Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To never be able to forgive this despite the context?

316 replies

Unda110 · 01/05/2026 21:05

Suppose I’m just looming for validation really. I know I don’t need that and any decision not to be with someone is completely fair and ok if that’s how you feel… but still, I would like to hear how you’d respond to this.

When I was pregnant (30) my then partner I was living with, albeit loosely as I still had my place I went back to from time to time, left me. He cut me out of his life and despite me calling and texting in the third trimester, he did not respond to one call or text. I didn’t know what to think or why he was doing that. He got a friend to message me to say if I contact ex again then we will get a restraining order against me. I was shocked, I remember bits of the third trimester feeling so low I could barely think about the baby. Obviously after that message I didn’t speak to him again and after claiming cms he then told them he wasn’t the father. Two months later he eventually attended a dna test and was forced to pay.

When dd was 6 months he got in touch saying he wanted to see her but then whenever I suggested a date he would go quiet. Eventually he saw her at age 1 and then has seen her since (age 3). Since she was around age 2 he’s tried to get back together. Hes apologised profusely for his behaviour and said he wasn’t ready to be a father and he handled it terribly. He was 40 at the time and while the baby was unplanned at first he was enthusiastic and came to scans etc.

DD adores him and they have a lovely bond now and even though I’ve resisted reuniting with him he will often get upset after seeing her and tell me he misses us and loves us. I’ve asked him not to say these things as it makes me feel confused and I want to move on with life after all the trauma. But part of me does believe he is sorry and he doesn’t deal with emotions well.

Neither of us are dependant on the other financially or anything like that so it’s not a case of him wanting to slip into family life and me provide a home etc.

I know it probably sounds crazy I’m even questioning myself. I sometimes feel I’m letting Dd down by not giving him a chance but then when I think back to what he did I feel sick to my stomach.

OP posts:
5128gap · 01/05/2026 21:57

You haven't forgiven him (understandably) and you have trauma from what he put you through. The only reason you can entertain the idea of him is because at the moment you are living well without him which gives you strength and confidence. If you got back together and enmeshed your lives, I think this might change, as you'd be living with the fear he could do it again and destroy all you've built without him.
Maybe one day this could change, but its too soon now.

Whettlettuce · 01/05/2026 21:49

So the grass wasn't greener and he wants to circle back because he can't find a replacement. That's literally all this is op ,don't over think it . If I was in your shoes I would be setting very firm boundaries and getting contact drawn up in court and using either a charity contact centre or a friend or family member for handovers . Regardless of whether he's a good father or not does not mean that will not all go out the window if he gets his feet under your table.

Templeofthedog · 01/05/2026 21:49

I think it's really telling that there's nothing in your posts about how you feel about him OP, just how he and DD feel. So you wouldn't be getting into a relationship with him for the right reasons, it's guilt (misplaced, you have nothing to feel guilty about) and the pressure of his feelings driving this rather than any real desire on your part to be with him. Don't get caught up in feeling you're letting DD down in some way, it's quite the opposite. You are informed by past experience of her Dad that she is blissfully unaware of and are protecting her accordingly.

faithfultoGeorgeMichael · 01/05/2026 21:47

Let him stay as the ex who treated you like shit so now has to be on best behaviour. Do not move him into partner territory, he has shown you who he is.

Ohpleeeease · 01/05/2026 21:35

I mean this kindly OP but it’s your DD who is the draw, not you. You deserve someone who wants to be with you, and accepts your DD as part of the package, not the other way round.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 01/05/2026 21:29

Thing is, even if he has changed, will you ever really be able to trust that he won't do it again?

DavesGirl90 · 01/05/2026 21:23

Unda110 · 01/05/2026 21:17

Sorry I meant to add that he genuinely is a great dad to dd now. And he is decent towards me, pays substantially more than cms states, buys flowers for dd to give to me and things like that.

He does these things because he’s trying to get you back. He doesn’t actually want you though or he wouldn’t have fucked off in the first place. He just wants what he can’t have and, like you, has a fantasy about the family you three could be together. But it wouldn’t be the way either of you want it to be, because he isn’t capable.

If you take him back he will treat you like dirt again. What he did to you was unforgivable. I don’t need to know you to know you deserve more.

Cocoa174 · 01/05/2026 21:23

You’re not letting her down, you’re protecting her.

Bridgertonisbest · 01/05/2026 21:23

He’s shown you who he is. Believe him.

HortiGal · 01/05/2026 21:19

I was waiting for he was very young, but 40?!?
He sounds pathetic and selfish, you’re doing fine without him.

Unda110 · 01/05/2026 21:17

Sorry I meant to add that he genuinely is a great dad to dd now. And he is decent towards me, pays substantially more than cms states, buys flowers for dd to give to me and things like that.

OP posts:
BatFeminist · 01/05/2026 21:17

Do not forgive because of the context. He doesn’t deserve you

ElephantPidgeon · 01/05/2026 21:14

He is trash.

AllyMacbealmyarse · 01/05/2026 21:12

He’s a shit and fucked you over. How could you ever trust him. Put him in the bin and tell him if he continues to stay stuff like this you’ll get a restraining order (or supervised contact).

Alwaysthesameoldstory · 01/05/2026 21:12

You are not letting your DD down at all OP.
What he did during your pregnancy with his child is not something that is redeemable.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/05/2026 21:08

Him being her father does not give him a right to your body, cooking and cleaning services and an ongoing obligation to care for him into his old age.

Do not feel obliged to give him that just because he's failed at getting himself a replacement.

Swipe left for the next trending thread