - the major difference here is that she was Deputy Prime Minister and he isn’t.

You also appear to have forgotten her getting trouble with HMRC not once but twice, lying in public, lying about politics to kids in a school, her thuggish outburst in the House of Commons etc etc.

She wasn’t even fit for office she held as her failure to pay tax due - ‘saint’ she is not.

It's fine. I get it. You're ok with any shit as long as the shit wears a suit.

FatEndoftheWedge · 12/05/2026 08:58

@Havanananana I was very into this subject at the time and it all came out in many exposes

BananaPeels · 12/05/2026 08:36

Havanananana · 12/05/2026 08:06

Blair did not change the workers' rights barriers - the Eastern European countries joined the EU and as such their citizens received the right to work anywhere in the EU, including in the UK.

The anti-EU narrative was that alll of these foreign workers were keeping wages low, despite the legal obligation to be paid at least the minimum wage, and one of the Brexit supporters claims was that once these workers all buggered off back where they came from, wages and employment for the poor Brits would boom. Which was quickly proven to be nonsense.

Hundreds of thousands of Europeans left leaving the UK short of agricultural workers, lorry drivers, construction workers, factory workers and healthcare workers. Crops rotted in the fields, delivery times were extended, construction projects delayed - and instead of the British workers filling the gaps, the UK began sourcing labour from Nigeria, Nepal, Zimbabwe and Ukraine instead.
Wages didn't rise and one stick that the right-wing is now trying to beat Labour with is the increase in the minimum wage - necessary because businesses are never going to voluntarily increase wages. Remember too that the "Britannia Unchained" Conservatives and Reform want to abolish the minimum wage on the basis that in order to compete with the low-wage economies of the world, the UK employers need to be able to pay as little as possible. Welcome to Sweatshop Brexitannia - already in place in the fields of East Anglia and the textile factories of the East Midlands, and coming soon to a town near you.

Lots of companies would volunteer to pay their employees more. I work at one of them. We sat and went through all the finances working out how we could do the annual rises. We couldn’t though. Why? Business rates increased by £10k. That was on top of the extra % on Ni a couple of years ago. All our potential pay rises got absorbed into extra government tax. Had that council tax bill not come in we would have paid that to our employees. Gutting honestly. I know people on mumsnet think that businesses are the bogeymen and the fat cats are creaming off the profits but in my limited experience in a lot of small businesses, most want to pay their employees well and employ lots of people but the grind of every increasing taxes mean it hasn’t been possible for a while. Allowing lower wages for some employees would mean we could employ more young people to gain experience. At the moment we have 1 when a few years ago we’d have had 3/4.

HelmholtzWatson · 12/05/2026 08:18

HappiestSleeping · 12/05/2026 06:56

Two things stand out in that report. The two who were caught were advisers giving spurious advice, QED it wasn't the asylum seekers trying to do it until they were advised to do so, and secondly, they've been caught and dealt with.

I heard one of the applicants interviewed, and he couldn't believe he was being advised to say certain things.

And yes, there will always be some who take the piss, but it isn't the majority.

Okay, so we've gone from "nobody is abusing the system" to "it isn't the majority", so I've proved my point.

Havanananana · 12/05/2026 08:06

FatEndoftheWedge · 11/05/2026 17:11

@Mangelwurzelfortea many labour MPs supported Brexit.

The wonderful lord frank field , old Mp for Birkenhead supported it because he saw his poorest of the poor constituents further affected in every way by the huge volume of esteem European immigrants who came when Blair changed the workers rights barriers.

Blair did not change the workers' rights barriers - the Eastern European countries joined the EU and as such their citizens received the right to work anywhere in the EU, including in the UK.

The anti-EU narrative was that alll of these foreign workers were keeping wages low, despite the legal obligation to be paid at least the minimum wage, and one of the Brexit supporters claims was that once these workers all buggered off back where they came from, wages and employment for the poor Brits would boom. Which was quickly proven to be nonsense.

