Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be fed up with my in-laws' reverse one-upmanship?

163 replies

GreenPoppies · 01/05/2026 16:13

I know I'm not being unreasonable because making disparaging comments about someone elses choices is always rude but does anyone else get so annoyed by reverse one-upmanship?

My in-laws are the ultimate in this. We are going on holiday to Portugal in August and they are flabbergasted that we are flying. "But why can't you just drive? It's so brilliant. We love driving. The views from the motorway are second to none. I don't understand why you're flying" Because, Not-So-Dear In-Laws, we have 9 month old and a 2 year old, and 2-3 days of driving is neither comfortable nor practical. "But just do it all in one go, it's only 24 hours if you drive non-stop, you'll be fine, it's so much fun, I don't understand why anybody would fly there in 2 hours when you could drive there in 24! Such luxury!".

We took our (then) 18 month old camping last year in our 4 man tent. "you sat on CHAIRS?! Oh wow, that's crazy, I can't believe you sat on chairs, we would just sit on a tesco bag. And that tent may as well be a castle, we just prop up a tarp and sleep under that, no need for sleeping bags, it's so much fun to camp without all the unnecessary extras".

We were once on a walking holiday with them and I mentioned (didn't make a fuss or anything) that I needed to stop at a shop. When they pressed ("why on earth do you need a shop? Just sustain yourself on beer for 3 days!") I said I needed some plasters as a stone had got into my walking boot and rubbed my foot raw, I'd bled all over my sock. I was made out to be the most precious princess ever, to this day I'm ribbed about "can't even do a 6 hour walk without needing a plaster the next day! We just walked through the blood!"

I'm getting fed up of gritting my teeth and putting up with it. I've bitten back a few times and told them to shut up if they can't say anything nice but again, I'm seen as 'dramatic' and it's ignored. I now try and avoid them but obviously they are my kid's grandparents and otherwise not bad people so needs must.

It feels like they assign a moral worth to anyone who does not suffer like bloody Christ on the cross! I'm a second rate human being because I fly, camp in a tent, use plasters and god-forbid breathe bloody oxygen. The fact I've run 10+ ultramarathons (so fully know what discomfort feels like) goes ignored....

Arghh I feel better for that rant now :)

OP posts:
thebabessavedme · 03/05/2026 09:37

I like camping, was talking to my parents about some stuff I had bought for next holiday, all I got was 'that's not camping!, electric lights! blow up mattress! yada yada, my reply? 'I'm astonished you both know so much about camping, I've known you for 63 years now and I've never once known either of you sleep in a tent' The silence was wonderful😂

LakieLady · 03/05/2026 09:35

ErrolTheDragon · 01/05/2026 16:16

Dear lord, they sound like they’ve escaped from some sort of comedy sketch show😂

As I was reading the opening post, I thought "This would make a bloody good comedy sketch"!

They sound really tedious OP, I'd be minded to go low contact with them, and give away very little about where you go etc.

Comtesse · 03/05/2026 09:34

While we’re on Monty Python territory “tis but a flesh wound” might be worth quoting liberally if anyone else takes the piss out of needing plasters!

sueelleker · 03/05/2026 09:25

ErrolTheDragon · 01/05/2026 16:16

Dear lord, they sound like they’ve escaped from some sort of comedy sketch show😂

I agree. "We walked to school in the snow, uphill both ways". I thought the first post was a joke.

Comtesse · 03/05/2026 09:23

SingingHinny · 01/05/2026 17:24

Just say laugh and say 'You two are such a hoot!'

Or play a tiny, tiny violin.

Great response - a bit patronising, just amused tee hee, better than they deserve tbh!

Turnitoffnonagain · 03/05/2026 09:11

This is one of the funniest threads I've read for ages.

The "yes, isn't it great" response on repeat is genius. Going to use that.

curious79 · 03/05/2026 08:55

Personally, I would be mimicking them each time once they started and just going one step further. I mean massive piss taking. Really lean into it and have fun.

SALaw · 03/05/2026 08:39

Eggandchipsandrockandroll · 01/05/2026 16:23

This reminds me of Monty Python's Yorkshire men, will give you a good laugh OP if you've not seen it!

Exactly! I was going to suggest that you call them that and start quoting some lines to them!

