Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say no to another in laws family holiday?

106 replies

Friedscrambledpoached · 08/05/2026 18:16

To say no or at least show that it's a bit if an imposition...Basically we have a young family and since our children were born our holidays have been largely dictated to us by in laws.

I genuinely love my in-laws and I like spending time with them. They're great with the kids, supportive and help out when we need it. However, we've had 3 'milestone' birthdays where the celebrations have centred around a holiday. I should add DH has a sibling who lives abroad, so I understand why it's a more important opportunity for the family to all get together as time together can be limited. However, I'm a bit sad that our annual leave and money are always dedicated to these extended family holidays which tbh aren't at places I would choose and tend to be very chaotic rather than relaxing.

If not for the 'milestone' birthday aspect I likely would have said no to so many extended family holidays until we had a few more holidays of our own choosing under our belt. We've only managed to get away as a nuclear family once so far. I also feel the need to try and balance things up by going on holiday with my family occasionally so they don't feel left out which doesn't leave much time or money leftover.

Now most approaching 'milestones' that I was aware of are over and I was looking forward to starting to spend our annual holiday budget and valuable annual leave on making memories as a nuclear family and doing what we want to do. Especially as the kids childhoods seem to be flying by so fast, there's certain things I want to do before they get too old. And we haven't been away together just as a couple in 4 years. However, FIL has just announced that their wedding anniversary is next year which will be another family holiday apparently. It does annoy me that this is presented as fact rather than an invitation!

The problem is I genuinely do love my in laws and although it could be argued they're being a bit short sighted/selfish when it comes to this, I really don't want to upset them. To say no to this feels like saying we don't care about their anniversary and don't want to celebrate with them. We do. We just we wish it was with a meal out or something rather than something that yet again swallows up all our money for the year and therefore cancels out anything we might like to have done. I'm starting to feel like I'm living life for them and extended family and what they want to do rather than for ourselves and what's best for our family.

I should also add that in laws have had a very privileged life and have travelled most of the world. I feel like I've blinked and I'm older than I thought and it should be our time now to start living. However, in laws are in their 70s and although are in good health, DH worries that every holiday may be their last big holiday so always wants to go. I do understand his point, but when does it end?

Should I just suck it up and defer our plans one more time and then say no after this last one? Our finances are stretched and we don't know what will come in the years ahead. It honestly makes me want to cry over all the thousands we've spent these past years on these trips. It's not that they haven't been enjoyable (mainly), more that it's prevented us from doing other things just for us if that makes sense? The thought of money becoming tighter and all the opportunities we had being used for these extended family occasions and then no longer being possible really upsets me.

Is it possible to broach this without looking like the bad guys?

OP posts:
MotherofPufflings · 08/05/2026 19:13

I can't imagine expecting my extended family to go away for an occasion that's primarily special to me/dh (like a wedding anniversary) and not paying. It's really rude, especially if they're well-off and you're not.

Purplewarrior · 08/05/2026 19:11

Just be straight. We won’t be able to join you this time. We look forward to catching up and celebrating your anniversary when you get back.

No further discussion required.

ThejoyofNC · 08/05/2026 19:09

It would be right of them to assume you don't care about their anniversary. Why would you care about someone else's wedding anniversary? I've always thought that was a thing for the couple themselves to celebrate.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/05/2026 19:08

I think definitely YANBU and you don’t have to justify yourself to anyone!

I did think from your OP that you kids were about 15 or so, with the worry about last chances and how many times you’ve been away together. You have almost their whole childhoods left! Doesn’t mean you should do what the in-laws want but you also can relax that you have plenty if years of family holidays to go. If that helps!

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 08/05/2026 19:08

Book whatever you want for 2027 NOW.

then you nothing qhen it comes up again....
"Oh no! I saw a good deal so i already booked a non refundable holiday in X for 2027. Holidays for 4 ij holidays are so expensive now - We cant afford two... so unless you can pay we wont he able to come."

I work too hard to spend my annual leave any way other than with my kids doing what I want.

RandomMess · 08/05/2026 19:07

I think you need to tackle this kindly and firmly.

”we do not have the funds or annual leave for extended family holidays. We’ve done x with DH family and we will match the same for my family but we are now doing our own thing”

How do you “share” Christmas. How involved were your DH grandparents when he was a kid?

AnnaMagnani · 08/05/2026 19:07

Friedscrambledpoached · 08/05/2026 19:02

I do actually wonder if this has come about due to us going away with my side of the family this year. It feels like we're constantly trying to keep balance and both sides think we favour the other one. Trying to keep everyone else happy!

OP my ILs got upset that we favoured my side of the family which is true as mine is a lot easier

After we pointed out that mine paid for us to go away with them, visit, subbed us for house renovations etc the ILs went quiet about 'unfairness'.

Abatyterntin · 08/05/2026 19:06

Friedscrambledpoached · 08/05/2026 19:02

I do actually wonder if this has come about due to us going away with my side of the family this year. It feels like we're constantly trying to keep balance and both sides think we favour the other one. Trying to keep everyone else happy!

I dont pay any attention to things like this.

We are kind and fair but I won't arrange our family life around wider family. Esp at the cost of our finances, holidays and annual leave.

Others feelings are not for you to manage. You're not doing anything wrong.

Tableforjoan · 08/05/2026 19:06

Just book somewhere you guys want with your children.

When they mention a holiday. Sorry can’t afford a second holiday and want the children to have some more child centric holidays.

If you can afford it maybe suggest a centre parcs style holiday or euro camp if you must have extended family holidays.