Hundreds of thousands of Europeans left leaving the UK short of agricultural workers, lorry drivers, construction workers, factory workers and healthcare workers. Crops rotted in the fields, delivery times were extended, construction projects delayed - and instead of the British workers filling the gaps, the UK began sourcing labour from Nigeria, Nepal, Zimbabwe and Ukraine instead.
Wages didn't rise and one stick that the right-wing is now trying to beat Labour with is the increase in the minimum wage - necessary because businesses are never going to voluntarily increase wages. Remember too that the "Britannia Unchained" Conservatives and Reform want to abolish the minimum wage on the basis that in order to compete with the low-wage economies of the world, the UK employers need to be able to pay as little as possible. Welcome to Sweatshop Brexitannia - already in place in the fields of East Anglia and the textile factories of the East Midlands, and coming soon to a town near you.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 12/05/2026 07:14

Happyjoe · 12/05/2026 00:21

Modicum of dignity? She was on down time, I'd argue should be private but are you really comparing her dignity to someone who's said to have goose-stepped in his youth, sang Hitler Youth songs, said he thought Andrew Tate was an important role model for young men, has taken money and not declared it, lied on brexit campaigns, dodged stamp duty on his Clacton house, lied, lied some more... the list can continue but I guess none of that matters because he wears a suit.

Angela Rayner is a saint in comparison.

Apart from most of your list being unproven allegations - the major difference here is that she was Deputy Prime Minister and he isn’t.

You also appear to have forgotten her getting trouble with HMRC not once but twice, lying in public, lying about politics to kids in a school, her thuggish outburst in the House of Commons etc etc.

She wasn’t even fit for office she held as her failure to pay tax due - ‘saint’ she is not.

BananaPeels · 12/05/2026 07:10

StarlightLady · 11/05/2026 20:08

Playing gambling games with other people’s money and making millions is not “working in finance”. Accountancy is.

No it isn’t! Finance is an industry - it means you work in the financial services sector. If you work in finance you work ostensibly is the banking sector but could be insurance or asset management. If you are an accountant you describe yourself as an accountant. 2 different things. You can be an accountant working in Finance but also working in industry!

and the ‘gambling’ you describe is the backbone of about 8% of GDP so pretty important. You might not like how Farage made his money but at the moment people like him are contributing a large amount to the economy.

HappiestSleeping · 12/05/2026 06:56

HelmholtzWatson · 12/05/2026 05:07

"nobody is abusing the system"? You must not have been keeping up with the news recently...

Two people arrested after BBC asylum investigation

Also, this "convert" tried to blow up a women's hospital when his asylum claim was rejected.

Liverpool Women's Hospital bomber had asylum grievance, police say - BBC News

Two things stand out in that report. The two who were caught were advisers giving spurious advice, QED it wasn't the asylum seekers trying to do it until they were advised to do so, and secondly, they've been caught and dealt with.

I heard one of the applicants interviewed, and he couldn't believe he was being advised to say certain things.

And yes, there will always be some who take the piss, but it isn't the majority.

HelmholtzWatson · 12/05/2026 05:07

HappiestSleeping · 11/05/2026 20:16

There is little proof of that happening though, and even if it does, their applications are reviewed every five years.

Also, as I said, if we don't like the criteria, we should change the system.

"nobody is abusing the system"? You must not have been keeping up with the news recently...

Two people arrested after BBC asylum investigation

Also, this "convert" tried to blow up a women's hospital when his asylum claim was rejected.

Liverpool Women's Hospital bomber had asylum grievance, police say - BBC News

An officer enters a house.

Two people arrested after BBC asylum investigation

A BBC report revealed some immigration advisers are helping asylum seekers pretend to be gay to stay in the country.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cg7p09p2evxo

Happyjoe · 12/05/2026 00:21

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 11/05/2026 23:26

I think the Deputy Prime Minister of the United Kingdom (as she was at the time) should have a modicum of dignity in public, yes.

She had access to the best media training available in the British government but still managed to do that.

She also had access to the best tax advisors in the country but look where that ended - I wonder if she’s paid us what she owes yet? It might seem to some that her behaviour and judgement is pretty poor. She is not remotely a good representative for our country.

Modicum of dignity? She was on down time, I'd argue should be private but are you really comparing her dignity to someone who's said to have goose-stepped in his youth, sang Hitler Youth songs, said he thought Andrew Tate was an important role model for young men, has taken money and not declared it, lied on brexit campaigns, dodged stamp duty on his Clacton house, lied, lied some more... the list can continue but I guess none of that matters because he wears a suit.