ThisJadeBear · 03/05/2026 08:27

@Steeleydan yes one thing we did have was the library.
We were called Junior Readers and had a blue card.
The kids’ section in my local library was as big as the adult section.
And I can remember going for meals occasionally and definitely getting clothed.
I can remember having a lot of stuff from a brand called Ladybird? And M&S stuff at Christmas, as well as C&A.

FeistyFrankie · 03/05/2026 08:26

MyCottageGarden · 01/05/2026 17:00

I’d test them! Make up some ott extreme tale of hardship (on some outing or something) but dressed up all fun & enjoyable then watch them scramble for ways to imply they suffered more or how you should’ve done it.

Yes, this. Next time you go on holiday, tell them you're walking there. All the way to wherever. And see what they come up with.

Steeleydan · 03/05/2026 07:19

AliasGrape · 02/05/2026 09:03

I have a similar relative, on my side of the family in this case, and I’ve found just sort of chuckling and saying ‘ahh you’re so funny’ works the best in that case. I think DH has a latent streak of this in him because I sometimes worry said relative is giving him ideas!

My MIL is a nice, kind lady but her version of this is claiming that certain things just didn’t exist when her kids were small. Some of it’s true - there weren’t all the baby sensory, baby swimming etc groups for example. And parenting expectations were different definitely. But she’s taken that theme and ran with it so that in her mind pretty much anything I ever did or bought for my daughter just simply didn’t exist in the 80s when hers were small. Forgetting I was also small then and remember that they did. Charity shops. Restaurants that allowed children in. Nowhere sold children’s clothes. They didn’t have children’s books at the library. Nobody made their own food when weaning it all just came out of jars - crazy to think that home made food is a modern invention! Conditioner. Colouring books (you just had to use scrap paper) etc etc etc. I just smile and say ‘wow really’ but I definitely have let it wind me up internally at times.

Edited

That library thing is utter shite! I was born in 1972, on Saturday mornings my dad took us to local library I'd be 5 or 6 ish so late 70s into early 80s.
I had every topsy and Tim book out of there, I loved getting my book stamped, the stamper thingy just fascinated me. I even had my own library card. So she's talking shite

SemiRetiredLoveGoddeess · 03/05/2026 04:10

Are these people for real?

They do not seem to understand what comfort. pleasure and enjoyment in life are about.

Sounds as though they would be happier living in Refugee Csmp.or War Zone..Where people genuinely suffer from shortages. terrible living conditions and limited resources on a daily basis.

Because they have no choice.

Eeh By Gum.

Best holiday we've ever had

Bunny65 · 03/05/2026 01:20

Tell them you're proud to be a princess. How bizarre to expect you to walk with painful feet. They sound incredibly weird.

Ifallelsefails · 03/05/2026 00:49

Don't older people get on your tits 😁

How old are they?

It's a combination of being annoying and not keeping up with the times, plus 'anything you can do we've already done it our way and it was much more fun'

We're in our early 60's but DD is only 20, I was an older mum. One day she's full of herself and we can't keep up but we ask questions to show her we're listening and showing interest - then she says we're thick cos we ask too many questions. Another day she's got the world on her shoulders and needs our advice - then she says 'how do you know so much'.

When DD was a baby, MIL used to tell me a story about 'our so&so' (my DH) everytime DD did something new - I got really pissed off with her & once said 'but this is our daughter not your son, he's 43 now', I got pissed off with her a lot. Now 20 years on, I'm MIL's age and I've noticed that I do the same thing, I refer back to a story when DD was whatever age. DD looks at me sometimes & says "you're doing it again mother". I think it's an 'reflex' or something like that, some people can't be happy for other people, they've always done better and you should do it their way.

My MIL caused me some right grief, she was mostly deaf so whatever you said to her she didn't hear it anyway.

WithTwoGiantBoys · 03/05/2026 00:10

Just wondering if you are my sister in-law! My MIL is like this, it's exhausting.

PrettyPickle · 03/05/2026 00:03

Cordeliasdemonbabies · 02/05/2026 08:08

Is this a chatgpt response? Reads just like one.

Sorry to disappoint but NO! Never used ChatGPT in my life. But if that is all you have to say after my long post maybe I will save my time and just use it in future.

SarahAndQuack · 02/05/2026 22:52

These must be my parents. For my sins I went on holiday with them and DD and I'd forgotten how bad they were. It's almost always food with them.

