Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why bidets are common in Italy but not England?

187 replies

Tonyritundo · 30/04/2026 23:39

Why are bidets mandatory in Italy but barely any English people have them?

OP posts:
Neurodiversitydoctor · 02/05/2026 09:37

Bidetsarethebest · 02/05/2026 09:13

Oh really. Have you ever actually been to Bergamo, Milan, or Bolzano? They’re very similar to Hull or Manchester in winter where I’ve been many times. Please stop generalising if your only reference is a short holiday in Florence. I’ve lived for years in different cities in both countries. The way some people in England talk about the weather here, using it as an excuse for everything, including still having carpet everywhere as if it were still the 80s as if it’s unbearably cold, is just exaggerated. You’re not living in Siberia.

Yes of course I have been to Milan ot is honestly fuck all like Hull.

Bidetsarethebest · 02/05/2026 09:13

Neurodiversitydoctor · 02/05/2026 06:08

The weather in Northern Italy is not like England in the winter. Please come to Manchester, Liverpool or Hull in December or January no way is that the same as Florence.

Oh really. Have you ever actually been to Bergamo, Milan, or Bolzano? They’re very similar to Hull or Manchester in winter where I’ve been many times. Please stop generalising if your only reference is a short holiday in Florence. I’ve lived for years in different cities in both countries. The way some people in England talk about the weather here, using it as an excuse for everything, including still having carpet everywhere as if it were still the 80s as if it’s unbearably cold, is just exaggerated. You’re not living in Siberia.

RampantIvy · 02/05/2026 08:47

When I moved in with exH his shower had a loose head and hose that was clipped to the wall / shower structure so it couldn’t be used freely. I hacksawed the clip off after a while.

The shower in our en suite was like that, and I did the same.

MrsShawnHatosy · 02/05/2026 08:03

RampantIvy · 01/05/2026 07:21

This is why I dislike rainfall showers. I prefer showers where you can remove the shower head from the wall and direct it to my nether regions.

I also find bidets useful for washing feet.

You can get showers that have both a rainfall and a detachable shower head. They are not that expensive. I like the rainfall for washing my hair.

NamechangebumpforMandy · 02/05/2026 07:53

What I am finding bizarre about some of the responses on this thread is the belief that using a bidet is somehow more dirty than just using toilet paper. So:

  1. Do you all use the same towel? No. Why do so many people assume this?

  2. You will get poo on your hand/in the water. No. You use toilet paper first. Granted your hand does then touch your bum/bits but I assume that you wash your arse properly in the shower which involves your hand touching your bum.

  3. You will create a bacterial breeding ground unless you use soap. No. Europeans do use soap with a bidet. Anyway, even if not used (cf Japanese toilet which squirts water but not soap up there) it still gets your bum cleaner than using toilet paper.

  4. Miscellaneous fear of developing some sort of bum flu due to cold water on the arse in winter. No. Bidets have hot and cold water…

montysmaw · 02/05/2026 07:41

How does it work with bidets?

Do you skooosh your bum every time or is it just after poos?

Do you have a wet bum afterwards? So you need bum towels? Do you share bum towels or does everybody have their own personal bum towel.

If you have visitors, do you give them a bum towel?

Natsku · 02/05/2026 07:40

lljkk · 01/05/2026 22:38

Bidets make no sense to me. Bum guns OTOH, I am a fan of this, but also thinking not practical in a cold climate.

They're extremely common in Finland, which is a much colder climate than the UK. But we heat our homes properly so our bathrooms aren't actually cold and damp.

IceStationZebra · 02/05/2026 07:15

CeciliaMars · 02/05/2026 05:58

Can I be honest and say I’m not really sure how they’re used?!

Same. Do you hover or sit your weight on it? Do you fill it with water like a sitz bath? And the bum guns, how does it not spray water everywhere? I am hugely in favour of good hygiene

agreed on proper shower hoses though. When I moved in with exH his shower had a loose head and hose that was clipped to the wall / shower structure so it couldn’t be used freely. I hacksawed the clip off after a while.

Alittlefrustrated · 02/05/2026 06:54

Tonyritundo · 01/05/2026 08:34

I’m sure it saves more water than it costs to chop down trees and process, transport and sell toilet roll.

You still use toilet roll beforehand.

Simonjt · 02/05/2026 06:48

We don’t have a bidet, but all but one of our toilets has a hose, with one having a Japanese toilet seat instead. I do find it off that bidets and hoses are unusual in the UK, but I also find it odd that until fairly recently it wasn’t unusual for their not to be a sink in with the toilet in a lot of UK bathrooms, surely a sink in the loo is more useful than a sink by the bath.

WhyamIinahandcartandwherearewegoing · 02/05/2026 06:30

GoodWater · 01/05/2026 06:50

Just FYI this is definitely against water regs.

Never knew that! Not that I have investigated the topic 😂 but now I’m wondering why!?

Neurodiversitydoctor · 02/05/2026 06:08

Bidetsarethebest · 02/05/2026 01:45

Please stop talking as if your experiences represent the whole of Italy. I’m from the north and have never had issues with droughts or not having running water. We take baths. The whole of Italy isn’t like a small rural village. I’m from a city, and I’ve always used a bidet like most Italians. It has nothing to do with water shortages.And yes, it’s hotter in the summer, but in winter the weather is very similar to England. And for the English folks: to dry yourself after using a bidet, you use..wait for it.. a small towel! The same way you dry yourself after a shower or a bath. Crazy, I know.🙄

The weather in Northern Italy is not like England in the winter. Please come to Manchester, Liverpool or Hull in December or January no way is that the same as Florence.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 02/05/2026 06:05

QuintadosMalvados · 01/05/2026 17:51

Agree. My heart sinks a bit when in a hotel/someone else's home and the showerhead is non-removable.

