Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Giving Reform voters what they voted for

195 replies

Nobarbsbeforecarbs · 06/05/2026 15:37

Taking the “giving people want they vote for” principle to its logical next step, if Labour or the Greens form the next government, should they:

  • Pass legislation to confirm the Human Rights Act no longer applies to Reform voters and/or anyone living in Reform constituencies.
  • Withdraw the right of Reform voters and/or anyone living in a Reform constituency to use the NHS unless they have private health insurance to cover the cost or can pay privately.

Just putting this out there.

AIBU?

OP posts:
PomplaMouse · 06/05/2026 23:12

Russian passports for all Reform voters, I reckon.

icepopsincoming · 06/05/2026 22:56

Ablondiebutagoody · 06/05/2026 15:50

I think that being able to opt out of some "services" is a great idea, providing you get a tax rebate. People should be able to take their share of the education or NHS or whatever budget to whomever they like. Rather than have to just accept the shitty Government provision.

So you don't benefit at all from the fact that all British citizens aged 3-19 can receive a free (at the point of service) education or that other people can be kept healthy by a free (at the point of service) healthcare system?

moderate · 06/05/2026 22:40

Petrolitis · 06/05/2026 22:36

Exactly.

Where has this shitty idea come from that we should only pay for what benefits us directly.

We all for part of society and society contains many forms of inequality. People who can contribute, should contribute to help those that can't.

It's no wonder people are shoplifting with impunity, not bothering to wear headphones in public and cheating the school admissions process, they're the me, me, me brigade.

Shocking selfishness

Or the shoplifters are the "society owes me a living" brigade who have been emboldened by the "gold star for everyone" brigade.

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 06/05/2026 22:38

If the Conversatives and Labour hadn’t allowed unprecedented amounts of economic migrants into the country over the last two decades, we wouldn’t be in a situation where Brexit happened and Reform are likely to get in. Absolute failure of government.

Petrolitis · 06/05/2026 22:36

CatherineRachel16 · 06/05/2026 16:36

Isn't the point you pay for things irrespective of whether they benefit you? Otherwise how does anything work? I pay for other children's education - that doesn't benefit me but I don't begrudge it. As an aside the NHS could very easily benefit you at any given moment. I, of course hope it doesn't, but you could be struck by a car and need an NHS ambulance, NHS emergency care team and NHS hospital.

Exactly.

Where has this shitty idea come from that we should only pay for what benefits us directly.

We all for part of society and society contains many forms of inequality. People who can contribute, should contribute to help those that can't.

It's no wonder people are shoplifting with impunity, not bothering to wear headphones in public and cheating the school admissions process, they're the me, me, me brigade.

Shocking selfishness

Castellio · 06/05/2026 22:28

onpills4godsake · 06/05/2026 22:16

Reform will probably get the majority of protest votes from people who are sick of the system that doesn’t benefit not reward hard working people

its depressingly predictable.

And that’s becoming more and more people. I vote Labour because we have a great Labour MP and I want to keep them so have no interest in voting Reform, but it is the people working a full week and ending up with less in their pockets than the benefit junkies that laze around all day that will vote Reform. It’s the people who are earning well but can no longer afford anything apart from just getting by that will be voting Reform. Do the mainstream parties have any interest in addressing their issues? I don’t think so.

Labour are doing well on getting immigrants processed and I respect Shabana Mahmoud but they are taking endless taxes without addressing pensions, benefits and NHS. They fare endlessly blocking houses from being built (driving up the cost of housing yet further) and factories and offices being built (turning companies away from investing and growing here). They need to bypass the NIMBYs, fish discos and bat tunnels, cut welfare and ditch the current NHS spending model, and show that they understand the issues and are prepared to address them.

onpills4godsake · 06/05/2026 22:16

Reform will probably get the majority of protest votes from people who are sick of the system that doesn’t benefit not reward hard working people

its depressingly predictable.

onpills4godsake · 06/05/2026 22:11

The medication I am on I pay privately because the nhs wait for adhd diagnosis was 9 years at the point I paid- not that it matters

dizzydizzydizzy · 06/05/2026 20:49

Castellio · 06/05/2026 20:32

Do you think most of the EU population have vacccinstions? Cancer treatment? A&E? Do you think at all??? Goodness!

