Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New food bins

239 replies

Toomanyuglyplasticbins · 07/05/2026 14:41

Will you be using the new food caddies & bins? Sick to death of my kitchen & garden resembling the local recycling centre. I do recycle most stuff & have regular trips to the tip; but even then one local authority varies from the next one in their recycling policies, so it all seems a bit.futile

OP posts:
user2848502016 · 07/05/2026 19:37

We have all been using them perfectly well in Wales for almost 20 years 😂

Pinkflamingo10 · 07/05/2026 19:37

In Scotland we’ve had food bins for 10+ years

Bokeitup · 07/05/2026 19:35

CasperGutman · 07/05/2026 16:13

Good grief, how did you manage to have maggots in week one? We've had a bin for 15 years and I've never seen a maggot. Just use the food waste bags, tie them up tightly, and keep the lid of the bin tightly closed at all times.

I did all of that but when I went to remove the bag from the small caddy to put it in the big caddy, there were maggots underneath.

JanBlues2026 · 07/05/2026 19:34

I don’t want another sodding bin. We have two recycling bins which are full every two weeks (I am happy to recycle anything possible!) one general waste and two garden waste. I honestly think a lot of people will either hide the waste in the general bin or flush it down the toilet which would not be good! I think the mumsnet demographic are pretty on board with recycling but I bet a lot of the general population don’t care or can’t be bothered and won’t be doing it. I only have a small kitchen and only have room for a small general bin and a small recycling bin which we take out pretty much daily.

Bokeitup · 07/05/2026 19:33

Needmorelego · 07/05/2026 15:42

Did you not use the special bags?

Yep but when I lifted the bag out, there were maggots underneath.

OnTheBoardwalk · 07/05/2026 18:48

I have 4 wheelie bins, general, garden/food, cardboard and glass/plastic which do take up a lot of room but cuts down on waste.

like pp I’ve got the JJ totem bin and love it. The food caddy inside is great and doesn’t take up any extra space

i dont use the bottom bit for recycling its far too small and not worth the hassle bending up and down. It is a great space for cleaning stuff, bin bags, dishwasher tablets etc

https://www.josephjoseph.com/products/totem-max-60l-waste-recycling-bin-starter-set-stainless-steel?variant=53607867646332&utm_source=google&campaign_id=23617230897&ad_id=799178468138&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=PLA_[B_BP](G-United_Kingdom)%7BBrand%7D&utm_content=194336915976&utm_term=&gclid=Cj0KCQjw8PDPBhCeARIsAOJwmWVvHoB5WfphFmt6Yh3iDAjlP6BDTBl3K50rzxN5sXvE1XMKxXltr2gaAmJPEALw_wcB&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=23617230897&gbraid=0AAAAADm6GSCBEgrSEfTFuQq8QXEQQHx4E

Waste Bin Totem 60L Set Stainless-Steel | Joseph Joseph UK

Shop our 3-in-1 Totem 60L stainless-steel recycling bin with 2 30L compartments & 3 litre waste caddy set with replacement food waste liners and odour filters.

https://www.josephjoseph.com/products/totem-max-60l-waste-recycling-bin-starter-set-stainless-steel?ad_id=799178468138&campaign_id=23617230897&gad_campaignid=23617230897&gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAADm6GSCBEgrSEfTFuQq8QXEQQHx4E&gclid=Cj0KCQjw8PDPBhCeARIsAOJwmWVvHoB5WfphFmt6Yh3iDAjlP6BDTBl3K50rzxN5sXvE1XMKxXltr2gaAmJPEALw_wcB&variant=53607867646332

YourWinter · 07/05/2026 18:28

My new weekly food waste collection starts next week, the kitchen caddies and outdoor suitcase-sized bins were delivered around the village a fortnight ago, with a starter roll of biodegradable bin liners for the caddy.