F* off with your fancy 'rainfall' shower if it doesn't thoroughly give the parts that need most attention a proper going over!! Lol.
I'd rather have a cheap shower with detachable showerhead any day.

Some have a separate hose at the bottom, though, don't they?

To be honest, I'd be fair happier skipping the daily shower if I had a bidet.

Also I don't want to wash my v. thick takes ages to dry hair everyday or get it wet before work on a freezing january morning.

CeciliaMars · 02/05/2026 05:58

Can I be honest and say I’m not really sure how they’re used?!

borntobequiet · 02/05/2026 05:45

They’re an historical practical hygienic solution in countries where the water supply is limited or inadequate and showers impractical to install, and people in this country aren’t keen on the idea of washing their bums, I’m not sure why (I can remember the days when hard shiny Izal toilet paper was thought effective).

LovinglyCrafted · 02/05/2026 05:40

Bidetsarethebest · 02/05/2026 01:45

Please stop talking as if your experiences represent the whole of Italy. I’m from the north and have never had issues with droughts or not having running water. We take baths. The whole of Italy isn’t like a small rural village. I’m from a city, and I’ve always used a bidet like most Italians. It has nothing to do with water shortages.And yes, it’s hotter in the summer, but in winter the weather is very similar to England. And for the English folks: to dry yourself after using a bidet, you use..wait for it.. a small towel! The same way you dry yourself after a shower or a bath. Crazy, I know.🙄

You will see I wrote: “in our village” and “SOME of the south”. Not talking about the whole of Italy at all. No need to be defensive, it’s not an attack.

OtterlyAstounding · 02/05/2026 05:26

It just seems unnecessary to me, for the average person. Wiping and a daily shower suffices for most people, and if needed on a hot day or prior to sex, a quick sponge bath with a wet flannel in front of the sink is just as good for a 'freshen up' for armpits/sweat/genitals, and doesn't require faffing about with a bidet.

PrinceHarrysBaldPatch · 02/05/2026 05:25

nomas · 01/05/2026 00:44

I don’t think they have ever been common in the UK.

We had them growing up. As did grandparents.
They take up space though so no longer put in. Hoses are much more convenient but you need to have a special valve or they can contaminate the water supply.

Itsanewdawnitsanewdayitsanewlife4me · 02/05/2026 03:03

We had one in Dublin, Ireland in the 80's. Did not notice if the norm or not but we were not exactly millionaire status family although we did move to a 'better' area and no bathrooms had one and I haven't noticed one in a home since being honest.

Bidetsarethebest · 02/05/2026 01:45

LovinglyCrafted · 01/05/2026 18:35

Glad you understand! In our village we get water on Mondays, Wednesdays & Fridays. We store it in big tanks in the house. Drinking water is bought or used to come from one of the local reservoirs. People here don’t understand that some of the south is not as modern. When my parents were building our house in the 1990s we stayed in a place my grandparents owned which basically had no running water! We washed with water collected in a massive barrel, when the government gave it. This is Italy! Crackers, I know, but not everywhere had running water all the time.

Please stop talking as if your experiences represent the whole of Italy. I’m from the north and have never had issues with droughts or not having running water. We take baths. The whole of Italy isn’t like a small rural village. I’m from a city, and I’ve always used a bidet like most Italians. It has nothing to do with water shortages.And yes, it’s hotter in the summer, but in winter the weather is very similar to England. And for the English folks: to dry yourself after using a bidet, you use..wait for it.. a small towel! The same way you dry yourself after a shower or a bath. Crazy, I know.🙄

BestZebbie · 02/05/2026 00:11

Greyblankie · 01/05/2026 08:19

Im confused by bidets, don’t you end up coming out the bathroom with a wet arse? I assume you dry yoursen with bogroll but surely you’d still feel wet?

Usually there are small fabric cloths (eg: mini towels) to dry off and then a bucket to put them in for washing.

Whyhaveibeencutoutofmamsnot · 02/05/2026 00:07

GasPanic · 01/05/2026 15:32

Maybe its due to the drains.

In some places you aren't allowed to put toilet paper down the drains because it blocks the sewers up and you have to put it in a basket beside the toilet.

The less "used" the toilet paper the less nasty the basket is going to be.

I always feel weird about putting toilet paper in the basket next to the toilet as the drains can't cope (even with the soft stuff that disintegrates when wet. Has to be emptied by someone

nevernotmaybe · 02/05/2026 00:06

Im always curious about liking them so much. Unless you are using soap, cleaning properly like a shower there, then drying fully, it just creates a breeding ground that will create far more bacterial growth than just wiping would.

But I haven't used one, so is that how it works?

Even then doing that every time I go to the toilet, for what amounts to zero health benefit unless you are unpleasant in some other ways, still seems like an annoying waste of time.

LabOwner95 · 01/05/2026 23:52

A few years ago we went to Morocco, and I came back to our hotel bathroom to find my lovely Liz Earle facecloth on the side of the bidet. The lovely cleaner bless her had used it as a cleaning cloth for the bidet. Had to throw it away...

LadyWiddiothethird · 01/05/2026 23:50

I gave birth twice in Italy,bliss afterwards having a bidet.