Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be fed up with my in-laws' reverse one-upmanship?

163 replies

GreenPoppies · 01/05/2026 16:13

I know I'm not being unreasonable because making disparaging comments about someone elses choices is always rude but does anyone else get so annoyed by reverse one-upmanship?

My in-laws are the ultimate in this. We are going on holiday to Portugal in August and they are flabbergasted that we are flying. "But why can't you just drive? It's so brilliant. We love driving. The views from the motorway are second to none. I don't understand why you're flying" Because, Not-So-Dear In-Laws, we have 9 month old and a 2 year old, and 2-3 days of driving is neither comfortable nor practical. "But just do it all in one go, it's only 24 hours if you drive non-stop, you'll be fine, it's so much fun, I don't understand why anybody would fly there in 2 hours when you could drive there in 24! Such luxury!".

We took our (then) 18 month old camping last year in our 4 man tent. "you sat on CHAIRS?! Oh wow, that's crazy, I can't believe you sat on chairs, we would just sit on a tesco bag. And that tent may as well be a castle, we just prop up a tarp and sleep under that, no need for sleeping bags, it's so much fun to camp without all the unnecessary extras".

We were once on a walking holiday with them and I mentioned (didn't make a fuss or anything) that I needed to stop at a shop. When they pressed ("why on earth do you need a shop? Just sustain yourself on beer for 3 days!") I said I needed some plasters as a stone had got into my walking boot and rubbed my foot raw, I'd bled all over my sock. I was made out to be the most precious princess ever, to this day I'm ribbed about "can't even do a 6 hour walk without needing a plaster the next day! We just walked through the blood!"

I'm getting fed up of gritting my teeth and putting up with it. I've bitten back a few times and told them to shut up if they can't say anything nice but again, I'm seen as 'dramatic' and it's ignored. I now try and avoid them but obviously they are my kid's grandparents and otherwise not bad people so needs must.

It feels like they assign a moral worth to anyone who does not suffer like bloody Christ on the cross! I'm a second rate human being because I fly, camp in a tent, use plasters and god-forbid breathe bloody oxygen. The fact I've run 10+ ultramarathons (so fully know what discomfort feels like) goes ignored....

Arghh I feel better for that rant now :)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mammajaz · 04/05/2026 20:03

Next time they say anything about your trip just say "you know what... I've done long distance running I'll just strap the kids and hubby to my back and run all the way to Portugal! I mean I might have to pack some plasters but yeah sounds feasible. I'll get going now and hopefully be there in time to check in."

These people sound insufferable but also maybe there's a jealously poverty element. The whole well we did it a different way because convienance and comfort weren't affordable but showing ourselves as martyrs makes us feel good about ourselves schtick.

Don't be annoyed just find I comical they sound like they are straight out of a sitcom and there's no malice there

TorroFerney · 04/05/2026 12:30

ThisJadeBear · 03/05/2026 08:27

@Steeleydan yes one thing we did have was the library.
We were called Junior Readers and had a blue card.
The kids’ section in my local library was as big as the adult section.
And I can remember going for meals occasionally and definitely getting clothed.
I can remember having a lot of stuff from a brand called Ladybird? And M&S stuff at Christmas, as well as C&A.

Oh i was in the junior readers club. You wrote a composition well review/synopsis of the book if I remember. I once had mine pinned up in the library, thrilling times.

SingedSoul · 04/05/2026 10:01

They are ridiculous. Next time they come for dinner lay out tesco bags for them to sit on.

honeylulu · 04/05/2026 10:00

Your in-laws sound like my parents. They are always horrified to hear we have booked a holiday full stop - "we don't need that, we've got a nice beach hut down the road, what a waste of money blah blah". I try not to mention when we have a holiday booked as its always "oh noooo, not another one" as if I've just said "oh I think I'll shoot up some heroin today mother".

And when my mother saw I owned a steam mop - "what's wrong with the good old ways, you can get a floor perfectly clean getting down on your hands and knees with a bucket and a cloth". Erm, because a steam mop is easy and effective and doesn't hurt my knees.

Life should be hard, sparse and punishing. What am I thinking using my own hard earned money to make things easier and more pleasant?

Loobyloot · 04/05/2026 09:39

Over 21 years I have learned that whatever I say to my MIL will elicit a comment aboit how she would have done whatever I talk about, so now I dont talk to her except to answer questions in the shortest possible way which offers no information. It's awful. But protects me.

sueelleker · 04/05/2026 09:05

Usernamenotav · 04/05/2026 07:27

This is so weird! And i don't think it can really be called one-up manship as they're not even upping you, they're downing you 🤣 so bizarre.