It makes it more complicated for because since 2003 we’ve had a very simple system of three bins:

  • green for all compostable, garden and all food waste, including meat and fish, bones and fat, plus tissues and kitchen roll, unbagged
  • blue for all recyclables, plastic food trays and bottles, steel and aluminium cans, cardboard, glass jars and bottles with lids screwed back on whether plastic or metal lids, unbagged
  • black bin for non-recyclable and non-compostable waste, can be bagged

I live alone and have very little food waste, mainly peelings, pips and carrot ends, but I make bone broth for the dogs and the bones and fat have always been able to go in the green bin with grass cuttings and weeds absorbing grease and any smell. It’s counter-intuitive to put these, and the occasional chicken or lamb bones, in a plastic bag in a separate bin! I put peelings and eg orange pips, and tissues, in a small bowl and empty it into the green bin at least once a day. I can’t imagine having it in a bag in a caddy in the kitchen for days, nor wasting bags by using one per day for very little content.

Our leaflet says the bags are optional, the caddy can be lined with paper or left unlined and just washed more often. It’s not compulsory to use it, if unwanted the unused caddies can be returned to a council collection point. Food waste CAN go into the green bin eg if a collection was missed, but not in bags. Any clear plastic bags can be used, eg supermarket packaging that my bag of spinach came in.

Yes, there are people that chuck out eye watering amounts of food, but I am amazed if the cost of this roll-out is worthwhile.

hahabahbag · 07/05/2026 18:19

I will admit that the crafty foxes and ingenious bird life here do try their hardest to break in on bin day - put the bins out yesterday and there were dozens of jackdaws, crows and magpies around the car park doing their best to beat the seagull proof clips, (18 houses back onto the car park)

Zanatdy · 07/05/2026 18:17

We have had them in our area for well over a decade - are you only just getting them? I always use them, better than the bin stinking. Never had any issues.

Martand · 07/05/2026 18:16

Got them and happy to use them. Inside the kitchen, fine. But the one outside, it’s me versus London foxes, and a 5am standoff where we glare at each other through the window. Mr Fox worked out how to open it and get at the contents when we left the big caddy outside. So now I put a folding chair on top of it which works.

The problem is leaving it out for the refuse staff to collect on bin day. We have to leave the bin out before we go to work. But the fox gets in and strews food everywhere. What can we do? If I put a heavy rock on top of it, the bin won’t get emptied… Even wedging it between the black and green bins doesn’t work.

thinktoomuchtoooften · 07/05/2026 18:10

HoldMyWine · 07/05/2026 17:21

It’s really not that difficult. Sigh.

Of course it’s not difficult. It’s just not something I will do.

Hankunamatata · 07/05/2026 18:05

I brought pull out bin set under sink from amazon - so 3 bins on a pull out system. Large one for plastic recycling, and two slim ones - one for general waste and one for food waste. Works well for us and no smells.
Putting some kitchen roll in bottom with essential oils can help smell fresh

TeenLifeMum · 07/05/2026 18:03

@Toomanyuglyplasticbins i have the Joseph Joseph 60l one - https://www.johnlewis.com/browse/home-garden/kitchen-bins/recycling-bins/_/N-dwcZ1z0rh9r

top section is general waste plus food caddy and the bottom is mixed recycling. I’ve sent the full list of options as it depends on the space you have. I use biodegradable liners.

MoonlightMemories · 07/05/2026 17:52

I've not received my actual small food caddy yet (live in an apartment and we seem to be being left till last minute for getting them and the communal bins for the new recycling), I have however got my own cupboard-hanging food caddy of a larger capacity ahead of time and to get used to when the new system is in place.

I've been using it like you would the council food waste one and anything likely to go off quickly like leftover meat carcasses etc from a roast dinner I've been bagging several and putting out in the current outside general waste (soon to be food waste) bins quickly instead of letting it fester as it would in the general waste kitchen bin otherwise.

No issues with maggots or smells etc as of yet. The other changes I've done is add a tall, thin bin in my kitchen for cardboard waste as I already have one for plastics and they go in separate bins in the new system, so that's easier for me. I also got a hanging bin for general waste like my food one (both 9L), I figure I'm probably not going to be filling up a huge bin anymore so I'm just going to empty them both at the same time...much easier then having to carry a big heavy 30l bin bag once a week down several flights of stairs, doing a few little bags instead.

I think I'm going to get on with the new system well, I'm not sure about my neighbours though, some of who already don't put the right stuffing the recycling bins as it is....

sittingonabeach · 07/05/2026 17:29

@Doggymummar doesn’t that get flies. And I assumed the food waste bin was for people who don’t have compost heaps or for waste you wouldn’t put on a compost heap. You wouldn’t stop using compost heap just because you have a food caddy

howshouldibehave · 07/05/2026 17:27

What new food caddies?

