Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel undermined by my mum's constant unsolicited advice?

31 replies

mullingitallover43 · 10/05/2026 14:20

My mum has a tendency to give me unsolicited advice / suggestions on how I should run my life.

Here's an example; we have a family wedding next weekend and my son is in the middle of GCSEs. Mum just called me to ask if he has any GCSEs on the Monday morning after the wedding. So I tell her again, yes, he does. She tells me "Oh, well you don't have to stay until the end of the wedding then, you can leave early and get him home."

I've discussed this with my husband already and we had already decided to do that as a couple, without her weighing in.

Another example. I recently had a minor surgery. She told me "I really want you to get a cleaner while you're recovering," and and that she would pay for it. A kind gesture, seemingly, but something I'd prefer to discuss with my husband and pay for ourselves.

For context I am 44, married, have a responsible and successful career. She did not have a career herself, and was a homemaker.

I know she thinks she's being helpful and caring, and that some might think I'm being ungrateful or cold, but I find it chips away at me and feels disempowering.

If you're reading this thinking why don't you just ask her to stop...on the couple of times that I have done that, she's been offended. I once asked her to not advise me on how much water to put in a vase of flowers, and she turned red and stormed out of my house in a huff.

This is a very entrenched dynamic that I've probably enabled for years. For example, she used to often answer for me when I was a kid. Then when I had my sons, she was very present and hands on involved with raising them, which was often super helpful but also overbearing at times. Whenever she's at my house, she'll get started with cleaning, or gardening, and always arrives with bags full of stuff for the house and for the boys.

YABU - Many of us would love the help of a caring mother, take the good from it and be grateful she cares in her way.

YANBU - This is overbearing behaviour and you need to set better boundaries with her.

OP posts:
Moonnstarz · 10/05/2026 16:53

I think YABU based on your examples.
The first one surely just sounds like making conversation, saying your son needs to be home early and you could easily.just say yes we have already planned for that.

The second example sounds like she is just being kind. She wants to help you following the op and perhaps thinks it's better to offer something practical like a cleaner than to simply turn up with flowers or something. Surely you could still discuss that with your husband - my mum has offered to pay for a cleaner, what do you think?

Malasana · 10/05/2026 16:49

I think for the 2 examples you cite, she just sounds like she wants to make things easier for you. It isn’t unsolicited advice as I’d see it.
Unless there’s a back story and she does other stuff as well.

ErlingHaalandsManBun · 10/05/2026 16:45

Honestly? I think you are getting your knickers in a twist unnecessarily and being a bit oversensitive.

Isn't this what Mums do? They care and give advice, even sometimes when its not needed. I know my Mum used to do it and I do it myself sometimes with my adult DD's. They just humour me, as I did with my Mum, and I normally get a 'Yes Mum' and an eye roll. But they know that everything I say comes from a good place and a place of care and love.

The examples you have given seem pretty minor IMO. It seems she has played an active roll in your life in a helpful and caring capacity so she is not just going to stop that now. Even though you are a capable adult with a successful career, its just who she is. Her offer to pay for a cleaner for you was just because she cares about you and doesn't want you stressing about keeping the house clean while recovering. How you can be annoyed at that is beyond me. And just because you and your DH had already discussed it, how was she supposed to know that?

I would just be grateful that you have such a loving and caring Mum (who annoys you occasionally but don't they all?) and try and just not let it bother you so much.

You will one day miss it, believe me 🌹

Endofyear · 10/05/2026 16:29

My mum does this too - yes it's annoying sometimes but it sounds like it comes from a place of caring for you all. My mum is in her 80s now and her life has shrunk, she doesn't have much to think about other than me and my sister and her grandchildren. She's always giving advice and sends me loads of crap she sees on Facebook too 😂 I just give it a thumbs up and move on!

I don't think she's trying to disempower or undermine you - she's just a mum who thinks she knows best! To be honest, I probably do it with my own adult children too a bit, and you probably will when your children are adults too! Most of the time, I bite my lip instead of giving advice but the odd one slips out 😂

Carryitjoyfully · 10/05/2026 14:28

From here, it looks like she really cares and is expressing that in a way that makes sense to her. I'd cut her some slack if you can.

parakeet · 10/05/2026 14:25

The examples you have given all seem quite mild and minor to me. So unless she's saying this sort of stuff several times an hour, I think you're being oversensitive.