There's a saying about people that always want to one-up
'If you've been to tenerife, they've been to elevenerife' but in this case I think they've been to ninerife? 😂

Or, to quote Shirley Valentine; , "I'm not sayin' she's a bragger, but if you've been to Paradise, she's got a season ticket

Needtosoundoffandbreathe · 04/05/2026 08:59

This is a bit like my elderly parents, but their foibles are not as grating, who cannot fathom that others may do things differently from them. This extends to all sorts of different things in life. When they were last round at our house we offered a drink before dinner and they asked for something I would definitely describe as niche, but which they have at home. In the 30 plus years since I've had my own place, they've never asked for this drink so it's not as if I should have got some in to be a better host.

Needtosoundoffandbreathe · 04/05/2026 08:54

Eggandchipsandrockandroll · 01/05/2026 16:23

This reminds me of Monty Python's Yorkshire men, will give you a good laugh OP if you've not seen it!

Exactly what I was thinking!

Mischance · 04/05/2026 08:53

They sound hilarious! - think Monty Python shed sketch!

I would just laugh at them ...

MaybeThisTimeILlbeLucky · 04/05/2026 08:52

The underlying truth however is controlling people who seek their own power by undermining people and proving them wrong all the time.

MaybeThisTimeILlbeLucky · 04/05/2026 08:51

@PrettyPickle excellent advise.

isthesolution · 04/05/2026 08:44

Eeeee I love hearing stories about how things were done in the olden days …… would be my response!

Firefly100 · 04/05/2026 08:39

Ha ha im really loving some of these replies. This would drive me crazy too. I’d probably do a combination of ‘yes, it’s great isn’t it’ and just seeing them less. However, the one about the plaster - that would really piss me off. That is not just feel good onedowmmanship, that is really unpleasant. I’d say bullying type behaviour.
If they tried to keep that one going I’d lean into it. Eg ‘I’m so happy that me in pain is such an ongoing source of amusement and pleasure for you - do let me known when you need hospital treatment so we can all have a good chuckle together.’ And if the subject of going on holiday with them comes up again : ‘No thanks. Last time I went on holiday with you, you belittled me and made entertainment of my pain. You still find amusement in it. Why would I ever willingly holiday with you again? They would be under no illusions how I felt about that.

Lunaballoon · 04/05/2026 07:49

I would definitely not be going on holiday with these people! Holidays are supposed to be precious relaxed times with loved ones, not an upmanship competition!

Usernamenotav · 04/05/2026 07:27

This is so weird! And i don't think it can really be called one-up manship as they're not even upping you, they're downing you 🤣 so bizarre.

There's a saying about people that always want to one-up
'If you've been to tenerife, they've been to elevenerife' but in this case I think they've been to ninerife? 😂

Plinketyplonks · 04/05/2026 06:48

Ha! My mum can br a bit like this. She uses the expression ‘in my day we just got on with it.’ A woman moved to her village who was a bereavement counsellor. Mum said she’d never heard of one of those and ‘in my day etc.’ etc etc

TeaCupTinsel · 04/05/2026 05:56

Oh gosh OP, this would utterly infuriate me. I'd be hitting their comments with sarcasm at this point, loud sarcasm and making sure others (non family, random strangers) hear it too
e.g. 'Oh yes, I am such a perfect princess for wanting a plaster to put on my bleeding ankle...however must I cope in life?'

Or if it's about doing things e.g. chairs and tesco bags I'd repeatedly use the catchphrases:

'Well, we can't all be martyrs Pete and Janet'

'We can't all fall on our swords Pete and Janet, thanks for taking one for the team!'

Or one-up them again with a sprinkle of cheek:

Pete and Janet: 'Can't believe you sat on chairs, we sat on Tesco bags.'

You: 'No, no, no Pete and Janet, the kids sat on the chairs, husband and I huddled together on the disused wrappings of an Aldi pasta bag... it was a comfortable evening.'

And I would not stop taking the p*ss and laughing at them, to their faces, until it became so uncomfortable they stopped.

This would be war.

(Although, I do hope you're ok OP? Trust me, I know inlaws drama and it is so draining, even when it's ridiculous!)

Nettie1964 · 03/05/2026 20:39

Cordeliasdemonbabies · 02/05/2026 08:08

Is this a chatgpt response? Reads just like one.

I think the suggestion that they drive with the kids while you fly is the best, your in-laws sound insane I know how grating it can be.

PoorEileen · 03/05/2026 19:41

My dad was a bit like this. Total fucking fantasist with it and all. If you’d got a splinter he’d be stabbed in the stomach.
He was a fucking tit. And my MiL is the same, DH and I bonded over it. I often think my idea of hell would be being a fly on a wall listening to MiL and my dad have a conversation.
My dad (who was given a detention in secondary school) to MiL - “I was once a prisoner of war”
MiL (who was once grounded) “I was captured by adolf hitler himself. I only survived by seducing him until I was rescued by Churchill’s top secret special forces”
Dad - “Oh Churchill once needed advice from me”…
Utterfuckingbollocks.
It’s misery olympics. These people’s personalities are simply just how tough they’ve had it and when they meet people who have genuinely had it tough they can’t loose and make up any old shite. It sounds funny when it’s described as in the op as how they sit on Tesco bags and a camping chair is a luxury, but it is draining and exhausting to be around.

wizzywig · 03/05/2026 19:39

Cant believe they are talking when just huffing at you will do

Abbyant · 03/05/2026 19:20

3 days driving in foreign countries sounds horrendous and I’d say as much why suffer in a car for days when you can travel in ease by plane and enjoy your resort.

