Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel disheartened by earning into the higher tax band?

340 replies

Chocolateapot · 10/05/2026 22:19

I have finally after many many years of studying progressed in my career to just slightly above the 40% tax threshold. Unfortunately I’ve realised this now means any additional income I earn is now taxed at 40%, student loan 9% and 2% national insurance, essentially giving a marginal tax rate of 51%.

Not sure why I bothered tbh

OP posts:
TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 11/05/2026 07:03

Enjoy it while it lasts OP. IF Reform get into government you'll be paying hundreds a month in Health Insurance and inflation on top.

Butterme · 11/05/2026 07:00

Surely you’re not being forced to do this job though?

Just take a job that’s lower paid if you feel you’ll be better off.

Tbh I feel more sorry for those who’ve spent years working their asses off and still can’t earn over the £35k mark.

At least you have options now.

Beesandhoney123 · 11/05/2026 06:56

Pensions are already taxed when you start drawing down. They are also going to be included in your total or inheritance tax purposes.

There are a few things you can to legally to pay less tax. It's not dodging paying, its legal means to reduce your personal tax burden. You need to see a really experienced tax accountant. Do your own research before going. Your bank might provide advice, you don't have to take it.

Ask your employer what alternatives are in place regarding the tax effect on high earners. Or do you just move abroad.

thepariscrimefiles · 11/05/2026 06:48

OneTealShaker · 10/05/2026 23:23

Someone has to pay for the freebie takers, OP. Who is going to pay their benefits, if not you and the other mugs who try and better themselves and their families. This is what you get for the audacity to earn a living and stand up on your own two feet.

Like PP said. Socialism at work.

How the fuck is this 'Socialism at work' when higher earners have been taxed at the 40% tax rate during the previous 14 years of various Conservative governments?

Lougle · 11/05/2026 06:46

happybug1234 · 11/05/2026 05:59

Seriously… universal credit it not earned income. Hardly the same thing is it.

If someone is going out to work, and that work doesn't pay enough for them to live, so has Government has granted them an allowance to bridge the gap, then why is that less deserving money than someone who is going out to work and that work does pay enough for them to live?

Would the optics be better if there were no in-work benefits, so that only people out of work got 'benefits' and businesses were given huge subsidies so that they could pay a reasonable wage? No. Because then people would moan that they work so hard as a high status professional and they're only getting a bit more than the waitress/bin man/cleaner, so what's the point?

At least with in work benefits, society knows where to point the finger at the scum, hey?

JuliettaCaeser · 11/05/2026 06:40

At least it’s deducted at source I have to pay mine over. So it’s in my bank account then I have to transfer it over to hmrc. Paid £30k to them last month. Of course it’s right to pay tax but this is ridiculous.

BIossomtoes · 11/05/2026 06:40

cricketnut77 · 10/05/2026 22:26

Socialism at work

Funny that it would have been exactly the same under the last government. 🙄

Chocolateapot · 11/05/2026 06:35

Posters are right as it’s a DB pension in the NHS so salary sacrifice impacts on this. I am already putting 10.7% in there (defined contribution) but may look at a SIPP.

For those who are saying they would swap, would you swap the years of studying I’ve done - basically sacrificed my 20s to do a job that I thought would be worthwhile. Just feeling a bit dispirited to see so much being deducted every month.

Im on a Plan 1 student loan (unlucky fuckers on Plan 2 have my full sympathy) and I have been paying it back for 9 years as I’ve worked full-time since graduating.

Ive paid of ….. drum roll £189 in TOTAL.

OP posts:
IDontHateRainbows · 11/05/2026 06:30

JuliettaCaeser · 10/05/2026 22:45

Solidarity. Just seems some of us are paying in for the “free at the point of use” services and many frankly are not paying but still get the benefit of it.
.

And some are paying in and not seeing the benefit, I for one am on a massive nhs waiting list and may have to go private rather than suffer for months.

dompedro · 11/05/2026 06:27

Hiddeninthetrees · 11/05/2026 06:14

Why would it reduce your pension? It shouldn't affect that at all. When we worked it out, it means that the money you would have paid in tax is the bit that pays for your car. It should also bring your salary down enough that you get your personal allowance back and access to things like free childcare? I'm definitely not an expert, but it may be worth double checking and fully running the numbers to check.

Salary sacrifice affects your pension (certainly your NHS pension) as it’s a DB pension.

eedie135 · 11/05/2026 06:26

Pension, pension, pension!!!!

Malasana · 11/05/2026 06:26

SomedayIllBeSaturdayNight · 10/05/2026 22:36

Happy to trade wages with you op!

Same - I’ll trade as well.

AyeupDuck · 11/05/2026 06:20

DH stuck additional voluntary contributions in to his pension scheme for many years. I think you can put in up to 60k PA.