Angela Rayner is a saint in comparison.

Thefastandthecurious5 · 12/05/2026 00:13

Bunny65 · 12/05/2026 00:07

Farage seems to have hypnotised the country to believe that all their problems are down to refugees in small boats. It simply isn't true. His worst nightmare would be another government dealing with the problem because he truly has nothing else to offer and he seems to be drunk on the idea of power. The councils where Reform won last time have had lots of problems. Many of the councillors have walked out because they were just names on paper - they didn't really want the job and they weren't community minded. All this nonsense about a Doge-style clean up of council waste was empty rhetoric - most of the council budget goes on social care, housing etc. There isn't enough money from central government so they are always broke. And the small boat problem became much worse after Brexit. As for flying out 1000s of asylum seekers every day - where does he think he is going to fly them to? You can't send people to a country that won't accept them.

As for flying out 1000s of asylum seekers every day - where does he think he is going to fly them to? You can't send people to a country that won't accept them.

Exactly. He’ll face the same problem Suella Braverman did. She thought she cracked it with the Rwanda plan. Did she actually? Nope.

Thefastandthecurious5 · 12/05/2026 00:12

Bunny65 · 12/05/2026 00:07

Farage seems to have hypnotised the country to believe that all their problems are down to refugees in small boats. It simply isn't true. His worst nightmare would be another government dealing with the problem because he truly has nothing else to offer and he seems to be drunk on the idea of power. The councils where Reform won last time have had lots of problems. Many of the councillors have walked out because they were just names on paper - they didn't really want the job and they weren't community minded. All this nonsense about a Doge-style clean up of council waste was empty rhetoric - most of the council budget goes on social care, housing etc. There isn't enough money from central government so they are always broke. And the small boat problem became much worse after Brexit. As for flying out 1000s of asylum seekers every day - where does he think he is going to fly them to? You can't send people to a country that won't accept them.

I’m genuinely curious about what Farage do if he ever gets into government. I don’t get how he’d be any better than what we’ve had so far. He has no qualifications, 2 years’ experience as an MP and no particular talents or skills other than self-promotion and making off-colour jokes.

Bunny65 · 12/05/2026 00:07

HappiestSleeping · 11/05/2026 08:20

The irony is that net migration is down 69% under this government.

Sadly, I think it could get to zero, and Farage would still be spouting "stop the boats".

Farage seems to have hypnotised the country to believe that all their problems are down to refugees in small boats. It simply isn't true. His worst nightmare would be another government dealing with the problem because he truly has nothing else to offer and he seems to be drunk on the idea of power. The councils where Reform won last time have had lots of problems. Many of the councillors have walked out because they were just names on paper - they didn't really want the job and they weren't community minded. All this nonsense about a Doge-style clean up of council waste was empty rhetoric - most of the council budget goes on social care, housing etc. There isn't enough money from central government so they are always broke. And the small boat problem became much worse after Brexit. As for flying out 1000s of asylum seekers every day - where does he think he is going to fly them to? You can't send people to a country that won't accept them.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 11/05/2026 23:26

Happyjoe · 11/05/2026 22:26

How dare she be in a vest in a boat eh?! Put that woman in her place, now!

As a note, Nige's photo's are carefully curated media shots, she was photographed with a long lens on downtime and yet still judged.

I think the Deputy Prime Minister of the United Kingdom (as she was at the time) should have a modicum of dignity in public, yes.

She had access to the best media training available in the British government but still managed to do that.

She also had access to the best tax advisors in the country but look where that ended - I wonder if she’s paid us what she owes yet? It might seem to some that her behaviour and judgement is pretty poor. She is not remotely a good representative for our country.

Happyjoe · 11/05/2026 22:47

Lifeomars · 11/05/2026 20:31

Ooh, forgotten about her, but now I think about her i recall her saying it was ok to give your left over antbiotics to a friend or relative during her brief tenure as Health Secretary, what a loss to health and wellbing she was!

Lol, yes, she was a shocker! She does hold some strange... views. House of Lords now isn't she? Good grief.

Thefastandthecurious5 · 11/05/2026 22:35

Happyjoe · 11/05/2026 22:27

The cult of Trump..

Got it in one.