Not everyone lives in the same town as you 😂

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 07/05/2026 17:25

We’ve just started food waste collection in our area. Four weeks in and the caddies are already broken from being thrown at houses by the bin men. When it’s windy they will join the plastic bags (bins would be much more practical) for cardboard/paper collection by being blown in the river. It’s like the council is determined to see our town turned into a giant open air tip.
A good idea in theory but not translated through to being good in reality.

Doggymummar · 07/05/2026 17:24

sittingonabeach · 07/05/2026 16:52

@Doggymummar where did the food waste go before? A bin is a bin. If it went in normal waste bin why didn’t it attract flies then?

On the compost heap

Toomanyuglyplasticbins · 07/05/2026 17:24

TeenLifeMum · 07/05/2026 15:54

where do you live that you don’t have these? we’ve had them for 11 years. I have a kitchen bin with a food caddy section so that’s tidy and then we use the outside bin from the council. We don’t use the council caddy as the bin we bought is nicer.

What kitchen bin with an inside food caddy do you use? That would be very useful. Just found out about clips to hang the outside food caddy to the inside of a big wheelie bin so will give those a go

OP posts:
HoldMyWine · 07/05/2026 17:21

It’s really not that difficult. Sigh.

NeverCouldGetTheHangOfThursdays · 07/05/2026 17:20

We took delivery of our new food caddies in March but we're not allowed to use them until June. I really don't have a problem with them because at the moment our food waste has to go in with general rubbish which is only collected fortnightly whereas the food caddies will be weekly.

The only problem I'll have is remembering which bin goes out on which week because as well as the general rubbish, recycling and garden waste bins we've also now been given a glass recycling bin - so four full sized dustbins plus a food caddy!

CatMum27 · 07/05/2026 17:13

It’s only just started round my way - bins were delivered last month and collections start next week. I can see why they’re doing it but we’ll see how it goes. Given that the council regularly forget to collect the three bins I’m already maintaining I don’t have full confidence but maybe they’ll surprise me!

Going back to the OPs original point I do sympathise. In the scheme of things the bins aren’t huge but they do take up space. I’ve managed to find some space in the kitchen for the little one after some reorganising but the outside one is proving a little trickier to house. I have bin sheds due to issues with vermin which means either a squeeze or storing it elsewhere which isn’t massively efficient. Not everyone has the same luxury of space as others and what works for one can be a massive pain for some.

I’m old enough to remember the little plastic boxes which preceded the recycling bins, one for paper and one for glass/tins etc. They also took up space and were massively impractical on a windy day given their lack of lids. They used to get chucked about by the bin collectors and quickly broke. Local council eventually scrapped them as they were more trouble than they were worth. Worst part was they weren’t actually recyclable and didn’t fit in the bin so sat gathering dust in many gardens for years!

OtherTemporaryUsername · 07/05/2026 17:13

If you are careful closing the bin (indoor caddy or outdoor, though compostable bags prevent issues in the outdoor caddy) in summer and flies can't get it, you won't get maggots. Bit grim when you do, but they don't kill you. My neighbour puts her little green compostable bags in the freezer in the summer when full, and then puts them in the outdoor bin on collection day. Prevents any pre-collection in-bin composting!

We've had a food bin for as long as I have lived here and it is fab - no smells from the wheely bin, ever! We recycle everything and are in one of the highest recycling districts in the country; we have one landfill collection every 3 weeks and ours (family of 4) is only ever half full.

I separate veg waste to go in the garden compost and cooked/fatty/protein waste to go in the council bin. Its all in bags outside, and the bin closes so it is rat-proof and fox-proof. Its worth getting used to it - sending food waste to landfill is criminal.

TeenLifeMum · 07/05/2026 17:01

Wynter25 · 07/05/2026 16:59

Durham area

I’m really surprised you’re only just getting this. It’s so much better to keep all the food separate so you don’t get maggots in the general waste.

DeathMetalMum · 07/05/2026 17:01

Had them for at least 10 years here. Occasionally get maggots when it's very warm. We have a smaller caddy on the counter top and empty it when needed.

Our general waste is emptied every two weeks, and with other recycling and taking soft plastics to the supermarket the general waste is often only half full.