GeneralPeter · 11/05/2026 06:17

Anyahyacinth · 10/05/2026 23:12

Depends really if you want to live in a society that isn't falling apart. Care staff, nurses other hard working people work extraordinarily hard - 12 hours shifts etc..who do you think should pay more (once they have enough) ?

If the answer is billionaires and you vote to make it happen then you'd at least be consistent...but are you? Or is it just moaning about a personal situation?

Our state NHS and social care model is one big reason wages in that sector are so low. 70-80% of the total market is effectively one buyer: the govt. If you don’t like abuses of monopoly power (monopsony, technically) start there.

38thparallel · 11/05/2026 06:17

Uc days out tickets are often £1 entry

Yes and families are included in the lower entry fee.

Hiddeninthetrees · 11/05/2026 06:14

Chocolateapot · 11/05/2026 06:09

I looked and an electric car would still reduce my take home pay by 300+ compare to my car loan of £180 and it would reduce my pension so I don’t think it’s worth it for me at this point but thank you for the suggestion, I’ll take another look.

Why would it reduce your pension? It shouldn't affect that at all. When we worked it out, it means that the money you would have paid in tax is the bit that pays for your car. It should also bring your salary down enough that you get your personal allowance back and access to things like free childcare? I'm definitely not an expert, but it may be worth double checking and fully running the numbers to check.

Chocolateapot · 11/05/2026 06:09

Hiddeninthetrees · 11/05/2026 06:05

I'm not the best at explaining it but roughly it's because the EV tax rate is only 4%. If you get one on a salary sacrifice scheme the cost is deducted before tax, so brings your overall tax down to below the threshold. Obviously it only makes sense if you actually need and want a car. It's to encourage people into using electric cars.

I looked and an electric car would still reduce my take home pay by 300+ compare to my car loan of £180 and it would reduce my pension so I don’t think it’s worth it for me at this point but thank you for the suggestion, I’ll take another look.

OP posts:
Chocolateapot · 11/05/2026 06:07

I am more than happy to pay tax and “pay my way” but as others have stated, I’m getting a bit sick of being seen as a cash cow with the biggest shoulders.

When I was 17, I had no idea that a student loan would mean that I paid 9% of my earnings over the threshold or that this threshold would be frozen so that it starts to impact on my wage significantly (it’s more than my car loan every month). None of my family have ever been to university or have earned into the higher tax band so we didn’t really have any idea what it would mean.

I also work in the NHS so every day see the appalling state of the public services so no I’m not “grateful” to be contributing, it’s a disgrace.

OP posts:
Hiddeninthetrees · 11/05/2026 06:05

Bjorkdidit · 11/05/2026 05:59

How does that work @Hiddeninthetrees? When I had a company car, it increased my tax, not reduced it. A lot of people gave up their company cars when they got promoted into the higher rate tax band, because it doubled the amount of tax they paid which, on top of a hefty contribution for personal use, made it an expensive way to run a car.

I'm not the best at explaining it but roughly it's because the EV tax rate is only 4%. If you get one on a salary sacrifice scheme the cost is deducted before tax, so brings your overall tax down to below the threshold. Obviously it only makes sense if you actually need and want a car. It's to encourage people into using electric cars.

Bjorkdidit · 11/05/2026 05:59

How does that work @Hiddeninthetrees? When I had a company car, it increased my tax, not reduced it. A lot of people gave up their company cars when they got promoted into the higher rate tax band, because it doubled the amount of tax they paid which, on top of a hefty contribution for personal use, made it an expensive way to run a car.

happybug1234 · 11/05/2026 05:59

Lougle · 10/05/2026 23:20

https://www.eqaccountants.co.uk/high-marginal-tax-rates/

Would it help to know you're not alone? Some Universal Credit claimants have a marginal tax rate of 83%.

Seriously… universal credit it not earned income. Hardly the same thing is it.

Hiddeninthetrees · 11/05/2026 05:42

I don't know if you drive, but the electric car schemes are often now really good for bringing down tax, essentially meaning that a chunk of what you would have been paying in tax goes on a car fpr you, without costing you anything extra.

mellongoose · 11/05/2026 05:41

Fiscal drag is rubbish and is the direct hangover from furlough.

Bjorkdidit · 11/05/2026 05:31

Fiscal drag. Yes it's annoying but that's a hangover from a Tory policy that the current government has hung onto because they inherited a huge mess.

You do keep the other half so are better off. But if you can manage without the pay rise, put everything you earn above £50k into a pension, you'll need to do a tax return to claim it though.

Summerhillsquare · 11/05/2026 05:04

Roastchickenagain · 10/05/2026 22:32

On here, you’ll be told to be grateful or to “check your privilege” or some other such shite. But yes, it’s shit and you do wonder why you bother.

You bother because you still earn more money.

Or because you otherwise wanted the job/promotion.

You can always give it up and go on the luxurious benefits, right?!