I was responding to someone who was saying They never used the NHS.

CatherineRachel16 · 06/05/2026 20:40

Menopausalsourpuss · 06/05/2026 19:18

These are such rubbish points. Alot of people (including me) just want to copy the best health systems (France etc) many of which are in Europe funnily enough so you'd think the rabid remainers would be keen to copy rather than sticking with our own rubbish system (which for the hard of thinking is not "free"). But alot of the hard people seem to think that the only alternative system in the world is the US. And yes happy to not having the HRA apply to me and everyone else - it didn't for most of my life (age 56) as was only incorporated into law in 1998 and before that we seemed to deport foreign criminals etc just fine.

Edited

Interesting point. Well reasoned.

millymollymoomoo · 06/05/2026 20:37

Sounds great to me
nhs is crap so I think private insurance is the way forward,
and human rights act needs complete overhaul in favour of common sense and law abiding citizens

hth

Menopausalsourpuss · 06/05/2026 20:37

EarthlyNightshade · 06/05/2026 20:10

I agree with you to a certain extent.

But is this something that your would trust Reform to do well?

I really don't know but at least they are talking about reforming the NHS which HAS to be done - it is a 1940s system which no longer works in today's world which is why it has such poor outcomes compared to other countries and why no-one else has copied it.

Castellio · 06/05/2026 20:32

dizzydizzydizzy · 06/05/2026 19:31

Have you had vaccinations? Given birth? Had smear tests or mammograms? Do you take the pill? Have you ever been to A&E?

I virtually never went to the doctor ever until my late 40s (10 years ago). I was very fit and healthy too. Since then, I have developed a number of serious problems - through absolutely no fault of my own. Apparently. I was genetically predisposed to them.

Do you think most of the EU population have vacccinstions? Cancer treatment? A&E? Do you think at all??? Goodness!

EarthlyNightshade · 06/05/2026 20:10

Menopausalsourpuss · 06/05/2026 19:18

These are such rubbish points. Alot of people (including me) just want to copy the best health systems (France etc) many of which are in Europe funnily enough so you'd think the rabid remainers would be keen to copy rather than sticking with our own rubbish system (which for the hard of thinking is not "free"). But alot of the hard people seem to think that the only alternative system in the world is the US. And yes happy to not having the HRA apply to me and everyone else - it didn't for most of my life (age 56) as was only incorporated into law in 1998 and before that we seemed to deport foreign criminals etc just fine.

Edited

I agree with you to a certain extent.

But is this something that your would trust Reform to do well?

Sesma · 06/05/2026 20:05

Perrygreen · 06/05/2026 17:48

So you'd like to die slowly with an untreated broken ankle, burst appendix, heart attack?

I would like an alternative instead of having to use the NHS where I would probably die slowly anyway through waiting

dizzydizzydizzy · 06/05/2026 19:31

onpills4godsake · 06/05/2026 15:49

I’d quite like to scrap the nhs and pay for my own health care - I am sick of paying so much tax for a nhs that doesn’t benefit me.

I don’t vote reform- I have been either Lib Dem or labour my whole life and now I just won’t bother to vote.

the toxicity of the current debates totally disengages me

Have you had vaccinations? Given birth? Had smear tests or mammograms? Do you take the pill? Have you ever been to A&E?

I virtually never went to the doctor ever until my late 40s (10 years ago). I was very fit and healthy too. Since then, I have developed a number of serious problems - through absolutely no fault of my own. Apparently. I was genetically predisposed to them.

Firetreev · 06/05/2026 19:30

Castellio · 06/05/2026 17:13

I think the voters you are referring to are those that came over in the 1960s /70s from India, Pakistan and the Caribbean and worked hard to get a life here. These are the sort of people who - rightly or wrongly - vote reform as they think the new immigrants haven’t the same work ethic and that no more people can be supported.