You want to eat a piece of fruit? During the daytime? When the fruit has all been specifically allocated a window of time for consumption, and also, it must be these specific, very hard clementines leftover from Christmas (it was Easter), because they need using up. You want to buy grapes? GRAPES?! And not even the bargain basement, tasteless ones?! You realise they cost a whole £3.50!

You think we might go to a nice cafe or pub for lunch? We always manage with a picnic. No, we don't need to buy food as such, we can share the three slices of bread between the four of us, and a slice of ham each. No one needs butter on bread on a picnic! And here is some lukewarm water we can share, all 200ml of it. Yay!

My mum likes to feel morally superior on eco grounds, so talks at length about how she feels uncomfortable about her carbon footprint. She managed to guilt-trip me recently by saying sadly how the manure I buy for the garden comes contained in plastic bags, and she herself can't reconcile herself to the levels of plastic waste involved in such a horrendous enterprise as putting horseshit on one's courgettes. She made it sound as if I'd been using rocket fuel to power my round-the-world-cruise on the hunt endangered species to maim.

TheRedBear · 02/05/2026 22:50

A friend of mine gave me the best counter for this sort of comment...
"What? You're flying to xyz?"
"I know, it's great isn't it?"
"But you could drive and see the countryside"
"I know, it's great isn't it?"

"What? That's your tent? It's massive"
"I know, it's great isn't it?"

"What? You sat on chairs?"
"I know, it's great isn't it?"

You don't need to justify anything, or extend your answer, just repeat that. Don't defend your stance, just let them know you think it's great. Don't get involved in any "you do you" that's defending your choice, you don't need to because it's your choice and "I know, it's great isn't it?"

Plus it works on those annoying dig questions like "Oh... You're still breastfeeding at 18months?"
"I know, it's great isn't it?"

Ohnobackagain · 02/05/2026 22:30

@GreenPoppies as others have said, turn this into ‘One Down-manship Buzzword Bingo’. Make
some actual cards for you and DH. Shout ‘house’ when you win, I guarantee you will feel better hooting with laughter and they will think you lost the plot. Win-win!

NevergonnagiveHughup · 02/05/2026 22:19

Would you suggest to them that they could drive your two children to Portugal and you’ll fly and meet them there?

i’d love to see that one…

noodlebugz · 02/05/2026 22:15

I really hope you have made this up - they are insane!

canyouseemyhousefromhere · 02/05/2026 22:15

Bettysnow · 01/05/2026 18:20

You should give a really mad reply every single time!lol Tell them you're considering hitch hiking to Portugal with the kids and next time you go camping you will all lie under a hedge as you enjoy being at one with nature

😂😂😂

Wooky073 · 02/05/2026 21:16

Are they working class northerners by any chance? My dad used to revel in ‘you’ve never had it so good’ at times… the old ‘when I were a lad’ …. Followed by stories of bathing in tin baths in back yard, having half a boiled egg on a Sunday as a treat and bedrooms so cold there was frost on the inside of the windows.

it’s also the post war generation who had to ration and make do and mend.

I think they may be enjoying their own humour and winding you up.

Hollybollyhughes · 02/05/2026 20:09

They sound delightful full of themselves total twats. Time to take them to task or the suffering will never end.

FormerCautiousLurker · 02/05/2026 19:10

GreenPoppies · 02/05/2026 08:21

Thanks all some of your replies have made me laugh! I hadn’t seen the four horseman thing but will quote it to them when they start going on 😂

FIL is worse than MIL for this. I’ve tried taking several of the approaches mentioned and he just grins and giggles at me like a teenage boy. He is slightly odd, it’s like he’s trying to wind us up but also genuinely thinks we’re a bit soft.

DH I think has grown immune and just ignores him now. I only let it annoy me when I’m in a bad mood 😂

Another one for you- suitcases. Who needs suitcases to go on holiday with? Surely all you need for a week away is a change of pants and a toothbrush in your Tesco carrier bag? Anything more…..SUCH LUXURY!

Wow, you old people are so funny!! What on earth do you need a toothbrush for? You can just used a bit of bog roll or your teeshirt hem? And pants? Blimey one pair will last 4 days if you turn them round back to front and then repeat with them inside out, surely? If you’re leaving for a week, double-up and wear the second pair on top - and begin the process again on day 5 with the top pair? No need to ruin the planet with a carrier bag, after all.