Happyjoe · 11/05/2026 22:27

Thefastandthecurious5 · 11/05/2026 21:59

Some Trump voters are refusing to accept it tbh.

The cult of Trump..

Happyjoe · 11/05/2026 22:26

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 11/05/2026 19:08

Although arguably slightly less healthy, as Nigel Farage was standing fully clothed enjoying his pint and his fag - Angela was looking far less dignified floating around in her vest on a dinghy with her vape.

I don’t understand your point about different standard as that is not what happened here. If Angela was standing around fully clothed with a pint and a fag but got slated for it you might have a point but she didn’t.

I’ll look forward to your Farage thread - if the extent of the gripes that people have with him are the often fictional or creative ones being aired on this thread, it will be a pretty positive one.

How dare she be in a vest in a boat eh?! Put that woman in her place, now!

As a note, Nige's photo's are carefully curated media shots, she was photographed with a long lens on downtime and yet still judged.

Thefastandthecurious5 · 11/05/2026 21:59

Addocorlo · 11/05/2026 21:58

Surely unless you’re a millionaire you don’t need the mainstream media to tell you living standards are falling? Because you’ll notice it with your own eyes

Some Trump voters are refusing to accept it tbh.

Thefastandthecurious5 · 11/05/2026 21:58

Zebedee999 · 11/05/2026 21:50

You're making stuff up (or lieing as you would say).

US GDP in 2024 was 2.8% vs 1.1% for the UK
US GDP in 2025 was 2.1% vs 1.4% for the UK
US GDP forecast 2026 is 1.9-2.6% vs 0.6-1.1% for the UK

Looking at numbers alone it looks like Trump's economic policies deliver far better growth than Starmer's by a very long way. So if Reform's policies are simply a copy of Trump's as you assert the the evidence is that GDP growth wise Reform will do far better than Labour are.

@ProudCat wasn’t talking about growth but living standards. It is true that living standards have gone down under Trump, as shown in a wide range of media sources:

https://www.epi.org/publication/47-ways-trump-has-made-life-less-affordable-in-his-first-year/

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2026/mar/14/americans-struggle-affordability-despite-trump-claims

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c04vqyl13rlo

Look at this: https://www.economist.com/interactive/trump-approval-tracker/economy

GDP grew at 2.0% per year in Q1. Inflation is at 3.0%. The unemployment rate is 4.3%. The S&P 500 is up 22.3% since he took office.

Before Donald Trump’s tariffs, America had come tantalisingly close to vanquishing inflation. In April of last year annual inflation was 2.3%, just above the Federal Reserve’s target of 2%. After that it shot up, reaching 3% in September, then dipped to 2.7%. The annual rate fell to 2.4% in January. The conflict in Iran is expected to push up prices again.

‘Everything is going up’: Americans struggle with affordability despite Trump’s claims

US workers are finding it difficult to afford basic necessities as the president claims ‘the economy is roaring back’

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2026/mar/14/americans-struggle-affordability-despite-trump-claims

Addocorlo · 11/05/2026 21:58

Thefastandthecurious5 · 11/05/2026 21:53

I think many Trump voters aren’t aware of falling living standards in the US because they exclusively consume pro-Trump media and distrust any mainstream/legacy media. I spoke about this with a British relative who supports Trump (and Reform), doesn’t read any mainstream media and didn’t seem aware of falling living standards (and likely didn’t want to accept it).

Surely unless you’re a millionaire you don’t need the mainstream media to tell you living standards are falling? Because you’ll notice it with your own eyes

Thefastandthecurious5 · 11/05/2026 21:53

ProudCat · 11/05/2026 21:40

Because people believed the lies.

We all know that change needs to happen. Think of it this way, if the Reform policies, that are a cut out from Trump's policies, really work, then why is the US in the shitter and the global economy failing?

Look it up. The standard of living in the US is going down big time. This must be what Reform voters want. The evidence is there for everyone to see. If people want to blindly believe something else, then that's going to be on them.

I think many Trump voters aren’t aware of falling living standards in the US because they exclusively consume pro-Trump media and distrust any mainstream/legacy media. I spoke about this with a British relative who supports Trump (and Reform), doesn’t read any mainstream media and didn’t seem aware of falling living standards (and likely didn’t want to accept it).