Tuesdayschild50 · 03/05/2026 16:20

🤣😂🤣 this would wind me up aswell.
Let's all slog it because they do .
How could you drive in one go to Portugal with little ones that young .. not to mention driving while tired the safety aspect of it ..
We did drive to Spain a couple of times and im not kidding its hard going my kids were 4 and 6 at the time really good they were amazing ..... but one was sick in the car everywhere before we got on a ferry .. we missed ferry's.. got lost all the time as their dad wouldn't use sat nav....
My sons are 23&25 now and always said why didn't my dad just jump on a plane for 2 hrs for God's sake 😂🤣 we did part ways not long after those trips so ignore your in-laws and tell them shut up .

FlapperFlamingo · 03/05/2026 15:21

That's so annoying for you OP. My MIL could be like this. An example that sticks in my mind was she asked what we'd done with the kids one day during school holidays, I said we'd gone swimming then geo-caching (kid's choices). She then regaled us with tales of how she didn't do boring activities, and how they walked up some mountain in Yorkshire and got completely lost but luckily met a man who walked them some of the way back, then went down the wrong side of the mountain and someone else had to take them back to their car and it was after dark when they arrived back. Oh and it was near a military zone and a soldier had turned them back from their path and helped them get to a village.

And I replied "Really? I like to plan things quite well so I don't disrupt the day of random people or require the armed forces to get me back to my car".

Anyway, my response was to reduce the number of times I saw her, and also reduce my speaking time when I did see her. If she started a rant about some activity and how hilarious it was I'd just go on my phone and let DH handle it.

MustWeDoThis · 03/05/2026 10:34

GreenPoppies · 01/05/2026 16:13

I know I'm not being unreasonable because making disparaging comments about someone elses choices is always rude but does anyone else get so annoyed by reverse one-upmanship?

My in-laws are the ultimate in this. We are going on holiday to Portugal in August and they are flabbergasted that we are flying. "But why can't you just drive? It's so brilliant. We love driving. The views from the motorway are second to none. I don't understand why you're flying" Because, Not-So-Dear In-Laws, we have 9 month old and a 2 year old, and 2-3 days of driving is neither comfortable nor practical. "But just do it all in one go, it's only 24 hours if you drive non-stop, you'll be fine, it's so much fun, I don't understand why anybody would fly there in 2 hours when you could drive there in 24! Such luxury!".

We took our (then) 18 month old camping last year in our 4 man tent. "you sat on CHAIRS?! Oh wow, that's crazy, I can't believe you sat on chairs, we would just sit on a tesco bag. And that tent may as well be a castle, we just prop up a tarp and sleep under that, no need for sleeping bags, it's so much fun to camp without all the unnecessary extras".

We were once on a walking holiday with them and I mentioned (didn't make a fuss or anything) that I needed to stop at a shop. When they pressed ("why on earth do you need a shop? Just sustain yourself on beer for 3 days!") I said I needed some plasters as a stone had got into my walking boot and rubbed my foot raw, I'd bled all over my sock. I was made out to be the most precious princess ever, to this day I'm ribbed about "can't even do a 6 hour walk without needing a plaster the next day! We just walked through the blood!"

I'm getting fed up of gritting my teeth and putting up with it. I've bitten back a few times and told them to shut up if they can't say anything nice but again, I'm seen as 'dramatic' and it's ignored. I now try and avoid them but obviously they are my kid's grandparents and otherwise not bad people so needs must.

It feels like they assign a moral worth to anyone who does not suffer like bloody Christ on the cross! I'm a second rate human being because I fly, camp in a tent, use plasters and god-forbid breathe bloody oxygen. The fact I've run 10+ ultramarathons (so fully know what discomfort feels like) goes ignored....

Arghh I feel better for that rant now :)

They sound absolutely feral.

My response? "Why on earth do you sleep in a bed at night!? I just sleep on the floor of a shop door-way. Much more fun! Tally-ho!"

Bobcurlygirl · 03/05/2026 09:43

Yes I had a FIL like that. He was more the sort to make snide comments. "your children will turn into delinquents as you are going back to work and using a nursery" (SiL didn't work).
I just stuck to the same response "oh FIL! We have a saying back home, if you can't say anything nice don't say anything at all" worked quite well.