I haven't met a single person of colour voting for Reform, I say this as a person of colour. Yes, there will be some, but they will be a small proportion of the ddemographic. A huge chunk of Reform support online is bots and people from the global south posing as 'George the Patriot' from Burnley. There have been huge exposes on this. There is genuine Reform support in the country, but a lot of what you see online is fake.

Menopausalsourpuss · 06/05/2026 19:18

These are such rubbish points. Alot of people (including me) just want to copy the best health systems (France etc) many of which are in Europe funnily enough so you'd think the rabid remainers would be keen to copy rather than sticking with our own rubbish system (which for the hard of thinking is not "free"). But alot of the hard people seem to think that the only alternative system in the world is the US. And yes happy to not having the HRA apply to me and everyone else - it didn't for most of my life (age 56) as was only incorporated into law in 1998 and before that we seemed to deport foreign criminals etc just fine.

BIossomtoes · 06/05/2026 19:14

UniquePinkSwan · 06/05/2026 17:01

I agree with her and I’m not on any medication and never go to the doctors. We need a European model

Most European countries spend more taxpayers’ money on healthcare.

passwordchanges · 06/05/2026 19:12

PhuckTrump · 06/05/2026 19:09

I believe that’s OP’s point…

Well quite. It’s just ridiculous.

PhuckTrump · 06/05/2026 19:09

passwordchanges · 06/05/2026 19:07

I think it’s about the same as reform saying they’ll build “detention centres” in green constituencies only. I wonder how our political landscape as fallen into such chaos.

I believe that’s OP’s point…

passwordchanges · 06/05/2026 19:07

I think it’s about the same as reform saying they’ll build “detention centres” in green constituencies only. I wonder how our political landscape as fallen into such chaos.

WeirdyBeardyMarrowBabyLady · 06/05/2026 19:05

DaisyDooley · 06/05/2026 18:48

Can you provide me with a link @Nobarbsbeforecarbs from Reform saying that they intend to privatise the NHS so -I presume-In theory the NHS ceases to exsist.
Ergo a link showing how we would have zero human rights -rather than just removing us from the ECHR.

Hi. He is quite cagey about it these days because his schtick is to hoodwink the sorts of voters who can’t afford health insurance but here’s a clip for you https://www.instagram.com/reel/DXMwZGygnoc/?igsh=aXI5bmR5bnplM3Bk

Jo Stevens for Cardiff East on Instagram: "Our NHS is not safe in Nigel Farage’s hands."

769 likes, 0 comments - jostevenslabour on April 16, 2026: "Our NHS is not safe in Nigel Farage’s hands.".

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DXMwZGygnoc/?igsh=aXI5bmR5bnplM3Bk

PhuckTrump · 06/05/2026 19:03

CatherineRachel16 · 06/05/2026 18:52

What about people who can't work though? Or don't have the highest level of insurance? What do they do? Do you think - and please realise I'm not having a go, I'm honestly curious - that people without children shouldn't pay for education? Or any supported child benefits? My view is that people shouldn't be be allowed to opt only into taxes that benefits them directly as it's shortsighted and a stable society necessities an element of give and take - and that applies to all services. But I respect you might think differently and I'm interested in that, but not aggressively so. Thanks.

Edited

Exactly. I’ve never needed the Fire Dept. Perhaps I should be able to opt out. And if my house ever catches fire, they turn up with a credit card machine, and we have to swipe £10k before they start, or watch our home burn to the ground.

CatherineRachel16 · 06/05/2026 18:52

Castellio · 06/05/2026 17:10

I have it through work. Pre existing conditions are covered.

Do you think pre-existing conditions aren’t covered in Europe? Do you think those in Europe can’t get cancer care? Because the UK cancer care is at the rock bottom of league tables compared with the rest of Europe and their partly insurance backed systems.

What about people who can't work though? Or don't have the highest level of insurance? What do they do? Do you think - and please realise I'm not having a go, I'm honestly curious - that people without children shouldn't pay for education? Or any supported child benefits? My view is that people shouldn't be be allowed to opt only into taxes that benefits them directly as it's shortsighted and a stable society necessities an element of give and take - and that applies to all services. But I respect you might think differently and I'm interested in that, but not aggressively so. Thanks.

Swipe left for the next trending thread