Also harshly probably be easier next year if you wasn’t doing your family this year. Next year in-laws will moan but last year your family 😩

GhostOrchid · 08/05/2026 19:06

Orders76 · 08/05/2026 19:03

Also I would value boundaries more than money, absolutely wouldn't ask for contribution.

Yep. Would much rather pay for all my own holidays that are my choice than lose agency.

FazeleysRoyale · 08/05/2026 19:04

@Kindling1970
What a perfect quote. Nails it.

Orders76 · 08/05/2026 19:03

Also I would value boundaries more than money, absolutely wouldn't ask for contribution.

FazeleysRoyale · 08/05/2026 19:03

OP your kids are now at the perfect ages to enjoy nuclear family holidays. Doing what you all want to do as a family. You’ve done the extended family holidays. Now it’s time for something different.

ILs could well be travelling and holidaying into their 80s if they are in good health. Could be another 10 years of dragging you all along. By which time your DC are teenagers and you have lost the chance for the childhood holidays. It happens so fast.

Friedscrambledpoached · 08/05/2026 19:02

I do actually wonder if this has come about due to us going away with my side of the family this year. It feels like we're constantly trying to keep balance and both sides think we favour the other one. Trying to keep everyone else happy!

OP posts:
Orders76 · 08/05/2026 19:02

As long as you both agree. The answer is in your first post.

"Amazing and we are so excited to celebrate your big anniversary, however for us it'll be local as we're planning a family holiday instead this year. Can we pencil in a weekend to book a nice restaurant?"

WiltedLettuce · 08/05/2026 19:01

Just say you can't afford it - it really is that simple.

If they question that, say "Oh, are you offering to pay? That would be lovely" and watch them squirm as they try to back out.

Then book your own family holiday based around the kids.

Kindling1970 · 08/05/2026 19:00

I live by this quote:

“If you face the choice between feeling guilt and resentment, choose the guilt every time. Resentment is soul suicide"

GhostOrchid · 08/05/2026 19:00

Sympathies, OP. You really need to put your boundaries down now. Talk to your husband.

I had something similar with my ILs who like to plan big family holidays for milestone celebrations and the like although they did always cover the accommodation costs. I would often insist we went for three or four nights and did our own thing the rest of the time. Despite the subsidised costs I am kind of resentful of using precious annual leave to go on holidays I don’t particularly want to go on where I always have to be on my best behaviour and never get to do what I want. ILs are lovely people, but not my first choice of holiday companions. I think over the years they’ve picked up on it and we usually negotiate something mutually agreeable. We don’t have kids which kind of makes the pressure greater as there’s always the assumption we’re totally flexible.

Assert your boundaries now even if it means being the bad guy.

Friedscrambledpoached · 08/05/2026 18:57

The sibling does travel here usually twice a year tbf. We travelled there once which also wiped out our family holiday spending that year but we feel a bit guilty we've only been once. But alongside the celebration holidays if we'd visited more we'd never manage anything together or with my side of the family!

It's funny, it feels like we have sacrificed so much and shelled out a lot of money but are still seen like we put in the least amount of effort compared with sibling.

OP posts:
Beesandhoney123 · 08/05/2026 18:55

Oh this sounds familiar, in laws exactly the same. Dh was hopeless at sticking up for himself. We did it anyway.

Just say oh, no, we have already arranged a family holiday next year, just us and the dc. Not telling anyone where in case it slips out and the dc find out!
They aren't paying! If they are so lovely they wouldn't be expecting this. Also, they should pay for you.

. Just say you can't do both, for money reasons. but would love to see them when they get back.

Friedscrambledpoached · 08/05/2026 18:53

I should say when I say my family's turn this year, my extended family. Still not nuclear 😂

Thanks for the replies everyone. I think the most sensible option is to broach the affordability issue. If they're happy to pay or contribute say half then that would be much more palatable. The trouble is 'affordability' can be subjective. I'd feel as though I couldn't spend anything on renovating the house that year or have a weekend away with partner as people could think we could have used that money if you see what I mean. But as you say, I suppose it's up to us what we spend our money on and how much we're prepared to spend on what.

I do feel vindicated. It's nice to know I'm not being unreasonable.

OP posts:
Rhaidimiddim · 08/05/2026 18:52

Also, does the sibling abroad ever travel in the opposite direction, OP, or is it always you shelling out to go there?

Rhaidimiddim · 08/05/2026 18:50

Whowhenwhatwear · 08/05/2026 18:43

Agree. 'The last holiday before they die' is not a sustainable way to live. Husband has to grow up and realise he has a family of his own now that he needs to prioritise

My older DGC are into their teens now, and the time shot by. Their parents are now into "this could be our last holiday as a family before <eldest> doesn't want to come on family holidays any more".

As someone earlier said, the DILs are being selfish and DH short- sighted.

sittingonabeach · 08/05/2026 18:50

Just say you can’t afford it

Abatyterntin · 08/05/2026 18:47

My husband's sibling lives abroad. Our parents are all aging and with plenty of money.

At no point has it been expected we have to spend our holidays with my husband's family and pay for it ourselves. My in laws paid for us to fly out when my child was younger so we could all be together for a week.

I understand how tricky it can be keeping familial relationships happy but it is fine to put your family first. Especially given the history.

I would just present it as a fait accompli and say, 'We're already doing X next year so can't come this time. Shall we celebrate when we're all home?"

No one can force you to spend your money on anything. If they get upset at a perfectly reasonable reply from you, that's not on you to fix. You're not doing anything wrong!